Taps: 19 / Bottles: -
Cask: Y / Beer-to-Go: N
Ratings: 27 | Reviews: 26 | Show All Ratings:
4.7/5 rDev +7.8%
vibe: 5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 5 | $$
I really had my doubts about this place since it is a cigar bar and I am allergic to tobacco smoke, but I am sure glad that I stopped here with some of the Madison BA gang. Walked in to a dimly lit social club kond of feeling place. Many were smoking cigars and inbibing with their favorite adult beverage, but somehow I didn't really smell any smoke. Quite a feat. Maduro just feels comfortable to me. Many stools along the bar along with some table and chairs and more than a few leather couches. The perfect place to sit and relax with a beer and enjoy the company that you are with. Great beer selection that obviously is picked with the distinguishing beer drinker in mind. I had Aventinus and Pilgrim's Dole. Served a little cold for my taste, but that is really tough to avoid at a bar. Bartender was quick to help and very friendly. Everything was reasonably priced. I will definitely be back here next time I am in town.
06-30-2007 13:47:29 | More by JeffKrenner
4.45/5 rDev +2.1%
vibe: 5 | quality: 5 | service: 4 | selection: 4 | $
Maduro has that classic "discerning man's" (or woman's) atmosphere, with great cigars, wine, Scotch, and martinis in addition to a dozen or so great beers on tap. It's relaxing in a timeless way, with solo drinkers reading newspapers at the bar while groups relax on the couches in a jazzy ambience. I suspect the tap lines are ruthlessly cleaned here, because more than once I've tried a new beer at Maduro and found it outstanding, only to try it a second time somewhere else and find it not quite as good as I'd remembered (or maybe the great atmosphere just biases me). The women tending bar are wonderfully knowledgable. Rotating selection, although Bell's gets a well-deserved emphasis. Happy hour prices are phenomenally good.
05-08-2007 02:13:57 | More by Flyer
4.22/5 rDev -3.2%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4 | $$
Great atmosphere in this place, dim lights and comfortable couches to sit on. A very nice place to sit with friends and relax, and enjoy good beers and conversation. Beer quality was very good, beer all seemed to be fresh, and I think they rotate pretty often. Service was good as well, bar tender knew about products and was able to offer suggestions to those that wanted them. Selection was not massive, but it is a quality selection. Once again I'll say that they rotate enough that it should keep things interesting for you. Prices are very competitive, especially for its location. A great bar that I will continue to visit when I visit Madison.
04-01-2007 20:10:30 | More by badbeer
4.56/5 rDev +4.6%
vibe: 5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | $$
When we first walked into this place I thought it was closed, but I guess it's just dimly lit, but with the couches and relaxed atmosphere it was awsome! We were able to talk between ourselves and have great conversations. There wasn't too many people there, the smoke was sweet and smelled like the best cigars! The beer was great and the service was quick. The selection was pretty good, I got a Bell's Two-Hearted on cask, and a Saint Bernardus 8. Overall the experience was great, I will definetly be going back.
02-11-2007 14:47:39 | More by Erdinger2003
4.56/5 rDev +4.6%
vibe: 5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | $$
This was a very narrow and not terribly deep establishment, so it there is an event that you are planning to attend, I recommend arriving early. Two big glass panes flanked the doorway that opened onto the wood bar to the left. Black leather couches, coffee tables, and vintage advertising on the wall dominated the right side. Just inside the door, on a buttonhook right, were a couple of high tables and stools as well as a green (not black) board. All of the way aft was a short, red velvet-lined stage for bands that perform twice a week. Beyond the bar, headed aft, was a humidor and beyond that, still on the left, were the washrooms, as well as a small reading library. Couple all of that with a pressed tin ceiling and exposed ducting and I ask you, whats not to like?
The back bar featured an impressive array of wines and liquors (or so I was told). They also had an equally impressive lineup of eighteen taps, including five Belgians, five Bells, three Lake Louie, Victory, and New Holland. I was further told that their mixed drinks are kick ass.
01-08-2007 11:05:10 | More by woodychandler
4.5/5 rDev +3.2%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | $$$
Maduro is a beautiful little cigar bar tucked away on Main street just a block from the Great Dane, and within walking distance of several other great restaurants.
From the black leather love seats and sofas to the brown tin-ceiling, this place is just slathered in style. Be sure to take a look at the tiled bar!
Beyond that, they bands are great, and the cigar and drink selections are more than adequate. I should warn you, however, it is a cigar bar, and it will be smoky. You can try that rare single malt scotch if you'd like, but your senses will probably be at least a little bit numb. That said, you're certainly not going to do to well with beer. However, I have been in early and found no one smoking at all, so who knows.
There are 18 taps and a cask, although I'm not sure how often they use it. Of the local beers they had on tap during my last visit, 5 were Bell's/Kalamazoo, and 1 was from New Holland (Dragon's Milk... at least it's a real good choice). The rest were imports, mostly Belgian and English with a few very good choices - nothing truly ordinary.
The service is great and the bathrooms are clean, what else can you ask for?
01-07-2007 17:47:46 | More by NeroFiddled
3.71/5 rDev -14.9%
vibe: 3 | quality: 3.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4 | $$
It was very smoky but has an excellent beer selection on tap which is rare in city of Madison. I had the Bell's Cream Stout hhhmmmm Cream Stout. They had a number of good beers on tap but the Bell's was the only Stout and I wanted either a Stout or Porter. The ambiance is nice with a smattering of just about every group in the bar at 10:30pm on a Saturday night, just be aware this is a cigar bar and there is much smoke from them there cigars. They also have a great selection of high octane liquors and wine for your choosing.
12-19-2006 18:41:08 | More by Musky
4.36/5 rDev 0%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4 | $$
A must for any visitor, and maybe the new best beer stop in Madison.
After being dissapointed by the Dane's mediocrity and stuffed with Come Back Inn's good beer and alright German fare, we capped the evening off at Maduro.
At 8:00 on a Saturday, there were about 10 other patrons there and it was warm enough to have the door open (which is probably why the smoke levels were quite tolerable). The music was good, classy, and at a sensible volume.
The bartender was very friendly and seemed knowledgeable. We were only getting one round. Although there were many high quality beers on the list, our decision was quite easy: Bell's Hell Hath No Fury, and New Holland's Barrel-Aged Pilgrim's Dole. The Bell's was in a nice chalice, and while quite good, it seemed to be going slightly south and taking on a sourness. The Dole was served in something like a 16oz water glass. Not the most pleasing glass, but a very pleasing volume of this strong and lovely beer. These two top shelf high gravity beers were $4 each, which is a great deal.
We sat on the comfy couch and leasuirely sipped our beers.
This is the place to go whether you want a relaxed, conversation friendly atmosphere or just want the best draft list in town.
10-15-2006 01:55:22 | More by Tbone
4.44/5 rDev +1.8%
vibe: 4 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 5 | $$
After reading the reviews here, I made a bee line for this place downtown with my wife.
It's a little different than I expected. It's much more worn in than their online pictures show. It was smaller than I thought. Quite narrow. There is a long bar on one side, a walk way down the middle, and not quite enough sofas on the other side.
The bartender was absolutely swamped. He had to do everything, include leave the bar to take orders outside. However, the bartender was completely friendly, extremely well versed in the beers, and would dote on you (which helped cause some delays).
In fact, after I got my first beer, I watched him come and go with this one pint of Guinness. He would pour it extremely slow for 10 seconds, and then leave to take someone's order. Later, he'd come back and do the same thing. 5 minutes later when it was finally full, he was able to "draw" a design of a 4-leaf clover into the foam with the last slow trickle of beer from the tap. He handed the beer to the customer and said, "As you requested".
Behind the bar is a looter's dream. Shelves and shelves of top notch liquor. All I could see were rows and rows of "8" and "12" shining back at me, denoting their years. Check out their web site for their huge list in PDF format.
At first, I was a little disappointed in their beer selection that night. Only because I wanted to try out their Bell's Two Hearted on Cask. They had nothing cask conditioned. I then wanted to try their St. Bernadus on tap, and they didn't have that either. So I had to console myself to their monstrous chalk board of 20 beers on tap! Silly me for reading the reviews here and expecting certain brands. They do swap out often, and in the end, that was a great thing.
I had some great beers here, starting with Urthel's Tripel. Best tripel I've ever had, and was recommended by the bartender. The bartender uses the correct glassware for the right beer every time. I was a little disappointed by the half pours I was getting. Mostly because that's not what I'm used to, but also because it took a long time for the bartender to get back to you. However, don't let that put you off, when I got the first bill of only $9 for 3 beers, it suddenly made sense. These are great prices for craft brews.
It is a cigar bar, and despite some of the other reviews, I found it quite smoky in there. However, it doesn't take long to get use to, and who am I to complain - I was smoking one by the end of the night anyway.
We did catch their Rat Pack music on Friday night. The guy futzed with his equipment forever and started 45 minutes late. Some of the songs were decent, and it definitely fits the theme and class act of this bar. It's just too bad the singer was obviously burned out doing the same thing for who knows how long.
I caught a lot of conversation while sitting at the bar. Someone asked about food, and the bartender explained that a lot of the local restaurants on the block liked to deliver food right to the bar, all he asked was that you tip them very nicely for the extra effort.
The variety of people in this bar was huge. Early in the afternoon there were mostly older gentlemen that looked quite comfortable with a cigar in their mouth. By midnight, the majority were much younger, trying to look cool with a cigar in their mouth. It seemed like everyone was there for deep conversation, and it's a very comfortable, relaxed place.
10-10-2006 19:29:24 | More by terrabyte
4.36/5 rDev 0%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4.5 | $
Maduro was a wonderful prize at the end of our Madison beer tour.
The space is a single room with large open windows on either side of a central door. Exposed brick walls, painted tin ceiling. Long bar along the left side with hefty wooden shelves stocked with top shelf liquor of all varieties. Cozy black leather couches on the right hand side and several tables and chairs. An organ or piano tucked into a back corner. Mostly candle lit. Cigar smoke that is present but not overwhelming around 10pm on a Saturday night. Also some tables on the sidewalk out front under red christmas lights. Very pleasant atmosphere. (especially having just come up the hill from the Essen Haus!)
The tap list was excellent and displayed on a chalkboard centered behind the bar: the standouts were Hell Hath no Fury and an Oak Aged Pilgrams Dole (both $4, Hell hath in a St Bernadus goblet and the Dole in a pint glass). The Hell hath was perhaps a bit off (or not as good as it was when we had it a couple months ago at the Map Room in Chicago) but the Pilgram's Dole was exquisite! Lovely oak and warm vanilla sweetness.
Rest of beer list was quite the selection: Einbecker Pils, Spaten Lager, Erdinger Weiss, Bells Oberon, Lake Louie Scotch, Bells Pale, Lindemanns Pomme, New Holland Black Tulip, St Lous' Framboise, Ale Asylum Trippel, Hitacho White, Echt Kriekbier, Urthel Hop-it and Heavy Handed on Cask (also Boddingtons, Guinness, Magners).
Service was fine -- almost everyone was drinking beer, and the bartender seemed to do a good job describing the styles to novices.
No food, but someone at the bar had a very nice plate of Sushi delivered (on a plate even).
This gets my pick as my favorite beer destination in the Madison area.
I was also favorably impressed by Quivey's which I had not been to before. Great to have two new wonderful destinations for beer travels.
10-08-2006 21:03:48 | More by 4thoseabout2bock
Maduro in Madison, WI
95 out of 100 based on 27 ratings.