1. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  2. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Guinness Extra Stout (Original) - Guinness Ltd.

Not Rated.
Guinness Extra Stout (Original)Guinness Extra Stout (Original)

Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
BA SCORE
84
good

3,242 Ratings
THE BROS
88
very good

(view ratings)
Ratings: 3,242
Reviews: 1,232
rAvg: 3.7
pDev: 15.41%
Wants: 51
Gots: 289 | FT: 1
Brewed by:
Guinness Ltd. visit their website
Ireland

Style | ABV
Irish Dry Stout |  6.00% ABV

Availability: Year-round

Notes/Commercial Description:
No notes at this time.

(Beer added by: SixpointJMH on 11-12-2000)
Beer: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters | Read the Alström Bros Beer Reviews and Beer Ratings of Guinness Extra Stout (Original) Alström Bros
Ratings: 3,242 | Reviews: 1,232 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of BigRedN
3.35/5  rDev -9.5%

St. Patty's day, time for me to make my once a year purchase of mass quantities of Guiness. I can find this in 6's along with the nitro bottles (and Harps) for $6.99, when it regularly sells for between $9-10. I only buy it at the low price, I just feel that that is what its worth, not the exorbitant prices that this normally sells at. I actually consumed a bottle while reading the posts on the "dumbing down" of Guinness. Hmmm, interesting.

Appearance: Poured into a standard pint glass. Black, when held to the light, still pretty darn dark, maybe with better lighting this may be reddish, but held to a 60 watt light bulb, still dark. Big tan head, at least 2 inches. Had to stop the pour, then finish. Head lingered well into the first few sips, lacing down the glass to the finish.

Smell: Malty, a little roasted/burnt aroma. Scent of chocolate and coffee. Slightly sweet to my senses.

Taste: Malty, a little sweetness, with a hint of hops bitterness detected.

Mouthfeel: Medium bodied, very smooth and creamy yet thick.

Drinkability: I'll admit it, I can't have more than two. For some reason, I just can't. That doesn't necessarily mean that this is a bad drinking beer, this beer just wears me out. Perhaps that is another reason I only purchase this about once a year.

BigRedN, Mar 18, 2005
Photo of SaCkErZ9
3.25/5  rDev -12.2%

Beer pours a very dark black, not quite opaque as I could still see some resemblences of light while holding it up to a bright, snowy, NC sky. The smell is of coffee and maybe chocolate? Lots of hop bitterness with touches of chocolate and coffee maybe a nut-raisin. There is a lingering bitterness long after the initial taste that resonates on the back and sides of the tongue and on the back palate. The mouthfeel is very dry. Due to the dryness and extreme bitterness in the aftertaste, one pint of this beer and my tastebuds are shot and therefore not a session beer.

SaCkErZ9, Mar 17, 2005
Photo of ommegangpbr
3.45/5  rDev -6.8%

Dark and smoky, light cannot penetrate its depths...
one of the best mass produced brews out there, one of the most respected brews out there, just gotta have one every once in awhile.
Can't drink a lot of it at a time which is fine. Something of this magnitude should not be rushed through anyway.
Dark chocolate and dark coffee flavors.
Did I mention that light can't penetrate its depths?
A toast to Guinness.

ommegangpbr, Mar 09, 2005
Photo of BadBadger
3.2/5  rDev -13.5%

Pours a slightyly watery dark color. The general appearance is the best thing about this beer. Not as thick as one would hope. A descent off-white head forms but does not last very long. The smell and taste are rather average. With so many other great stouts out there, I would not recommend searching this one out. However, when the pickings are slim give it a go.

BadBadger, Mar 09, 2005
Photo of OStrungT
3.35/5  rDev -9.5%

This beer pours a dark reddish brown. The head is thick and creamy. It is tan. It fades slowly leaving thick laces all over the glass. It smells of roasted malt and hints of coffee. Taste is mild. Not too aggressive. It tastes malty with a slight sweetness to it. It is slightly bitter. Coffee flavor is slight. There is a slightly metalic taste to it, but not too bad. It is just a little over carbonated. It goes down smooth leaving a malty taste on the palate. This beer would make a good session beer due to its lower alcohol content and its non aggressive flavors. This beer will probably not frequent my refrigerator because there are so many better beers out there. Don't waste your time on this one.

OStrungT, Mar 03, 2005
Photo of Gagnonsux
3.53/5  rDev -4.6%

I wasn't sure how I'd feel about this beer after having a bad expirience with Guinness Draught at a restaurant. Extra Stout is almost black in color; head is large, tan, and fairly creamy. Aroma is roasted, similar to coffee. A light sweetness is also detected. Taste is also similar to roasted coffee, but this is probably a little too bitter for me to love. There is a light sweetness here, especially in the dry finish, but not enough to make this great in my book. Drinkability is pretty good, but I think polishing off a six pack might be a little much. This is my first Irish Dry Stout, I need a few more to have a better picture of the style.

Gagnonsux, Mar 01, 2005
Photo of henrysunset
2.95/5  rDev -20.3%

looks liek you expect, big head with hold, black nectar.

smell is fruittier than i remember of the regular stuff. Almost raspberry. ok smelling but not what i was expecting.

taste is pretty dry, not really taking me off into orbit. some of the good dark taste is there, but masked with not so much a bitterness as a funny twang (sourness) that is biting me in the back of the throat.

feels ok in the mouth, but as it is try, it is pretty thin too. is it drinkable, well; sorta. Not for me though. Give me the regular guinness please.

henrysunset, Feb 28, 2005
Photo of ChrisBowers
4.15/5  rDev +12.2%

I feel as if this is an often overlooked and underrated beer. While not the FES from St. James Gate, its a very solid dry stout, far more tasty than the draught version that's pulled with nitro. Pours jet black with a small tan head. Smell is of roasted malt and a bit of hops. Taste is slightly sweet in the beginning with a nice biting dryness and a nice bitter chocolate and hop finish. Definite notes of bitter chocolate and roasted malts here. Slightly sweet and creamy up front and dry and bitter in the finish makes for a very interesting and pleasing beer. I feel as though most people overlook this beer in lieu of craft brewed oatmeal and imperial stouts, but I feel as though this is an all-time classic that can hold its own against just about anything out there.

Respect beer indeed!

ChrisBowers, Feb 27, 2005
Photo of BigBry
3.53/5  rDev -4.6%

Standard 341ml brown bottle, neck label is the only place it admits to being brewed under license by Labatt Brewing Co.
Pours black, hardly any light can sneak through, with a nice brown head a couple inches high. Too bad the foam doesn't last for long but it leaves small traces along the glass. Smells roasted, almost burnt malt, also some coffee-like notes. Taste is full, with coffee taste (same as its aroma), and some bitterness. Need to sip, but could have a few over the evening. Thicker, more body and flavor than Guinness Draught.

BigBry, Feb 20, 2005
Photo of Litterbean
3.88/5  rDev +4.9%

Traded a grilled cheese sandwich for this bottle. Not a bad deal.

Appearance - Black as fudge. I'm pretty sure its gravity is so high that light bends into it. There's a nice brown head that forms and can get out of hand if you pour even slightly fast. It doesn't stick around for long but it leaves traces along the glass as it is consumed.

Smell - Smells roasted, which I can attribute to the malts. There's also a faint metallic smell that's not really that offensive or anything, but it's there. Not sure what this would be caused by.

Taste - Sweet tasting. Very thick, unlike the watery Guinness Draught. Light carbonation spices things up. A decent amount of bitterness brings it all home. The mouthfeel is lacking just slightly while still being above average. There's still that nagging metallic, coppery characteristic that lingers after a sip.

Drinkability - Certainly good to quaff. I wouldn't sit down with it on a regular basis, as there are better stouts out there. For a macro stout, however, this must be the best, superior to the bland Draught. Recommended, w00t!

Litterbean, Feb 14, 2005
Photo of bearrunner44
3.58/5  rDev -3.2%

Pours a dark, slightly reddish brown with a 1 1/2 inch head. The head eventually shrank to about a quarter of an inch and stayed there for the remainder of the drink. It's not quite as beautiful to look at as Guinness Draught, but it has a nice appearance all the same. Smell is of coffee and dark malt. The mouthfeel is about on par with most stouts in terms of thickness, but the carbonation was a little much. The taste is very bitter, and the roasted malts really come through. The Extra Stout is like Guinness Draught's evil twin brother. The Draught is smooth and creamy, while the Extra Stout has a much more substantial bite to it. I think the bitterness is a little over-the-top, but Extra Stout wins some points for having character to it. It's not a beer that I would want to drink all night, but it could make a nice change-of-pace brew.

bearrunner44, Feb 02, 2005
Photo of PorterLambic
2.85/5  rDev -23%

Pours a very dark brown, almost black with just a little light around the edges. A fluffy, dark tan 2" head develops that is, as usual, slow to drop, but leaves little lacing. The bubbles are noticeably larger than in the tap-drawn version.
Smell is roasted malt, oak, caramel, toffee & coffee.
Taste is heavy on the coffee and roasted, almost burnt, malt flavors. Hoppier than one would expect. Not well balanced.
Mouthfeel is thinner than on-tap, almost watery for a stout, medium-bodied. Feels like a brown ale trying to masquerade as a stout.
Drinkability is pretty low. Stick to the tap version for this brew. The balance and flavor are better and better balanced. Mouthfeel is chewier as well. The foremost stout in name is just middle-of-the-road in the glass, at least when it comes from a bottle.

PorterLambic, Jan 21, 2005
Photo of Sycodrummer
4.1/5  rDev +10.8%

A better offering from St. James Gate IMO at least insofar as what's available in the states.

Poured a 12oz. black bottle into a British Imperial Pint Glass and it formed a think 1.5 finger beige head that lasted the enitre duration of the sample. Almost no carbonation present.

Smell is of toffee, coffee, caramel, and the taste substanciates this smell. More so than its canned draught widget cousin, this beer has a chocolatey toffee like character much like chocolate stouts.

Thick on the palate but not murky. Easy to swallow and enjoyable all around. A easy beer to drink and to cook with.

Sycodrummer, Jan 20, 2005
Photo of JustinBathurst
3.58/5  rDev -3.2%

This is for the Labatt-brewed version with 5% ABV.

Pours a big tan head with a good amount remaining for quite a while, then the lace completing it all. The brew itself is the real dark brown-red that would pass for black. Yep, it's a stout.

Smell a bit of the celery and grass, some coffee, nice and roasted.

The mouthfeel is heavy-ish and smooth, but not thick like the nitro-can or the tap variations. Not overly carbonated, just as much as expected for a stout. It coats the tongue.

Taste is at first a nice sweetness, with the roasted malt topped off with a bitter, hopped metallic finish. I find a trace of alcohol even in this 5% version. My big complaint is that the finish becomes strangely unusual after the beer warms, much more harsh and off-putting. It shouldn't, obviously.

As far as Guinness goes, I enjoy this bottled Guinness better than the nitro-can. I haven't had it on tap in ages, so it's not fair to compare in that area. I like it, but I don't think this is the best stout.

JustinBathurst, Jan 19, 2005
Photo of Biggness
3.93/5  rDev +6.2%

I remember being at the bar...claiming to be an Irish guy and never having had tried Guinness. So I ordered one.... YUCK.... but man I gotta suck it up.... I gotta like this stuff I am Irish! So I force fed it to myself for a few weeks. Then I acquired the taste, and could not get wnough of this stuff. I then sat my brother down ordered him a Guinness and shoved it down his throat for a few weeks and he as well became a Guinness lover. It is hard to just drink Guinness all night but is a great Started beer and oh the enjoyment watching a Guinness Settle.... oh the frothy first sip! Damn I am thirsty

Biggness, Jan 16, 2005
Photo of karst
3.6/5  rDev -2.7%

Black as back of a cave. Poured from the 1 pint 6 ox bottle it flashed deep ruby at edge of my glass. Its 3/4" brownish tan head fell quickly leaving some lace and persistant rings on side marking each level as I drank. Faint aroma of roasted malt. taste gets stronger as this stout warms and I detect something metalic. Drinkale and went well with my pot of chilli and hot corn bread.

karst, Jan 13, 2005
Photo of apintofknowledge
2.83/5  rDev -23.5%

Guinness used to be a standard order for me in the years before I discovered the world of craft beers. Dining at a restaurant recently with a very limited beer selection, I decided it was time to try it again...

It arrived in a nitro-can, which I was happy to find provided a decent tan creamy head on top of the cloudy chocolate brown stout. Those classic tiny bubbles were definitely present. The aroma... much more mild than other stouts I've had recently... a very mild coffee and toast smell. It had a very smooth mouthfeel, surprisingly similar to what I'd get out of a tap. The taste however was watery to me. Nice flavors of coffee, toffee and toasted nuts, but all very mild. I guess I've been drinking much more flavorful, concentrated stouts lately. The pint went down almost too easy. Still a good brew, but nothing in it to knock my socks off.

apintofknowledge, Jan 07, 2005
Photo of Luigi
4.03/5  rDev +8.9%

Poured from a 12 oz. brown bottle. The appearance is beautiful! Black with ruby edges and a large brown head. I can smell dark roasted malts and coffee. Medium bodied with a dry finish. Coffee and roasted malts make up most of the flavor. There is a strong hop flavor that last from start to finish as feel. Has kind of smoky aftertaste. This is very fine Irish stout I can say. Still one of the best.

Luigi, Jan 04, 2005
Photo of Sixpoint
4.83/5  rDev +30.5%

Guinness for Strength! What a great beer. Let's face it - Guinness has set the standard for dark beers worldwide. Without Guinness, many people would never drink anything darker than a pilsner.

I've had Guinness on four different continents... not bad for a beer that is dark as night.

The beer poured a deep black color, but not completely opaque. There was a bit of light shining through the bottom and sides of the glass.

Wonderful aroma of roasted malts and fruity esters, and just a hint of hops too.

What balance - nice roasted malt flavor coming through with a decent amount of bittering hops. 6.00% by volume? That's definitely a strong and robust beer for an Irish Style Stout.

This beer was thin to medium-bodied, and left me wanting more. Ok, I think I'll have another.

Sixpoint, Jan 04, 2005
Photo of elricorico
2.75/5  rDev -25.7%

Pours the colour of Dark Chocolate with a bubbly, two finger tan head. The head dropped down to a thin layer, but left sticky lacing all around.

I can't find much smell from this beer. Maybe I've recently been trying more aromatic brews, but this one seems damn close to odorless. I can detect a faint bitter coffee smell if I try hard enough.

For taste.... not good. Hard to describe right now, but I am starting to wonder if this is a bad bottle. Almost a sour flavour to start, and it leaves the taste of dust in my mouth.

The mouthfeel is decent. Somewhat creamy, bit on the high side of carbonation.

I can't finish this bottle. The taste is near making me gag. I have one more chilling, so I shall soon see(and edit this review) if this is just a bad bottle.

Edit: Well, the next bottle was better, but I don't think I'll ever be a real fan of this beer. I don't find enough flavour up front to balance the dry finish. I knocked up a couple of the scores in the end.

elricorico, Dec 31, 2004
Photo of mynie
4.25/5  rDev +14.9%

Guinness Stout? On tap? Well, this is something that I just need to try.

And my god is it tasty.

The best-looking Guinness I ever bought. Much more opaque than usual, still the same fine, perfect head.

Smells kind of faint like roasted malts. Coffee and chocolate all burnt and sweetened. This is good, but too faint.

Tastes great. The burnt coffee bean taste of Guinness, along with a fine chocolate maltiness. In the back, and this is the kicker, is a very nice kiss of roasted hops. The bitter taste in leaves in your mouth is divine.

mynie, Dec 30, 2004
Photo of jdhilt
2.85/5  rDev -23%

Pours with a two-finger light brown head that is thick and frothy leaving a ton of lace. Totally black color. Light-medium carbonation and heavy bodied. Nose is barely there can't get anything distinguishable. Starts with a strong roasted, almost burnt coffee flavor and finishes slightly bitter with a lingering aftertaste, goes good with dry peanuts.

jdhilt, Dec 27, 2004
Photo of allengarvin
4.22/5  rDev +14.1%

Appearance: Deep black appearance, until you hold up to the light, and then you get a nice ruby tinting. Not a big head, but rather a nice pancake of tan foam across the top.

Aroma: Sharp roasted grain aroma, slightly coffeeish.

Flavor: Roasted, almost-but-not-quite burnt malt flavor. Sweetness is balanced more from malts than from any detectable hop bitterness. Finish is astringent, dry, and lingering.

Body: Grainy mouthfeel, full bodied, average carbonation.

A world classic. I don't drink too much of it anymore, and there are many bolder beers out there today, but there are no real flaws here. Just, a very good beer.

allengarvin, Dec 18, 2004
Photo of RushLimbmalt
5/5  rDev +35.1%

Ok I admit it. I am of Irish heritage so I LOVE my Guinness, no matter what version. The Extra Stout is definitely their most flavorful version. It pours as black as any Guinness should and has a nice rocky tan head that leaves a ton of lace behind. Can you say beautiful? I did, so anyway it has a nice clean aroma, a touch of sweetness from the unmalted barley and some faint coffee like aromas make it really irresistable. The flavor is a bit more extreme, a nice sweet beginning that follows with a decent bitterness from the dark malts that almost overpower the experience. I probably shouldn't give it all 5's, but it is Guinness.

RushLimbmalt, Dec 18, 2004
Photo of RoyalT
3.98/5  rDev +7.6%

Appearance – This one was beautiful right out of the bottle. It poured a dark brown in color with a full, heavily-tanned puffy head. The foam showed a lot of retention as it laced the inside of my glass on its way down.

Smell – The rich, roasted malts are very subtle here at the nose. I can pick up some good brown sugar as well. The aroma here is simple yet very pleasing.

Taste – The roasted malts come out sharp and raw at the taste. They are very bitter and need every grain of the sweet brown sugar compliment. The beer has an overall coffee flavor to it that’s very enticing.

Mouthfeel – This medium-bodied Stout has some bitter black burnt flavors with some good dryness in back of the tongue. I would have liked to have seen a bit more body to go along with the huge flavors, but overall the mouthfeel was good.

Drinkability – It isn’t the most balanced Stout on the market, but it is raw and edgy and a great effort from such a high-volume brewery

RoyalT, Dec 06, 2004
Guinness Extra Stout (Original) from Guinness Ltd.
84 out of 100 based on 3,242 ratings.