1. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  2. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Smoke - Surly Brewing Company

Not Rated.

Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.

716 Ratings
no score

(send 'em beer!)
Ratings: 716
Reviews: 266
rAvg: 4.09
pDev: 12.47%
Wants: 333
Gots: 222 | FT: 7
Brewed by:
Surly Brewing Company visit their website
Minnesota, United States

Style | ABV
Baltic Porter |  8.20% ABV

Availability: Rotating

Notes/Commercial Description:
No notes at this time.

(Beer added by: BeerAdvocate on 12-05-2007)
Beer: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
Ratings: 716 | Reviews: 266 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of bobsy

Ontario (Canada)

4.72/5  rDev +15.4%

Huge thanks to Russ for bringing this beer over! The cap is hidden under a crazy amount of wax, but its well worth the effort.

Dark brown body, bordering on black, but betrayed by ruby highlights. A small tan head quickly drops to a film leaving only the odd spot of lace. The nose is intriguing, bringing well-integrated smoke to a mixture of dark fruit, molasses, chocolate, brown bread and alcohol. Smells fantastic. The tastes is heavenly, with a great smoked chocolate character, and a profound depth of chocolate flavour. This is more than complemented by prunes, earth, molasses, light roast and vinous notes. Complex, but well balanced, with the smoke as well-integrated as you could hope for. Medium bodied with a creamy carbonation.

Awesome, awesome beer! Thanks again Russ!

07-05-2010 13:17:51 | More by bobsy
Photo of jjfancybeers


4.7/5  rDev +14.9%

draught @Firkin (Libertyville, IL)



Lingering, tan head. Opaque. Yep...grillsmoke and roasted malt in the nose. Creamy chocolate/+/hops upfront. Subtle smoke in an otherwise warm finish. Strong. Tasty. Want to pair it with ...smoked venison summer sausage.

12-23-2007 07:24:33 | More by jjfancybeers
Photo of Derek

British Columbia (Canada)

4.7/5  rDev +14.9%

A: Black with a tan head, thin ring of retention, light lacing.

S: Smoky, coffee, chocolate, demerara/molasses licorice.

T: Truly exceptional. Just try this!

Bakers chocolate, molasses, dark roasted coffee, dark bread, hint of lagery sulfur, smoky spice.

M: Extremely smooth, moderate body, off-dry finish.

D: I could drink this all night, but I'd surly regret it in the morning.

07-06-2010 00:58:39 | More by Derek
Photo of natasharai


4.68/5  rDev +14.4%

Appearance: Poured with a thin layer of head on top that is tan and a made of small bubbles. The beer is black in color and does not let any light through. The small amount of head that was in the glass dissipated after a few minutes.

Smell: Quite smokey up front, followed by a lot of roasty malts

Taste: Very nice smokey flavor balanced well with the roasted malt flavor, all finished off with a hop bitterness, verry small amount of alcohol presence.

Mouthfeel: Very smooth, not too thick and not too thin, with a small hop tingle on the tongue.

Overall: Pretty drinkable, the smoke flavor is not too overpowering, generous amount of roasted malt, there is a very nice hoppyness towards the end that gives this beer an extra bit of character.

02-21-2009 01:07:37 | More by natasharai
Photo of br3wmeister


4.68/5  rDev +14.4%

A- Dark black liquid topped with a small head that dissipates quickly leaving no lacing.

S- Lots of smokey aromas, more peat then wood smokiness. Good malty character gives is some roasted notes.

T- Some alcohol and light hop bitterness up front that is overwhelmed by smokey malts and roasted flavors. Some dark chocolate and hints of molasses come through in the middle but drops right back into the roasted smokey malt. Some alcohol warmth in the end leaving your palate with a nice smokey flavor.

M- This is a medium full bodied beer that is smooth, silky, and slightly oily. Great balance helps to keep this beer very drinkable. Almost perfect carbonation, this beer feels great in your mouth.

Overall- This is one of the best porters I have ever had and would recommend it to anyone looking for a nice smokey porter.

02-12-2009 15:27:57 | More by br3wmeister
Photo of AdmiralDiaz


4.65/5  rDev +13.7%

On-tap at the Blue Nile for the Surly Three release party.

A: Very dark brown with lighter edges, no head at all but I'm going to call that the bartenders fault.

S: Burnt coffee and smokeiness with strong roasted malts and strong molasses.

T: Highly roasted malts upfront that subside into pure smoked flavor rolling into a bitter roasted coffee finish. Excellent, this brew knows what it wants to be and pulls it off perfectly. With so much smokey and roasted tones it stays very well balanced between precise flavors. Best Baltic Porter I've had!

Overall: Very good porter, nice arbonation and very enjoyable as far as mouthfeel goes. Highly drinkable beer as well, the alcohol doesn't come out as much as it should for such a high abv beer. One of Surly's most impressive.

02-12-2009 05:33:16 | More by AdmiralDiaz
Photo of feloniousmonk


4.65/5  rDev +13.7%

On tap, (at the Blue Nile) in a Big Ass Tripel Karmeliet glass, why the hell not...
Black as it gets, with a roasty tanned head. Looks absolutely perfect for the style.

Smoked malt from Bamberg in this, and it wafts out slyly, but confidently. There’s bacon down there, but I get salmon as well....mmm, smokey!

Taste: mmm, a beautiful mix of the roasted chocolate malts, the deep, dark fruits, like raisin and plum, but so smooth. The smoke aspect is just sliding along in the flavor, not a dominant aspect at all, but it hangs in there and never lets you forget it. The strength is sneaky, too, you don’t get hit on the head, but it creeps up on you, and invades your mind with stealth. Delicious stuff, and so easy to drink, though you have to pace it...too strong for sessioning! But you want to, you really really want to!

I have to wonder if other American brewed "Imperial Porters" are as faithful to the style and actually made as a lager, as Todd did here. How do you get this dark and this deep, with a lager? But it's a wise choice, as the flavor is there aplenty, and the mouthfeel is so smooth, so clean, so sumptuous, as well. This is one of my favorite styles, though the smoked porter variety isn't, exactly. So glad that the smoke is not intrusive, and merely in the end, a side characteristic, ...maybe the oak aging aided in the mellowing of the flavors? Whatever, it really came together in Smoke!

Really magnificent! This needs to go in bombers and blow some minds out there! Til that happens, I'm happy to drink it down on tap right here! Ahhh!!!

12-08-2007 07:07:56 | More by feloniousmonk
Photo of stealth


4.63/5  rDev +13.2%

Served from a bottle to a tulip.

This is the first and only 'smoked' beer I've had. 'Drinking a campfire' was what came to mind immediately. Smelled like a campfire. I thought the wife would smell my clothes and ask where I was after I drank this. Very immersive experience that made me want to go out and make some smores. I can't say I was crazy about the taste overall, but man, the great smell, great smooth mouthfeel really made it a nice.

01-12-2012 09:01:40 | More by stealth
Photo of Graham21


4.63/5  rDev +13.2%

Had this one on tap at the Blue Nile and Surly. Went up to Min. for some Darkness, wish I woulda brought back a growler of this bacon grease.

Rustic black in appearance, with a nice creamy brown head that left small lacings. Smells of smoked ham and campfire.

Definitely had characteristics of smoked fish or bacon, but not over the top. Nice malt balance. Bitter chocolate is also mixed in with the flavors.The smoke flavors are light and not abrupt and thats what I like about this beer.
The alcohol is high, but well hidden.

This was a well balanced, medium bodied, well rounded beer.

12-19-2007 16:27:54 | More by Graham21
Photo of Chasmill70


4.61/5  rDev +12.7%

a- Thick, tan head persists well. Black color.

s - Smoke and dark fruit. Malty sweetness. Really nice aroma that starts by overpowering smoke but moves to the Baltic porter character.

t - Taste is similar to smell...on first sip I thought it was WAY too smoke forward. But each sip after seemed more and more balanced. The smoke perfectly compliments the dark fruit, roast, and malt.

m - The highlight of the beer. It's rich and velvety.

o - This is a darn good Raucbier! It really hides the 8% alcohol, which could be dangerous in a bomber. I'm glad I gave it a chance beyond the first sip...each sip has been better than the last!

04-17-2014 01:41:12 | More by Chasmill70
Photo of copyguyadam


4.6/5  rDev +12.5%

First review even though I've been a BA for over a year... just wanted to get a good selection of styles in my belly before sharing my opinion. Found this rare bottle by way of "friending" my favorite liquor store on Facebook.
Let my wife have a sip (she's not a BA) and she said "mmm" and smiled.

Served via bomber into a Duvel Tulip.

A = Nice and dark, not too much head. Just right.
S = Hint of smoke. Kind of sweet... in a good way for me.
T = Warmed up nice and smoke was perfectly placed.
M = When the smoke kicks in, you don't want to swallow. I could brush my teeth with this.
D = Would prefer a smaller bottle. Seems like a lot. Took 1.5 hours to finish this big boy. I will buy this again if Surly releases it.

Another example of Surly showing us why we love them.

05-09-2010 00:24:52 | More by copyguyadam
Photo of mtullius


4.6/5  rDev +12.5%

Had it on release night at the Muddy Pig, and a couple days later at the Happy Gnome.

Black and intriguing in appearance.

You'll want to take your time and really smell this one: yep, that's a bit of bacon, mixed in there with port wine, and general dark malty goodness.

You should take your time drinking it, too, though that's hard to do-- it gets better as it warms (and it was served quite cold both times I had it). Definite smoke character, but it's subtle (thank goodness). Dark fruit, dark chocolate, all kinds of dark and mysterious flavors happening in this beer.

I found the mouthfeel very satisfying-- appropriately chewy for such a high-alcohol, high-complexity brew.

This is highly drinkable, dangerous even. Another triumph for the geniuses at Surly. Bring on the "two"!!

12-12-2007 04:42:39 | More by mtullius
Photo of KarlHungus


4.6/5  rDev +12.5%

I had this on tap at Cafe Twenty Eight. This beer is an opaque black color. The head was small when the beer arrived, but a nice cap of lacing lasted until the beer was gone. The aroma is immense. Smoke bacon, maple syrup, burnt caramel, and bitter chocolate. The taste is as large as the aroma. The smoked flavors are prevalent, but are well balanced with the beers other attributes. The mouthfeel is full bodied, silky in texture, and has light carbonation. Overall, this is a beer to contemplate. I would certainly drink this again.

12-23-2007 03:08:37 | More by KarlHungus
Photo of kbutler1


4.6/5  rDev +12.5%

Had this at the release party at Brasa's on 11/30/09. Was poured from tap into a 10oz glass. Little to no head was a little bit of a dissappointment, not sure if that was caused by the pour or if it is just that way. Needless to say, the lack of head hindered the aroma of the beer a little. Smelled of slight smoke and a subtle sweetness. What a taste though! Very smooth with a slight smoke taste that ends with a subtle sweetness, just like the smell I guess. Very drinkable! With a name like Smoke, I was expecting a Smoked Porter taste but was pleasantly surprised. This is an extremely good beer. Love to see it in bottle or can...

12-01-2009 23:37:32 | More by kbutler1
Photo of alexgash


4.6/5  rDev +12.5%

750 ml bottle. 2010 vintage.

Pours a dark, inky brown-black. Sticky, dense, khaki brown head. Good lacing. Wonderful nose of peaty, smoky, meaty, roasty, caramel-y, coffeeish malts. Well-balanced and very inviting.

Roasted, toasted malt up front. Light coffee bitterness is there as well. Palate soon swells with a mix of sweet and smoky. Smoked meats, campfire, and peat blend nicely with caramel, dark fruits, and chocolate. Long finish with lingering smoke and chocolate-caramel. Roasted bitterness is there is well. Medium-full body with a chewy, yet creamy feel. Delicious!

01-01-2012 02:08:06 | More by alexgash
Photo of Buebie


4.58/5  rDev +12%

Got a 2nd chance to review this, the first being on tap, this one from a growler filled 12/30/08.

Poured from my growler into an oversized snifter. Color is all blackout out, with a 1 finger fizzy brown head. Thin greasy brown streaks of lcae are left behind. A small thin layer of retention sits atop the beer.

Aroma is quit toasty with charred oak. It smeels like burnt buttered wheat toast.
Ceral grains, wiffs of dark chocolate and smokey burnt wood. It smells like a summer sausage.

Mouthfeel this time around is much more smooth and creamy. Its somwhat thick with a mellow amount of carbonation up front. Kind of a summer sausage like flavor, not so much the meat, but the smokey skin on weiner flavors. Slight resemblance here folks, dont let this tidbit ruin it for you.
Molasses flavors, some dark fruit and a hint of cherries. Smokey charred oak comes out through the swallow. Lingering after the swallow with a bittering dark roastiness.

Very good, much better then my plastic cup at the brewery. No signs of alcahol at the knose, but some mild warming comes around after the swallow with the lingering bitterness.

01-02-2009 19:41:08 | More by Buebie
Photo of homebrew311


4.58/5  rDev +12%

Received as a kick ass extra from millah!! Hell yeah... what better beer to crack for the Lost finale!

A: Pours black with very little head and a slight bit of light passing through, a little bit of lacing

S: roasted barley, smoke, coffee, roasted notes, very malty and little hops

T: lots of roasted barley on the front, lots of classic porter/stout roastiness in there with the added dimension of hickory and smoke. The smoke is most prevalent on the finish with a touch of chocolatey sweetness

MF: medium body, seems on par for a baltic porter brewed with lager yeast, medium carbonation

D: a nice showcase of roasted and smoked malts, everything is in nice balance, the ABV is undetectable. I am convinced that Surly is incapable of brewing a beer that is anything less than spectacular.

05-24-2010 00:51:46 | More by homebrew311
Photo of lhaqq


4.58/5  rDev +12%

A: Opaque black-brown body with a thin off white head.

S: Dark malts, bittersweet chocolate, good smell but not too strong.

T: Grains and malt, some smoke and oak, bitter coffee finish.

M: For the abv, it's surprisingly light. Packs a lot of flavor without being too heavy.

D: Good flavor and body with a high abv but still easy to drink.

12-15-2010 21:33:44 | More by lhaqq
Photo of jgagne


4.58/5  rDev +12%

Poured into 16 oz Funky Buddha Snifter

A- pours an opaque, oil jet black. With a nice dark brown head.

S- at the nose you get an amazing bacon, chipotle, and maple wood scent. Real intense smokey smell. Impressive.

T-great, rich tastes just layer this beer. I get intense smoke flavors with a nice under layer of dark fruit.

M- thick delicious leathery body layers your mouth. heavy and mildly carbonated.

O-another really impressive beer by Surly. Very unique and delectable. As far as smoked beers go you probably can't find a better example. World class.

01-25-2012 01:34:39 | More by jgagne
Photo of bwiechmann


4.53/5  rDev +10.8%

On tap at Stub and Herbs

A- Pours nearly pitch-black. No substantial head to speak of, minimal lacing.

S- Perfect. Wood smoke ballanced with roasted, sweet malts. A touch of hops provide some earth-notes.

T- Wood smoke is here too, but certainly not over-done. Most akin to smoked, pulled pork. A touch of espresso in the background.

M- Not oily, but smooth. Medium body and carbonation.

D- alcohol is unnoticeable- very drinkable.

This beer is absolutely a treat. Surly scores again. Get your hands on some if you can.

04-09-2010 16:20:57 | More by bwiechmann
Photo of DarkerTheBetter


4.53/5  rDev +10.8%

Found at the Blue Nile. (reviewed from notes)

This beer pours a dark black with raisin highlights and a creamy ring of irregular cola-like head.

Smells of sweet, rich rauch smoke with a nice and subtle ham. There's some dark fruits and a dry dark chocolate, but it's sweetness holds back.

Tastes thick and creamy like chocolate milk with a sour snap of smokey grain. This is oddly reminiscent of a garden salad. There's a sour sting or tingle to this too of pungent rye bread.

Feels big, slick and frothy, but far from sticky. Nice.

It's really easy to forget this one's 9.5%. Watch out!

03-15-2008 02:11:50 | More by DarkerTheBetter
Photo of zulufactor


4.53/5  rDev +10.8%

750ml bottle, 2011

A- Dark brown or nearly black. Pours with a coffee brown head that leaves quickly not leaving a trace of its self behind.

S- Toasted malt with dark fruit and a bit earthy. kind of syrupy

T- The rich toasted malt hits right away. It quickly breaks down into toffee and coffee. The richness meets with a bit of hops that turns in to a crisp dry earthiness.

M- For being as thick as this beer is there is more carbonation then i was anticipating. It creates a great bright richness.

O- Surly struck a balance of richness and brightness that is fantastic. There are some thing lingering in there, a complexity that my less experienced palette can quite put a name to.

01-01-2012 03:41:34 | More by zulufactor
Photo of ryancl


4.5/5  rDev +10%

08-02-2012 21:19:00 | More by ryancl
Photo of SjConroy


4.5/5  rDev +10%

02-24-2014 21:29:52 | More by SjConroy
Photo of mtpHokie

South Carolina

4.5/5  rDev +10%

04-17-2013 14:16:31 | More by mtpHokie
Smoke from Surly Brewing Company
91 out of 100 based on 716 ratings.