Dismiss Notice
Microbrew Invitational
Join us June 3 + 4 in Boston and help us drink 300+ beers, ciders, kombuchas, meads, sakes and more!

TICKETS: beeradvocate.com/micro/

Selin's Grove Brewing Company

Place Score:
Selin's Grove Brewing CompanySelin's Grove Brewing Company

Type: Brewery, Bar, Eatery

119 N Market St
Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania, 17870
United States

(570) 374-7308 | map

No notes at this time.

Added by BeerAdvocate

View: Beers | Place Ratings | Events
User Reviews
Sort by:  Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
Reviews: 113 | Ratings: 166
Photo of RblWthACoz
4.29/5  rDev -1.2%
vibe: 5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4

If only so many other brewpubs could be just like this. Small, quaint, and with a load of personality. This place is amazing. Upon first stepping inside, you get this sense that you are in a special place. The service was fine and the beers were quite good. I tried several different ones and they all showed very nice brewing ability. Took a growler of the IPA with me and it was quite nice. If you are anywhere near this place, then you owe it to yourself to check it out. I wish I lived closer so that I could visit more often.

 530 characters

Photo of Rifugium
4.03/5  rDev -7.1%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 3.5 | selection: 4 | food: 3.5

I made a point to stop here on the way to Pittsburgh. It's a really nice little place with a tidy, rustic, organic, quasi-colonial, craft-fair/antique shop feel to it, much like the entire town (despite the seemingly large amount per capita of adult bookstores and shops seen on the way there). There's a small bar and a fair amount of seating inside, lots of wood and dim lights. Since the dog was with us though, we sat outside, where there are a few tables in a cozy and comfortable setting. Laid back and quite enjoyable.

They had a very nice selection of house brews on tap, with one or two cask-conditioned, with enough style variety to please almost anyone. All beers were solid. I always love to see pour-size options at brewpubs, and these guys gave the choice of 4, 8, 12oz., and full pours. Excellent.

Food was decent, but the stuff we had was pretty much diner quality. Good diner, and quite tasty, but still not really above and beyond.

Now despite my appreciation for the laid-back aspect, I have to say the service was really slow and uncomfortable. I suppose the staff was friendly enough, but it was almost like they were not at all experienced in restaurant/bar service, which is a bit hard to believe considering the place has been open for well over a decade. And it was mid-day, and they didn't seem understaffed, so it's not like it was slammin' busy. But anyway, if that's my only complaint, then it's still not too bad overall. And to be fair, I'm used to sitting at a bar, where there's almost always someone standing right there that can see your empty glass and potentially fill it. If this service was at the bar, I'd give it a 2.5-3, but since we were out on the porch, I'll generously do 3.5.

Prices were all decent, and we actually ended up spending more on merch than we did on lunch. So basically a German growler (empty) and a pint glass cost more than two wraps, a generous sampler flight, and two 8oz. pours.

Great little gem of a place, and worth the trip if you're doing any kind of PA beer venture, whether it be from the west to Philly, from the east to Pittsburgh, from the north to Harrisburg, or from the south to Williamsport. Nowadays, since my original visit/review, I attempt to get out here at least once year.

 2,264 characters

Photo of nh2032
4.3/5  rDev -0.9%
vibe: 5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 3.5 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4.5

Review from a visit on 2/5/11. A really nice space in the basement of an old house in downtown Selinsgrove. Low ceilings and great atmosphere.

The Beer - a little disappointed that they were out of SNAFU IPA, Framboise, APA, and Love Buzz, my 1st 4 choices, by the time that we got there. I was still able to try the White Horse Porter (really good), Dubbel (good), and Oatmeal Stout (disappointing compared to the reviews on BA). It is really nice that they offer 4 oz, 8 oz, and full pints of all the offerings and for very reasonable prices. I also got a growler of the Scottish Ale to go which was still very good when I opened it a week after getting home.

The Food - I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food. We had the nachos for an appetizer and they were very good. I had a roast beef sandwich on a pretzel bun for my entree which was excellent. My wife enjoyed her BLT as well.

Service - our waitress was good, but she was stretched very thin trying to serve at least 6 different tables on a busy Saturday afternoon. They could certainly use more help and I imagine they are much more attentive at slower times.

Overall, a great brewpub. Good beer and good food, just wish they could brew in greater quantities so that they wouldn't run out as often - very disappointing to drive so far and be out of the brews you were anticipating.

Updating after my recent visit on 10/14/11. When we saw pumpkin was on tap we made the drive down. The selection seemed much better than our last trip - 7 or 8 beers on tap, 2 on the beer engine although one kicked before my order could be filled. Food was really good again, especially considering how small the kitchen area is. For a Friday afternoon it was pretty busy and service was somewhat slow, but can't fault them too much for that.

Update after my visit on 3/3/12. Beer is still the highlight for me, but the menu was redone is just as good or maybe a little better than before. A lot more vegetarian options now.

 1,999 characters

Photo of CliffBrake
4.38/5  rDev +0.9%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4 | food: 4.5

Selin's Grove sits in the walk-out basement of an antique house built of limestone blocks, in a historic section of downtown. Inside, the pub continues the colonial Pennsylvania feel with simple, poorly lit spaces, old style wooden tables and chairs. The atmosphere seems authentic - you almost expect to see Ben Franklin stroll in for a pint of grog!

Service was efficient and cheerful. I arrived a little before 5 PM on a Saturday to a pub that was about 1/2 full. Within a 1/2 hour there was no-vacancy and a waiting line at the door. I was impressed with how the staff managed to keep the seated patrons served while negotiating with those who were waiting for reservations, or to fill to-go orders.

The printed beer list during my visit was about 1/3 crossed out in red marker. Although Galaxy IPA was still listed and described, it had kicked a few days earlier and Olde Frosty had taken its place. A lot of the more special beers had kicked and had not been replaced. I definitely got the impression that beers kick pretty frequently and the staff was too busy to keep the list up to date. Perhaps the brewery is too small to keep everything consistently stocked as well. On the other hand, everything seemed very fresh!

Food selections were sandwiches, salads and a soup and one hot selection of the day (jambalaya today). All were fresh, well prepared, and presented on heavy ceramicware, seemingly in concert with the colonial theme.

I drove out of my way to use Selinsgrove as a stopping place for a multiday trip just to visit this pub. I was not dissapointed and would go out of my way to visit again, hoping to find a few more specialties not yet sold out.

 1,675 characters

Photo of sawsyon
4.45/5  rDev +2.5%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 5 | selection: 4 | food: 4

We needed to be near Selinsgrove to get some specialty wood and always check BA for brewpubs nearby (why, oh why don't you have 'show all in the area' mapping function?!?), and found the Selin's Grove. With the outstanding reviews all around we had to try (as if it would take much to convince us).

The brewpub is in the lower level of a historic 18C house that was once home to a PA governor, and has a rustic colonial theme. The bar room is under the main house and is relatively dark, low-ceilinged, and welcoming. There is one corner with a fireplace (not functional, I think), about a dozen tables in this room and a small bar that could seat perhaps 10 people). The back room is brighter with a gas franklin stove, windows that look out to the garden courtyard, and has only 7 tables (only one 2-top and two 6-tops, with the rest being 4-tops). So overall it is quite a small place and if there were 40 people it would feel hopping; I'd be surprised if you could get 100 in there.

Our server, who is also a airline attendant for his regular job, mentioned that the brewhouse is the carriage house out back and that we were there at a particularly plentiful time in terms of taps. They had 12 beers on tap, though apparently sometimes is is more like 6, so we were blessed. The service was quick and friendly. Always interested in eavesdropping, we heard three guys taking a road trip from Boston to Seattle and hitting brewpubs on the way (oh to be young again!), some locals who clearly knew the server, and a number of local businesspeople in for lunch. Most telling though, is that in the small room where we were sitting, of the 6 parties that were there, three of us had growlers ready to be filled as we left.

I'll rate the various beers here under each one we had, but I should just say that the food was really, really good. Not high-end or phroo-phroo, but hearty, flavorful, and just made you feel you had a really good lunch for a reasonable price. The cock-a-leekie soup was wonderfully home-made with big chunks of chicken. Their brewhouse bread was a moist, soft dense and chewy semi-whole wheat. My wife's comment was that the biggest problem was that the butter was too cold and wouldn't spread easily (rough life!).

The lunch menu is mostly sandwiches and wraps. They like their Monterey jack cheese (shows up on a lot of them), and their deli meats were fresh and generous. My pita was wonderfully soft. My wife had the Scotch beef pie, which was ground beef and vegetable in a double crust in a 8" bowl. It was quite nice, though asked for a bit of salt and pepper. My potato salad curiously was mayonnaise and mustard-based, but was tasty enough. They were pushing the homemade desserts but we, umm, well, we drank our dessert (see the review of the Framboise!). We'd happily go back for the food if we were in the area, but the beers--oh the fabulous beers--will definitely draw us back.

I can unhesitatingly recommend the Selin's Grove Brewing Co. for lunch and for their beer. Our server mentioned that they do get packed in the evenings, though mostly an older crowd (the students at the local Susquehanna Uni. apparently don't frequent it, so it is faculty and townies), and I can imagine that it is wonderfully friendly and lively then. We'll be back whenever we can find an excuse to be traveling the Susquehanna north of Harrisburg. Worth the drive, definitely!

 3,401 characters

Photo of DWolf
4.75/5  rDev +9.4%
vibe: 5 | quality: 5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | food: 5

Simply put, this place is OUTSTANDING. The atmosphere is rustic and comfortable. I'd add the word cozy, as well - as in it's small, so plan on a wait or to stand if you're arriving at a popular time. More importantly, almost everything brewed tastes GREAT. The food is simple, but fresh and fufilling. The only thing I'd change is to require that they have their popular brews on tap, as you would expect they would, especially the IPA. Is this too much to ask? They tendeth to runneth out too frequently, unfortunately. But, I guess that speaks to this place's popularity as well.

 581 characters

Photo of rfgetz
4.38/5  rDev +0.9%
vibe: 5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4

In the basement of a stone house, right off the main strip in small town Selins Grove sits this great little brewery. Exposed stone, brick and wood coupled with the dim lighting, wooden tables and old hearth provides one of the coolest, natural atmospheres in all of my beer travels.

8 or so beers on tap, 2 on cask and one on nitro at most times. The IPA and the seasonal fruit beers are not to be missed. Most others are true to style with nice little twists. 2oz, 4oz, 8oz small pours available for most brews 14oz or 16oz depending on the style for a full pour. Growler fills available on most brews. Prices were great for the beers with only 2-3 special items being more than $5.

Food list made up of mostly sandwiches and other small items. A great cup of vegetarian chili to please even the stingiest carnivore. Fresh deli meats and fresh breads make for great sandwiches, no matter which of the dozen or so you choose from. Service was good.

Atmosphere and brews alone make this well worth a day trip from anywhere in PA.

 1,034 characters

Photo of smakawhat
4.65/5  rDev +7.1%
vibe: 5 | quality: 5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4

Just off Market street sits a small tavern like establishment. If you go behind it you will find a place to park you car instead of leaving it on the main road which has a two hour limit. Pass through a small courtyard to a door and you are inside one of the most unique taverns I have the ever been in.

Inside is quite dark with a lot of wood. Staff is incredibly courteous to help you with the selections from the brewer. After trying a few, my only complaint was that I couldn't drink them all.

As I mentioned here the atmosphere is top notch. The place is filled with locals all coming in for their regular pints. One guy is simply known as King Henry, another is a charming lady who is great to talk to, heck she even buses the bar for the staff sometimes!!! The place allegedly has a ghost! And it feels like it too. What more do you want?!

The brewer's beers are real solid to make a long story short. Occasionally there are special seasonals that he makes as well, and plenty of growlers to be sold, although they will limit fills to leave beer for inside consumers and will not growler fill anything on nitro.

The food is pretty basic but with touches off homemade care. The bread on my sandwich had to be homemade as it just crumbled around the bacon. But the biggest surprise food wise is the inexpensive pretzels which are made and baked on the premises.

The pretzel is hands down the best one I ever had anywhere in Pennsylvania. It's dough is soft and warm with bread sweet chewiness. It is to die for. If you come you have to get a pretzel. I could have ate them all day!!!

The other thing that makes the experience so wonderful for me is that coming from the DC area everything priced here is just a bargain. Having quality brew at 3.50 a pint is a big change from 7 to sometimes 12 in the places I frequent.

I loved this place it is everything I look for in a tavern and it has more. Great stories, history, charm, feel, exceptional beer I wish it wasn't a three hour car ride to get there. I would go every day if I could I love this place!

 2,068 characters

Photo of prdstmnky
4.45/5  rDev +2.5%
vibe: 4 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4.5

Made the trip up on 7/31

Atmosphere: Interesting place, seems its simply a house that was converted into a brewpub. Small, cozy, laid back atmosphere. Its very dimly lit, almost too much so (that would be my only complaint).

Quality: Quality is great - the beer was phenomenal and the food I had was delish.

Service: No complaints, always had a beer in front of me, food arrived in a very timely manner. Very well run operation.

Selection: Lots of different beer options, though nothing on cask that day which was slightly disappointing. Food menu was somewhat simple but expected.

Food: Can only speak for what I tried - I had a bowl of ham / green bean / potato soup that was very hearty and quite tasty. Certainly something Id have again and recommend.

Value: Reasonably priced, boarding on inexpensive. I would have spent much more at a random craft beer bar/pub, and the quality wouldn't have been close to this experience.

Great brewpub, plan on making it back in the fall (and Im sure many times in the future)

 1,024 characters

Photo of SpeedwayJim
3.88/5  rDev -10.6%
vibe: 5 | quality: 3.5 | service: 4 | selection: 3.5 | food: 4.5

Came here on a recent road trip with the girlfriend.

Selin's Grove brewpud is actually a house in a little out-of-the-way village. Very homely and very charming. There's a seating area in the back yard and the main dining area is actually the living room with the bar in the dining room. Very dimly lit all over. Like a great place to hide out and drink amazing beer. There's board games you can play too!

The beer was served in appropriate glassware and at the right temperature. An addition of .5 points for how amazing their offerings really are.

Servide was decent. The place was small and it seemed like it never really gets packed out. Still though, we were able to order in a timely manner, got our food and drinks quickly, and got our checks quickly when we left.

Selection is pretty good. With about 8-9 house beers on tap and 1 on cask. Again, +.5 for how good all the beer was.

The food is surprisingly good. I got the shrimp wrap and was able to taste the roast beef sandwich (served on a pretzel bun) and both were amazing. The shrimp wrap was one of the best that I've had and the pretzel bun does something to the roast beef that's really magical. Plus, they had a selection of beer ice cream and other beer-related deserts. Can't beat that!

About $4.50 for a pint and around $10-$12 for entrees. Very reasonable prices, especially considering the overall quality of the food and drinks.

Selin's Grove is not a big name by any means but its definitely a hidden gem in my eyes. For a lover of small, quiet, quaint brewpubs (see my review of Alpine), this is right up my alley. Their beers are out of this word and the atmosphere and area just add up to a can't miss place.

 1,699 characters

Photo of Tucquan
4.33/5  rDev -0.2%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4 | food: 4

Visited here for the second time on 2011-07-23.

It'd been a couple of years since my wife and I stopped here on our way back from hiking the waterfalls at Rickett's Glen. On that day, we sat outside on the small patio-garden and had a delicious vegetarian meal and glasses of the extraordinary Kriek. My wife tried to order a growler to take home but as luck would have it, we got the last two glasses in the last keg. Ah well.

Yesterday, I noticed a Facebook update that Kriek was on-tap. My wife is in India buying silks for her fiber art. Not wanting to miss this fine brew, I drove 90 minutes to the brewery and got there as they opened.

This time, I sat inside at the bar. I ordered a Kriek and 8oz glasses of their newly-created Sour Red and well-rated IPA. You can read my reviews but suffice it to say, the Kriek is the standout.

The woman tending bar recommended the Italian-vegetable-pasta-sausage soup of the day, which was spicy and satisfying. She knew the beers well and offered interesting comments and stories about them and other beers from around the country.

While eating, sipping my beers and jotting down notes, I had a chance to chat with some fellow patrons who were also quite beer-knowledgeable. Our bartender joined in these conversations making it a homey, relazed atmosphere. This is a small place with good-great beers that made me feel welcome on this Sunday.

I ordered a growler of Kriek to go and just as it was topping off, it kicked. The bartender wiped it off, handed it to me and told me that was the last of the last keg. I appreciated the irony. This growler is now sitting well-sealed and unopened in my fridge awaiting my dear wife's return from India.

 1,699 characters

Photo of stakem
4.03/5  rDev -7.1%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 3.5 | selection: 4 | food: 3.5

I have been going to SGB for several years and was confused why I never took the time to write a review, well lets remedy that now.

I remember the first time I visited, I drove past the location at least twice having not noticed it based on the picture listed here. The sign for the brewery really blends in with the rustic building. Parking out back can be a bit of an issue during busy hours and driving a large truck makes for a real pain trying to maneuver into the parking spaces available outback. Before you even walk in, the atmosphere is awesome and much like a beer garden. Depending on the season, hop bines are growing all over the property. A few places to sit outside and inside is rustic with seating made up of chairs and benches. At times the lighting seems a bit dim but it is cozy and inviting.

The quality of beer pouring out of this establishment is fantastic. I am not even a fan of fruit beers but the ones made here are unreal in the way they are fresh and natural tasting. I always find myself going to the brewpub for a pour each time they are released. Their pumpkin ale on nitrogen might be one of my most sought after seasonal brews...ever. There is a usual lineup of roughly 5 beers that can almost always be found on tap and a few rotations based on season offer a pleasant change of pace and variety. Total tap selection comes out to roughly a dozen draft options and 2 hand pumps. However, I have never seen both hand pumps in operation at the same time and of the 12 taps, 1 or 2 of them are usually dried up and one of them is dedicated to a nitro pour.

The food here is a bit of a let down. Don't get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with anything I have ever had to eat here, it is just slightly frustrating when you are in the mood for something warm to eat. The selection is quite lacking which is understandable I guess considering the small scale they are working with. The menu consists of mainly cold cut wraps, sandwiches, cheeses and a variety of appetizers which are quite tasty and which are what I find myself gravitating towards each time I want something to eat. There is always a daily special which consists of something different and a soup.

The service is typical. It has its good and bad moments. When sitting at the bar, you get the most attention. While sitting in the dining area, you can find yourself sitting with an empty glass longer than you might like. Regardless, the wait staff is attentive and does their best checking up on you and making sure you are happy. This is a must see establishment. If you find yourself in the area and you don't stop to check it out or have a pint, there is something wrong with you.

 2,683 characters

Photo of philbe311
4.43/5  rDev +2.1%
vibe: 4 | quality: 5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4 | food: 4

A - Small... Quaint... Simple... Well kept... Inviting... Good background music in the bar area where they rotate through current CDs (Mumford & Sons and Anders Osborne)...

Q - Quality was across the board as this seems to be a very well run establishment... The beer is top notch... The food is more than adequate given their limited footprint... The venue itself is pristine and well kept...

Ser - Service was very good... No complaints... We received ample attention on a busy afternoon... Server was courteous and attentive... Very helpful at checkout with multiple growler fills and t-shirt requests...

Sel - This is a very small little place and while the food menu was somewhat limited, it suited this place very well... We were in on a busy Saturday afternoon and no one seemed to mind... The beer choices were varied and all of up most quality...

F - Food was simple and basic... Some nice appetizer choices and a good selection of cold sandwiches... No real hot food to speak of... I personally recommend the artichoke dip in bread bowl and vegetarian chili... The sandwiches were average...

V - Walked out the door after 3 pints, 3 half pints, 2 meals, 1 appetizer, with two filled growler (one brought with and one purchased) and t-shirt for just under a $100 buck before the tip so I can't complain, especially given the top notch quality...

 1,361 characters

Photo of jp11801
3.84/5  rDev -11.5%
vibe: 4 | quality: 3.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 3.5

On a sleepy Saturday I ventured up to Selin's Grove from Carlisle to check this place out. I was very excited and brought a few growlers with me based on the ratings the brew pubs beers received.

I arrived in town quickly located the place, this town is a great place for a day visit and it's a really nice ride from the Harrisburg area. The bar is in the basement area and I opened up to a quaint pub like atmosphere. I took up a seat at the bar betwena few locals chatting about the beer festival that had sold out in 4 hours the previous day or so. Nice overall bar atmosphere.

The service was friendly and fast and just what you would expect from a smallish PA town. The bartender had a great smile and sense of humor and was having a great time with the locals that were there. Not a beer expert but this is not that kind of place. They make beer but its not really a beer establishment like a 20 tap place would be.

Selection was limited to what they brew I tried a Stout, the IPA and the Scotch Ale. Up first the IPA and I was really excited to try it as I was expecting to fill my growler with this. It was ok not my style of IPA as I like more of a hop presence. I was let down based on my expectations but it was an ok beer. The stout was next and it was a nice representation of a dry nitro stout. I finished up with the Scotch Ale and overall it was my favorite although thi style is normally not a go to for me.

I skipped on food and headed back to Enola/Hamden for lunch and a pint. Overall it is worth the trip but I do feel the beers get a local ratings lift. If you are in the area definitely stop by or take a nice ride north from Harrisburg to give it a try.

 1,685 characters

Photo of sudzweasel
4.5/5  rDev +3.7%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5

Visited on 3/27/11 and was immediately taken with the atmosphere of the place. Cozy bar area with a small sitting room to the left and a small dining room off the bar. Quaint, several hundred year old basement in a former governer's mansion from what the server told me. The beer I had - a triple, IPA and pale ale were of excellent quality - we did not eat as we had head out. Could have easily stayed and made a day of it. The staff was very attentive and the locals had plenty of stories about the area ...and the staff. Funny stuff. We drove out of Harrisburg on 15N to get to this place and then we did not want to leave it as it seemed a perfect little hangout. I bought one of their distinctive growlers and filled it with IPA before I left. The growler was a bit pricey for glass but I could not leave without it. You can see how they look on their website.

 865 characters

Photo of bigfnjoe
4.38/5  rDev +0.9%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4 | food: 4.5

Selin's Grove is a quaint little place in the middle of the town of Selinsgrove, on the bottom floor of an old mansion. Slightly confusing to get to, but we got there in the end. 7 beers on tap and 2 on cask. I had the framboise (a little too sweet), IPA on cask (not balanced well and SUPER sweet), and the porter (fantastic). My buddies each split up the other 6 beers, including a wee heavy (way too boozy), oatmeal stout (fantastic), dubbel (not my favorite style), brown ale (alright, nothing special), dunkelweizen (alright), and a cream ale (loaded with corn). The vibe of the place was really nice, very laid back...no college kids, which was a blessing giving that Selinsgrove is a college town. Didn't try the food. My only knock on the place was that it was HOT. Not sure if that's just how they roll with how small it is, or if they had the heat turned up, but it could be a sauna come July. The beers were also really cheap. A dollar for a 4 oz pour of the standard beers? Giddy up! Will definitely be back again.

EDIT: a second visit this October, and I tried the food this time. My chipotle chicken wrap was on another level, and something I'll be eating every time I come here. Fantastic

 1,204 characters

Photo of eagles22
4.6/5  rDev +6%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 5 | service: 4.5 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4

Selins Grove brewery is my favorite watering hole. They always have fresh beer on tap and the service is always wonderful. Me and my girlfriend go here often and we are always pleased with the beer and service..the framboise is exceptional as one of there winter offering and so is all there other fruit beers and can't forget there IPA and cream ale.

The food is mostly sandwhiches which are fantastic and also they have great soups esp potato and leek! They also offer 4oz pours of there brews which is nice because they usually have around 8to10 beers on tap.

This place is top notch one of the best kept secrets of PA!!

Thank you SGB!!

 643 characters

Photo of Bmoyer0301
4.22/5  rDev -2.8%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4 | service: 4 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4.5

This is a no brainier must visit place if you are anywhere in the area because its like taking a step back into history. Upon coming in the basement double doors I feel like I am going to belly up to the bar with some colonial soldiers and have a pint of bitter. The atmosphere is dim lit and has stone walls and large wood plank beams holding up the ceiling. All the tables remind me of something you would see at a persons house not the typical "restaurant" styled tables. The staff is always friendly and knowledgeable and love talking beer. Every time I visit there is at least 6 or more drafts on and they all blow me out of the water especially the Kriek and Oatmeal porter. All their food seems to be rather healthy and non traditional pub fare which makes the experience ever better, great wraps, and hummus. This place is a must see and you will be glad you stopped by for good beers and reasonable food prices , and a great time.

 939 characters

Photo of drabmuh
4.06/5  rDev -6.5%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4 | service: 4 | selection: 4

Popped in this place during my tour of central Penn with Thorpe429. This looks like (and I imagine probably is) an old colonial house converted into a bar. We sat at a table as the bar was full.

Our waiter bussed a table and took our order for a pint very prompty and returned immediately with our beers. He filled our growlers as well very promptly and gave us our check so we could be on our way...very promptly.

The costs of the beers were reasonable, they offered about 10 different beers in a variety of forms, nitrogen, draft, cask, and overall it was a nice location. I would definitely head up there again in the future. I enjoyed it.

 645 characters

Photo of PittBeerGirl
4.33/5  rDev -0.2%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4

I've been really looking forward to taking a trip out to selins grove for a long time-and finally made it out there in September!

This is located in the basement/lower floor of a very old establishment in Downtown Selinsgrove. There is a nice porch/garden seating area outside.

The place is rather small on the inside-and very colonial. Think of a pub in revolutionary war times and this is what you get. Old brick, laterns, etc. The bar is immediately inside the enterance and a small dining area is located in the room behind the bar.

It was a crowded friday night when I visited and although our server was helpful and attentive-it was very busy. The menu is a lot larger than the website lets on. Our food was deleicious.

The beer here is top notch-which is why this place has a good rep. There wasn't anything super-special on tap the day I was there as the place was going to be closed in two days. I had the IPA and the Hefeweizen-both were wonderful. I was looking forward to the tripel-but missed it by a beer.

This is definately a must stop place in PA!

 1,070 characters

Photo of JunkYardJake
3.9/5  rDev -10.1%
vibe: 4 | quality: 4 | service: 4 | selection: 4 | food: 3

First time visiting this place. I went in with pretty high expectations after reading reviews. I would say overall I wasn't disappointed but I wasn't extremely impressed either. The place was alot smaller than expected but had a cozy local-watering hole feel to it. However, it was more expensive than most small town brew pubs, especially for central PA. The food here is clearly an afterthought. The menu is small and unappealing with no real pub food to be found. I get the feeling that if it weren't for PA laws, they wouldn't even serve food. The soft pretzel and mustard was pretty good though and the local cheese plate was decent, but pricey. Selection was pretty good for the size of the place. After having the sampler, I decided on a growler fill of the IPA and the Baltic Porter. Only after getting my bill did I realize the porter was a staggering $20 for a 2L takeout. It was good but I would've picked something else at a more reasonable price if I had checked the price sheet. The IPA, the Baltic and the Saison de Peche, which had great flavor, were top notch. However, I thought their other brews were rather pedestrian and overpriced. Especially the organic pilsner, which was my least favorite. That said, alot of their highly regarded brews like Framboise, Wee Heavy and Kriek were not available while I was there, so I'll visit again to get the whole experience. Despite it's shortcomings in a few areas, I can recomend this place because the IPA is reason enough to stop in.

 1,497 characters

Photo of orangesol
4.44/5  rDev +2.3%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4.25 | selection: 4.5 | food: 4.5

Visited the pub about a month ago. Just getting around to writing my review now.

Vibe/Atmosphere: A little hard to find from the main street. Actually drove right by it the first time. Wish I would have found out about the parking lot in the back the first time. I will be using that on future treks up there. Set in an old building is this gem of a brewery. Going down a set of steps leads you into the garden and the lower level/basement of the building revealing the actual bar area. The bar is small with seating for 10-12 and a few side tables. There are a few tables outside in the garden area as well.

Quality: The food was made with quality ingredients, most of which are from the local area. The beer is top notch as well. Not really sure what more quality you would need.

Service: Service was good. They only had one server on when we went up so she was a little busy. Every time my glass was empty I was asked if I would like another. It took a little while to order the food but that was mostly my fault because I didn't know what I wanted, being my first visit and all.

Selection: A very good selection of 8-10 beers upon my visit. I started with the Phoenix Kriek, which in my opinion is the best beer they make. It was sublime. I got two growlers to go. Went with an IPA for the meal, in my opinion their second best beer, and it was not as good as the first time I had it but still good. Finished the trip off with a Barrel Aged Wee Heavy from the hand pump. What a way to finish, almost like liquid caramel. One of the best BA wee heavy's I have ever come across.

Food: Food was good. I got a spicy pretzel sandwich. Wish I could remember the name of it, oh well. It tasted great and I will definitely get it again in the future. I also got to try some of the soft pretzel, since it is huge, and it was awesome as well.

Value: Prices were a little high but not too bad. The food was a tad expensive but the beer prices were pretty spot on for what you get. I have seen a lot worse.

Overall a great brewpub that deserves all the hype it gets. I will be going back up as much as I can.

 2,108 characters

Photo of beerthulhu
3.7/5  rDev -14.7%
vibe: 3 | quality: 4.5 | service: 2.5 | selection: 4.5 | food: 3

Vibe/Atmosphere: The place was hard to pick out from the street, with only a small sign that blended in rather well with the surroundings. A narrow pathway leads down to the lower level/basement of the building revealing a darken and cramp setup more akin to someones basement bar. The bar area was small with seating for 10-12 and a few side tables. Seating in the so-called restaurant was limited as well and very cramp, about the size of your average living room. Tables and chairs are squashed together, tables are bare and wooden and the overall appeal was one of a rustic unkept cabin set out in the woods. More of a dark college hangout if that's your thing, was mine 10-15 years ago, but offered little flair and not really a family place or one I would go to eat lunch at, even though I did with my family. Things are noisy inside, even for a Saturday lunch crowd. If your going to grab a few beers with your buddies then this is suitable, but not so much for those looking for family or lunch as their menu is extremely limited and unappealing.

Quality: Had a chance to sample 2 beers and took one to go growler. Their Saison de peche and stealth triple were absolutely fantastic, wish I could say the same about the growler of ipa I was stuck with. Their oatmeal stout sounded tasty and most of the other offerings got good reviews as well. Overall a nice supply of quality beer, not so much quality experience.

Service: Here is where I beg to differ from most. The place was packed for a Saturday lunch, by that I mean all 6 tables inside and 4 tables outside. We were outside. Two waitress seemed to be on hand and were unable to tend much attention and had to seek them out several times. Service was slow, sat about 15minutes after first seating before she even came around to take a drink order. Usually not to concerned about service and generally lax, but just think I was stuck with a uncaring waitress as compared to others who gleam about the service. A cold sandwich ordered took 25 minutes to arrive and was certainly nothing to rave about. Their kitchen is most likely not more stocked then mine. The waitress didn't take the time to even ask how things were and if you wanted something had to stop her on the way in the door. A quick reply and set down of your request was about all you could hope for. Again she just looked disinterested in even being there and maybe just got a bad server on a bad day, others seemed to have no problem.

Selection: A very good selection 8-10 different styles on hand, tripel, ipa, saison, and stout. Wide variety gets good regards here.

Food: Mixed feelings here. Very limited menu but was warned of this going in. I just didn't know how limited, didn't see any typical bar food like hamburgers , fries, but rather just an assortment of cold sandwiches with a simple side dish that was pricey (about $8 for a turkey bacon) but have to say the quality of the meat was very good as was the mustard and crunchy bacon. The food was pricey for what it was worthy so don't expect to much here. However the pretzels at 3 for $6 got you a big serving with again a nice mustard sauce.

Value: Prices for the food were pricey, a bit of a reach. The price for the beers were a bit pricey as well ($6.50 for the peche & $6 for the tripel) with a eye opening $29 refill for the saison de peche (but very tempting after you have it). The triple was $17 and the ipa was $14 a bit more reasonable, until you tried it at least. For comparison I live in NJ and these prices are common in my area, expected a bit less here, but it is a college town so soak mommie and daddies money for all its worth I guess. Also I purchased a growler at One Guy (Berwick brewing) the week before for $8. The saison I would of gladly paid for, the ipa was disappointing, and most likely my fault for not sampling beforehand. All in all paid $60 for 2 drinks, 1 growler of ipa, salad, 3 pretzels and a turkey bacon sandwich, take it for what its worth.

End Musings: Great quality beer, well worth the trip and a decent hang out place for the college crowd but you will pay the price. Go on a sunny day if you want to eat, nice being outdoors and chances of getting a table in limited seating area is slim to none. Can't imagine this place packed on a Friday night when the small crowd here was more then enough. Wouldn't recommend this as a family place (Bullfrog was much nicer with a much better menu and atmosphere for that) so I would venture up the road a bit. But if your young, like the dark, cramp seedy bar scene but with top quality beer then this works for you.

 4,605 characters

Photo of SamuelJackson45
4.55/5  rDev +4.8%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 5 | selection: 4 | food: 5

A- It was hard to find at first it's in a basement of a building and the entrance is in the back of the property.But the landscape is beautiful and the inside is nice as well.

Q- Very rustic looking with all the brick work and old church pues for bench seating. I thought that was clever.

S- Wonderful service very helpful.

S- They had a good selection of beers only try 3 on my first visit.

F- The food was awesome very tasty.From the soup to the sandwich wrap very yummy.

V- The price was reasonable.Worth another trip again.

 532 characters

Photo of koopa
4.1/5  rDev -5.5%
vibe: 4 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 4 | food: 3.5

10/08/10 REVIEW (3rd Visit) a4.0, q4.5, s4.0, s4.0, f3.5, $$$

Stopped into Selin's Grove today with grassblue on our Northern-Central PA road trip. We arrived around 1:15pm on a Friday and found the place to be painfully empty. Our server (didn't catch her name but it might have been Kim) was very nice, polite, attentive, and showed some beer knowledge. Upon request, she also recommended that we check out Berwick Brewing on our way home and she hit the nail on the head with that recommendation. Tap selection was good as ever at Selin's Grove considering every line available had something on. Also, there was little to know redundancy in style on the lines. Some brews offered at this time include: Hop Nouveau, Saison Peche, Fest, Cream Ale, Hefeweizen, Baltic Porter, IPA, Pilsner, etc.

07/16/10 REVIEW (2nd Visit) a4.0, q4.5, s3.5, s4.0, f3.5, $$$

Second visit went a lot smoother than the first visit. I made sure to ask many more questions of Heather this time before deciding to take the trek over with beerloco. I had her confirm that they not only had Phoenix Kriek on tap, but that they had more kegs available for tapping in case that one kicked.

When we arrived we sat in the dining room this time instead of at the bar. Our server Lynn was pretty fun and laid back. She was a touch forgetful but good spirited about it.

The brews I tried were really enjoyable...especially the Wit, the Kriek, and the Barrel Aged Wee Heavy. Besides those gems, I also sampled the cream ale, the organic baltic porter, the Goldings Special Bitter, the Pilsner, etc.

The food menu is extremely limited...mainly a few appetizer platters, some sandwiches, and maybe 3-6 entree choices. I had a sandwich that was good but also felt like something I could make at home and I'm no chef.

07/09/10 REVIEW (1st Visit) a4, q4.5, s2, s3.5, fn/a, $$$

After calling to confirm that Phoenix Kriek was available today and that it wasn't a bad idea to drive 3 hours each way to get some growlers, I took the drive out and the Kriek kicked after depositing 20oz's in my first of three growlers. The lady looked in the back, came out and said oops, then announced to the bar that it was the only Phoenix Kriek keg they had available for the moment.

This disappointment comes fresh off the heals of last weekends disappointment with this place. Last weekend I had a room at the inn across the street reserved. I called the bar the night before and they confirmed having 5 brews on tap. The next morning I drive to Bullfrog for the El Diablo Deluxe release and somebody at the release tells me that Selinsgrove's brewer is off for 2 weeks and they only have 2 beers on tap! WTF is up with this place? Decent beer but they don't seem to know how to manage a business. The brewer and the staff do not communicate enough (probably because he is married to one of them LOL!) and forget about anticipating a customers needs. This place can't even have the brewer go on vacation for 2 weeks and keep 5 beers on tap on Fourth of July Weekend, let alone double check the stock room to make sure that the beer you just advised wouldn't run out tonight won't run out tonight. Even despite the website which says in big bold red letters "Please call first before making a special trip for a special beer" well I did call first and you were lazy about checking. 6 hours of my life, $40 worth of gas, and a terrible 2nd impression (after a bad first impression the week before) is what your nonchalant attitude cost me ladies. Nor did I enjoy your lack of knowledge about beer.

Even when calling on the phone for information, the two women who screened the calls (and were behind the bar when I arrived) were quite aloof and wishy washy about answering questions. I was going to chalk what I've seen from them in the past week up to inexperience and growing pains, but in doing some research I found that this establishment was opened in 1996. This surprises me because it seems to be run like an establishment that is in its fledgling stages of development.

Bellyaching aside, the place itself was pretty cosy and both the Kriek and the IPA were enjoyable. I'd like to also note that they were served at the proper temperature which is a huge plus in my book. One of my pet peeves is a place that has enough attention to detail to arrange an amazing tap list/brew highly nuanced craft beers, but has the beer pour way too cold. The bar seats about 10, plenty of indoor tables to go around, and a few outdoor tables too.

 4,502 characters

Selin's Grove Brewing Company in Selinsgrove, PA
96 out of 100 based on 113 ratings.