Murray's Whale Ale - Murray's Craft Brewing Co.
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 33 | Reviews: 19 | Display Reviews Only:
2.85/5 rDev -8.7%
Chilled 330ml poured into a plain pilsner glass.
Pours a mildly hazy lemon straw yellow body color. Effervescent head that quits pushing up at just under 2 fingers.
Nothing to exciting aromatically. Mild summer fruits like pears and apples blend with hops and citric notes. Some herby spice sits in the blend but its either very buried or I'm trying to pull out something that just isn't there.
Taste is similar again to the aroma but with the hops acting a lot more pronounced in the taste then the nose. There is a definite big yeast flavor but the fruits detected in the nose are not so noticeable in the taste. Spicy notes round out the blend nicely.
Look, this is a nice beer and there certainly are worse offerings out there, however, this is not a distinctive beer and it certainly isn't definitive enough to stand up to the market. I really can't ignore the elephant in the room either - this just isn't a Wit and to be honest I can't even see any characteristics in this beer that makes me think this even comes close.
02-09-2011 08:37:43 | More by SleepyMonk
3.15/5 rDev +1%
A - Pours a fairly clear golden colour with a 2cm white head that falls fairly fast.
S - Herbal hop notes, some spicy phenols and sweetish grainy, malted wheat.
T - Pretty much the same as the smell really but sweeter than expected.
M - Lighter side of medium body with a medium to high carbonation.
D - Nothing wrong with it just not very exciting. But I guess I can accept one or two blandish beers from Murrays given that they also make some pretty impressive beers.
12-24-2010 09:30:52 | More by brendan13
3.4/5 rDev +9%
Pours hazy pale amber/straw with a large lasting head.
Nose shows lots of light fruit: pear, lemon, green apple and orange peel. Underneath is sweet light malt. Later on the citrus really dominates.
First flavours are more sweet fruit before some grainy malt and a light metallic bitterness enter. The latter are not too strong but are mildly unpleasant.
Carbonation is too high even for the style.
11-01-2010 10:03:53 | More by CrazyDavros
3.23/5 rDev +3.5%
The first thing to say is that this definitely isn't a witbier and so I won't review it as such.
The aroma is moderately grainy with a light sweetness and a light spicy hop note.
It is mostly clear with a moderate sized, foamy, white head.
The flavour, reflecting the aroma, is almost like a classic lager with a touch of wheat and a small hit of hops. The flavour is very subdued and clearly aimed at craft beer newbies but it isn't bad per se.
Medium bodied with moderate carbonation. This is actually quite good.
Overall, it's a fairly straightforward gateway beer. There is a little bit going on but I think they could be more adventurous.
05-27-2010 07:18:56 | More by dgilks
2.33/5 rDev -25.3%
Poured into a Hoegaarden glass
A-- Poured a hazy gold yellow color. Very small head, no real lacing, medium carbonation and lacking the liveliness that wits have in the head department and in the color department.
S-- Very thin smell, some yeast, some orange peel but not a lot to get excited over. A little more body than a Aussie lager but this is a wit, not a lager. Could pass for one though.
T-- Floral, spicy hop taste with the orange in the background. Not as fruity as others. Quite thin for what it is supposed to be.
M-- Mouthfeel is better but this is still missing the orange character of a wit. The carbonation is good but lacking in excitement that wits have. Has more of a lemony taste and feel to it. Not sure if it wants to be a wit, hefe, or lager.
D-- Like what Murrays does but not in this beer. One is enough and will not look for again. Needs more of the orange smell and taste of classic wit's. As a pale lager or a straight lager it is workable. No real excitement from this beer at all. Go find the Pilsner instead of this.
03-09-2010 05:36:01 | More by mulder1010
3.38/5 rDev +8.3%
Pours initially a haze-free pale golden colour.... but a quick swirl of the bottle brings out a yeasty haze.
Fair leaning towards the coriander seed in this beer.... but also a candy perfume which only subtly leans to citrus.... Some meaty/fleshy hints.
Spice again picks up on the palate, including some other notes such as ginger powder & white pepper.
Palate a touch hollow, but not offputingly so. Some wheaty creaminess in the body, and a slight citric tang.
The coriander seed persists into the aftertaste, and that ain't bad.
Compared with other Australian attempts at this style, I think this is probably one of the better ones.
07-18-2009 08:16:16 | More by vancurly
3.05/5 rDev -2.2%
Dark golden yellow colour, a little cloudy but not very. Doesn't look much like a wit. Decent frothy head that turns into a film. Lots of carbonation. Not bad, but not really wit like.
Reasonable, but a little thin nose of citrus and herbs. Very subdued, but the Curacao style candied orange peel is pleasant.
Reasonable, light entry, completely smashed with a large yeasty character. Quite dull, and rather thin with a strong coppery metallic aftertaste. It's not huge and it's not terribly interesting, not a lot of the fragrance promised on the palate. Mouthfeel is a little flat, but it feels like there's a lot of dissolved carbontion feels bloating.
It's not too bad. It's not unpleasant, but it's certainly not very exciting. Drinkable enough, I guess, but not nearly as good as some of Murray's other offerings.
05-24-2009 08:02:47 | More by lacqueredmouse
3.3/5 rDev +5.8%
Pours a golden colour with a lot of bubbly carbonation. Sparsely bubbled head sinks slowly but dramatically. A few specks of lacing here and there. Looks nothing like a witbier, in fact looks like a pale lager. Very blah.
Nose is better, good hit of spicy hops. Slight citrus character and a hint of fresh milled wheat but not enough, not very potent. Actually smells quite like a pale ale. Not a bad nose but again, not particularly witbiery.
Good spicy yeast character, with hints of coriander and clove on the mid-palate. Fairly prominent candied orange character hiding behind and persisting through the palate. Finish is quite grassy and a bit sour. Overall the fruit and spice are well balanced to give this good wheat characters, and the mouthfeel is tingly and pleasant.
This is quite drinkable but not quite spicy or potent enough to impress me. Tasty but not very impressive.
05-18-2009 00:19:54 | More by laituegonflable
Murray's Whale Ale from Murray's Craft Brewing Co.
75 out of 100 based on 33 ratings.