Stone 05.05.05 Vertical Epic Ale - Stone Brewing Co.
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 305 | Reviews: 214 | Display Reviews Only:
3.9/5 rDev -0.3%
Got this one a long while ago from Kahn's Fine Wine.. Pours dark brown and fairly clear.... nice tan head with good lacing.
Nose is spicy with raisin and dark brown sugar.... a bit plummy.. hints of tawny port.
Flavor is better with much more pronounced BSDA elements... nice phenolic spiciness is a bit surprising after all these years.. clove and cardamom, but the fruitiness is sorta heavy fig and dark raisin..
Overall, there are hints of oxidation.. but I've been keeping the bottles certainly on the cool side of things. Sherry is very minor... and Port is a little bit more present, but still very minor.
11-07-2010 08:22:19 | More by JohnGalt1
3.3/5 rDev -15.6%
Had the 05, 07 and 07 wine barrel all side by side at Churchkey the other night, and those three were all rather disappointing.
I have a bottle of this in my "cellar" and I'm not sure I want it now. This beer was oxidized (IN A KEG) and really oddly sweet. It was dark amber and mildly hazy. Spicy, sort of, and mostly malty. THere is a decayed hop background to the beer that indicated that one day, perhaps 5 years in the past, this beer was palatable.
10-06-2010 14:43:24 | More by drabmuh
3.4/5 rDev -13%
From 10/04/10 notes. Had on tap at Churchkey for the Stone Tap Takeover event.
a - Pours a dark amber color with 1 inch of off white head and low carbonation evident.
s - Smells of caramel malts, sweet dark fruits, and a little bit of alcohol.
t - Tastes of dark fruit, sugar, bready and caramel malts. Not bad but a little too sweet.
m - Medium body and low carbonation.
d - A decent strong dark ale, but it seemed more like a barelywine to me after these 5 years. I thought the taste was too sweet. Probably wouldn't seek out again.
10-05-2010 20:13:31 | More by mdfb79
2.85/5 rDev -27.1%
On tap at Church Key today. I haven't had this before, but I can say with certainty that this hasn't aged well.
Brilliant ruby red with a dense, light brown head with great retention and lacing, this looks great. It smells great too. Despite being rather sweet with a rather noticeable caramel and toffee character without much yeast, this is enjoyable. Brandy, fruity oxidation is present. The palate really is a disappointment. Cardboard and fruity oxidation with some fruit and some caramel and chocolate dominate. The finish is sweet, rather strongly cardboard-like and rather unpleasant. Medium in body and rather over-carbonated, the poor finish is also to this beer's detriment. The finish has flavors of brandy, fruit, caramel and cardboard. Not particularly enjoyable, this.
10-05-2010 01:12:22 | More by DefenCorps
4.6/5 rDev +17.6%
Shared at a Vertical Epic tasting with my friend Armand. This and the 03.03.03 were my favorites.
A-Very dark brown color, tight white/brownish head. Great carbonation.
S-Dark cherry sweet aroma. Carmel aroma.
T-I get alot of carmel flavor from this one too. I don't get alot of anything else but I like the flavors I get.
M-Light body with great carbonation.
D-I wish I had more of these! I could drink these all day.
08-26-2010 01:36:33 | More by ZX6Chris
3.25/5 rDev -16.9%
Chilled bottle into a glass. Shared at a tasting.
A: Pours a translucent maroon body that glows faintly ruby against the light. Carbonation filled the glass on the generous, vigorous pour that I received.
S: Wow, well-oxidized. In the good way (sherry, port-like aromas) instead of cardboard -- but it's very overwhelming. I never had the beer fresh, so I can't compare. It's very dark-fruit dominated. I searched for spices but I couldn't detect any.
T: Sherry, as the nose suggested, but it's also going toward wet cardboard, which the nose didn't suggest. It's spicier than I picked up on the nose; it delivers pepper in the finish with a touch of clove (?). Lots of dark fruit here: raisins, dates, figs, maybe plums.
M: Not austere, but it's not sugary. I'd call it semi-dry or a touch drier. The oxidation really dominates the flavor and the taste buds. This affects the...
Drinkability: This would be a pretty decent sipper, but a large pour at this tasting wound up getting tossed into the bushes since I just didn't care to have it anymore. Glad I tried it, also very glad I don't have any more.
06-26-2010 00:02:49 | More by Arbitrator
3.38/5 rDev -13.6%
Arbitrator shared this one. Thanks, buddy.
Dark translucent mahogany brown with amber highlights. Still lively and well-carbonated after 5 years.
Big sherry and dark fruit aroma. Lots of oxidation, raisins, dates, blackberry preserves. Strong esters and oxidation cover up most of the malt and hop character.
Very oxidized palate. Sherry, perhaps a bit of wet paper. Heavy on the esters and phenols, spicy and peppery but simultaneously sweet. Dates, figs, berries. A bit thin. Finishes peppery, phenolic, spicy. Hints of clove, some grainy astringency. Not bad, this has held up fairly well, though I don't think I'd care much for the beer fresh or aged.
06-24-2010 23:19:22 | More by largadeer
4.15/5 rDev +6.1%
Good sized (4-5 ounce) pour at a Stone Vertical Tasting Event sponsored by Belmont Party Supplies on 5/12/2010, served in a very cool Stone Vertical Epic tasting glass.
A: Very dark brown mahogany with a thin tan head.
S: chocolate, alcohol, caramel and dark fruits in the aroma.
T: Chocolate and caramel with some spices reminding me of soy sauce.
M: Better carbonated than previous beers in the series, but just a bit thin. Nice finish with raisins , dark fruit flavors and chocolate cocoa.
D: Very nice beer -- so far, this was my favorite of the series of the ones tasted.
05-16-2010 17:09:16 | More by chaz01
4.33/5 rDev +10.7%
Pours a very dark brown with a kaki head that dissipates quickly leaving some lacing. Pretty good for its age.
Smells of roasted malts, raisons and an absinth like anise smell that makes the aroma really complex.
The taste is just as complex if not more. Anise, hop bitterness, earthy, spicy, and a sweet malty finish.
The mouth feel is dry which helps it go down pretty well.
This was a little oxidized and flat but considering the age it is expected.
03-14-2010 22:39:49 | More by JoePat
3.98/5 rDev +1.8%
Thanks DrJay for the sample! Dark mahogony body topped with a thin mocha ring. Plums, brown sugar, yeast and hops in the aroma. This beer is sweet, sugared fruit and candy, with an approriate spicy profile to balance out the sweetness. Slight acidity, bitter/sweet finish, leaving a spiced malt aftertaste. Pretty damn good
02-15-2010 00:14:29 | More by mrmanning
3.53/5 rDev -9.7%
Bomber into a wine glass. Been waiting four years to try this.
Appearance: A nice and dark layered amber color with good lacing. Weird balance of dark on top of light, almost like a black and tan at a bar, made with a spoon between the beers.
Smell: Dark roasted malts, chocolate, and coffee. Good and balanced? Yes. A Belgian Strong Dark? Seriously?! More like a Porter, and one that I'm not going nuts about. Stone's always quality, but I expected more here.
Taste: Same here. Initial chocolate and coffee and roasted malts. Phenolic activity's providing pretty much absolutely nothing. I'd say this was a 6.5% ABV Porter if this was some challenge to guess what's going on. Lingering sourness and roasted malts and sweetness. Again, balanced, but not a lot going on to the point where I'm excited about it.
Mouthfeel: The carbonation seems like it's really trying to push through the body, and though it's almost there, there's still a bit of a watery nature to the brew by the end that I'm confused by, especially since it's been sitting here for over four years. Or was it supposed to be like this?
Drinkability: There's nothing to complain about necessarily regarding this brew, but I don't know if age has done anything for it. I do have a bottle left. And yes, I'll wait until 2012. But what's going to happen? How much more complex and nuanced is it going to get? I feel like if this wasn't Stone, people would be giving it less of a rating overall, in some ways. I'm not sure. How long should we wait, though, really?
12-30-2009 06:33:21 | More by asabreed
3.68/5 rDev -5.9%
22oz bomber poured in a sampling glass.
Pours a dark brown ruby with a tinge of brown and ivory head. Nose is diacetyl and sweet, a bit malty.
Taste is a bit buttery and sharp, noot that belgian but still very nice. For a 4 year old brew this is gonna be awesome in 2012
11-07-2009 22:48:33 | More by kingcrowing
3.43/5 rDev -12.3%
See 06.06.06 review for background story....
Well, it pours a burgandy dark with a great head. Chunks of lacing, nice looking brew.
Smell reminds me of a quad. Musty dark fruits, subtle but earthy, again with the tea leaves.
Big bite of caramel and dark fruits. Not bad but ....
Good carbonation, especially considering the age. Feels decent enough I guess.
Overall: expected EPIC, got good
08-29-2009 18:56:00 | More by PatronWizard
4.13/5 rDev +5.6%
Thanks to Solomon420 for sending me this a few years back. He must have a bunch of these still. Dark amber colored with nice clarity. Thin, tan head develops but is short-lasting, leaving behind a ring. The aroma seems a bit ripe, so I'm hoping it's not past its prime. Sweet and malty smelling, with caramel and dark fruits, plus touches of roast. The alcohol is somewhat evident also.
The taste suggests this has held up well, in fact it has mellowed nicely. The flavor is sweet with a keen dryness. It's very rasiny and doughy, almost chocolatey. The finish is really nice as the bitterness is lasting and complements the sweet malt character. The only thing lacking is that it doesn't come off as distinctly Belgian. You could probably convince me this is a Scotch Ale or maybe a Barleywine, as the yeast character isn't evident enough to set it apart. Nevertheless it is good. The mouthfeel is not heavy, in fact it's very smooth, with fairly sharp carbonation that foams up just slightly on the palate.
Glad this one tastes good after 4 years. It was the only 05' I have ever had (and probably the last), so I don't have to kick myself for not trying it sooner. This is better than the last three...
08-09-2009 05:28:15 | More by bennetj17
4.13/5 rDev +5.6%
Acquired via trade from Solomon420, so a big "Thank You" goes out to him. Poured from a 22oz bottle into an imperial pint glass.
A: The beer is a deep reddish brown color, with a large off-white head that fades very slowly and leaves a thick lace on the glass.
S: The aroma is of dark fruit, Belgian yeast, caramel, brown sugar and a touch of hops.
T: The taste is sweet up front with flavors of caramel, dark fruit and brown sugar that are quickly followed by a good Belgian yeast breadiness and a hearty malt character. The hops presence is mild but complementary and brings a good balance. The after-taste is slightly sweet.
M: Crisp and very smooth, medium body, medium carbonation, finish is slightly sticky.
D: Tasty, goes down quite easily, not too filling, good kick, very good representation of style, this is a very nice dark Belgian that has help up very nicely for 4 years. Overall it's a very good beer to drink for a long time.
06-18-2009 03:34:02 | More by TheManiacalOne
4.38/5 rDev +12%
APPEARANCE: Dark brown, nearly black, but with a very subtle burgundy hue. Very Clear. Noticeably tan head.
AROMA: A very malty, caramelly smell, with a slight coffee note and with some definite alcohol notes present.
FLAVOR: Malt, malt, more malt. Wonderfully smooth, rich, and somewhat sweet, but not cloyingly so. Subtle hints of caramel, chocolate, molasses, and (maybe) a slight coffee-ish note. Some noticeable bitterness of hops, but they were not overwhelming.
PALATE: Definitely leaning toward full-bodied, but extremely well balanced. There was a noticeable, but light, heat (of alcohol) about it. Would love to know where it was at ABV when we cracked it open.
NOTES: I could easily make this a session beer, but it would be a session beer that rendered me completely stupid drunk after two or three pints. It was full, but very enjoyable, and very rich.
05-14-2009 03:27:14 | More by HopHed
3.75/5 rDev -4.1%
Second to last...I must continue...
A: Poured similar to the 06' VE, but with an exceptional head....superb! The lacing is thick and clinging, similar to a double IPA. WOW!
S: Smell the 06'...but more potent...and more soy-saucy as well.
T: I am actually impressed by this beer...a very complex and musky flavor profile. An enhanced version to the 06' VE, but obviously more advanced. Robust fig flavor along with brown sugar qualities that personified the beer...at least in my opinion.
M: Another WOW for me...viscous, well-carbonated, with some creamy qualities.
D: Overly impressed...alcohol is hidden...good on a warm summer night.
Overall: Really good...a try it beer. Cheers!
05-13-2009 04:48:24 | More by OlieIPA
3.48/5 rDev -11%
22oz bomber courtesy of sunnydlyte23 poured into a snifter.
Pours a deep, clear copper underneath a healthy tan head that lingers as a cap for the duration and leaves good lacing.
The aroma is sweet with lots of dark fruits - figs, raisins, pears - soaked in booze. Plenty of brown sugar and some licorice and spices. It actually has a slight hint of oxidation in the nose with a bit of stale cardboard coming through.
The taste has the same booze-soaked fruity sweetness as the aroma. There is plenty of dark malts forming a solid backbone along with Belgian sugars before the spices leave a slight tingle on the palate in the finish. Again, signs of oxidation in the taste, just as in the aroma.
The mouthfeel is medium bodied with decent carbonation and the oxidation seems to have thinned it out slightly. The alcohol is definitely present in the finish.
This is a very good beer that I think is probably a little past it's prime. Very sweet with a good spice presence to mix it up a bit.
04-17-2009 01:42:19 | More by gford217
4.1/5 rDev +4.9%
Been waiting for a reason to try this. I just had a great weekend, so this will hopefully be a great way to wrap it up.
Pours a clear and dark brown color with a decent off white head.
Aromas are spicy, some bright fruits, apples, some cider, caramal and oak.
Taste is spicy, oaky, with some sweet caramel flavors. Pretty dry with some light boozy alcohol, chocolate, and and earthiness. Finish has a bit of a funky yeast like bite.
Mouthfeel is nice and full. Feels thick but not overly heavy.
All in all, a really interesting and tasty beer. Pretty unique, not my favorite epic, but a very solid one. I also think this one has legs to keep going for a few more years. It seems like it might make it to 2012.
03-09-2009 02:55:49 | More by flexabull
3.88/5 rDev -0.8%
Good day lil' beer - you're looking good in the ol' Corsendonk tulip with your deep mahogany pour and rich tan head.
Aroma is BW style - sweet caramel, fig, cherry and orange licorice. Mellow quaff combines all these ingredients, but just a bit of orange medicine and hot alcohol in the finish. I was hoping the aging would benefit the brew, but I'm a bit disappointed in this one - a good beer but nothing outstanding.
03-08-2009 17:34:18 | More by Vancer
4.47/5 rDev +14.3%
Appearance: Pours a very dark amber color with garnet highlights; with over three years under its belt, I suspect the head is no longer what it used to be but it does produce a bit of lacing as it quickly fades to a ringlet
Smell: Dark fruit dominates, primarily figs and prunes; caramel, brown sugar and hints of anise
Taste: Rum-soaked dark fruit opens the fray, with bitter zest arriving by mid-palate (its Stone after all); rich caramel spice cake; after the swallow, the flavors mellow into a subdued but complex mix, with deep undertones
Mouthfeel: Full bodied with moderate carbonation
Drinkability: This beer has held up remarkably well; one has to wonder why Stone doesn't brew a BSDA as part of its regular line-up
10-26-2008 00:45:59 | More by brentk56
4.33/5 rDev +10.7%
Finding this at The Publick House Provisions was definitely one of those "Wow!" beer shopping moments for me....
Pours a handsome burgundy/mahogany color, small tan head fades out pretty quickly into a nice collar around the glass, not a whole lot of lacing to speak of. Smell is outrageous. Chocolate/cocoa/carob smells, something earthy/woodsy about the whole thing, and a pronounced alcohol aroma wafting up. Lots of chocolate flavor, fruity...maybe raspberries? Some fig & plum, brown sugar. Finely carbonated, medium-bodied, very slightly sticky, lots of lingering spice. I'm really wishing I had bought some more of these...a very unique beer drinking experience for me.
10-23-2008 00:21:22 | More by corey0212
4.22/5 rDev +7.9%
Tie for first place in the 2004 to 2008 tasting (see other posts)
A: Dark brown, with a reddish hue
S: Dark caramel malt, candied fruits, cloves
M: Full-bodied creamy mouthfeel
D: Very drinkable
Big fan of Belgian dark strong ales, so not altogether a surprise I thought this one was one of the best. Even still, great beer. Wish I had saved more than one.
10-07-2008 03:39:14 | More by abfraser
4.13/5 rDev +5.6%
Second in abfraser's Vertical Epic tasting.
A: dark, mahogany, with some lacing
S: I was not a huge fan of the smell. Chocolate and fruit.
T: But I was a fan of the taste. More chocolate, alcohol, fruit, sweet.
M: Medium body, medium carbonation.
10-06-2008 00:40:57 | More by waltonc
3.15/5 rDev -19.4%
I was looking forward to trying this one as I expected it to be drinking rather well at this time. It poured a deep amber color and smelled of toffee. The taste was a bit disappointing though as it had a bit of a metallic character to go along with the toffee that I was looking forward to. Not sure if the bottle had been compromised so I'd like to try it again sometime soon.
06-04-2008 13:09:30 | More by dill
Stone 05.05.05 Vertical Epic Ale from Stone Brewing Co.
88 out of 100 based on 305 ratings.