1. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  2. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Or - Cigar City Brewing

Not Rated.
OrOr

Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
BA SCORE
91
outstanding

166 Ratings
THE BROS
-
no score

(send 'em beer!)
Ratings: 166
Reviews: 103
rAvg: 4.09
pDev: 11.25%
Wants: 26
Gots: 32 | FT: 2
Brewed by:
Cigar City Brewing visit their website
Florida, United States

Style | ABV
American Black Ale |  11.20% ABV

Availability: Limited (brewed once)

Notes/Commercial Description:
This beer is retired; no longer brewed.

No notes at this time.

(Beer added by: CampusCrew on 11-12-2010)
Beer: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
Ratings: 166 | Reviews: 103 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of DmanGTR
DmanGTR

Florida

4.33/5  rDev +5.9%

Shared this at a tasting last week. Compared side by side with Either.

Looks exactly the same as its twin, Either. Dark brown, cream/beige head, and clear with some deep maroon hues. That's about it with the similarities. Much more citrus and grapefruit forward and the chocolate, cocoa, and coffee are much less pronounced. An abundance of grapefruit rind, orange peel, and a hint of pine makes this a much more assertive beer. Rather than being a hopped up porter akin to its counterpart, this is a DIPA with some roasted malts added to the grain bill. That scores it a little higher in terms of aroma and flavor, as it worked very well. However, I couldn't drink as much of this so it falls just slightly in that department.

12-30-2010 06:47:02 | More by DmanGTR
Photo of 7ways
7ways

Georgia

3.43/5  rDev -16.1%

Looks exactly the same as its counterpart, black with a mocha head, fat globs of lace... except the head retention isn't as strong and the carbonation isn't as fine and creamy.

Smells much more of hops than Either, and more specific fruits. More focused. The chocolate aroma is more like brownies than dark chocolate, and it has none of the licorice or fresh bread I picked up in the other one. Much more wood. And a slight sourish quality that makes me think I have a dirty glass (it's clean).

The taste is not as focused as the nose, but it is a little more cohesive than Either. Unlike Either, this one actually tastes something more like a black IPA. A tipsy balance of hops and black malt, with the hops barely winning. Caramel and vanilla are still in the lead, but the finish is a little acerbic compared to Either, which I'll blame on the cedar.

Mouthfeel is probably about right for the "style", but I'd prefer it to be more full and accommodating. Still well done.

Clearly a well made beer, but not for me.

12-29-2010 00:03:38 | More by 7ways
Photo of weeare138
weeare138

Pennsylvania

4.05/5  rDev -1%

Appears a dark black with a small head of tan fluff that doesn't want to fade away. Scattered streaks of lacing are left around the glass.
Smell is of heavy citrus, roasted malt, cocoa, floral notes, caramel, and pine.
Taste is of the aromas with spritzy hop notes zinging along the back of the palate.
Mouthfeel is medium-full bodied, zingy, with a semi-dry citrusy finish.

12-28-2010 20:22:27 | More by weeare138
Photo of wisrarebeer
wisrarebeer

Wisconsin

4/5  rDev -2.2%

Purchased at Ward's in Gainesville, FL for $6.99/12 oz. bottle.

A: opaque, black beer - not much head except for tan colored ring around glass
S: intense and strong nose, earthy hops, burnt licorice malt, loads of EtOH, nice and chewy
T: at the ABV and huge malt body balanced by intense hops this is more of a barleywine, balance is good, good malt up front but could use just a bit more, nice hop bitter finish, this one would age extremely well
M: very nice, well-balanced
D: surprisingly drinkable for a beer with so much guts and no aging

12-22-2010 02:12:51 | More by wisrarebeer
Photo of wethorseblanket
wethorseblanket

California

4.22/5  rDev +3.2%

Bottle shared by Austin - Thanks!

Pours black with barely any head except for a few bubbles. Nose is dominated by a hop character and wood. Taste is oaky and slightly tannic. Some faint cedar is noted. Mouthfeel is mellow and smooth. At bit heavy, but not so much as the "Either" version. Overall, easier to drink than the "Either" with a lightness and oak rather than big cedar. Liked it very much.

12-19-2010 03:59:21 | More by wethorseblanket
Photo of beersensei305
beersensei305

Florida

4.28/5  rDev +4.6%

Now it's time for the Or... this is a live review. I bought the bottle form my local liquor store...

A: Pours black with a nice fizzy tan head that lingers nicely...little lacing

S: the aroma gets me as soon as I pop'd the bottle I can smell the cedar and the sweet honey, piney and hopy

T: Very Different than either, and I may like this one more.. Nice roasted character, bitter. Chocolatey and good cedar notes. Hopy which leaves a slight nice dryiness. As it warms the sweet honey comes out. A hint of coffee

M: Smooth, medium bodied brew. leaves a dry tangy note on the cheeks. Decent carbonation.

D: Fairly strong, not as boozey as Either, but it is there.

12-18-2010 23:59:48 | More by beersensei305
Photo of BeerImmediately
BeerImmediately

Pennsylvania

4.5/5  rDev +10%

Served at a cold cellar temp into a tulip glass.

Pours with a thick, yet short tan head over an opaque black body. Head seems to drop more quickly than the Either. Still has great lacing, however.

Aromas are full of cedar, pine bark, touch of caramel, and touch of burnt toast.

Mouthfeel is quite smooth, leading to flavors of citrus hops, chocolate malts (more milk chocolate than cocoa), and plenty of cedar in the finish... just a touch of tobacco quality as it warmed. Finish is terrific. Mouthfeel was smooth throughout, with touch of bitter twang.

Enjoyed the balance which adds a lot to the drinkability for something this strong.

Both Either and Or are killer beers, and I'm not sure I could really choose one over the other. Or has a touch more milk chocolate quality, while Either is slightly more dark and/or bittersweet chocolate. Cedar rocks both.

12-17-2010 23:22:54 | More by BeerImmediately
Photo of PorterLambic
PorterLambic

Florida

4.08/5  rDev -0.2%

Poured nearly pitch black with a very nice creamy dark brown head.
Smell is almost all hops with faint maltiness way in back.
Taste is hoppy, with malt, a slight note of smoke.
A very creamy, richly textured full body with a noticeable though not overpowering alcohol note. Smooth with a light effervescence. A slightly woody note shows in the aftertaste. A really good brew fromt a really fine brewery.

12-17-2010 18:53:00 | More by PorterLambic
Photo of brentk56
brentk56

North Carolina

4.4/5  rDev +7.6%

Appearance: While the color of the beer is as dark as "Either," the head is a darker shade of tan, more densly packed and leaves a lot more lacing

Smell: Unlike the rich malt elements of "Either," the hops are much more apparent, bringing a piney character

Taste: The piney character from the hops is much more dominant in the flavor profile, as well, with the chocolate elements of the malt providing more of a backdrop; by mid-palate, the cedar adds its dimension and, while the honey appears in the back, in never makes quite the impression that it did in "Either"

Mouthfeel: Medium to full body with moderate to high carbonation

Drinkability: I first tasted this at the brewery and leaned toward "Or" and now having it in the bottle, my initial impression was tilted in the same direction; by the end, however, I began to appreciate "Either" even more and have shifted my preference; you really cannot go wrong with either, or or

12-17-2010 02:20:54 | More by brentk56
Photo of MasterSki
MasterSki

Ontario (Canada)

3.8/5  rDev -7.1%

Thanks to Joey for this one. Served in a Sam Adams perfect pint glass.

A - Looks almost identical to Either, but with slightly more foam. More of a true 4.5 in appearance here.

S - This has less burnt character, and more dark chocolate. The hop character is more herbaceous, with some light catty notes.

T - Again, this is less bitter, with less of that burnt malt bitterness and char character I find in a lot of Cigar City offerings. Nice caramel flavors, honey, and solid hop bitterness in the finish.

M - Pleasant zesty carbonation, medium body, nice viscosity. Quite similar to Either.

D - This is quite similar, but I like it more as the burnt and char notes are more attenuated and there's a bit more balancing sweetness. I had this again on-tap at Cigar City and the draught seemed a bit fresher than the bottles.

12-15-2010 20:27:08 | More by MasterSki
Photo of djmichaelk
djmichaelk

Florida

3.83/5  rDev -6.4%

12oz bottle into a CCB snifter.

A - Pours a near-black, with a pretty solid-looking khaki-colored head with good retention. Great lacing all over the glass.

S - Not as sweet-smelling as Either, having more muted elements of the brown sugar and toffee. Maybe a touch more hoppy that its brother, and less roasty.

T - Roast, caramelized sugar, and some char. The hops are more prominent in this one, giving the bitter finish a sharpness that is pleasant. The finish is long and dry, and has an acrid feel that takes away from it just a little.

M - Again, great mouthfeel. Perfect carbonation and full without being too much.

D - This is part 2, and I'm definitely feeling the abv between them. I could've probably gone for two Eithers, but not Or.

O - Again, price is a bit high but I'll probably grab another pair since they're one offs. Pretty good stuff.

12-15-2010 13:02:06 | More by djmichaelk
Photo of aubuc1
aubuc1

Florida

3.9/5  rDev -4.6%

12 oz bottle poured into a snifter.

Pours a dark black with a thin tan head.

Smell is a big citrus with some light roasty malt.

Taste is a big roasty, bitter, coffeeish slightly boozy and honey sweet.

Mouthfeel is silky smooth.

Drinkability is a little off of good due to stiff bitterness and light booziness.

12-14-2010 01:02:34 | More by aubuc1
Photo of adam42381
adam42381

Florida

4.03/5  rDev -1.5%

Poured from an 12 ounce bottle into a Spiegelau tulip. Purchased along with Either at Cigar City Brewing taproom on 11/20/10.

Appearance: Pours a coffee black color with a 1-2 finger foamy tan head. Looks like a stout. Excellent lacing.

Smell: Piney hops, bitter citrus, roasted malt and mildly astringent alcohol.

Taste: Pine with a hint of citrus up front followed by warming alcohol in the middle then ending with roasted malt and coffee at the finish. Distinct cedar notes throughout. Aftertaste is bitter hops. Flavor definitely expands as it warms up.

Mouthfeel: Full-bodied with a good amount of carbonation. Very creamy and prickly at the same time.

Drinkability: Decent drinkability. This is a beer I would drink slowly. Because of the high ABV, I wouldn't drink more than one.

Overall: Good beer overall. This is another solid offering from Cigar City. I'd have a hard time recommend trying this because it's $7.50/bottle. If you don't mind the price, it's definitely worth giving a shot.

12-12-2010 20:15:32 | More by adam42381
Photo of GOGRANDE
GOGRANDE

Colorado

4.58/5  rDev +12%

A: pitch black, agressive pour gives it a nice moca head.

S: cool combo of light coffee and hops, nice roasted malt nose but with a nice piney background.

T: sooo good...mmm. roasty dark, mildly sweet flavors up front. Light coffee,mild sweet chocolate then a fairly bold roasty middle section followed by a nice hoppy bite/dry finish to end the experience. Piney hops are very present and taste great. Flavors work well together roasty and hoppy pretty much at the same time. The balance is perfect.

M: medium silky smooth. Very nice. Perfect for this style.

D: DANGER! very drinkable...this is one could sneak up on you quick. Its over 11% abv...

Great colab! this beer is great. Best black IPA I have ever had.

12-12-2010 04:46:24 | More by GOGRANDE
Photo of kingcrowing
kingcrowing

Vermont

4.2/5  rDev +2.7%

12oz bottle poured into a Duvel tulip.

Pours a nice dark brown, it looks near black in the glass but while pouring you can see light hints of red, it's a nit lighter than 'Either'. There's a nice creamy one finger head with some light lacing. The nose is super fresh and fruity, floral hops and mango.

Taste is better than 'Either' right off the bat. That graininess is present but it takes a back seat to the sharp bitterness and dark malts. There's a nice roasty finish that just seals the deal for me. Prime time. Mouthfeel is also pretty highly carbonated, but it's still creamy and smooth. Very good!

12-11-2010 22:05:29 | More by kingcrowing
Photo of meatyard
meatyard

Pennsylvania

4.05/5  rDev -1%

Pours a nearly opaque black/brown with a 1-finger, brown head that falls quickly to a cover leaving scattered lace.

The smell is cedar followed by pine hops and then roasted malt, interesting so far.

The taste is light piney hops and cedar up front then some roasted malt and finishes with the cedar again and a dry bitterness.

Mouthfeel is medium and smooth.

Drinkability is pretty good though it is large in the ABV (the alcohol is there but is not huge or distracting). It has a lot of"interesting" going for it too.

12-11-2010 21:37:53 | More by meatyard
Photo of kiddynamite920
kiddynamite920

Pennsylvania

3.85/5  rDev -5.9%

A: A thicker head than the Either, looks a bit lighter as well. The beer is around the same black color though.

S: I pick up the cedar in this one, and a more aggressive hop profile. I am also getting a dank, marijuana like aroma from this one. The hops here are more earthy and piney, less citrusy and juicy. Not picking up the big roasted malts that balanced the Either out so nicely.

T: The roasted malt is there on the palate in the same dry, bitter quality as the Either. Interesting how the cedar aging comes into play on this one, but not the other one. Big wood notes with some tobacco. The hops are very present here as well and offer some pine and sharp citrus flavors of grapefruit.

M: A little harsher on the palate than its counterpart, tends to pull at the teeth and gums a bit more. Has a bit more of a carbonation bite.

D: Overall just the harsher version of the two. More hop forward with less roast to balance it. More wood notes that only further unbalance it. Lacks the creamy quality of the Either.

12-10-2010 02:42:48 | More by kiddynamite920
Photo of kbutler1
kbutler1

Minnesota

3.9/5  rDev -4.6%

Bottle. Poured into a large tulip glass a very dark brown/black color with a medium sized bubbled tan head that slowly recedes. An interesting aroma; grassy, roasted malt, woody, and almost an underlying mint but this could be the toasted cedar throwing me off. Medium mouthfeel with nice carbonation. The first thing I notice is the sweetness of the honey followed by the toasted cedar flavors. The hops are there and in abundance with notes of citrus rind. Nice lace left on the glass. The alcohol is not as noticeable as I would have thought. I get some licorice flavors in this as well. This has a pretty bitter lingering finish that but also leaves your lips slighlty sweet. Overall, pretty good but for $7.50/12oz bottle, it's a little bit on the steep side.

12-09-2010 21:17:37 | More by kbutler1
Photo of gford217
gford217

Georgia

4.28/5  rDev +4.6%

12oz bottle courtesy of Axic10.

Pours nice and dark, very nearly black with only hints of light passing through the edges. Big, thick head that recedes quickly to thin cap and leaves a little lacing.

Aroma is hopper than Either, or at least seems to have more citrus bitterness and less roasted malts. That said, there are plenty of malts and chocolate, but the citrus is more prevalent than Either.

The taste reverts back to the big roasted black malt backbone with the oranges and pineapple coming through as well. The taste, again, has a tad less sweetness and more bitterness than the Either.

The mouthfeel is full bodied with a nice carbonation and very creamy. The alcohol is a little less noticeable than Either. I think both of these beers are blurring the lines between black IPA and strong ale. These are some big beers.

12-08-2010 03:12:00 | More by gford217
Photo of steve8robin
steve8robin

Massachusetts

3.93/5  rDev -3.9%

Got this on a trip to Florida. I have had many great CC brews. Let's see if this one follows suit. 12oz bottle...

A: Super perfect pitch black with a thick 1 inch mocha colored head that fades slowly. Very good.

S: Super bitter citrus hop upfront with some nice creamy chocolate cocoa notes quickly followed. Some great caramel in the middle with some sweet vanilla and earthiness on the backend. Very good.

T: Get a super intense bitter hop blended with a boozy warming burn. Some chocolate notes in the middle with some sweet fruits blended in. More of a boozy burn on the backend. Very boozy. Good.

M: Full bodied with a very nice carbonation feel. Super dry boozy finish. Good.

D: A little harder here from the heavy booze burn. Decent.

All in all, this is a good brew. Not one of the CC greats, but definitely solid. If you like boozy BIG hoppy IPA's with a unique twist, here you go. Definitely worth the try if you like CC brews.

12-08-2010 02:45:15 | More by steve8robin
Photo of Dreadnaught33
Dreadnaught33

District of Columbia

4.35/5  rDev +6.4%

Shared a bottle of this last night with drabmuh, thanks Matt!

A: Black color with brown on the rims, nice tan full head with excellent lacing and retention. Excellent

S: Hoppy clean dark malt scent. I can definitely tell it was aged in cedar, it comes off well. Very earthy outdoorsy smells.

T: Smoky overall like drinking burning wood. Meaty bacon mixed with citrusy hops and malty bitters. Salty as well with a sweet edge of honey. Grapefruit hops come through strongly in this. There are just so many flavors all at once, I am quoting Matt but everytime you smell or taste this something else comes through.

M: Creamy and the carbonation is excellent. Smoky and very well done.

D: This seems like an IPA mixed with a rauchbeer, very tasty but hard to drink a lot of. The half bottle I got was plenty! Nice work from Cigar city once again.

12-04-2010 00:05:18 | More by Dreadnaught33
Photo of drabmuh
drabmuh

Maryland

3.85/5  rDev -5.9%

Poured into a Bruery tulip. Beer is black with a nice off white to tan head of small and medium bubbles that leaves some lacing on the glass. Carbonation low.

Aroma is complex, a little smoky, very woodsy, grapefruit hoppy, mildly malty sweet. Lots going on here, it seems that every time I smell it I get something different than the last time. With so many big aromas in here, they tend to clash and fight for dominance.

The taste is the same, well first its medium in body and mildly carbonated on the palate. Second, the palate is so crammed with flavors from hops, to wood / cedar, to a little smoke, I can't make a lot of sense from this beer. THERE IS A LOT GOING ON HERE! Every time I take a sip I think something different. For example, strong grapefruit in the first sip, second sip I get a lot of dryness and some smoke, third sip...I get sweetness medium body moderate finish. This beer is all over the map. I don't know what to think of it....I'm confused!

12-03-2010 13:49:57 | More by drabmuh
Photo of Stigs
Stigs

Pennsylvania

4.28/5  rDev +4.6%

12oz bottle, the second half of the Either/Or combination graciously sent to me by BA'er (and new homeowner!) Infestaxtion. Thanks!

Served in a Stone Levitation glass...

A - pours with over an inch of rich, creamy, thick khaki colored foam. the beer is just about pitch black in color. a thin, yet sticky and filmy wall of lace eats up most of the free space on the glass going down.

S - a nice, pungent and bold bright citrusy hop aroma fills the room during the pour. from the glass, the hops remain fairly strong, supplanted now by some rich roasted, yet not charred malt, toasted nuts, and bits of milk chocolate.

T - huge flavors, all around. massive hop bitterness immediately strikes and takes no prisoners...bringing a hefty amount of bitter grapefruit, and massively earth and pine alone. roasty, charred malts struggle to get noticed alongside bits of chocolate, rum-like booze, and woody cedar. only a slight bit of metal and grains which often show up in a beer this big.

M - medium, creamy and slightly syrupy body in spite of a healthy dose of tingly carbonation. bittering throughout, yet finishes quite crisp and "clean". long, lingering earthy bitterness and lingering roast which is closed up nicely by a quick alcohol burn.

D - extremely well done al around, perhaps my only qualm is that everything in here is just overdone a tad. wonderful on the eyes, nose, and mouth. this is head and shoulders above "Either". this goes down so well, almost too well for its high ABV. warming me up on this snowy night!

12-03-2010 01:44:48 | More by Stigs
Photo of Patrick999
Patrick999

Florida

4.22/5  rDev +3.2%

I sit here desperately clinging to the hope that I'll like Or a hell of a lot more than I liked Either. My love/hate relationship with CCB's beers is perplexing, but I HATED Either. I gave it a C+ and that was really too generous, I think. Let's see about Or:

It looks good. Poured into a small CCB snifter. Thin foam, looks dark but not that crazy dark when held up to the light.

I love the aroma when the beer is really cold, I get that nice green, weedy hop aroma. It's still there as the beer warms, but I feel the need to deduct a half point because it starts smelling a bit boozy as it opens up, closer to what I did not like about Either. Still good, though.

OK. Now this is just a much better beer, in my opinion. Big hops and caramel with the occasional hint of smoke. No annoying mint/menthol taste. And further, it hides the considerable alcohol quite well.

It does feel like the big beer that it is. Full, slightly syrupy but not in a sweet way.

Still a big beer, but I think it's much better than Either.

12-03-2010 01:38:38 | More by Patrick999
Photo of Thorpe429
Thorpe429

Illinois

3.33/5  rDev -18.6%

Served in a Hill Farmstead wine glass.

Pours near black with a finger-and-a-half of light mocha head and some pretty good lacing as it goes down. Nice retention with some sticking power that's greater than what I found in the Either without a hard swirl. The nose is a bit hoppier than Either, with some citrus notes coming through as well as earth. The earthiness of this is quite prominent alongside a bit of roast.

The flavor starts out with some citrus hops and a bit of tangerine peel. After that comes a touch of light sweetness as well as some roast. A pretty good amount of booze is here as well, though not nearly as much as in Either. Medium body and not quite as creamy as Either, though the lack of alcohol dominance is nice. There are some hops in the finish, which is fairly dry. This is pretty decent and more drinkable right now than the Either, but neither one really stands up to what I would expect from these breweries.

12-02-2010 01:30:15 | More by Thorpe429
Or from Cigar City Brewing
91 out of 100 based on 166 ratings.