Maduro Oatmeal Brown Ale - Cigar City Brewing
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 1,670 | Reviews: 584 | Display Reviews Only:
District of Columbia
4.15/5 rDev +5.9%
12oz bottle from the brewery; the sixer cost $9 I believe. Poured into an imperial pint glass.
Appearance (2): Very dark brown with dark gold around the edges. Half a finger of light cream head nearly disappears with a slight ring around the outside and a small patch of tiny bubbles. Nearly no lacing.
Aroma (4.5): Very rich, malty aroma with milk chocolate aromas and some sweet caramel malt.
Taste (4): Slightly sweet chocolate up front and some pine hops. Pretty mellow in the middle with some oatmeal and then some roast in the finish. Lingering flavors of mocha and maybe some pine. Not very hoppy overall.
Mouthfeel (4.5): Pretty smooth with medium to high carbonation. A little prickly in the mouthfeel but a velvety sweet feel overall.
Drinkability (4.5): Some pretty strong flavors here despite the low ABV. Very smooth and drinkable though. I wouldn't drink this all night, but only because I don't normally session Browns.
01-09-2011 03:19:22 | More by grover37
4.08/5 rDev +4.1%
Apr 2011 - Poured from a 12 oz bottle into a snifter.
A - Murky dark brown color. Light does not go through. Tons of bubbles constantly rising through the beer. Head is creamy and mousse-like and a yellowed tan color. It is initially almost 1" tall, then fades to a steady 1/8" with thick lacing.
S - Aroma of wood, bourbon-like alcohol, fresh tobacco leaves, grainy malt. Very complex. This is a much fresher bottle than the last one I reviewed. Now that I have a comparison, it is obvious that the first bottle had serious problems and was not representative of the beer.
T - Sweetness, dark fruit and alcohol hit first. In the mid-palate there is brown malt and chocolate malt, maybe just a touch of roasted grain. There are dusty grain and wood notes in the finish. The oat is not evident, unless it is the dusty grain I am tasting.
M - Moderate body. Low hops bitterness. No alcohol burn. Creamy carbonation that lightens the body; the creaminess could be partially due to the oats.
D - Nice brown ale character edging toward porter, with added complexity from wood and bourbon-like notes. Very creamy and enjoyable, but too rich for me to want to drink more than one.
Jan 2011 - Poured from a 12 oz bottle into a snifter.
A - Murky, dark brown color which shows a reddish brown when held to the light. The head was truly impressive, piling up about 1.5" of creamy tan foam.
S - The aroma is of a Flemish brown ale. Classic horse blanket dominates. Behind that is some muted malt and chocolate, but the Brett character is so overwhelming I can't believe no other reviewer mentioned it.
T - The initial taste is a mix of the Brett horse blanket and hops bitterness. Later a little malt and chocolate milk plays around the edges. Again, this beer has gone in a direction that I was not expecting.
M - The body is a little thin and the Brett flavors seem to come with a mouth-drying astringency.
D - Not at all what I was expecting, although it is a well-executed beer. This is a pretty nice Flemish-style brown, but why has every other reviewer treated it as an American brown with no mention of funk? I have checked and rechecked the label and this is not a special bottling. The label matches the photo above perfectly. Either I'm crazy, or they've significantly changed the recipe, or this bottle has magically been funked in a very drinkable way.
01-07-2011 05:15:40 | More by Radome
3.83/5 rDev -2.3%
Had on tap at Ravenous Pig in Winter Park Florida.
A: Copper brown with light tan head and a little lace on the side of the glass.
S: Oatmeal/ light coffee/ chocolate/ toffee/ Malt
T: The oatmeal and bitter chocolate come through nicely on the palate with a nice malt finish
MF: Nice medium body mouth feel with a very balanced texture.
D: Very easy to drink, it would not be a problem to have a multi beer session.
Very pleasant beer. Nothing earth shattering, just a well made beer that is fun to drink.
01-06-2011 03:24:40 | More by TriGuy20
4.23/5 rDev +7.9%
Poured out of a 12 oz. bottle into my Duvel.
A - Nice shade of brown almost looks like Coke. Pours a small, tan head that quickly recedes. No real lacing.
S - Toasty malt smell. Its very faint. Bit of sweet. Almost like a light chocolate. Not a strong smeller at all.
T - Nice vanilla flavor bursts right through this. Just a tiny bit of sweetness with a bit of smokiness. Light mocha and chocolate. Breathy alcohol at the end.
M - Creamy indeed. Coats the mouth pretty well. Deep breathes in and you get that vanilla again and again. Medium body.
D - Hell yes. I loved this beer.
01-05-2011 00:28:22 | More by GallowsThief
3.83/5 rDev -2.3%
Another CC beer thanks to scottyshades. Thanks Scott.
A: Pours a redish brown but appears darker brown when held to light mostly due to cloudyness. Little to no head. Not much lacing.
S: Malts, oatmeal, hints of citrus, some sweet caramel like notes finish.
T: First off this is a very well balanced beer. The malt and oatmeal hits first. The aftertaste leaves a very mild caramel sweetness that permeates quite nicely. Alcohol is not very present. After several sips I'm starting to pick up that citrus I was smelling. A very tasty beer.
M: Viscous at first, but dissipates quickly. Carbonation provides just enough tingle helping to spread the beautiful sweetness mentioned above.
D: Despite the richness of this beer, it feels much lighter. It tastes great and has an abv under 6. This is a beer that will work well paired with a good dinner and I would be just as comfortable with it on a nice sunny afternoon. This beer is very drinkable.
Overall I love this beer. One of the best brown ales I've ever had. I will certainly be seeking it out again. Thanks again Scotty!
01-03-2011 05:03:00 | More by mrmiles
4.45/5 rDev +13.5%
Picked this one up at random; had never had anything from Cigar City before. What a pleasant surprise! From a 12 oz bottle into my Sam Adams glass (thanks, guys!), it pours a rich reddish brown color with lots of carbonation. Even a careful pour yields a towering head of brownish-tan foam which sticks around well into the glass. Impressive nose with notes of oak and vanilla right up front. Very sweet and slightly medicinal with hints of dark fruit. A bit of "cherry lambic" on the nose. In the mouth, more oaky vanilla and raisins or plums along with woody malt. Very complex flavor--totally BLOWS AWAY my expectations for a "brown ale." Finishes on a slightly sweet malty note. Mouth is watery but somewhat chewy; steadily precipitating carbonation also keeps things crisp. Drinkability is very good; though there are big vanilla/oak/sweet malt flavors, the whole of it is subtle enough to enjoy several of these, and the 5.5% ABV is appreciated.
Overall: OK, I was seriously taken off guard by this one. I spotted a Brooklyn Brown, which I enjoy but which has become oddly hard to find in my neck of the woods. Maduro is NOTHING like Brooklyn Brown or a "traditional" brown (much less English). It's closer to Dogfish Head's Palo Santo Marron take on the "American" brown, except sans the 12% ABV. Delicious, drinkable, and at the 8.99/sixer price I found it at, a definite new go-to brew for me.
01-03-2011 00:27:03 | More by jettjon
4.25/5 rDev +8.4%
a - poured a one finger thick tan head into a snifter that left a thin sheet and good lacing. the body was dark brown, almost black.
s - chocolate, sweet malts.
t - bitter chocolate malts.
m - thin to medium on the tongue.
d - great beer and maybe the best brown i've ever had.
01-02-2011 01:44:58 | More by GPHarris
3.9/5 rDev -0.5%
I poured from a 12 ounce bottle into a sa perfect pint glass. The pour is deep amber with reddish highlights. The aroma is sweet and bready. The flavor is bready with a decent amount of caramel and enough hops for balance. It has a clean finish. The body is light/medium and well carbonated. A nice sessionable brew from CCB.
01-01-2011 21:07:52 | More by bonkers
4.33/5 rDev +10.5%
Thanks goes out to Bartrash for this brew.
Pours a nice golden brown color, nice carbonation, nice little fizzy light tan head, which does leave some nice sticky lacing behind. The nose is malty, sweet, with lots of caramel. The taste is sweet, malty, lots of caramel. Medium body. Very Drinkable, this is a very fine ABA. Thanks Pete.
12-31-2010 00:16:54 | More by Wasatch
3.73/5 rDev -4.8%
Appearance- very dark brown with light chocolate around the edges. Fizzy white head that dies down quickly. Very little lacing.
Smell- toasted malts and milk chocolate. Light hops are in the background but faint.
Taste- huge chocolate and toasted malt flavors with a balanced hop bitterness. Overall fairly sweet.
Mouthfeel- medium to thin. Decent carbonation. Nothing spectacular.
Drinkability- the finish of this beer makes you thirsty for more!
12-30-2010 21:44:56 | More by ztaylor1
3.75/5 rDev -4.3%
12oz bottle from a 6pack purchased at DeCicco's in Brewster.
Pours a really dark brown color....almost black, but not quite... smell is OK. some chocolate and toasted malt. tastes like a good brown ale. malty, toasted, smooth. delightful flavor profile with a medium body. mouthfeel is medium-thin....Drinkibility is OK....but i'm not a huge fan of brown ales....however this one is pretty good, i'd drink it again.
12-29-2010 01:37:27 | More by drewd0g
4.3/5 rDev +9.7%
A: pours with a finger of darker tan head. The beer is a rather dark brown that looks amber under the light.
S: really good aroma. Smells like a tiny hit of vanilla with chocolate and maybe a tiny bit of hidden dark fruits. Very gentle aroma, like no aggressive smells, just great aroma.
T: perfectly balanced with a hint of citrus fruit and chocolatey malt sweetness. Slighty bready, wh
12-29-2010 00:23:05 | More by OnThenIn
4.47/5 rDev +14%
Pours a very dark mahogany color. There is some light penetration and if enough gets in you get a lot of orange in it. Nice tightly bubbled head, not a big pile of foam. Good lacing.
Smell is roasted malt, cocoa, coffee, wet cardboard.
Taste is toasty malt, bittersweet chocolate, coffee and a slight cardboard note. Light oatmeal.
Medium/full body with a light effervescence. A nicely balanced dark chocolate / roasted malt aftertaste lingers for a long time without being annoying or displaying any harshness. A really well-rounded brew. No wonder they use it as the base for so many others.
12-26-2010 21:10:49 | More by PorterLambic
3.98/5 rDev +1.5%
Poured from a 12 oz. bottle into a Piraat tulip.
Appearance: Pours a nebulously murky garnet-brown color that looks akin to a Belgian style dark ale. Maduro is a pretty dark brown ale but when held up to the light it becomes fairly reddish. Even a vigorous pour can only stimulate a half-finger head to form, and it disappears almost instantaneously.
Smell: This brew has got a pretty nice nose on it for a brown ale. It smells a bit more like a stout than a traditional brown ale, as it has a lot of coffee and oatmeal in the nose. Lurking in the background, though, there are some typically sweet malts that assure me this is definitely a brown ale. Still, it smells very nice, especially considering it doesn't have a head anymore.
Taste: The promising smell leads to a bit of a disappointing beer for me. It has a lot of the standard dark(ish) malts that you find in most brown ales but steers away from the coffee and oatmeal found in the nose, though they are minutely present somewhere in there. This brew is just a bit bland for me and the individual tastes don't jump really jump out at you, they just get jumbled together.
Mouthfeel: This beer seems to be quite noticeably undercarbonated to me, which is probably why it hardly has a ring of foam around the top. I think with a little more carbonation this could be a really nice beer, but alas, it is destined for mediocrity without adequate carbonation. The lack of carbonation, however, doesn't cause anything to stick your palate.
Drinkability: Despite the relative flatness of this beer, it is a nice drinking beer and I think I might be awarding it a higher score in a drinkability than I might otherwise to raise the overall, as this is a pretty nice beer.
Overall, this is a pretty good beer. I'm generally not a big fan of brown ales, as I feel they are just manufactured to be pretty average. Maduro, in kind, is a pretty average beer but probably an above average brown ale and definitely unique for its type.
12-26-2010 19:55:39 | More by zoso493
3.43/5 rDev -12.5%
Poured from a bottle into a Celebration pint glass. The beer pours a murky brown with dark ruby glowing edges. There is a thick two finger off white head that slowly regresses, leaving a lot of foamy lacing on the walls of the glass.
The smell is muted. Toasted grains, brown sugar, hints of caramel, vanilla and faint alcohol sweetness. Some earthy hops. None of the oats that were promised in the name.
The taste follows the smell, toasted grains, bready malts, brown sugar, vanilla and caramel. The taste has a bit of nuttiness and chocolate, and the whole thing is slightly balanced by a fruity hop character. Not bad, not necessarily good, but not bad.
The beer is medium bodied, well carbonated and has a nice juicy hoppy aftertaste given how malty and sweet the beer tasted. This is an average brown ale, certainly not bad, but I was really looking forward to the oatmeal addition and what I perceived that would add to the style.
12-24-2010 03:23:14 | More by rpstevens
2.88/5 rDev -26.5%
A-Opens with a hiss and a burst of gunsmoke, before it rises and spills all over the table. Pours chocolate brown with 4 inches of frothy tan head. Reduces slowly, leaving spotty lacing.
S-Chocolate milk mix, rich, earthy cigar tobacco, nutty malts.
T/M-Dissapointingly weak and thin. Very little flavor. For how much head this had, there is practically no carbonation. Drainpour.
D-I have a feeling this is a bad bottle, judging by the other reviews here.
12-23-2010 23:16:18 | More by DaveHS
4.2/5 rDev +7.1%
12oz bottle from Abe's of Bethlehem pured into standard pint.
A- Dark "strong iced-tea" color that is brown with a amber red tinge. Medium head fades quickly to thin layer.
S- Dark creamy ale. Sweet with a touch of oats. Not very strong scent, but very good.
T- Bitter hops are evident, as is oats and caramel. Not quite as rich as a like, but very good. Earthy qualities.
M- Very nice creamy mouthfeel. Hovers in the mouth, although it does not quite beg for another sip like a high-quality brew does.
D- Very high due to the somewhat weak flavor. This would be a good "starter" beer into craft brewing since it is not real strong or offensive.
With a name like maduro, I was expecting dark rich chocolate and coffee notes like that of a maduro cigar. Its a tad gimmicky that it doesn't really have much of that in it at all. In fine cigars, maduro typically indicates a stronger flavor too.
12-21-2010 02:28:12 | More by TheSupremeAJ
4/5 rDev +2%
Appearance: Dark chestnut brown color. Little to no head.
Aroma: Nutty, caramel, and almost like a molasses and perhaps a hint of toffee.
Taste: Dark, caramel, very nutty taste. I imagine this as the beer form of a cigar. Great taste overall.
Mouthfeel: Good mouthfeel. Not too light and not too thick. Just right for a brown ale.
Drinkability: Pretty drinkable. Not something I'd usually drink and found myself wanting more. Would go great with a light dessert.
12-20-2010 19:34:29 | More by ninaturner
3.78/5 rDev -3.6%
Nice appearance, crystal clear dark chestnut brown color. But there is not much head to it.
Good aroma, light roasty and nutty notes.
Flavor is good but not exceptional. It is smooth and some what full feeling, but thin on flavor.
A very drinkable brown but not exceptionally noteworthy.
12-18-2010 18:21:52 | More by Naugled
4.15/5 rDev +5.9%
Review from notes taken on 12/1/10. On tap at Al's of Hampden.
Served in a pint, appears a hazed brown color with some ruby coloration and lighter brown around the edges. A dark creamy tan head forms across the top and doesn't retain all that well.
The smell of dark malt with sweet toffee suggestions emits from the glass. Some floral hops fill out the back of the nose.
Taste includes dark malt with sugary molasses and toffee flavors that are lightly smokey and modestly bitter with herbal and earthy hops. A slight fruity alcohol flavor is present that warms the back of the throat. Roasty flavors linger with a nice contrast to the hops. There is a lingering flavor almost like cigar wrapper and ash that is left inside the mouth.
Medium bodied with a light level of carbonation. This is quite a smooth, drinkable brown with a broad array of flavors. A little more bitter than your typical example of the style but I'm not complaining.
12-16-2010 20:22:08 | More by stakem
4.13/5 rDev +5.4%
From notes I made on my iPhone after a long night at work. Not super extensive, but it's all I got:
Lots of taste from this brown ale. Got notes of cinnamon,coffee, molasses, in nose. Taste follows nose, bring out the cinnamon, coffe and molasses. In the finish, a hint of bubblegum pops up
12-16-2010 02:42:17 | More by mjsheehan08
4.88/5 rDev +24.5%
Thanks to my buddy Brett in FL for sending. We cant get this in TX, and it drives me crazy.
A: Chocolate Brown pour into a dogfish head tulip glass. About 1.5 fingers of head tht quickly dissapated with a little tan lacing
S: Brown sugar, oats, caramel, tobacco, and a hint of nuttiness. I definetely thought of brown sugar oatmeal
T: This has some nice complexity- the oatmeal caries through, it has some really nice caramel nutiness, and just a little bit of musty flavor. Its obvious and impressive that the brewer had in mind a great beer to pair with a great cigar- the tobacco flavors get your palate reved up for a stogie.
M: Nice thickness to this one- medium bodied and consistent all the way down.
D: Highly drinkable, sessionable brown solid ale. Another great creation from the good folks at CCB.
12-15-2010 22:38:33 | More by lnashsig
4.18/5 rDev +6.6%
Blind beer #5 as part of Blind BIF #3 thanks to mtunnell.
12 oz bottle poured into a tulip.
pours a murky bud color with an off-white bubbly head that dissipates quickly.
First things to hit the nose are maple, coffee and molasses. Definitely some hints of roasted nuts. As it warms, there is some spice that I can't place...nutmeg? allspice?
The first taste really reminds me of something; I feel like I've definitely had this beer before. Just a light coffee and burnt caramel flavor, followed by a dry roasted nut finish. Possibly a little cinnamon.
Carbonation is light and small, and this is a medium-bodied beer. Definitely some butter/oil finishing on the tongue, but I really enjoy this in the beer.
Overall, insanely drinkable. I feel like I could put this away in seconds since it goes down so easy and leaves such a great little light caramel aftertaste.
Overall, seems like a lightly spiced brown ale and it reminds me of something like Dick's Double Diamond or GD Hibernation.
Time for the reveal...Cigar City Maduro Brown Ale
Wow, definitely have had this beer and love it. I never picked up on the spiciness before, so loved tasting this blind. The beer got better in mind.
To rate to style:
12-15-2010 22:31:20 | More by ChrisPro
3.48/5 rDev -11.2%
thanks to zimmerbloke for this one.
poured cold from the bottle a murky reddish brown to a dogfish head shaped pint glass with a tan head leaving nice retention.
slightly acidic aroma of dark cherries, followed by nuts and dark sugars as the beer warms a bit.
nice sweet, dark brown, nutty, smoked almonds, coffee and brown sugar.
thicker than the average brown, medium bodied, light carbonation.
drinkable - yep. very.
12-15-2010 02:07:48 | More by robwestcott
District of Columbia
3.7/5 rDev -5.6%
I got this as an extra from Pittsky. Thanks Jesse!
A: Poured a nice healthy, textbook brown color, with about 1.5 finger head that VERY quickly melded into clumps of bubble formations.
S: Brown sugar, oats, caramel, and a hint of nuttiness. It was almost like some sort of breakfast pancake or waffle topping.
T: Not nearly as candy-like on the taste though. Very subdued actually. However, I appreciated the lack of in-your-face brown sugar and it was very smooth indeed. This was a light to medium bodied brew.
M: I was able to take fairly large gulps without wincing and the carbonation was spot on for the style. The lacing was minimal to nill.
D: Highly drinkable for sure, however, this was sort of a let-down. I could have used some smokiness to the flavor just to add some pizzazz. Still, this was solid.
12-14-2010 00:44:03 | More by Chaney
Maduro Oatmeal Brown Ale from Cigar City Brewing
88 out of 100 based on 1,670 ratings.