Redhook Winterhook - Redhook Ale Brewery
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 812 | Reviews: 456 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by ntillemans:
3.15/5 rDev -12%
12 oz bottle poured out into a pint glass.
A - dark amber, tan-brownish...low carbonation...less than a finger of head was gone within minutes
S - Slight roastiness and maltiness and a hint of fruitiness...but the overall culmination of that balance was neither appealing nor very potent...no alcohol smell I could detect.
T - I didn't care much for the balance. Not enough malt or (seasonal) fruity charm for a winter. Strong roast overtones and very hoppy (some fruitiness) but a very dry finish that I disliked.
M - Bitter, dry finish ... a lot of tingling on my tongue that caused me to salivate for want something a little more malty. This one's missing a fuller body one expects in a winter ale.
D - I may be biased against this one because it's heavy on the bitter hops and light on the maltiness and robustness I tend to enjoy. I could drink several of these and I could think of many beers I would dislike more than this one. I just won't seek this one out.
01-19-2008 02:22:11 | More by ntillemans
More User Reviews:
4.13/5 rDev +15.4%
Had this on tap at Brixx Pizza,first time on tap.Poured a lighter brown almost amber color with athis head that left a thin sheet of lace,picked up a bigger than expected hop presence in the aroma some pine along with some roasted malt.Big and hoppy up front on the palate very piney and resiny with a enough of a roasted malt backbone to hold up to the hop attack making for a big,bold,well rounded brew.Very pleasntly suprised with the character of this brew,have had it before and dont remember such a hop profile.
12-10-2004 03:54:24 | More by oberon
3.95/5 rDev +10.3%
Appearance - The body is a very dark brown but clear. The head was just gorgeous. It lept up instantly, held on for a while, pitted beautifully, and left tons of shaving cream lacing on the glass.
Smell - The sweet malt aroma is faint, yet very winteresque. There seems to be a mild hop balance as well.
Taste - The flavor is thinner than I had anticipated from the nose, but the malt sweetness is good. It's very one-dimensional though and pales in comparison to the taste that I had on-tap at the brewery. I didn't write a review for that one because I didn't take any notes, but I remember it being much fulller and substantial.
Mouthfeel - Very little carbonation to this light to medium-bodied ale. It's very light and smooth; thin in the mouth yet non-intrusive.
Drinkability - This has the ease and drinkability of a summar ale yet the yearning flavors of the strong, old style. I think it's lost in a time warp. It's too light for the acclaimed style yet too dark and malty for a summer refresher. The worse of both worlds? It's really not that bad, but I must consider it a miss on most counts.
Update - The 2004 bottle is better than the one I sampled in '03. It seems a bit bigger and the hops are definitely bigger, at least I'm picking them out that way. I still thought the Mouthfeel should be bigger for the flavors but am otherwise moving all the other ratings to 4.0.
Update - The 2005 vintage is right on par with the '05. The Mouthfeel is still lacking but overall it's a good brew.
Update - The 2009 vintage has now extended the pattern. This beer has nice flavors and actually looks pretty cool but lacks a strong body.
10-31-2003 04:27:46 | More by RoyalT
3.65/5 rDev +2%
My wife picked this up at the store. Sounded interesting. This is my first Redhook.
The beer is a dark red brown. There is a decent finger, late' colored head. There is some lacing but nothing to write home about.
The smell makes you think that there is some alcohol there. It's malty with bread, caramel, coffee and molasses.
The taste is quite like the smell. It's like a cross between a red and a porter. I don't like that too much because the bitter porter gets in the way of the sweeter, breadier malt and it's too weak to feel too much like a porter. The finish is a nice bite of hop and bitterness from coffee and molasses.
It's a pleasant enough brew but it's a little to o thin and watery at times.
11-22-2009 06:51:41 | More by sgoodship
2.7/5 rDev -24.6%
Pours a dark lager with little carbonated fizzy head which is a pure white. Not exactly what I would have expected for the style.
Smells a little bitter and biting. I dont sense any depth, little hops.
Not much spice, not much flavor for the style. No depth, not much of much.
Feels ok, maybe a little over carbonated.
Rather move forward from the beer than back to it. So many other options out there, I dont see myself wanting another one of these.
12-20-2006 02:24:59 | More by JasonA
4.22/5 rDev +17.9%
I'm surprised this beer hasn't been reviewed. Redhook East is a good brewery, and the pub serves great food. Anyway, this winter seasonal is a nice dark amber color with a fairly thick creamy head. Good lacing. It has a sweet molasses smell to it, and a fruity, cinnamon taste. Good mouthfeel, not too carbonated. A very drinkable beer.
01-17-2006 12:52:21 | More by lordofthewiens
3.2/5 rDev -10.6%
Poured from a 12 oz bottle with a newer label than the one pictured (as of 2/27/06) and an embossed "Bottled" date on the bottom-right of the label.
Appearance: Nice reddish-brown hue. 1/2 beige head with impressive retention and lace.
Smell: I detect a fate toasted caramel scent accompanied with some citrus.
Taste: The taste presents the caramel and a toasted malt flavor. The hops add the bitterness and aroma, but I would say to a mild to medium extent. The fruity and spice flavors add to the mix. The alcohol is detectable, but not immediately.
Mouthfeel: Thin-to-medium and smooth body. The carbonation is right on track.
Drinkability - A tasty winter treat that (at 6.0%) will warm you up nice. Also, the alcohol is balanced well with the malt and hops making it easy to drink several before noticing its "warmth".
Notes: It may not be exceptional (a little on the thinner side for a winter beer), but definitely worthy of a six-pack in the fridge for the winter months.
02-28-2006 02:11:51 | More by BlitzShadow
3.88/5 rDev +8.4%
No head, just a slight ring of khaki on the edge. Dark and clear amber color. Very smooth mouthfeel, with a bit of bitterness that breaks through to you. Lightly carbinated. Not too heavy at all. -Could not get any scent on this one at all (was drinking at my hangout which had become a bit smokey, when I shoved it at beerbud in frustration to see if he could catcha whiff, he said he could smell generic cola). Decent drinking brew.
07-05-2004 14:53:05 | More by shapudding
3.63/5 rDev +1.4%
Poured into a pint glass.
A - pours a nice clear red. Bit of cream head. Nice lacing.
S - Not a whole lot going on. Little bit of sweetness & malt. Little bits of spice.
T - A bit of the same. Some spice and caramel sweetness, some nice evergreen hops. Hopped a bit more heavily than I'd expect... it isn't really all that much, just a little bit more than I'd expect in balance to the malt. Finishes with a bit more spice and the hops.
M - Fairly thin, nice carbonation.
D - Pretty good. Wouldn't be hard to finish several of these.
Ok winter warmer, nothing terribly exciting. There are better ones out there, but this is worth a try.
02-02-2009 03:08:17 | More by cschepers
4.2/5 rDev +17.3%
One winter seasonal that I have probably seen the most improvement over the years is Winterhook. Its been around since 1985 in one form or another but seems to be on the stable path for several years now. Bright clarity off of the deep copper color brew, awesome looking lacing as it leaves a web like trail down the glass. Malty aroma of toasted grain and caramel, hint of floral and grassy hops as well. The smoothness is certainly there with a small crispness that drops off quick in the medium body. Spicy, herbal and bit time floral hop flavor don a balanced bitterness that lingers far into the drying finish.
High in drinkability, flavorful and a bit complex yet approachable enough to bring to a holiday party. By far its one of my favorites each year.
12-18-2007 04:13:24 | More by Jason
3.5/5 rDev -2.2%
Has a pretty medium copper color after poured into a pint glass. Little head retention, but nice lacing that hangs around. Pleasant nose is a bit complex, but dominated by malt sweetness, hops, and a hint of woodsy spices. Medium bodied in the mouth, definitely crisp with hops. I swear that there are some kind of spices trying to reach out and bite your tongue. Dry aftertaste and definitely a belly warmer. Above average for a seasonal ale.
11-12-2003 22:51:47 | More by merlin48
4.08/5 rDev +14%
Light brown and foamy, left alot of foamy lace. Crisp and refreshing, nice qualities for this syle beer. Very smooth and long malty center, Mild/mellow hop finish. nice balance and drinkability. Good session brew. A pleasant quaffer. Tried this one on tap. Didnt have the time to let it warm up abit in the glass.
02-07-2004 02:17:32 | More by Billolick
3.51/5 rDev -2%
Single bottle from Premier Gourmet in Buffalo. 2013 edition. Part of a haul of Christmas themed ales I picked up for the season. Unique bottle design, to say the least.
Poured into a nonic. Dark chestnut ruby in colour, with a quarter inch of light foam that recedes into a thick ring.
Nose is still fairly malt-forward, but there is a nice earthy grassy hop presence coming through as well.
Solid winter warmer that is malty enough to fall within that heavier brewing category, but has enough pale ale elements to be quite drinkable. Malty, bit of chocolate, earthy hops, light taste of pine, bit of fruit and spice, grassiness. Mild booziness to it.
Tasty enough brew - it isn't the big winter warmer I was expecting, but it is certainly a tasty ale with a good hop presence.
12-04-2013 04:02:29 | More by JohnnyBarman
3.68/5 rDev +2.8%
Appearance: dark brown with some reddish hues , the head was large when first poured , dissipated to a quarter inch of offwhite foam. A moderate lace left.
Smell: a fair amount of hops ( kinda evergreen) in the nose , a little bit of maltiness , hint of spice and alcohol.
Taste: medium maltiness , lots of greener hop flavor and bitterness , the flavor profile does have a bit of holiday feel ... somehow. Almost reminds me of a christmas tree?
Mouthfeel: slightly slick and medium bodied.
Drinkability: This winter warmer is quite drinkable and appropriate for the holidays , and has a pleasant flavor , its just not quite up there with others that iv'e tried. I am glad i tried it though.
11-25-2006 05:45:25 | More by Byeast
3.5/5 rDev -2.2%
12oz.amber bottle. Born on date of 9/25/03.
Poured a deep amber in color. Shafts of ruby-red light can be seen when held up to the light. Excellent lacing of the glass with a tannish-colored head. Aromas are a mixture of grassy hops and some sweet malt. Flavors are hoppy up front and finishes with a caramel sweetness combined with a bit of a metallic flavor. Mouthfeel is nice. Creamy smooth and medium-bodied. Drinkability is average, with the metallic flavor costing points in this category.
Notes: Not too much in this one to make me think of this as a winter brew. It's probably the best Redhook beer I've had, but it's more of a regular amber beer than a winter brew. Not one that I'd rush out to buy each year to see how it's changed.
12-21-2003 01:03:51 | More by OldFrothingSlosh
3.11/5 rDev -13.1%
Served on tap in a pint glass.
Appearance: Reddish amber with a white head. Mild lacing on the glass.
Smell: Roasted malts, maybe some spices and hops.
Mouthfeel/Taste: Smooth medium bodied. Taste of spicy roasted malts, some grassy notes as well.
Overall: Not a bad winter brew, I have had this one quite a bit over the years, can't really go wrong with it.
04-26-2012 22:51:34 | More by Cavanaghty
3.23/5 rDev -9.8%
Bottle poured a clear amber with a medium white head. Nutty aroma with some herbs and tea. Flavor is smoother than one would expect, malty and earthy. The taste is almost like a low-alcohol barleywine. Its okay, but not really what I was expecting from a winter brew.
12-12-2008 22:12:12 | More by magictrokini
2.65/5 rDev -26%
served into tall pilsner glass,from a 12oz.brown long neck bottle crimped-on cap.
Medium copper,reddish hue,off white head dissapated quickly to layer of foam.
Nice pleasing aroma,very spicey,citrusy,yeasty aromas Belgium-like spiceyness to the nose.
Spicey taste not as spicey as the aromas would suggest. A kind of bland taste midway through. A dry,tart finish a bit citrusy. Kind of a let down after the nice aromas.
Medium mouthfeel,slightly chewey,a bit harsh going down. Average beer not exciting,couldn't drink too many of these.
01-07-2007 04:34:16 | More by jcdiflorio
3.79/5 rDev +5.9%
Beer poured out a brownish caramel colour from the bottle, and had a creamy, low head. Had the faint aroma of floral, citrus hops with a hint of sweet malt. Taste was on par with the smell; there was a mild hop presence that was smoothly blended with a slight sweet malt flavour. Medium bodied and flavourful, with a lingering hop taste of the palate.
Would I buy this beer again? Definitely.
01-12-2013 05:51:05 | More by NilocRellim
Redhook Winterhook from Redhook Ale Brewery
81 out of 100 based on 812 ratings.