Smuttynose Big A IPA - Smuttynose Brewing Company
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 1,497 | Reviews: 872 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by salvo:
4.15/5 rDev +4.3%
The Big Ass IPA is an extreme beer; no two ways about it. So I'm writing this extreme review: after taking notes on a freshly poured cold 12oz bottle, drinking a third when cold, then letting it warm slowly over an hour, tasting and note-taking every 10 minutes or so. The beer changes dramatically, and I wanted to try out a review like this. The review compresses time, but I think you get the idea.
Pours murky yellow-orange with lots of debris filling the glass under a two inch head. At fifteen minutes, there is still a finger of foamy head. 30 minutes and the surface remains covered in foam. The glass is etched and oily, and I can see how much was taken at each interval. At 30 minutes, most of the sediment is at the bottom. At an hour, the beer is nearly clear.
At first, the nose is all earthy, grassy hops with very little malt. Slowly, malt creeps into the nose: honey at 10 minutes, biscuit at 20, and hints of bread at half an hour. At an hour, I'm only smelling malt. Perhaps my palate is hopped out after all this time, but now the malts are really strong in the nose. There's a little BO in the background, too.
The taste starts really sharp and astringent with the cold beer. At 10 minutes, some sweetness emerges (honey) but still sharply astringent. 20: malts really begin asserting themselves with biscuit the dominant sweetness. At half an hour: the beer is really nicely balanced, just shy of room temperature and palpably cool but not cold. After an hour, the head is gone and the carbonation is just about dissipated which impacts the mouthfeel. Throughout, the astringency of the hops is almost mouth-numbing, and the finish of each sip is long and slow, with many different hops profiles emerging and falling away over time. Astringent, grassy, earthy, tea; sharp and pungent.
I enjoyed the beer, and enjoyed playing with the review. Let me know if it was worth reading.
0 minutes: ice cold
10 minutes: still cold
20 minutes: glass is cool to the touch
30 minutes: glass is warm, beer still cool
45 minutes: less than room temperature
1 hour: pretty much at room temp
04-11-2011 00:08:55 | More by salvo
More User Reviews:
3.98/5 rDev 0%
Poured a dull light golden with a thinner white head that left a trace amount of lace as it settled quite quickly,as expected the hops are the attraction here in the nose grapefruit rind and pine really stick out hints of alcohol show thru but they are subdued.Pretty resiny on the palate with alcohol dipped tangerine flavors wich were nice there is a noticable lightly sweet caramel malt base underneath but it stays in the background as I drank more it became quite sticky and sweeter.The hops are big and its enjoyable not as in your face as some others of the style,I liked the different flavors not just one dimensional with the citrus and pine flavors.
09-24-2006 13:28:46 | More by oberon
4.03/5 rDev +1.3%
Appearance This one poured a beautiful thick yellow in color with a full, white head. It just screamed quality from head to toe and was one of the more inviting beers of the evening at the first annual Skyhand Bavarian Beer Fest.
Smell The big pine aroma was actually matched fairly evenly by a huge, malty balance. This really is an even-handed mix of full, unabashed malts with a complex, resiny hop compliment.
Taste This is definitely a DIPA. The malts are big and thick at the tongue but, again, are well-balanced with the complex hops.
Mouthfeel This one is a big medium-bodied that somehow manages not to be overly bitter. It finishes with a sweet caramel taste that really rounds out the beer.
Drinkability This terrific DIPA screamed quality from start to finish.
Comments The first annual Bavarian Beer Festival at Casa de Kim was a huge success, and a big BA thanks emanates from all for busting out this beauty shop.
08-30-2005 01:29:08 | More by RoyalT
3/5 rDev -24.6%
This may be a somewhat inconsistent beer, or maybe it's a year-to-year variation, or maybe it's a bottle v. tap issue. I had this on tap at Korova in Ithaca, NY, and was sorely disappointed on a couple of fronts, though I can't deny the things this beer does right.
Pours orange and slightly hazy with decent head that didn't las as long as I expected it to. Some lacing, but nothing major.
Nice big nose-full of citrusy hops. Opens more and more as it comes up to temperature.
Tase is disappointing - the darn thing is too darn sweet. There's a great citrusy opening and a lot of oily, piney tastes at the back end, but in between the two there's so much sweetness that it comes across as out of balance (think a cabernet sauvignon with 4% residual sugar). The sweetness somehow lets the alcohol show through in a slightly displeasing manner.
Mouthfeel is incredible if you can divorce it from the flavor: nice and thick, very satisfying when it comes up to temperature.
Could have been an excellent DIPA that comes up a bit short due to an excess of sugar.
Oddly enough, my first experience with this beer (also vintage 2007) was straight out of a 22-oz. bomber while camping with some friends and coworkers. I lost a lot of visual and olfactory cues, but the taste seemed way more in tune with what I expected.
06-25-2007 03:57:03 | More by TuckerCarlson
4.08/5 rDev +2.5%
Pours from the bomber a bright reddish orange with a cragly, fluffy two finger head. Delicate rings of lacing coat the side of the glass. Inviting. Hybrid grapefruit citrus pinecone hops waft up into the nose. Candy sweetness with just a hint of caramel.
A nice wave of earthy, piney, citric hop flavors coats the tongue. Caramel, bready malt follows along with a nice hit of bitter on the way down. Alcohol esters peek in and out. A nice double IPA by Smutty...I could still use a bit more hop flavor in there though.
Mouthfeel has a nice, full and creamy body. Satisfying. One bomber is enough for me...but it is enjoyable to drink and goes down easy. I look forward to trying more of the Big Beer Series. Many thanks to dmeadows for the opportunity!
01-20-2005 03:00:39 | More by orbitalr0x
3.73/5 rDev -6.3%
This is a pretty good beer, but I think it could be a little bit bolder. Not disappointing by any means, just a little tame. It is an orange color with a medium head, as well as some nice lacing. A sweet, floral aroma. Predominant hops taste, with a little citrus. Good mouthfeel, very drinkable.
07-15-2006 12:43:28 | More by lordofthewiens
4.38/5 rDev +10.1%
Bottle about two months old; Poured into a tulip.
Pours a cloudy orange brown with a lot of suspended material (bottle was stored upright; maybe poured to vigorously?) and two fingers of head. Head does not have great retention, but leaves a lot of lacing behind.
Smell is very floral hops with tropical fruits (pineapple and mango). some citrus as well. Aroma is pretty subtle.
Taste is nice, juicy hops as it hits the tongue. Pineapple with a faint amount of pine. Nice bitterness with a pretty solid malt backbone, though it is hard to pick out specific malt flavors. Very tasty and satisfying.
Mouthfeel is medium and slightly oily, with a nice juiciness, almost chewy. Finishes with lingering dry bitterness.
A very enjoyable, balanced DIPA.
07-05-2011 21:54:40 | More by warnerry
3.23/5 rDev -18.8%
Presentation: 1 pint 6 fl ozs. bomber bottle. No freshness date.
Appearance: Cloudy, murky, unfiltered orange / amber coloured beer with a magnificent off-white creamy, fluffy, frothy, sticky and lasting head.
Smell: Mega citrus, floral, sweet pale malt and fruity aromas.
Taste: A rather dry brew. Smooth, creamy, chewy, juicy mouthfeel that turns coarse with grain and a semi-astringent hop character, that then explodes into an aggressive raw leafy bitterness; rind, salt and a palate stinging character. Notes of wood line the one-dimensional malt character, which is fruity with faintly sweet. Alcohol is apparent. Finish is ruled by strong hop residual falvours.
Notes: As far as big IPA's go, this one is about average. Malt characters are a bit bland. A well-made IPA, but it's lacking balance and uniqueness. Still a good brew, but nothing I'd frequent.
Note: the "A" stands of "Ass" ... but they weren't allowed to put the word on the label.
06-16-2002 11:04:05 | More by Todd
4.6/5 rDev +15.6%
Bottle conditioned in 2006. medium dark gold, white head lasts forever, aroma has a depth of citrus hoppiness and fruity-toasty maltiness balanced with whiffs of alcohol. Hints of a good bud.
Love this brew. Starts with a toasty-caramelly maltiness followed immediately by a bracing, citrusy-slightly-piney hoppiness that just envelops the mouth. Solid, rockin' bitterness all over the tongue. Mid sip it all blends in perfectly. The alcoholic warmth shows up near the end, adding more complexity. Finishes with a grapefruit-and pine, resinous hoppiness along with the maltiness, tongue tingles from the bitterness, mild buzz confirms the alcohol, empty glass confirms the drinkability. Completely appropriate body - not too syrupy, but not thin at all.
One of my favorite DIPAs.
10-03-2006 01:48:15 | More by sponberg
4.78/5 rDev +20.1%
Poured with a thick head atop an incredibly cloudy unfiltered looking ice tea colored bres. Can't see through it. Scents mainly citrus. Tons of grapefruit rind flavor, that is the main thing jumping out at me, then the hops. Highly carbinated, but not annoyingly so- just enough. Very drinkable.
07-07-2004 02:59:53 | More by shapudding
3.98/5 rDev 0%
Poured from a bomber into a Dogfish Head signature glass. A slightly more aggressive release of carbonation then normal is produced while removing the cap.
A: A slightly aggressive pour produces a creamy off white head. Directly below a sits a copper colored brew. Like usual a steady stream of carbonation constantly bubbles to the surface. Eventually the head thins out, a thin lacing sticks around forever.
S: Grapefruit, Pine, and a slight alcohol smell. Not nearly as aggressive as Ruination, but there are some pretty hardcore hop sents in here. A mild alcohol note hits your nose at the end. Understandable with the above average abv.
T: Bitter hops up front. Some grapefruit follows. Small alcohol at the end, but pretty hidden for the abv. Unfortunately it all comes down to a almost typical dipa, but still very enjoyable.
M: Fucking sticky. Sticky mouthfeel, sticky on the glass. Alcohol, and slight carbonation. Lingering bitterness on the tongue, but there is nothing wrong with that.
D: You can finish a bomber in on sitting easily. For the style and abv I find it suprising, but welcome.
Yet another great offering from Smutty. The big beer series doesn't usually let you down.
02-13-2010 01:57:53 | More by euroslvt
3.65/5 rDev -8.3%
This beer is received as very golden in color with a thick white head that laces pretty well
The aroma is full of hops. Citrus and piny hops fill the nose with a slight hint of alcohol.
The taste is bold as you would expect from a DIPA but its color and aroma are deceiving to the taste. It is sweet with a slight citrus hop but it finishes with a big pine bitter finish.
12-14-2010 21:15:32 | More by bishopdc0
Smuttynose Big A IPA from Smuttynose Brewing Company
89 out of 100 based on 1,497 ratings.