1. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  2. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

The Bishop's Collar

Not Rated.
The Bishop's CollarThe Bishop's Collar

30 Ratings
Ratings: 30
Reviews: 21
rAvg: 4.01
pDev: 5.49%
Taps: 12
Bottles: 17
Cask: N
Beer-to-Go: N
[ Bar, Eatery ]

2349 Fairmount Ave
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 19130-2515
United States
phone: (215) 765-1616

visit their websiteWebsite view map and get directionsMap @thebishopcollar

None, yet.

(Place added by: WilliamPhilaPa)
Place: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
Ratings: 30 | Reviews: 21 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of ColForbinBC

New Jersey

3.88/5  rDev -3.2%

Swung by here based on the tap selection. I have been wanting to check this place out for a while, but I am very rarely in the art museum area.

A relatively simple setup inside. Narrow room, bar along the right and table area in the back. Nothing elaborate, except for the bobble-head collection running along a shelf above the bar.

Tons of philly sports teams represented through pictures, pennants, etc. Not scoring any brownie points from this NY sports fan, but I can appreciate the dedication.

The tap list was about 12 deep and included Pliny the Elder, Bell's Two Hearted, Deschutes Black Butte, Chouffe, and a couple of Allagash's. I went for the Pliny and followed that up with a Two Hearted. The bottle list was small, but they had some heavy hitters.

Service was on par, no real impressions either way. A solid neighborhood bar.

09-19-2011 14:06:12 | More by ColForbinBC
Photo of jmdrpi


3.65/5  rDev -9%

Stopped here after a tour of Eastern State Penitentiary for food and a few beers. Standard city bar, narrow with the bar to one side and tables further back. Jukebox and crowd at the bar made for a noisy atmosphere.
Beer selection was about a dozen beers on tap, and about an equal number more in the bottle. Mostly american craft, with a few Belgians. I had glasses of Troegs and Victory, as they we the only stouts on tap. Prices were good for the city.
I had a very good flank steak sandwich, and every else said their food was good too. Service was about average.

07-01-2011 04:32:30 | More by jmdrpi
Photo of rfgetz

New Jersey

3.83/5  rDev -4.5%

The bar looks like your standard, corner bar with misc. beer related decor strewn throughout the hasnt-been-updated-since-the-50s furniture and fixtures. A few TVs and a jukebox are the only things that make it feel modern. The taps at times can house a majority of macro crap along side average local product but strewn throughout is a minimal selection of high-grade American craft. Hit or miss, so check before you go whats available - a little bit of an identity crisis.

While the crowd is commonly diverse and local, on weekend evenings, the place also appears to cater to the post-college douchey crowd who yearn for days long passed. The food is decent bar food, nothing much else to be said about it. The bar tenders are topnotch however and always do a great job. I have a love hate relationship with the place, but come back a few times a year.

06-16-2010 14:12:44 | More by rfgetz
Photo of John_M


4.13/5  rDev +3%

Missed the Larry Bell event the preceding Friday, but stopped in after the Philly Craft Beer Festival on Saturday afternoon. They had run out of the Hop Slam (naturally), but still had on tap 8 other beers from Bells, as well as something from Yards, the white rascal from Avery and Guinness. So the tap line-up was still pretty solid and was augmented by some interesting bottles listed on the blackboard over the bar.

This place is incredibly popular and was filled to overflowing even at 3:00 on a Saturday afternoon. The place is not all that large to begin with, looking to be a converted row house with a long narrow bar running down the right side as you walk in from Fairmount Ave. There are some tables and chairs in the back as well, but not a lot. So I'm thinking it wouldn't take much for this place to feel pretty crowded (as it did the afternoon I was there).

The vibe is pretty comfortable here, with a couple of flat screen TV's, an array of knick knacks and other decorations, and a number of bobblehead dolls behind the bar. Feels like a good place to hang out and have a cold one.

Service was very good the day I was here and the bar tender was on top of the tap list. She was quick and efficient, and I give here extra points for having me taste the Bells Cherry Stout before ordering a glass. She noted that a number of patrons had been put off by it, though she didn't think it was spoiled. In any event, I appreciated her thoughtfulness, all the more so as I wasn't happy with the Cherry Stout after all either.

As for food, I just ordered the wings. While nothing special, they were still pretty good and were quite meaty. What was surprising was the price. $5 for 10 wings? Been a while since I've seen that kind of deal unless it was happy hour or they were on special.

This is a solid place. I'd certainly go back.

03-09-2009 13:21:46 | More by John_M
Photo of corby112


3.78/5  rDev -5.7%

This is a really good neighborhood beer bar in the Fairmount section of Philadelphia. Can be overcrowded with a lot of jocks in there but there are about seven or eight outdoor tables weather permitting. I would say that about eighty percent of the building is taken up by the bar area. In the back there is a small dinig section with about four tables/ wooden booths. The food is above average pub fare, offering very good appetizers and burgers/ sandwiches. The beer selection is also quite good, featuring local craft beers, west coast micros and imports. The last time I was here they had Pliny the Elder on Tap.

12-03-2008 23:11:14 | More by corby112
Photo of slander

New York

3.86/5  rDev -3.7%

On the move again, trying to keep to that loose lack of a schedule we don't have if we're going to make lasagna night in Queens later (so not happening). Just picked a few places to see, nowhere near each other; scattered about in the corners of here and there. I kind of enjoy this town while Dave does not, that which makes horse races. I'm getting somewhat slightly almost noticeably not better at navigating Philly without a compass now, and am easily staying within the boundaries of the rivers. So, up on Fairmount now, the neighborhood's gone gone again...

Little suspect stand alone bricky place awninged up on the corner. I wonder lots of stuff, like what used to be attached or next to it and where they've gone; they don't just build onesies like this. 8 tables outside run both sides of the corner for seasonal seating, see. Inside, just to the right, something different, a strange "Y" shaped wood bar, being a straight bar with an angle on the end and a piece jutting out. Foot rail below, I take notice of them in bars now, I didn't always did but my dogs get a-tired when there's nowhere to foot 'em.

Barback is shiny mirrored old stainless steel unit, with booze over mirrors and a chalkboard running the length above listing food (salads, soups, apps & sandwiches), bottles & tap selections in colored chalk. Phillie's bobbleheads & figurines line bordering below the boards on one side, nic nacs, figurines, plaques, and pics on the other side. Baby track spots above the boards, and mounted flat screens in both corners. Glassware and 3 tiered booze below the bar back.

Red painted walls, trim & molding against a beige ceiling, slab marble tile floors, sunken spots in the molding above, and spinning fans. Pub signage and neons, and Halloween décor just now. A bench to the left just inside the door, a bar counter on the window just past there, and a CD juke sit adjacent to the bar. Shaking through, 8 tables on church pew seating in a step up room to the rear, with some art, a large Guinness mirror, and some beer signage.

12 taps on a single tower on the center of the bar. Some local Pennsylvania wares (PBC Kenzinger, Yards Philly Pale Ale, Sly Fox Black Raspberry Reserve, Yuengling Lord Chesterfield Ale), some regional micros (Fisherman's Pumpkin Stout, Allagash White), some irregional micros (Russian River Pliny the Elder, Green Flash Hop Head Red), a few fantastic imports (Delirium Tremens, Stella, Guinness) and a cider (Ace Perry Cider).

Also a dozen bottles listed on the boards above, a small collection of mismatched micros (Moylan's Hopsickle Impy IPA, Bells Two Hearted Ale, Hoppin' Frog Bodacious Black & Tan, Pennichuck Engine 5 Red Ale, Fisherman's Brew, DogFishHead Theobroma), a few Belgians (Chimay Red, Westmalle Dubbel, Urthel Hop-It, Sara Buckwheat Ale), and imports from somewhere (St Ambroise Oatmeal Stout, Hitachino Sweet Stout). I also spotted some other random bottled selections in the stickered cooler fridge down past the bar (Anchor Steam, Sam Imperial Pilsner, Victory Hop Devil, Guinness, Magners, Lindemans Framboise).

Um, Pliny please, perfectly pretty no brainer, huh. Beer was what with being damn tasty and all, no surprise, and seemingly well kept. Not a happy girl bartending. It very well may have been the too many goddamn "Philly bar crawl 2008" kids here drinking Twisted Tea, but I cannot say for sure. No, I can say for sure. And so goes the crowd here today on their amateur day crawl, but we are not deterred. All that aside, kind of edgy yet not uncomfortable in any way, it's a good little bar, and Pliny, too.

12-02-2008 03:26:25 | More by slander
Photo of BWH3


3.88/5  rDev -3.2%

Went to this pub last night for the first time. Dank, somewhat dingy bar long and dark with seating in the back for eating or drinking. Place seems to be mostly locals from the neighborhood. Crowd young, loud and boisterous watching some of the 76ers game. Beer selection and quality are nice. I had Bells Best Brown and St. Bernardus Christmas. Other than their homage to Guiness, the selection is pretty diverse and contained a mix of local, domestic, and foreign. I deduct a few points from quality because the St. Bernardus was served way too cold. Waitress did not really know much about the beers when my friend asked. Food came out at an appropriate time but was a bit cool. All in all the food was tasty and plentiful but nothing remarkable or fancy. I would say the Bishop's collar is a good place to stop if you are in the Farimount neighborhood or are looking for a change of scenery, but this is hardly a destination for serious beer advocates.

11-13-2008 14:23:48 | More by BWH3
Photo of Seanibus


3.63/5  rDev -9.5%

The inside atmosphere is dank and not entirely pleasant, but the outside seating is the best in the area. The food and service is highly inconsistent, but good more often than it is bad. The appetizers are usually a better bet. The Sunday brunch is a big avoid. But the beer list is outstanding - a dozen well-considered selections, with a decent balance of style and geography, though it is often heavier on IPAs. The owner goes out of his way to find interesting and unusual beers, and often he has a keg or two of something red hot in the beer press.

This should be a stop on the itinerary of any beer lover.

08-09-2008 22:10:24 | More by Seanibus
Photo of cobalt60

New Jersey

4.14/5  rDev +3.2%

we stopped here for a quick one after a Sunday afternoon visit to the Perlman building, part of the Phila Museum of Art. It's a block up the street!
Crowded..football on the boxes..nicely buzzing crowd. Loitered a bit looking over the beer chalkboard behind the bar.
Quickly noticed by the barman & got a couple of draft St Bernardus brown ales. A really nice selection of about 10 drafts (i think 4 belgian) and as many bottles. Some folks behind us made us room at the standee board by the window.
Very impressed by our short visit & will go back.

01-14-2008 01:35:24 | More by cobalt60
Photo of GnomeKing


3.68/5  rDev -8.2%

There were two Heineken girls in thigh-high boots and tight tees there the night I went, but they ignored me because I was sipping a Double Daddy IPA, a Blue Point Toasted Lager, and then a Hop Wallop. The girls' scam was to find a guy drinking Miller Lite or the like, and then say, "I see you're drinking Miller Lite, we'd like you to try Heineken Lite." I would have liked some attention from the beer chicks, but my beers kept me company...there are some interesting choices here--Blue Point and Speakeasy aren't brewers that get distributed much around Philly, so I was happy to see them on the chalkboard. The overall selection is small, though, and the quality isn't earth shaking. 3.5s for both.

The food is cheap and good. The menu is somewhere between bar food and bistro food...mini crab crakes, nachos, spring rolls, turkey sandwiches, etc. My friends and I split a few appetizers, and they were all very good. This is not a place well-suited to having a relaxing dinner (see talk of crowds below), but nibbling on some appetizers works.

Lots of grad students and mid- to late-20s singles hang out here. It gets pretty crowded, sometimes bumpin' elbows crowded. If you want to sit down and relax, go right up the street to Bridgid's.

03-12-2006 03:53:16 | More by GnomeKing
The Bishop's Collar in Philadelphia, PA
90 out of 100 based on 30 ratings.