Dark Horse Reserve Special Black Ale - Dark Horse Brewing Company
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 991 | Reviews: 559 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by the Alström Bros:
4/5 rDev +1.3%
From BeerAdvocate Magazine Volume II, Issue II:
Here we have a great example of originality in American craft brewing. Put a donkey on the label and say that it is somewhere between a Stout and Porter, and it is a Strong Ale as well. Odd label, not an exact style, we love the concept. Dense tiny bubbly brown lace forms off of a hard pour. Is there anything darker than black because this is one sooty beer. Aromatic with molasses, dark chocolate, dark roasted ice coffee, black currants and a mild ester alcohol. Super smooth with a feigned semi-syrupy body, light on the carbonation. Charred wood, molasses and intense dark cocoa flavors lock down the taste buds for a good while. Some sweetness breaks out in the middle with a juicy nugget of burnt black berries. Hops are mild with a slightly balancing bitterness and vague herbal flavor. Ends with a bitter burnt flavor that never seems to go over the top.
The darker the better and one hell of a kick to the taste buds. Big, bold, complex and in-your-face. No need to debate on whether it is a Stout or Porter or even a double of the style, its good drinking. Enough said.
11-13-2009 19:12:40 | More by BeerAdvocate
3.65/5 rDev -7.6%
12oz brown bottle with a very amateur drawing of a donkey (?) on the label. Noted as a "Black Bier Ale" but there's no denying that this is an Stout.
Pours thick, ultra-black, topped with a 3-fingered creamy coffee coloured head containing signs of cascading and holds amazing powers of retention and climbing stickiness. Unfiltered.
Lovely aroma. Robust. Full of roasted black malts with notes of grain husk, astringency, wood and chicory.
Smooth, rich, solid medium-bodied and extremely robust. Astringency is dominant and assertive. Flavours of dark ripe fruits, wood, earth, sherry, nuts, black-strap molasses and a twang blends with a limey citrus hop character (what one might find in a Schwarzbier). Notes of aging (oxidation) are also present within the wood and wet paper flavours. Finish dry with lingering lime and molasses flavours.
Quite the brew ... would have sat better with me if the brew hadn't shown so many signs of oxidation, and without a freshness stamp there's no real way of telling how old my sample is. Still, very worthy of a try ...
Thanks to trbeer.
07-01-2003 12:38:10 | More by Todd
More User Reviews:
4.05/5 rDev +2.5%
On tap at Ashley's in Ann Arbor,poured a near jet black but there was a noticable crimson hue when held up to the light a thinner quick to faid almond colored head atop.Aromas were roasted and sweet with notes of molasses and French Roast coffee and bitter chocolate no hop presence to this one.Big and sweet up front with some molasses and dark fruit notes very roasty with just a hint of earth in the finish wich doesnt dry it out much.Its a big hearty beer sweet and it packs a punch
07-02-2007 21:31:34 | More by oberon
4.15/5 rDev +5.1%
Appearance The body is, yes, black, with a very dark tan head that was gorgeous and enchanting. It came up wonderfully, left some nice lacing, and never did go all the way down. I can even see some foam at the BOTTOM of my glass.
Update on Appearance: No, wait, thats darkly tanned sediment at the bottom of my glass. Now it gets a 5.
Smell Big, burnt malts and milk chocolate lead the way here. The sugars are of the refined cocoa variety. I can also pick up some coffee grounds. Nice.
Taste Boy, is this bitter. The sweet chocolate from the nose steps back a bit, which is good because I enjoy smelling these flavors in a stout a little more than tasting them. I am now licking coffee grounds out of my golden cone filter.
Mouthfeel Full-bodied and bitterly dry. This is probably the driest Imperial Stout that Ive had to date. You almost need to chase this with a pale lager or something.
Drinkability This is for true stout lovers only. If you want over-the-top burnt coffee ground madness, this is for you.
Comments A big thanks to garthwaite for sending me this offering from Dark Horse.
08-04-2004 00:42:51 | More by RoyalT
3.6/5 rDev -8.9%
Black as a somber alleyway on a moonless night. Thick looking, I mean really thick, semi-solid even. Head is light brown and heavily and root beer like, foamy and chunky. Retention is solid. Obviously unfiltered.
Great aroma. Just plum chalk full of dark, dark malts. Reminds me of black bier, fitting name. Lots of chocolate, grain husks, some chicory, and wood.
Smooth. Very nice. Thick, luscious, creamy body. Plenty of coffee and chocolate with a heavy astringency, some wood, and an oddly faint sense of citric hops. Smoky. Semi-dry.
Not that drinkable for me. To much smoke and astringency but in general probably good.
02-09-2007 14:56:59 | More by DaPeculierDane
3.75/5 rDev -5.1%
This pour an intense jet black with thick brown head.
Rich malt aroma and american hops with some carmel and coffee aromas. There is a light alcohol hint in there but overall the aroma is subtle.
The flavor has a one two punch of strong hops bitternes and medium dark grain bitterness. There is a little bit of malt sweetness for support and moderate citrus hops flavor in the middle before a dry finish with a long hop flavor and bitterness in the aftertaste.
medium heavy body with low carbonation and a very slight astringency that seems grain derived. A slight alcohol warming.
A big, bitter and malty brew with juicy citrus hops flavor.
06-28-2012 00:25:31 | More by MadScientist
4.13/5 rDev +4.6%
Nice ass on the label of this one! Pours from the bottle a super dark midnight black with an impressive two fingers of frothy tan foam on top. Nice sticky lacing with no light daring to escape. Aromas of dark, roasty burnt malts with powdered cocoa accents and a hint of coffee. Some dark fruits (black currants) float in and out along with a slight note of cream. Quite nice.
First sip brings a wall of rich, roasted, toasty slightly burnt malt flavors melded with lots of powered cocoa and good helping of bitter instant coffee. Dark fruits show up again in the flavor with a touch of smokiness. Finishes with a brash residual bitterness and a touch of green, herbal hops on the way down. A bit astringent on the palate and overall a very enjoyable double stout.
Mouthfeel is big with a nice creaminess and ample carbonation. The carbonation helps cut through this one making it more drinkable. This is a tasty stout that I wouldn't mind having around. Goes down quite easily and I would love to have a few on a cold night. Dark Horse continues to impress. Thanks to Cornboy for the opportunity.
11-03-2005 03:58:34 | More by orbitalr0x
4.33/5 rDev +9.6%
Nearly pitch black, only hits of dark brown at the edges. Tan head that reduced down to only a ring around the glass with a slick surface on top. No lacing to speak of.
Super nice dark toasted malts, black coffee and dark chocolate. Hints of smoke waft in as well.
Really robust flavor. Dark toasted malts run around unchecked, char and black coffee again. Smoke again. Very similar to the smell.
Mouthfeel is medium to full. Carbonation is low. Its hard to say this is fully b/c it isn't quite creamy, but it is slick. Flavor sticks around and lingers.
This is pretty damn drinkable to have this strong of a flavor, but I like my stouts like this and not overloaded with sweet flavors. Overall its very simple with dark toasted flavors, but just good. Good stuff...a must try.
05-15-2007 01:50:35 | More by blitz134
4.3/5 rDev +8.9%
A_Pours jet black with a thick,creamy brown head with great retention. Thick lacing covers the glass.
T_Same as the nose and then some.Rich molasses, espresso, brown sugar,cream, bitter chocolate, and lots of roast.
M_Thick and creamy. Definitely full bodied with moderate carbonation.
D_Pretty heavy stout ale but I have no problem putting down a few.
09-05-2010 14:12:45 | More by nickadams2
4.7/5 rDev +19%
WOW! This is sooo not what I was expecting at all! I had no idea what I was in for. This one poured out like an imperial stout. Pitch brown with a thick caramelly creamy brown head that reduced quickly to a bit of a dusting and a thick ring. Huge aroma. Total shocker here too. Scents of lambic, rich imperial stout, alcohol, with tons of hoppiness. Merlot, chocolate, coffee, deep and roasty. Smooth and slightly creamy with a bitey carbination that snaps at you towards the end of the sip. Nice toasty dark hoppiness with a good bite. Blackened toast, dark bittersweet chocolate and espresso. This is damn luscious. Great flavors and feel. Nice one!
03-11-2005 02:48:40 | More by shapudding
4.15/5 rDev +5.1%
I bought this beer at the Brass Rail in Cambelltown a couple months ago then left it on the workbench in the garage. I spied it yesterday and thought it was time to check it out before it turned into a pumpkin. Well, it's a very nice beer and not so much a load that one couldn't drink it in the summer (84 degrees today). Like noted below, the frothy head quickly skittered away but laced the glass (16oz tumbler) as it went down. The Black Bier is very dark and opaque but looks very nice in the glass. Big malts on the nose toasty but not sweet.
Very smooth with a nice balance and a lingering finish. Initially, incredibly drinkable; hard to believe it's 7.5. (I think I better slow down!) The garage storage doesn't seem to have affected anything.
Not sweet at all, sort of like a Schwarzbier on steroids. I wasn't expecting a sweet beer and can see how this classifies as a "black ale". I think the hops are in the background keeping a nice tang in the finish. All in all, very nice.
05-31-2010 21:04:49 | More by BeerIsland
4.05/5 rDev +2.5%
Didn't know what to expect from this one. Initially thought it would be a schwartzbier. Pours an almost black body with a small cocoa head that has some garnet hues. Some nice sheet lacing. Looks like a stout. Aroma of burnt dark malt, chocolate, and red apples. Medium body has a subdued carbonation. Taste has a biter bite from both hops and dark roasted malts. A red apple fruitiness softens the edges quite a bit. A very interesting brew here. More like a stout than anything else.
03-03-2008 18:45:27 | More by merlin48
4.35/5 rDev +10.1%
Thanks to Eyedrinkale for this one...
Pours a thick dead black color with no light passing thru...a half a finger of cocoa-colored head with a gentle pour. Most of the head disappears rapidly with very little lacing.
An excellent aroma filled with chocolate colored cherries, cocoa powder, a vinous character and just a hint of smoke.
The taste is fabulous and just what I was expecting from the nose...less a hint of sweetness that I am glad to see.
A nice hop profile to bitter it up ever so gently and the smokiness really drys up the finish.
Mouthfeel is a bit thinner after seeing this one pour out, but it is by no means thin...fits right into a double stout IMO.
Carbonation is spot on and the drinkability is thru the roof if you remotely enjoy porters/stouts.
Another winner from Dark Horse...I am quite jealous I cannot obtain more of this gem...trade anyone?
12-15-2005 23:57:58 | More by warriorsoul
3.63/5 rDev -8.1%
Appearance: 1/3 inch head, opaque, black in color
Smell: chocolate and toasted malt
Taste: burnt malt, dark coffee, and chocolate
Mouthfeel: medium/light bodied, sweet with a slightly bitter end, low carbonation
Drinkability: A very drinkable strong ale that hides the abv well. It tastes like a slightly more complex schwarzbier. I could have a couple of these to sip, but am not likely to go out of my way and order this.
03-24-2010 13:11:50 | More by tigg924
4.3/5 rDev +8.9%
Pours an dark black color with a tan and darker brown colored head, looks nice and creamy. Smell is hoppy, roasty, and chocolatey. Taste is slightly astringent, but plenty of hops in there and a nice cocoa flavor and a roasty undertone to help balance things out, quite good. Mouthfeel is nice and thick with lower carbonation, just about perfect. A very solid beer that I plan on getting again. I think this one will get even better with age, a hypothesis I plan to test out.
09-12-2006 03:38:13 | More by badbeer
4/5 rDev +1.3%
Thanks to Exiled for sharing this bottle.
The beer pours a dark brown to black color with a tan head. The aroma is chocolate and roasted malt. Pretty basic, but very inviting.
The flavor is more of the same - roasted malt and chocolate. Medium mouthfeel and medium carbonation.
There is nothing really special about the beer, but it is a very solid porter.
11-03-2010 04:10:38 | More by Mora2000
4.18/5 rDev +5.8%
From notes on 13 December 2008.
Opened 12 fl oz bottle, poured into Nonic Glass.
Poured a luscious brown head atop an opaque black beer.
Smell is of dark malts and an earthy aroma. Taste is of dark caramel and nutty component. Hints of chocolate round out a wonderful brew.
Nice smooth finish on the palate and no aftertaste. No ABV listed on bottle, so I guessed it at 6% - I was surprised to see it at %7.5.
01-16-2009 19:28:32 | More by mattster
4.47/5 rDev +13.2%
Serving glass: Poured from bottle into Nonic Imperial Pint.
Appearance: Pure black with thin brown head and light lacing lines.
Smell: Roasted aroma, but quite sweet - molasses, cookies & cream, chocolate, vanilla, licorice and something reminiscent of a Christmas tree.
Taste: Strong roasted flavor but fairly creamy and sweet. Chocolate, light coffee, cream, licorice, molasses and pine. Ends somewhat bitter, but a nice touch of creamy sweetness remains throughout. Tastes like a blend of a Stout, a Cafe Mocha and, more some reason, Anchor Christmas Ale.
Feel: Relatively low carbonation. Body is creamy, silky and smooth, but surprisingly not quite full-bodied.
Drinkability: Very nice - both very complex and easy to drink. BA and Dark Horse both claim this is not a Stout, but surely it is a Stout of some kind. It seems like a ramped-up, bitter and higher alcohol Cream Stout, with a strange dash of holiday spirit.
02-15-2010 13:09:29 | More by bsp77
3.58/5 rDev -9.4%
Very dark... pretty much black. Even when held against a light there is no seeing through it.
Licorice comes through as well as a burnt malt smell.
Strong burnt malt flavor in finish. Has a nice sweet taste in mouth. Overall it's nice but just a little bitter for me. Has grassy hints as well.
Feels heavy in mouth, just like I would expect. Overall very nice feel.
A nice tasting beer but a bit bitter for my taste. I would have a hard time drinking a bunch of these.
03-07-2004 02:21:13 | More by jsolack
3.51/5 rDev -11.1%
Acquired via trade
An appropriately pretty black ale: black throughout and a small, but persistent, creamy brown head of small bubbles. I can't exactly say why, but I thought this really looked like Bell's Expedition Stout as it poured from the bottle. Sticky, lined, brown lacing left down the glass. No doubt about it, this is a pretty beer.
Plenty of roasted malt and baker's chocolate make up the abundance of the aroma, along with a touch of a cream sweetness. A mild pine hop presence as well.
The flavor follows the aroma: lots of roast and black malt, a touch of chocolate, and coffee creamer sweetness, interestingly. There's a touch of licorice as well. Nice flavors. Comes together nicely. The flavors fall apart though as the beer warms and the thin mouthfeel shines through.
Thinner in body than anticipated. Lower-medium bodied with low, but creamy, carbonation.
A nice, sweeter stout.
05-02-2013 01:36:53 | More by ehammond1
Dark Horse Reserve Special Black Ale from Dark Horse Brewing Company
89 out of 100 based on 991 ratings.