1. Extreme Beer Fest. March 20 & 21, 2015 in Boston, Mass. Join us!
  2. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  3. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Pitcher's Pub

Not Rated.
Pitcher's PubPitcher's Pub
BA SCORE
95
world-class

37 Ratings
Ratings: 37
Reviews: 37
rAvg: 4.31
pDev: 11.14%
Taps: 22
Bottles: 30
Cask: Y
Beer-to-Go: N
[ Bar, Eatery ]

120 Manville Hill Rd
Cumberland, Rhode Island, 02864-2334
United States
phone: (401) 658-0058
// CLOSED //



Notes:
None, yet.

(Place added by: Beerguy on 06-08-2006)
Place: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
« first ‹ prev | 1-25 | 26-50  | next › last »
Ratings: 37 | Reviews: 37 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by RunawayJim:
Photo of RunawayJim
3.83/5  rDev -11.1%

Went for the first time last night. The place is tiny and in the middle of nowhere - kind of out of the way for me. They had a good selection of beers, though there was a Bud Light tap handle mixed in with the craft beer. They had some German, Belgian, and American craft beers on tap (about 12 taps total it seemed). I had an Unearthly IPA and a Berkshire Coffeehouse Porter. Both tasted good and fresh.

My only complaint is that the bartender seemed disinterested in helping me. Several of the tap handles were turned so the labels were facing the bartender and not the customers. I found that annoying and she didn't seem overly interested in reading them to me.

The atmosphere was OK, kind of like a sports bar. There was no music playing when I got there, but some started later on. Last call was at midnight, which I am not used to, but considering it really is in the middle of nowhere, I don't imagine they get overly packed on a regular basis.

RunawayJim, Apr 04, 2008
More User Reviews:
Photo of mnewsom
4/5  rDev -7.2%

Sadly, this pub has shut down. Anyone know the story? Hopefully reopening in new location? Tweet me @louvanpr if any news. Thanks.

I always had a good time there, too bad it was something of a far drive for me. I always loved beer selection and anticipated what they would have new on tap. I see I have to type some more in order to get up to 500 characters, so here goes! I also like Doherty's in Pawtucket and track 84 in Warwick. Mews Tavern in Wakefield of course. Cambridge, Mass has some awesome joints!

mnewsom, May 27, 2011
Photo of Chincino
4.36/5  rDev +1.2%

I've gone to Pitcher's Pub a couple of times and each time has been a good experience.

They have some good beer reads such as the Yankee Brew News to read and they offer table games and trivia if you want to play a game while you're there. The atmosphere is very relaxing and has a local bar feel to it.

The beer selection is good. I had a Clown Shoes Tramp Stamp and a Lagunitas Little Sumthin Sumthin. I tried part of a sample of the Lagunitas Brown Shugga.

This place is a great spot to just hang out and try some good beer and watch a game.

Chincino, Feb 19, 2011
Photo of Fernans
4.28/5  rDev -0.7%

A hidden gem to say the least. Out of the way compared to other locations. 24 brews on tap that rotate through the seasons. Something new and interesting. Micros from all over the place. My only quibble is the infrequency of cask beer, but that's minor. Atmosphere is real local, if you go there more than once you'll see the same faces. The exterior does set low expectations (since it looks like ranch style house) but the interior will surprise. The Staff is helpful and tentative. Selection always changes and fresh. Food is very good considering the kitchen is the size of a closet. For top notch micros, it's a great value. Just the kind of unpretentious place to enjoy great beer. Cheers!

Fernans, Dec 29, 2010
Photo of coachdonovan
3.9/5  rDev -9.5%

Pitcher's doesn't look like much from the outside, but once you walk in the door it has a nice feel to it... almost like a family restaurant. The relatively small space is cut in half- bar on the left, tables on the right.

My first (and so far, only) visit was on a Southern Tier promo night, so I can't fairly judge the draft selection, since at least 10 were dedicated to ST that night. But the other taps included a couple from BBC and Left Hand Milk Stout (on nitro). They have a hand pump as well. I quickly looked over the bottle list and was surprised to find some things you don't often see. (And yes, there is Bud Light on tap also.)

I only had a few bites of a burger and fries, but they were good. Menu was mostly bar food - sandwiches, appetizers, etc.

I look forward to going back again when it's not so crowded, so I can sample some more food and more thoroughly explore their complete beer list.

coachdonovan, Apr 30, 2010
Photo of Samichlaus
4.22/5  rDev -2.1%

What a treat hidden in the woods of Cumberland! I always wanted to check this place out and finally got the chance a few weeks ago with some friends who are locals (Woonsocket area). Beer selection is fantastic. Great pub food. Always a great live musician strumming away and singing his heart out. Great crowed of people. Bartenders are always friendly. Atmosphere as far as adornments is typical but the energy in here is so high that it just makes for a great experience. Loud and fun without being a college bar (College bars piss me off pretty quick). Every time I've been we lose track of time and end up closing the place. Worth a trip from wherever you are!

Samichlaus, Apr 25, 2010
Photo of donway
4.03/5  rDev -6.5%

Drove to Cumberland RI from Worcester MA to meet a friend for a few cold ones last Friday, chose Pitcher's Pub based on location, reviews and beer selection. Was not disappointed.

Was very "Cheers" like. Mostly a middle-aged crowd, some younger folks as well, generally seemed to know each other. A large screen TV at bar and a couple smaller TVs in the seating area.

Young ladies tending bar were attractive and attentive, didn't have to wait long between drinks despite the capacity (small facility) crowd. Reasonable blend of micro brews and brand beers. Didn't experiment much, happy with the $4 Ithaca Apricot Wheat. When killed that keg, had an unknown Belgian that was stronger.

Limited, but adequate, food selection, mostly sandwhiches, good quality.

Will return for more.

July 2011-surprised in the Information Age there is nothing posted online that discusses the status of Pitcher's, what the problem is and whether/when it will reopen. I miss it.

donway, Jan 12, 2010
Photo of BrewMasterG
4.15/5  rDev -3.7%

Pitcher's Pub is my home away from home. They are constantly rotating the taps to provide a great selection of local, and regoinal brews. The food is great pub food - don't miss the blue cheese burger and onion rings!

Almost weekly, they have brewers and/or reps in for tasting events.

Pitcher's has a great local feel to it and one of both of the owners are there quite often.

The staff is great - though a bit overwhelmed as the place is almost always packed. The place seats about 50 so get there early - but get there often.

BrewMasterG, Jan 07, 2010
Photo of mostpoetsdo
4.68/5  rDev +8.6%

Was in Northern RI, where there is NOTHING for good beer. If you want good beer you have to go into downtown Providence, or South County (the Mews). Saw this place while looking on BA, then found it again on a friend's phone, and by word of mouth by another friend. Had to check it out.

Great atmosphere. It was a Saturday night, mostly young crowd, college to college grad majority. Small place, I'd like to refer to it as a "house party with good beer." Lot's of cool micro brew signs and such.

Great service, no matter how packed it gets. Helpful too, if you don't know what you want. They even let you sample to see if you want a pint of a specific beer.

Standard bar food. Friends ate, I just stuck to the beer, but everything looked good, and nice portions.

Quality and Selection were excellent, counted 20 great micro brews on tap. Had a lot from Berkshire Brewing Company, some Ithaca, Wachusetts, and various others. There is also a large list of bottles and bombers. I stuck to BBC: Shabadoo on nitro, Imperial Stout, and Holidale. All were excellent and served in pretty much correct glassware (a major plus, especially considering the size of the place).

This place is fantastic. Other reviews call Pitcher's Pub a "hidden gem" and I can't agree more. Great prices, atmosphere and beer. This will be my bar of choice when in Northern RI.

mostpoetsdo, Dec 27, 2009
Photo of GJ40
3.6/5  rDev -16.5%

I've been meaning to check out Pitcher's Pub but given its somewhat remote location, it's taken me a while. But I finally made it. Pitcher's Pub is a local watering hole that has added a bunch of taps for craft beer. It's similar in concept to Doherty's and Track 84.

The atmosphere is busy with lots of people that appear to be local and regulars. The decor is nothing special but it's sufficient. The room isn't that big and fills up pretty easily.

The beer selection includes local New England beers, a few other US beers and some imports. I'm guessing there were about 20 taps with at least as many in the bottle. They also had a beer engine for hand pulled beers but I didn't get to ask if they had anything on. I went with a Blue Point Hopticle Illusion and it was nice and fresh.

Pitcher's Pub is basically a BMC sports pub with a craft beer selection. If it was local to me, I'd go but otherwise it's not really worth the effort to get there. It's got a decent selection but it lacks the selection and atmosphere of better beer bars.

GJ40, Sep 30, 2009
Photo of PawtucketPat
4.58/5  rDev +6.3%

First, I'm not a regular here but I do stop in frequently (at least once a week). I started coming to Pitcher's about two years ago and it's now my local pub to have a beer and watch a game.

The beer: the rotation is constantly changing, always keeping it interesting. The pours are in the correct glassware (or close to it) and the prices are unheard of, especially for Belegian imports.

The staff: always willing to help with your beer decision and are attentive. At times, when the pub is crowded, you can get lost in the crowd. I've had a chance to speak to the owner's, Mark & Frank and they are great friendly guys.

The food: it's a small place and they have a basic menu but it does not disappoint. I suggest the ribeye steak sandwich, it is worth every cent.

PawtucketPat, Jul 23, 2009
Photo of lrwells
3.98/5  rDev -7.7%

Saw this place had good reviews on here, so I decided to check it out. They had an okay beer list, not as much it seemed fom their ratings, but they did have some quality selections. The food was okay, typical bar food. I wasn't crazy about the atmosphere though, maybe it was just that I went on Friday night when they bar was busy. Seemed like it was a neighborhood bar, though, so that was cool. Even though Cumberland's not my neighborhood. Would go there again, definitely better than you avergage Bud/Miller Lite bars.

lrwells, Mar 13, 2009
Photo of kevd193213
4.33/5  rDev +0.5%

Found this hidden gem while driving around the northern part of RI. As we pulled up and spotted a tiny bar, I was getting ready to feel the wrath of my wife for suggesting we drive 40 minutes to check it out, but when we opened the door I immediately knew it would be worth it. A nice crowd was present, along with an acoustic one man band who was pretty good. Twenty two domestic and international taps greeted us (Left Hand, Storm, Ayinger, Speakeasy, Avery and many more), as well as a cask of Ipswich IPA they had tapped for the evening. They also had a long list of bottles. No beer menu available, but the bartender pointed out the draft and bottle menus on the walls. Decent pub fare and I washed it down with some west coast brews. They also have a couple of meads available. The staff were cool even though the place was packed, and both owners seemed to know everyone besides us in the place, but we weren't treated as outsiders, which has happened to me a few other times I walked into a neighborhood bar in search of some fine beer. I also liked that it was an older crowd (at 31 I was one of the younger ones in the place), instead of the Mews where you have to deal with obnoxious college kids while enjoying your beer. Would definitely go back when I am in that part of the state again.

kevd193213, Dec 05, 2008
Photo of SUjunkie
4.03/5  rDev -6.5%

Pitcher's is a hidden gem in Cumberland, RI. I have gone here a few times over the past year and it is my favorite place in RI to go when looking for a good Belgian.
With 22 taps the owners focus is on getting quality beer. They also have a good mix of hoppy, malty, darks, lights beers. Last night for instance they had Tripel Karmeliet, Scaldis Noel, Brooklyn Winter, BBC Steel Rail, a Belgian Brown, a couple options from Clipper City and many more. They had ST Cuvee Series 1 in bottle.
Frank (one of the owners) was there to talk beer. He is very knowledgeable and friendly. Mentioned they have a lot of Winter/Stouts kegs in the basement waiting to be tapped (ST Creme Brulee, Hoppin' Frog, etc.).
I always end up chatting with patrons at the bar. The bar has a very neighborly feel. This is the reason I come here more often as it is always crowded and my friends and I always have a great time talkin' beer with the 'regulars'.
The food is okay. It's your typical pub fare of nachos, wings, burgers and wraps. Nothing fancy, but the portions are large. It's not like you come here for the food.
A great place that everyone should check out when they are in the RI area.

SUjunkie, Nov 26, 2008
Photo of BeTheBall
4.15/5  rDev -3.7%

Went with my wife last Saturday (5/31) while on a shopping trip to Yankee Spirits. I had read about the place here on BA, and had been looking forward to trying it. We got there about 5:30, and got two seats at the bar.
Nice three sided bar with taps in one corner; various tables in the rest of the space; which is not big, but adequate. Immediately struck up a conversation with two guys that were leaving; talked about Cooperstown, cellaring, etc. Every person or group on both sides of us, which all seemed to know each other (where were Cliff and Norm?), all very friendly and made us feel like home; even the scratch golfer drinking Mich Ultra next to us.
Great deal there, six 7 oz. beers for $8.00; yikes! My wife got one and it is lots of beer for sure to be served at once. One guy who was leaving even said he decided to stay to watch her try to finish all those glasses.
They had about 20 taps I think, including the Scaldis that Frank tapped while we were there. St. Bernardus Abt 12 was in house, some nice Leffe Brown, Rogue Chocolate Stout, and many that frankly I can't remember. OK, not a world class selection, but far, far better than usual. Worth the 30 mile drive for sure.
We first ate nachos; there were so many that the 2 of us couldn't finish them without the threat of ruining dinner and more beers. I ordered their steak sandwich with fries, my wife had a burger. Sandwich was excellent; nice and juicy, and the fries were really good. Great pub food.
My wife had one or two beers plus the $8.00 sampler, I had 4-5 beers; the burger, nachos and steak sandwich and our bill was about $60! Wow, if this were Boston it would have been $110, and free parking to boot! A keeper. Thanks Frank and company for a fun evening.

BeTheBall, Jun 09, 2008
Photo of berserka
4.05/5  rDev -6%

Went to Pitchers Pub last night. Overall, I really liked it. Great selection of beers, comfortable environment, good food. One problem was there was no beer menu. The waitress had a list of what they had on tap written on the back of her order pad. We were told they didn't print a beer menu because the selections changed on a daily basis. I think it's great that they have such a variety and continuously turnover new and different kegs, but how hard would it be to keep a list of beers they have in a word document, with a brief description of the style and where they are from, and print it up every day. I think its a reasonable suggestion. Especially since the waitress, while very sweet, had no clue about any of the beers and couldn't tell you a thing about them.
Anyway, I had an awesome Belgium (St. Bernardus) and a Hazed and Infused Pale Ale. The pale ale was so fresh, it tasted like the hop flowers were just put in.
Another big plus for this place is the prices. The beers that I drank were in the $4 to $5 range. About the same as a gallon of gas, but a lot better tasting.
I still like Track 84 better.

berserka, Jun 02, 2008
Photo of iluvbeer67
3.25/5  rDev -24.6%

Have heard alot about this place so i had to make the trip. Overall I think its a good place, but not great. The service was more then a bit slow (I sat there waiting for a beer several times) The selection was very good with lots of craft on draft and plenty in the bottle (not all on hand though). I had a corned beef sandwich which i would not recommend and the fries were cold. The atmosphere was that of your typical local pub and the place was clean but a little unkept. Overall I thought it was a good local pub with an outstanding selection but rather poor food and service. I will go back again, just not when hungry.

iluvbeer67, Apr 05, 2008
Photo of auxiliary
4/5  rDev -7.2%

Bout time I came here. It took a day of a Cisco to have a keg of Cisco Blond for me to come down. Only one in the state from what I was told.

Decent selection, I have to compare it to track 84. I think track that day had a better selection.

Place was hopping, most of the time track is not.

I didn't try the food, but I saw some and it looked tastety.

Bartenders were friendly.

East place to find, kinda out of my way though. I would stop by again to try some stuff, maybe in the summer I will drive up.

auxiliary, Apr 04, 2008
Photo of BeerRay
4.83/5  rDev +12.1%

The best beer bar in Rhode Island! They have 21 craft beers on tap at all times, as well as a good selection of bottled beers. They usually have 3 or more Belgian beers on tap. I believe they will have a cask ale beer engine soon too.

Although places like The Muse in southern Rhode Island do have more taps, they don't change the selection often. This place changes one or more beers almost daily. They also have great bar food. The owners are very knowledgeable and friendly. This is a great place to hang out and try a new beer.

BeerRay, Apr 02, 2008
Photo of Jwale73
4.4/5  rDev +2.1%

Visited Pitcher's on a Saturday afternoon. I've been wanting to hit this place for a while and the opportunity finally presented itself. About 3 miles off of exit 10 on 295N, it's pretty easy to get too. Not a large place, but nice tavern atmosphere. Lots of wood and good sized bar. Tap list was outstanding, so I didn't even check the bottle list:

Left Hand Milk Stout & Saw Tooth
Cisco Grey Lady
Kasteelbier Brune
Guinness
Duchesse De Bourgogne
Newport Storm Blueberry
Great Divide DPA
BBC Coffee House Porter
Ten Penny Scottish Ale
Leffe Brown
Z Street Mocha Java Stout
Avery Maharaja & Ellie's Brown
Narragansett Bock
Magic Hat Irish Red
Leinenkugel Sunset Wheat
Heavy Seas Loose Cannon

Hearty pub fare - had the Calamari, Nachos and a Burger. All reasonably priced and very satisfying. Service was excellent. The bartender/waitress was very friendly and attentive and used style appropriate glassware when she served us.

Great experience and definitely plan on going back again soon.

Jwale73, Mar 30, 2008
Photo of fleurbier
4.83/5  rDev +12.1%

What can I say? I have been going to Pitcher's for a little under a year now and can't get enough. With 22 taps, 20 of which are non generic beers, Pitcher's offers a variety of beers and beer styles. From the hoppiest of beers to the maltiest, from the white ales to the dark, Pitcher's has what you are looking for. Can't find it on tap....just ask! There is a good chance they have it in a bottle. Along with the wide selection of beer, the owners and staff are very friendly and beer connoisseurs in their own right. The owners, who happen to work at the bar, are more than happy to explain the complexities of the beer you decide to drink. They are very knowledgable about the beer they bring into the bar. You can tell they are beer lovers by the expression on their face when someone tries their first Belgian or IPA.
The food is also something of a relic when it comes to Pitcher's. Along with the freshness and great taste, the portions are usually more than one can eat in one sitting. All in all, Pitcher's is definitely a place for a visit.

fleurbier, Feb 23, 2008
Photo of ThirstyBird
4.85/5  rDev +12.5%

Pitcher's Pub is a fantastic place that is run by great people! I first found out about Pitcher's about a year ago - it is a little difficult for me to get to from Providence so I only make it there occasionally but always look forward to the visits that I do make. They always have great Belgians on tap sometimes Germans too and they always have a nice selection of American craft brew.

The food is pub food but the burgers are hand made with fresh ground beef and the steak sandwich is awesome!

It's sometimes difficult to get a seat at the bar but that is for a good reason...

ThirstyBird, Feb 23, 2008
Photo of YankChef
4.72/5  rDev +9.5%

Pitcher's Pub was a little out of the way, but it is definitely worth the trip. They have about 20 taps of constantly rotating micro-brews, with a couple that are more popular and tend to be main stays. There is also a decent bottle selection if there isnt anything on tap that suits your fancy, but they had a lot of variety including DFH, Saison Dupont, Scaldis, Left Hand, Watou, and several others. Pretty much 50/50 between american and belgian which is nice. The owner and bartender were incredibly friendly and obviously passionate about beer.

YankChef, Jan 14, 2008
Photo of PoollShark
5/5  rDev +16%

I found this little gem of a beer bar about 2 months ago and have been there about 5 times since and I haven't been dissappointed once. 22 taps with an everchanging array of brews, if you can't find something here that you like then you don't like beer.
The owners and staff make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in the door. My latest visit on Sunday 10/7/07 was no different than the rest. I was happy to see one of my favorite brews on tap, Left Hand Brewery's Milk Stout and ordered one up immediately. Delicious is all i can say. I spied St. Bernardus ABT12 on another tap but decided to hold off on the higher ABV brews until i had some food in my stomach(always a good idea).
The food is above average pub fare with a good variety of choices. I ordered the colossal burger(minus the guacamole) and it was excellent and was served up with a large portion of fries. The food seemed fresh and was prepared the way I odered it(always a plus).
After my lunch I was ready for the ABT12 and this brew, which I've enjoyed many times from a bottle was even better on draft.
As far as the crowd goes, in all my visits I have found a friendly, sociable crowd of beer lovers there with the average age of the patrons appearing to be around 40ish. On this visit I was there to watch the Patriots game as well as the Red Sox playoff game and enjoy some great brews and some good company and I wasn't dissappointed in either respect.
All in all this is the spot to go in Rhode Island if you're a beer connoisseur

PoollShark, Oct 08, 2007
Photo of drinkmorebeer07
4.36/5  rDev +1.2%

Pitcher's is a great place to hang out and have a few really good beers. If you are into craft beers then this a place you need to check out. There selection of draft and bottled offerings is very good for a place their size and location. The atmosphere is very relaxing and often when I have been there was a live band playing. The prices are very reasonable for the quality of the beer. The service is very good and the owners are very personable and knowledgeable about their beer. I recommend a visit for some Quadruple Imperial or a Dead Guy Ale.

drinkmorebeer07, Apr 03, 2007
« first ‹ prev | 1-25 | 26-50  | next › last »
Pitcher's Pub in Cumberland, RI
95 out of 100 based on 37 ratings.