Smuttynose Winter Ale - Smuttynose Brewing Company
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 840 | Reviews: 469 | Display Reviews Only:
1/5 rDev -72.8%
Hazy deep brown color with amber highlights. Well retaining grayish head. Earthy barnyard scents on the nose with a faint hop presence. Some burnt toast on the nose as well. Something off putting about the nose already. Doesn't smell good.
Mouthfeel is slick and watery and flat. Taste is barely there with some burnt biscuit malt and seasonal spice. Barely perctable though with a pale finish and a slightly sweet after taste. Bready at best.
What is this? And is that style, a "dubbel" marked properly? I might've accepted this as a crappy winter warmer but a dubbel? No, severely dissapointing
12-13-2011 04:17:50 | More by jtierney89
2.03/5 rDev -44.8%
Sometimes a beer has kind of a vomit taste. Not full on vomit, just kind of. This was one of those times. It was from an hours-old growler. I've had a couple of other beers with that prominent flavor note, and once it was with a beer that did not normally have a vomit taste. Is it me? Or is it some particular thing that has gone wrong with the batch? I don't know. But with so many yet to try, I don't want to try this one again to find out.
01-02-2012 23:44:20 | More by BrownNut
2.05/5 rDev -44.3%
Oh hell no. This is a trainwreck of a beer. Looks ok translucent brown with a white head that dies too quick and little lacing. Smells of sweet spices a little raisin with a hint of green apple. The taste is not right I thought I might have got an off bottle but no after dumping the first bottle the second tasted the same. Slight burnt paper taste covered in sweet malt with a fruityness and cinnamon fake flavor. I guess it has a decent body and it is utterly near undrinkable.
02-17-2006 17:49:55 | More by Higravity
2.08/5 rDev -43.5%
A - Mid dark amber color. Head was small. Rminded me of poring some flat soda. Fizzled like a soda. Not much lase on it.
S - Hoppy smell to it, not too crazy about it.
T - Malt and hop taste to it, kinda of an odd taste, not to crazy about it.
M - Odd feel to it, just like the taste.
D - This on the low point of a Winter Ale. Not to crazy about it. I won't be drinking this again.
01-07-2007 22:45:51 | More by auxiliary
2.3/5 rDev -37.5%
A: Apperance is great, pours a dark reddish brown color good sized head, nice lacing.
S: I'm really trying here but it doesn't smell like much of anything. Maybe caramel sweetness in there??
T: Slightly sweet fruity flavor up front, earthy toward the end.
M: Medium bodied, good amount of carbonation.
D: Nice apperance and mouthfeel but where is the smell/taste with this one....very bland beer.
12-16-2010 02:43:37 | More by loren01
2.38/5 rDev -35.3%
I like Smuttynose brews, but this one was really disappointing to me. Supposedly a Dubbel, but seems very distantly related. Pours a very dark brown with a thin head. Spiciness dominates the nose. The spices don't seem to go with this beer, and there's an overwhelming bubble gum flavor that just cloys and annoys. Personally, I don't like the taste of bubble gum in my beer. There's also a cloying underlying sweetness, and the taste of the spices and bubble gum linger for an unpleasantly long time on the palate. A pretty poor offering for a winter ale from Smuttynose, and one that I find a chore to drink. There's many better choices to be made, and I'm surprised that Smuttynose chose this beer as their annual offering.
12-29-2005 20:51:15 | More by LarryV
2.53/5 rDev -31.3%
This beer was definitely the loser of our five tastings. Only one of our 11 drinkers gave it an overall rating over 3, and that was mostly because she enjoyed it more than any other winter ale. Most found it too sweet, with not enough bitterness to balance out. Some thought it was just undistinguished, with no clear flavor or identity.
Overall average: 2.6
02-29-2008 19:41:20 | More by lvbs
2.7/5 rDev -26.6%
Wolf. This is nasty. Reminds me of state watered down Ommegang abbey dubbel. The flavors are there, dried fruit, caramel, toffee, but it was thin and bitter. It was a pour, I just couldn't drink it. I'm normally a Smutty fan, but I think they severely missed the mark on this one.
12-12-2013 19:38:34 | More by taylor714914
2.73/5 rDev -25.8%
Smuttynose Winter Ale
Appearance- dark blood red with a thick head that quickly disappears.
Smell- cherries and cinnimon.
Taste- smooth cherry with a sh!tload of cinnimon maybe a dash of clove dumped in. Alcohol is present in the flavor.
Mouthfeel- smooth and warm. Very bland.
Overall- A incredibly bland ale! What little flavor is so watered down. This would be a decent Winter Ale if they kicked the flavor up a notch or two. Very disappointing from such a good brewery!
12-30-2005 18:29:57 | More by NJpadreFan
2.73/5 rDev -25.8%
Pouring this ale produces one inch of foamy, light tan head. The head is retained nicely before leaving a thin layer behind. The body is a very rich mahogany color displaying quite a bit of carbonation.
The nose is quite weak but it presents a rich, malty sweetness mixed with rich spices. Hops a very light but noticeable. Overall, this smells a bit like a holiday cookie but it lacks punch.
A maple syrup sweetness is briefly presented before a rich, bready taste. Nutmeg and hops mix for a little excitement but these flavors quickly fall flat. The finish is quite watery with lingering hops and spice. Some cocoa notes appear in the finish as it warms.
The moutheel is quite thin, oily and lacking carbonation.
Drinkability is okay but nothing too spectacular. A somewhat disappointing effort from a good brewery.
12-14-2006 00:10:03 | More by Budlum
2.73/5 rDev -25.8%
Pours out a slightly translucent brownish-red with a thin head of tan bubbles that disappears pretty quickly and with minimal lace. After that, the head is gone. For good. No bubbles at all.
Smell is bubblegum, banana, cotton candy, sugars, and a little bit medicinal.
Flavor is sweet, slightly phenolic, with bubblegum flavors and lots of banana coming through. Not the typical complex-dark-fruit-sweetness that I've come to expect from a dubbel. There's a decidedly toasty/bready malt flavor that sneaks through on the back end, but as I drink it, the lack of carbonation and complexity start to remind me of drinking a really flat cola. It was something of a struggle to finish it.
Overall: A disappointing offering, and I have loved a lot of Smutty's stuff. The phenolics, dead mouthfeel, and cloying sweetness of this one are just kind of off-putting. Not epically terrible, but I wouldn't give it to a good friend.
12-18-2005 04:01:41 | More by whartontallboy
2.75/5 rDev -25.3%
Poured from 33cl bottle into plastic party glass, unfortunately.
A: Dark brown, some head and lacing.
S: Caramel, toffee. Basic but pretty true to style.
T: Mostly caramel with a lot of hop bitterness. Feels pretty odd for the style, way too americanized. Beautiful Belgian yeast character.
M: Velvety but not sufficiently carbonated considering the low apparent carbonation.
Overall, an interesting beer but not really a traditional Dubbel. It is an American Dubbel, if there is such a style.
11-20-2011 07:10:49 | More by atlason
2.75/5 rDev -25.3%
pours a chestnut color with a half inch light tan head that quickly fades to the beer, some lace to start with that also quickly fades away. some aromas of caramel and roasted malt and a sharp scent of alcohol. taste is of roasted malt, slight caramel with some brown sugar.slightly oily slick mouthfeel, light to medium body with a carbonation that sort went flat. i don't think i'll be buying this beer again.
11-23-2007 17:05:15 | More by billybob
Smuttynose Winter Ale from Smuttynose Brewing Company
83 out of 100 based on 840 ratings.