1. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  2. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Captain Swain's Extra Stout - Cisco Brewers Inc.

Not Rated.
Captain Swain's Extra StoutCaptain Swain's Extra Stout

Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
BA SCORE
87
very good

210 Ratings
THE BROS
92
outstanding

(view ratings)
Ratings: 210
Reviews: 151
rAvg: 3.88
pDev: 12.89%
Wants: 18
Gots: 8 | FT: 0
Brewed by:
Cisco Brewers Inc. visit their website
Massachusetts, United States

Style | ABV
Foreign / Export Stout |  8.00% ABV

Availability: Year-round

Notes/Commercial Description:
No notes at this time.

(Beer added by: BeerAdvocate on 02-21-2001)
Beer: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters | Read the Alström Bros Beer Reviews and Beer Ratings of Captain Swain's Extra Stout Alström Bros
« first ‹ prev | 1-25 | 26-50 | 51-75  | next › last »
Ratings: 210 | Reviews: 151 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of aleyeast
aleyeast

South Carolina

1.68/5  rDev -56.7%

I read the reviews to be sure my bottle wasn't errant. $7.99 at whole foods for a 750ml. Was expecting a really good stout with the packaging and brewery location.

Virtually undrinkable. To say the carbonation is a slight problem is an understatement. Poured gently into a pint glass, I received less than an inch of beer and the rest head, and it did not settle. Subsequent pours even very slowly produced similiar resuts. And the carboation was in the beer which ruined the taste (which was hiding) and of course the mouthfeel. I was unaware you could dissolve this much carbon dioxide in beer. The only way to choke down this beer was vigourous shaking of the glass to emancipate the carbon dioxide. Actually, the flavors weren't bad in my mechanically flattened beer, but for the price, I don't expect to have to work this hard. Buyer beware. I plan to bring this up to my merchant and emailing the brewery if possible.

I have seen other reviewers speak of nothing ut head in the Cisco Beers, but then rate it ok. I think this is a major defect and needs to be fixed.

Update after contact with brewer. Brewer admits to carbonation and suggests letting the beer settle, offered to send me a fresh one which he believes will not be as heavily carbonated as the one I sampled. Very good response and quick, will update after I have the next one.

02-23-2006 15:30:06 | More by aleyeast
Photo of cfalovo97
cfalovo97

Ontario (Canada)

2/5  rDev -48.5%

11-06-2012 16:38:57 | More by cfalovo97
Photo of Naerhu
Naerhu

Japan

2.1/5  rDev -45.9%

Thanks to Jimbo to sending this off to us BAs in Japan.

A - Dull black body on a fine brown head.
S - Odd chemicals, old socks, and hoppy spice.
T - Slightly roasty, slightly sour. A lambic stout? Cola. Next to no bitterness.
M - Light body, too heavily carbonated. Tasted like it had less than half the 8%.
D - Three of the four people in the tasting group poured out their share.

05-21-2005 14:18:45 | More by Naerhu
Photo of ZekemusMaximus
ZekemusMaximus

New York

2.5/5  rDev -35.6%

02-19-2012 07:11:05 | More by ZekemusMaximus
Photo of erlenmeyer
erlenmeyer

Maine

2.5/5  rDev -35.6%

01-22-2012 05:05:17 | More by erlenmeyer
Photo of stoppertb18
stoppertb18

Massachusetts

2.5/5  rDev -35.6%

02-17-2013 22:08:09 | More by stoppertb18
Photo of Bighuge
Bighuge

Minnesota

2.5/5  rDev -35.6%

Black beer with a bubbly brown rimming. Lace comes in sporadic rings. Milky and chocolatey and coffeish. Decent. The taste is immediately tainted with a sourish, lemon juice off flavor that sticks around on my tongue long after the swallow. This aspect overshadows anything good that is happening underneath. It swallows it up. The mouthfeel is more on the flat side, which could actually be acceptable if the taste was good. Bad experience once again with Cisco.

I've heard this place makes good beer. I've just yet to witness it. Seems like a pipe dream to me after 4 samples that were either way overcarbonated and off or just plain ass sour. Do they have quality control over there???

12-23-2004 06:41:18 | More by Bighuge
Photo of hopdog
hopdog

Pennsylvania

2.55/5  rDev -34.3%

750ml bottle.

This one poured all head (light tan). Settled into a dark/deep brown color. Aromas of yeast, roast, chocolate, and somewhat earthy. All thought that sounds fine, they just didn't work well together. Tastes of roast, some dark fruits, and light chocolate. Had a sour finish. Body over carbonated. This one just didn't pull anything together and was going in a million different directions.

Notes from: 3/7/07

01-27-2009 16:44:07 | More by hopdog
Photo of biglite351
biglite351

Pennsylvania

2.7/5  rDev -30.4%

A - very dark with only a crack of red at the edge. Tall tight lasting medium dark head.

S - equal parts of malts and hops. Slight chocolate.

T - high o roasted malts with a hop flavor coming through in the middle. Some chocolate and oat in there as well. After taste is light but mostly hop.

M - mild coating with slight tingle on right side of tongue and upper throat.

D - one would be okay, but my dislike of hop flavor would keep me from having a second.

05-24-2010 01:02:47 | More by biglite351
Photo of MuddyFeet
MuddyFeet

North Carolina

2.75/5  rDev -29.1%

Reminds me of my first attempt at a homebrew: a caramel porter. Overly sweet that comes across as sour. Pours a very dark brown, but I could hardly get any head to from in the glass. Spots of lace around the glass. Smell is really sweet and makes me think of a Belgian, except for the roasted malt aroma. Odd sugars are present in the nose. Flavor is really sweet. Like sweetened chocolate, but just the sweet and no chocolate. Very sour caramel and toffee notes as well. Mouthfeel is deceptive. Medium body, but very thin. Not too sure I am gonna be able to finish the rest of the bottle.

06-30-2005 00:39:40 | More by MuddyFeet
Photo of brentk56
brentk56

North Carolina

2.78/5  rDev -28.4%

Appearance: Pours a dark brown color with a nice frothy head that laces well

Smell: Decent coffee aroma

Taste: Starts out OK, with a nice coffee flavor that quickly turns rather sour. (I think this bottle may be old although I just bought it.)

Mouthfeel: Medium bodied with way too frothy carbonation

Drinkability: Bearing in mind the source, this beer is a real disappointment. I haven't been on Nantucket since 1976, but I suspect I would like this beer a whole lot better if I were there. Put a date on it, Cisco!

03-02-2007 03:24:05 | More by brentk56
Photo of codon2004
codon2004

Massachusetts

3/5  rDev -22.7%

11-29-2011 22:40:04 | More by codon2004
Photo of disemgrowler
disemgrowler

Rhode Island

3/5  rDev -22.7%

01-04-2012 23:25:56 | More by disemgrowler
Photo of thepeter
thepeter

United Kingdom (England)

3.03/5  rDev -21.9%

Pours black with a slightly more than a film head. Smells of dark fruits, coffee, roasted malt, and booze (more than I would have thought for 8%). Tastes much of the same but with a very bitter bite right up front that was not one of those pleasant bitter bites. The fruit came back towards the end but not enough to balance this out. Medium to heavey bodied and not very drinkable at all in my opinion.

07-06-2010 23:06:16 | More by thepeter
Photo of lpayette
lpayette

Vermont

3.08/5  rDev -20.6%

Pours dark and black with just a hint of a red hue. The head is big and frothy with some staying power and plenty of lacing.

The first thing I noticed in the smell was the very pronounced citric acid smell. There's a deep roasted malt background in there too, but the citrus is just too much for me and very distracting.

The taste is an improvement for me over the smell as the various malts meld together to form a nice rich flavor. bakers chocolate, chocolate pudding, coffee, dark milk chocolate, orange peel, and some smoke all are flavors that come to mind. I really wish this had less of the citrus rind sorts of the flavors though... also seems a bit oxidized. Gets better the warmer it is.

Mouthfeel is real nice to begin, but the finish is less enjoyable. Drinkability is average with a slight improvement as the beer warms to room temp.

Overall a well crafted beer with an impressive supposed 13 different malts. I was hoping for something sweeter with less astringent citrus flavors however. It just tastes like the yeast was a little stressed to me... I never find those citrus tastes in stouts very pleasant.

04-04-2008 06:52:45 | More by lpayette
Photo of maximum12
maximum12

Minnesota

3.13/5  rDev -19.3%

Thanks to kelp for this bottle. Needed a bottle to celebrate a rare Twins win. Often need two or three after watching a game so far this season. Alex Burnett, please go use whatever kind of degree you have, somewhere else.

Pours black. Smell is warm stout - roast, little smoke & chocolate.

Captain Swain's Extra Stout is a notch above average, a solid black beer with all the classic trimmings. More smokiness than I expected, it's the beer's defining characteristic. Bitter roast is strong, too. Plinking notes of chocolate.

Decent enough stout that I'll be happy to quaff, but nothing distinctive about it, & the smoke/roast/harsh combo just doesn't quite do it for me.

05-29-2011 02:28:42 | More by maximum12
Photo of CRJMellor
CRJMellor

Arkansas

3.18/5  rDev -18%

Pours dark bacl with just a hint fo dark maroon. Largest head I've ever seen on a stout. Pratically exploded out of the bottle once the cork was popped. Actually seemed overcarbonated.
Aroma of milk chocolate, lactose, sour apple notes and a Belgian-type yeasty profile.
Flavor of lightly bittered chocolate, very sour green apple. Is this a stout or a dark Belgian. To me the yeast style they chose for this stout just doesn't work here. Too many conflicting and contradictroy flavors for the palate to enjoy.
Mouthfeel is medium, maybe even light bodied. Definitely off for style. Sour aftertaste is actually a put off-putting.
Drinkability is average. Very creative for sure but low mars for overall appeal.

03-12-2005 21:23:45 | More by CRJMellor
Photo of shippos
shippos

New York

3.23/5  rDev -16.8%

bubbly froathy coffee head on a dark brown body.
sweet roasted burnt coffee aroma.
has a thin body but a decent mouthfeel, the carbonation takes away from the body and hurts it.
dry finish with some bitterness and a spicy carbonation.
drinkable and worth a shot but i wouldn't seek it out.

06-16-2005 22:23:10 | More by shippos
Photo of ThisLadyLovesBeer
ThisLadyLovesBeer

New Hampshire

3.25/5  rDev -16.2%

04-21-2014 22:07:16 | More by ThisLadyLovesBeer
Photo of MaltLover001
MaltLover001


3.25/5  rDev -16.2%

06-15-2012 21:25:16 | More by MaltLover001
Photo of Vylo
Vylo

New Jersey

3.25/5  rDev -16.2%

04-24-2012 23:44:19 | More by Vylo
Photo of johnnnniee
johnnnniee

New Hampshire

3.25/5  rDev -16.2%

Picked this up at Bert's, a new edition to the growing selection of beer available in NH.
Pours a pretty solid black color with a huge light tan head that sticks around forever.
Aroma is heavy on the brown and candy sugar side with hints of vanilla and perfume. Very little roast or chocolate or coffee in the nose, odd. Hint of milk chocolate as shes warms, but also brings to the forefront a Belgian-esque phenolic aroma as well.
Taste is rich malty and chocolaty with a bevy of dark fruits and a slightly acridic taste in there as well. Slight hop bite midway through leaves a long lingering roast bitterness in the finish. Creamy mouthfeel, medium body, high level of carbonation. I'm not sure if there are some wild yeasts in here or if its supposed to taste this way. The Belgian character is subtle, but its strong enough to notice and the carbonation is a bit high. Its an ok brew as is, but I think it could be so much better. If I dare resample this one I will re-review.

03-29-2010 00:03:59 | More by johnnnniee
Photo of Nipitato
Nipitato

Massachusetts

3.25/5  rDev -16.2%

Purchased a bottle at Julio's Liquors in Westborough, MA.

A: Deep brown. Opaque. Poured with a huge medium tan head with a good 1/2 inch retention. Sticky lacing.

S: Lots of rutiness - plums. Roasted character. A really nice sharp hop aroma.

T: Strong roasted grain. Lightly burnt. Long bitter aftertaste.

MF: Dry. Smooth and creamy. Lightly carbonated.

D, notes: Roasted and dry - too much so.

02-13-2009 18:05:58 | More by Nipitato
Photo of YouSkeete
YouSkeete

Massachusetts

3.25/5  rDev -16.2%

A: Very dark brown, black appearance. Red tint at the edges of my snifter. Short khaki head with weak retention. Fades into slightly bubbly lacing.

S: Roasted, almost burnt coffee, dark bittersweet chocolate, molasses, caramel. Hints of cream and oak/wood.

T/M: Bitter coffee upfront; almost tastes like old/burnt coffee. Smooth hops, bittersweet chocolate, molasses compose most of the body. Light hints of dark wine-like fruits permeate through the heavy bitterness of the overall flavor. Aftertaste is tangy and almost sour. Medium carbonation with a medium body as well.

D: A decent stout, with an overpowering hop bite that doesn't really fit in my opinion.

05-14-2011 02:22:03 | More by YouSkeete
Photo of meathookjones
meathookjones

Virginia

3.33/5  rDev -14.2%

This came in a nice big 750ml bottle. Pours out black with a tall tan head. There were decent rings of lace left around the glass as it is consumed. Aroma smelled of licorice, fruit a bit of chocolate and an odd soy sauce type note. Taste was of chocolate, coffee, a bitter earthiness and a bit of sourness. Very complex and interesting taste but the sourness and another odd flavor kept me from enjoying this as much as I could have. Mouthfeel was a bit thin but not too bad. Drinkability was pretty good even though there was some off flavor lingering in the background. I will probably give this another chance if I come across it again but this time it just seemed off.

11-23-2004 16:20:09 | More by meathookjones
« first ‹ prev | 1-25 | 26-50 | 51-75  | next › last »
Captain Swain's Extra Stout from Cisco Brewers Inc.
87 out of 100 based on 210 ratings.