The Original Basil T's
Active Beers: 7
Beer Ratings: 76
Beer Avg: 3.36
Taps: / Bottles:
Cask: N / Beer-to-Go: N
Ratings: 36 | Reviews: 34 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by donniecuffs:
1.95/5 rDev -47.6%
vibe: 1 | quality: 1 | service: 2 | selection: 3 | food: 3 | $$$
For what I paid for both food and drink, I expected A LOT more. This particular establishment is another example of one that has benefited immensely from what I'd like to call a 'slam-dunk' location. Yuppies from some of the wealthier nearby towns (in addition to other locals) jam this place and like to brag that they're a member of the mug club, when the majority of them wouldn't be able to tell you the difference between an ale and a lager. But I can live with that; what I can't live with is the pretentiousness, which abounds here in buckets. This is considered the premier brewpub on the northern Jersey shore (with former sister Basil T's Toms River king of the southern Jersey shore) because there is NO other competition. Zero. Therefore, don't make the mistake of getting excited reading stellar reviews from people who live nearby as, no offense, but they have no competition for a basis for comparison. FYI, don't associate the Toms River location with this one, as it is apparently no longer owned by the same group, and furthermore, Dave Hoffmann of Climax is now brewing in Toms River, so you can expect great things to come. As for the 'Original' Basil T's in Red Bank, don't bother; I consider it one of if not the worst brewpubs in the state...and I've been to all of them.
07-27-2009 15:58:17 | More by donniecuffs
More User Reviews:
2.28/5 rDev -38.7%
vibe: 3 | quality: 1.5 | service: 4 | selection: 1.5 | food: 1.5 | $$$$
I've always known of this place, but never bothered checking them out until recently, as it stood at a somewhat convenient mid-point between Kane and Starland Ballroom--my other two ventures of the day.
The place is a bit smaller than I expected for some reason, but from what I could see there are two bar areas as well as tables for dining. And I couldn't see much...even in the brightness of the mid-day, it was dark as night in here. But contrary to some, I actually like that in a bar. Clientele was horrid yuppies with bad taste.
I can't really say too much good about this place overall. There were six of their own brews on tap, so I got a sampler flight. They were all pretty mediocre, with some being downright pitiful. As I gazed around and saw literally hundreds of ceramic mugs from their mug club hanging on the bar, and people getting growlers filled, my mind was pretty boggled, because I couldn't imagine who in their right mind would regularly drink this swill. But they've been around a while, so I guess why change if the customers are satisfied with their low standards? There also seemed to be a large wine selection, but I don't care about that.
The food was pretty awful as well. A one-page menu doesn't give you many choices, but what is there is generally Italian in style, ranging from salads to pasta dishes to fish and steak. There were no appetizers nor were there any kind of small plates, and I don't think I saw one thing on the menu less than $15, with the steak coming in at a whopping $40. Not wanting to empty my wallet on a large meal, I opted for the burger. The fries were sub-McDonalds in quality, and the burger was so badly made, that I had to put salt on it just to get some flavor out of it. I don't think I've ever had to put salt on a burger before. Even the pickle was bad, and I'm dead serious.
On the plus side, the service was pretty good. The bartenders all seemed like seasoned veterans, and at least three of them tended to me while I was there, and I never had to wait for anything.
So one bland burger and one flight of 6 samplers of bad beer, and my bill was $27, not including tip. This place was a rip off, and on top of that, the beer was pee, and the food was garbage. There is absolutely no way I'd ever consider going back here, and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
05-04-2014 06:16:58 | More by Rifugium
3.78/5 rDev +1.6%
vibe: 4 | quality: 3.5 | service: 4 | selection: 3.5 | food: 4.5 | $$$
Vibe: This is an upscale Italian restaurant and you wouldn't think that this was also a brewery unless you saw the fermenting tanks in the window from the parking lot or behind the bar. They have a huge wine list and the beer is seemingly hidden on the menu.
Quality: All beers were served in pint glasses at the proper temperatures.
Service: The wait staff was very attentive and provided prompt service. The personalized cheese grating over your dish added a nice touch. Our waiter also brought a tray over with the entire dessert selection on it.
Selection: The brewpub had six beers on tap, including the five regular offerings and one seasonal beer, which was a pumpkin ale when I went.
Food: The food was very upscale Italian and the entrees were well worth the price. I tried the Orecchiette and it wasn't dominated by pasta and had lots of sausage and vegetables.
Value: The food was pricey, but seemed to be well worth the price. If want value, you can order the beer sampler platter, which came with six beers for only $9.
09-29-2013 13:11:29 | More by metter98
4/5 rDev +7.5%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 4.5 | service: 4 | selection: 3 | food: 4.5 | $$
We’ve eaten here several times and each time we leave feeling satisfied that we spent both our money and our time very very well. The food is soooo good, and very creative in their implementation of different ingredients. LOVE the seafood, LOVE the squid-ink pasta, but can you beat the homemade Gnocchi? I THINK NOT!. My favorite of the beers is their Irish Stout but Rosies Pale Ale is very very good, too.
As for atmosphere, what can be said other than it’s among the best places in one of the best towns (Red Bank) in NJ. A lively, enjoyable crowd, combined with a friendly and very knowledgeable staff, makes this a place we love to return to, again and again. Forza Basil T’s!
05-31-2012 21:10:15 | More by JerryRiso
3.88/5 rDev +4.3%
vibe: 3.5 | quality: 4 | service: 4.5 | selection: 3 | food: 4.5 | $$
Stopped in with my girlfriend on a busy Saturday night to get a feel for the place. The bar was dimly lit and crowded with people waiting to take a seat in the dining room. We quickly found seats at the corner of the bar and proceeded to settle in for a drink while we waited to be seated in the dining room. I asked the bartender what they were serving this evening and he proceeded to give me a list of beers instead of just taking a few seconds to list the 6 beers that are served at the establishment. I understand he may have been a bit busy for the moment and the listing did describe these beers in more detail than just spouting them out. We took in the decor and the hundreds of mugs that hang from the shelving and ceiling of the bar. Nice to have a mug club somewhere in Central New Jersey, this place is barren of a good craft beer bar. We waited for about 15 minutes and were never approached by our bartender again, even when we asked to pay our check. Seemed odd to have 3 bartenders for a 15-20 seat bar and service bar area, but maybe instead of acting busy all the time they could spend time to get to know people sitting at their bar and giving them money. Maybe I am jaded from working the biz.
Either way we sat at our table and asked for a beer sampler to start off our dining experience. The sampler included 6 beers that were being offered and a bonus black and tan because the waitress had made a mistake of informing me that they did not have their summer seasonal beer for the evening, even though they did. Not a big deal in my mind to be out of a beer and then find out that you are still serving it, but I did appreciate the black and tan being thrown in without asking for anything anyway. As far as the sampler goes, a red ale, cherry wheat, esb, pale ale, stout, and summer ale were all brought over on a round platter with the black and tan on the side. None of the beers were outstanding with exception of the stout. True to style and very well crafted, I can see why it had received medals at the GABF.
Our meals were very good. Traditional Italian restaurant with appreciation for fresh ingredients. The cucumber and watermelon salad was excellent and very light. The caesar salad was very good as well. Our entrees, the ravioli and the bolognese were fantastic and worth raving over. For dessert the cannoli was a nice ending to our evening.
Overall, we had a wonderful dinner. The food is worth the trip alone even if the beers they offer could use a little tune up. The atmosphere was pleasant, a little crowded and noisey, but it was 7 pm on a Saturday night. The dining room was well lit as opposed to the bar, and the service was much better. The decor of the restaurant was more of an Italian restaurant than a brew pub. With all the grapes all over this place it seems like it is more intent on selling wines than beer. I know we will be back, but not because of the beer.
08-09-2010 17:30:08 | More by Jiggamyte
3.88/5 rDev +4.3%
vibe: 3.5 | quality: 4 | service: 3.5 | selection: 4 | food: 4.5 | $$$
when walking it looked like a nice restraunt kinda classy with very nice hosts and servers.. we sat down in the dinning room for dinner and got chicken parm .. homemade spaghtiti was great.. i wanted to see the brewery so i walked to the bar.. nice set up with the beer in a glass fermanting .. it was nice.. fillled up a growler for 24$ .. not too bad.. when we were leaving it began to fill up with poeple but over i thouight it was a nice place and enjoyed the beer .. i got rosies pale ale.. cheers
05-05-2009 14:20:27 | More by njthebestofme
3.7/5 rDev -0.5%
vibe: 4.5 | quality: 3.5 | service: 4 | selection: 3 | food: 4.5 | $$$
This was stop #254 on my quest to visit every quality brewery/brepub in North America.
I stopped in around 7:30 on a Thursday evening in later September. I grabbed one of the bar seats with my back to the brewing equipment.
I had a pale ale and dry stout (gold GABF winner). The pale was a tad below average and the stout was a tab above average.
I had a caprise sald and lasagna. The food was delicious. Salad had true ripened beefsteak tomatoes and the bichemel sauce in the lasagna made it especially light and tasty.
Around 8, a light-jazz duo set up and began playing. By this time the bar was crowded and the music was annoyingly loud. There were no other beers on tap that were of interest to me so I headed back to my hotel for a Smuttynose IPA I picked up at a bottle shop earlier in the day.
Bottom line as others have said is that this is quality Italian restaurant first and brewing is secondary. While the food was pricy, the portions were generous and of excellent quality. My ranking is based primarily on beer.
09-26-2008 13:40:13 | More by Yetiman420
2.85/5 rDev -23.4%
vibe: 3.5 | quality: 2.5 | service: 3.5 | selection: 2.5 | food: 2.5 | $$$
I was in the area for the week on business. Had to stop here as it is one of the few beer destinations in the area.
I agree with the bulk of what's been written about this place by other reviewers. With a couple exceptions.
First off, this place is barely, by the thinnest of definitions, a brewpub. Yes, they make the beer they serve. But that's about where it ends. I'd hardly consider it a pub and beer isn't even a secondary consideration here. Sure, people drink it and there are certainly lots of mugs in their mug club. But really, this place is a full blown restaurant first, bar second, and brewery dead last. Way last.
The beers were all well made (no flaws detected) but totally uninspired. Pale, wheat, red, summer, stout, blah blah blah. Seen it a million times all across the country and nothing at all was remotely noteworthy. It's basically all done to a formula from the brass and ferns brewpub designers manual.
It was a Tuesday evening when I was there and it was busy with only a couple seats available at the bar. Looked like mostly an after work crowd. And mostly locals or commuters returning from NYC jobs.
Pints were $5.95 - fine, I can handle that, but as noted by others the prices all go way up from there. I had the rapini pizza to eat and it was just okay. And $19. I rarely ever note anything about prices but it's worth mentioning for this place as they are simply out of line. There are dinners on the menu in the upper 20s and 30s and it's all pretty basic Italian. Again, nothing even that interesting.
To me this place is basically like a Fridays without all the cutesy crap. It's only okay at best and not a good bargain for the price. But what the hell do I know? It was full of people on a Tuesday so obviously people like it.
They can have it. I won't be back. That says it all. There is real beer to be had out there...
P.S. The service was good, I'll give them that.
08-13-2008 01:33:38 | More by jfindley
The Original Basil T's in Red Bank, NJ
85 out of 100 based on 36 ratings.