1. Extreme Beer Fest. March 20 & 21, 2015 in Boston, Mass. Join us!
  2. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  3. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Tyler's Restaurant & Taproom / Speakeasy

Not Rated.
Tyler's Restaurant & Taproom / SpeakeasyTyler's Restaurant & Taproom / Speakeasy
BA SCORE
90
outstanding

18 Ratings
Ratings: 18
Reviews: 16
rAvg: 4.01
pDev: 8.48%
Taps: 38
Bottles: 0
Cask: N
Beer-to-Go: N
[ Bar, Eatery ]

102 E Main St
Carrboro, North Carolina, 27510-2308
United States
phone: (919) 929-6881

visit their websiteWebsite view map and get directionsMap @tylerstaproom

Notes:
The Speakeasy is the name of the back bar area.

(Place added by: beerinator)
Place: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
Ratings: 18 | Reviews: 16 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of woodchip
3.5/5  rDev -12.7%

woodchip, Jul 23, 2014
Photo of dirtylou
4.11/5  rDev +2.5%

Tyler's has been in the game for a long time, but this was my first visit.

Directly across from Steel String brewery, so a natural parlay. The interior shows its age and is a little dull in the ambiance department. The speakeasy wasn't open yet so i cant comment on that.

The bartender was very friendly and accomodating.

They had a pretty expansive tap selection - the foothills Jade IPA was my choice. There were a lot of other NC taps and some nitro/cask offerings as well.

dirtylou, Jan 01, 2014
Photo of flipdog0
4/5  rDev -0.2%

flipdog0, Dec 18, 2013
Photo of Mantooth
4.08/5  rDev +1.7%

On a recent trip to Chapel Hill, NC, we readied ourselves, making certain our passports were in order, and walked the five step journey to Carrboro & Tyler's.

38 drafts of mostly great stuff served by pint or half pint - including:

Delirium Tremens
St. Louis Framboise
Kasteel Rouge (never seen that anywhere on draft)
Brewery De Halve Maan
New Belgium Lips of Faith, Prickly Passion Saison
Foothills People's Porter
Sierra Nevada Ruthless Rye IPA
Foothills India Style Brown Ale
Rogue Mogul Madness
Old Rasputin Nitro
Young's Double Chocolate Stout

We were in twice over the weekend & found the bartenders to be knowledgeable and very cool. The bar has an extensive list of blends they make from the drafts, something I've not seen done many places - at least to the extent of their menu for it. A bartender made us a mixture of Young's Double Chocolate & Kasteel Rouge that was quite good.

Overall, we had a blast there. The bar is small but nice & there were lots of choices. Pretty hard to beat a half pint nitro pour of Old Rasputin for $2.25. We didn't try the food but the menu looked good. Give it a shot, and be sure to drop by the Carrboro Beverage Company & Bottle Shop next door for a very nice selection of beers catagorized by type - nice Belgian and smoked sections - growlers & draft samples.

Mantooth, Feb 13, 2012
Photo of jonmacklin
3.2/5  rDev -20.2%

While its true that this is the original Tylers, I have to say it is the saddest of them all in terms of the beer selection. you'll find some good stuff on draft, but nothing geeky, out of the ordinary or anything you haven't seen before. On top of this the atmosphere is pretty stale with very basic and non-descript pale wood tables and booths. The food is pretty straight forward bar food with pizzas, burgers and sandwiches serving as the staples.

I'm a big fan of the other Tyler's locations as they each have a far better beer selection than the one in Carrboro. If Carrboro had better beers I'd be all over it, but sadly there just aren't that many exciting or interesting beers on tap.

Check our their locations in Durham or Apex (haven't been to the new one in Raleigh yet) for far superior draft selections.

jonmacklin, Jan 10, 2012
Photo of VncentLIFE
3.9/5  rDev -2.7%

The bar is kid of small, but the beer selection is actually pretty good. There are beer signs everwhere (although I spied PBR and other AAL signs), and the bartenders know their beer for the most part. The lady told me that Flemish Red was really sour (It was a Rodenboch and was a solid Flemish, but not overly sour). Last time I was there, they had Kasteel Rouge (which was actually good) and Lindemans Peche. They had loads of local brews (gotta love that), as well as some other staples.

The biggest knock was the people there. Im rather young, and there were families playing pool and things in the side bar. Not really what Im looking for when I walk in carrying a bag full of Boon Lambics and plan on having some solid brews like Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin. They did have Harvest Time Pumpkin Ale which is rather hard to find on tap in the Triangle (its kind of like Christmas Ale in Ohio: they cant meet the demand at all. like not even close).

The food was average. Overly garlic fries and a chili cheese burger.

The beer was a bit pricey for the selection. Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin is the same price as Kasteel Rouge and Lindemans Peche? not good in my book.

VncentLIFE, Oct 01, 2011
Photo of EasyReader
4.33/5  rDev +8%

I've been hoping to have a chance to stop by Tyler's Taproom, and finally got the chance on a recent trip through the Triad. The restaurant looks reasonably spacious, but I sat at the bar. They have a nice selection of local, American and import craft beers. I had the Brooklyn Brewmaster's Reserve Main Engine Start and a selection from local Fullsteam Brewery. The food was pretty good as well, and I'd have no trouble stopping back by for a bite of dinner and a couple of beers on a future trip.

EasyReader, Jun 01, 2011
Photo of cvstrickland
4.5/5  rDev +12.2%

I'm a big fan of Tyler's in Durham, so I made a point of checking out the original in Carrboro!

Set in a partially-refurbished older brick building in the middle of downtown, Tyler's is casual and a bit rustic. The ceilings and upper walls are tastefully unfinished, the decor mostly consisting of empty wine and liquor bottles. The centerpiece of the tavern is a gleaming mahogany bar sporting twenty-one tap handles, two flat screen TVs, and appropriate glassware for all the drinks offered.

The atmsophere was light and friendly with a few dozen patrons in the bar on a Sunday afternoon, plenty of conversations going on, but with the volume kept to tasteful level.

Service was quick and friendly, knowledgeable of the products, and more casually-clad than the shirt-and-tie operation in Durham, but hey, this is Carrboro... you have a hard enough time getting the barefooted free-lovin hippies to put on their Birkenstocks, let alone get them to tie a necktie!!

So, back to it, Tyler's original bar has nice selection and variety, and the folks there have opened a bottle shop next door that will feature a craft tap or two of its own (Founders Red Rye the day I stopped in). With Weaver Street Market a mere pitching wedge away and Milltown a few minutes walking distance, a one-stop craft beer Mecca has sprung up right next door to Blue Heaven.

cvstrickland, Sep 01, 2008
Photo of SIRIUS2
4.2/5  rDev +4.7%

Atmosphere of a typical older building with some relatively recent updates. Very casual and comfortable, the kind of place I could get used to visiting regularly if it were closer to me.

I had a couple different selections on my recent visit and both were very good quality and served in the appropriate glassware. No chilled mugs or frosty glasses and the staff seemed relatively knowledgeable.

Great waitstaff; very prompt and attentive. My visit was on a Saturday afternoon and the place was probably at about 30% capacity. Everyone was very friendly.

Beer selection was decent, but I have been spoiled by the newer Tyler's in Apex and their monster selection! However, they have a nice solid baseline of brews - local, domestics, and imports - along with some specials and harder to find items like the Brooklyn Brewmaster's Reserve. So much more than your typical bar stop.

Good food, a few notches above the normal pub fare. Tyler's is noted for their garlic fries and they didn't disappoint here. They go great with the pulled pork sandwich and nice hoppy IPA!

If you get a chance, stop by and see these guys. They really do have some great beer and good food and the atmosphere is quaint and comfortable. Another perk is the bottle store that they opened right next door. I wonder if they are going to eventually offer the selection at the restaurant that they have in the bottle shop? That would be perfect!

SIRIUS2, Aug 26, 2008
Photo of GJ40
4.08/5  rDev +1.7%

I've been meaning to try this one for a while and it didn't disappoint.

They have a great selection of beer on tap including Delerium Tremens, Rogue Dead Guy, Rogue John's Private Locker Stock, Sierra Nevada PA and Maredsous 8. It's got a great atmosphere too. It's one big room with a bar on one side and dining throughout. It's a very casual feel which I like.

The food is pretty good too. I had the Pulled Pork. The garlic fries that come with most sandwiches are great.

I look forward to the new one opening up in Apex which is very close to me. By the looks of it, it won't have the same casual atmosphere but as long as the beer selection is good, I'll manage.

GJ40, Mar 31, 2008
Photo of blackie
4/5  rDev -0.2%

a: Decent atmosphere, but nothing to really set it apart. Visited on a quiet Sunday evening.

q: The Foothills Oktoberfest was a little warm, and the Kasteel Kriek was too cold, but the actual quality of the beer was fine.

s: Good service. Waited for a bit as the barkeeper struggled to get a new keg hooked up and working, but no big deal.

s: Selection not nearly as impressive as the Durham location, but still enough to keep things interesting. A few locals, a few Belgians, Blanche de Brooklyn, and others.

blackie, Sep 10, 2007
Photo of atsprings
4.2/5  rDev +4.7%

I have visited this bar twice now and I must say, I enjoy the laid back atmosphere for a place that carries such good beer. As the Raleigh Flying Saucer is now shying away from the Rogue Locker Stock series, this place and the Durham location will now become a more common stop for me even though they're out of the way. They also now carry the Brooklyn Brewmaster's Reserve series. On my last visit, a Saturday night, my friends and I were able to snag 3 seats at the bar even though a UNC game was starting in one hour. I was pleased to see that they still had Highland Cold Mountain Winter on tap. The waitress informed me that they had pulled it several times so they would have it later than anyone else. They have about 20 taps and always have glassware that matches the brewer, a nice touch. Service can be a little slow when their busy, but that's to be expected. The food is pretty good as well, I love the garlic fries. This is a pretty cool place and I will likely try and visit around once a month.

atsprings, Feb 23, 2007
Photo of wedge
4/5  rDev -0.2%

Through a mysterious swinging door in the back of Tyler's Taproom (or the door on the street I suppose), you decend a small ramp into a darker, more laid back bar. The atmosphere is decidedly different from its more polished neighbor, though pretty much the same establishment, this place has a much more hang-out with your buddies, shoot some pool, type of feeling. Old-looking walls with exposed brick, the pool tables and arcade games, the darkness, really make the "speakeasy" atmosphere in the main room. The bar hugs the wall to the right, a few TVs stuck in and around it. There's about 15 taps of good beer on the wall, probably not what people unfamiliar to the place would expect. If you want a Corona or Pabst, you get it in a bottle. There are bottles of good beer too: Delerium, Unibroue, Duvel...and more but that's all I can remember. Basically, if you're not satisfied by the draughts, they've probably got you covered. The selection was great on tap though: Hercules, Celebration, Hop Devil, 90 minute...lots of IPAs now that I think about it.

In the back, there's another room filled with couches and comfy chairs and a couple of large televisons so you can just sit down with your friends and shoot the shit. Very casual and informal overall.

This place might not be for everybody, and in fact, is probably more attractive to the younger crowd. If you don't like the smoke or the more gloomy feel, go next door, Tyler's is the place for you. For me, its just part of its charm - a casual, relaxed, good-times kind of bar with great beer.

wedge, Nov 01, 2006
Photo of yessri
4.15/5  rDev +3.5%

Had a good dinner last night at Tyler's. Not hard to find, parking can be a bit of a challenge depending on time of day/year. Nice selection of beer on tap, including several Belgian beers, a mead (Raspberry flavored - good), a few stouts and porters, but mostly saisons and summer brews. The Young's double chocolate stout was very nice, as was the Avery Imperial IPA. Ommegang's saison was the special of the day and was tasty. Points for proper glassware. We both had bacon and blue cheese burgers which were delicious. A very enjoyable place, worth a trip but not much of a detour if you're not close.

yessri, Jul 22, 2006
Photo of cracgor
4.06/5  rDev +1.2%

Tyler's is on Jones Ferry/Main/Franklin St...it all seems to be the same street just past Greensboro St when you're coming from the Jones Ferry Rd end. They have limited parking behind the restaurant...and I believe there is a little more just up the street.

It is a clean and classy looking little bar. Pretty much all wood, well dressed staff. The bar had a good selection of beer on tap that matched the website to the T...for those scouting. There is a dining area behind across from the bar with booths and tables, and a couch seating area just past the bar.

Tyler's is busy and though not overcrowded, it is not empty. Lots of people are talking, and it seems easy to meet people. I imagine it would be busier once school is back in session.

The service in Tyler's is nice. The bartender poured beer properly and everything I could expect. The selection of beers is pretty good too. Though I didn't eat, the food looked typical of a beer bar--not outstanding, but I'm not going here for food in particular anyway.

cracgor, Aug 03, 2005
Photo of GCBrewingCo
4.58/5  rDev +14.2%

Tyler's is located just off Main (I'd call it Franklin). I found some parking in a dirt lot behind Wendy's and entered through the Speakeasy.

Tyler's was well lit and smoke free. Very family oriented place with an emphasis on craft beer. The bar had 19 taps by my count and one of those was a mead. The draw was a Rogue special edition beer and oddly enough this was my first experience at Tyler's. We ordered a round and plopped down in the couch area just above the bar. Great location for conversation.

Tyler's was a bit noisy, but the food smells were phenomenal. We didn't order anything, but the next time it will be on the list of things to do. All the taps were well chosen and interesting and once the limit is raised this will probably be the premiere destination or the new location that will soon open in Durham.

Service was stellar and the gentleman (Tyler?) ran a tab without a blink of an eye even though we were sitting away from the bar. Great way to do business!

GCBrewingCo, Jul 15, 2005
Photo of Stoo333
3.98/5  rDev -0.7%

I met a few friends here on a busy friday night. We sat at the pleasant wooden bar and I welcomed the lack of any tacky decor.

Beer list included a few suprises... at the moment they were offering Ephemere and a winter seasonal from Lost Coast. Other nice standards were 60 Minute, Dead Guy, and a couple Brooklyn offerings.

I only tried a couple appetizers. The wings were average but the fresh chips smothered in funky blue cheese were quite delicious. I'd be interested to try their other selections.

I can't complain about service too much due to how busy they were; though they did seem a bit understaffed at the time considering the amount of people that were there.

I haven't been to too many other places in the triangle, but I'd consider this one of my top choices at the moment. A solid, good experience.

Stoo333, Jan 07, 2005
Photo of Ninjaworm
3.39/5  rDev -15.5%

As it has been explained previously, Tyler’s and the Speakeasy are adjoining through a single door. Because of the timing of my visit I was only able to visit the Speakeasy. I did not have any food during this trip. The bar has around 10 taps with assorted craft beers and a beer engine that did not have anything available that day. Behind the bar is 3 pool tables and foosball. The other room that makes up the Speakeasy is a sitting room that is filled with couches and chairs to hang out.

Atmosphere:
A very nice atmosphere for hanging out and having a general good time, the only thing that bothered me was being a non-smoker is was quite smokey in the sitting area.

Quality:
The beer selection was good but I feel 2/3 beers that I tasted were not very fresh.

Service:
The bartenders were very prompt and courteous with their service.

Selection:
There are approximately 10 craft taps along with a beer engine when available. I did not look closely but there seemed to be a selection of bottled beer also.

Ninjaworm, Aug 17, 2004
Tyler's Restaurant & Taproom / Speakeasy in Carrboro, NC
90 out of 100 based on 18 ratings.