1. Extreme Beer Fest. March 20 & 21, 2015 in Boston, Mass. Join us!
  2. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  3. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Carlyle Brewing Co.

Not Rated.
Carlyle Brewing Co.Carlyle Brewing Co.
BA SCORE
88
very good

31 Ratings
Ratings: 31
Reviews: 25
rAvg: 3.89
pDev: 16.45%
Active Beers: 13
Beer Ratings: 69
Beer Avg: 3.99
Taps: 12
Bottles: 0
Cask: N
Beer-to-Go: Y
[ Brewery, Bar, Eatery ]

215 E State St
Rockford, Illinois, 61104-1010
United States
phone: (815) 963-2739

visit their websiteWebsite view map and get directionsMap 

Notes:
None, yet.

(Place added by: Dogbrick)
Place: Ratings & Reviews
Sort by:  Usefulness | Recent | High | Low | Top Raters
« first ‹ prev | 1-25 | 26-50  | next › last »
Ratings: 31 | Reviews: 25 | Display Reviews Only:
Photo of stouts4me
3/5  rDev -22.9%

stouts4me, Aug 24, 2014
Photo of mr8073
5/5  rDev +28.5%

mr8073, Jul 31, 2014
Photo of Tconder
3.25/5  rDev -16.5%

Tconder, Jul 13, 2014
Photo of Piske41
4.5/5  rDev +15.7%

Piske41, Mar 25, 2014
Photo of foretheloveofbeer
3.75/5  rDev -3.6%

foretheloveofbeer, Mar 23, 2014
Photo of smmeier819
3.4/5  rDev -12.6%

Bring back that damn pizza already! To fill out the obligatory character requirement...pizza pizza pizza, now now now! Crud, I'm still about 130 characters short...how bout now? Nope, still not enough. Well, to make a long story short...beer goes great with food. The only thing worth eating here was the pizza, and they got rid of it. I wish they would bring it back...that's got to be enough letters and punctuation for sure.

smmeier819, Mar 02, 2014
Photo of DOCRW
3.25/5  rDev -16.5%

DOCRW, Feb 07, 2014
Photo of KFBR392
3.73/5  rDev -4.1%

Atmosphere: A very relaxed and easy going atmosphere, even on some nights where it is packed with people. Shuffle board, darts, and billiards are all available to the patrons. A couple different seating areas which easily accommodate a large group or yourself and a date is very nice. No doubt a fun relaxing place to have a few beers.

Quality: The quality of the beer is good but nothing great. All of their beers seem to have the same piny hop character. Not sure what specific hops they are using but it runs throughout their whole line. Its not an offensive flavor but lacks diversity. That being said though, I will no doubt take their brews over all of the usual places to go in Rockford.

Service: No real problems here, but nothing that ever blew me away. There was always a waiter/waitress in close range to get ahold of. Servers were always pleasant, even on busy nights which is always appreciated.

Food: Perfect beer drinking pizza! Very thin crust with many different toppings available. They also have some traditional snacks like salted pretzels which is a favorite of my girlfriend. Definitely have something to tide that appetite during a long evening of drinking.

Overall: A great place to go and I highly recommend it to anyone passing through/in the Rockford area. Good beer and some very solid food. Just switch up those hops every once in a while and we would really be in business!

KFBR392, Apr 09, 2013
Photo of Lemke10
3.76/5  rDev -3.3%

My wife and I dropped by in December 2012 before heading off to see a show at the BMO Harris Center that is located just a block away. Located in the downtown older part of Rockford, this is a fairly decent sized place as there is kind of a hidden part to the building. On a Saturday night this place was hopping. We weren’t offered any kind of seating so we took it as a “seat yourself” kind of place. The food menu is pretty basic brewpub food, just something that pairs well with beer. Staff was nice and the beers were average to above average quality wise. A nice little place I would be interesting in visiting again. However their website could really use some help. No food menu and talk about weird hours opening at 3pm most days. Closed on Sundays? That wouldn’t fly in Wisconsin! More hours and a more appealing lunch/dinner menu would greatly help this place.

Lemke10, Dec 14, 2012
Photo of Yetiman420
4.94/5  rDev +27%

Stop #354 on my world brewery tour.

Located in what appears to be a slowly gentrifying area of historic downtown Rockford next to a chocolate shop and running store. Lots of people riding by on their bikes but not for exercise. Old building with a good view of the brewing operation.

I went with two sampler flights and a full pint. From a style execution standpoint, these beers were as good as I've ever had. If you've ever been turned off by a bad Helles lager or cream ale, Carlyle will make you a believer in great session beers. A couple of comments where appropriate on the beers I had....

Flight one
Pale Ale - wonderful crystal malt balance.
Helles
Saison
Hefe
Vanilla Cream - Fantastic! "Fresh vanilla," I'm brewing one next summer.

Flight Two
Honey Ale - The least desirable of the beers I had. Still ok
Humulus IPA (full pint) - Beautiful IPA with full flavor
Irish Red - Testament to great malt balance
Scottish
Stout - Wonderfully roasty and complex

The only beer I didn't sample was the Quad as I was driving and didn't want to overdo it.

I didn't have any of the food but it seemed more like snack food than what you might have for dinner (not a lot of options). Service was friendly and proactive...lots of older locals enjoying themselves at the bar.

Highly recommend for the beer and historical ambiance.

Yetiman420, Sep 06, 2012
Photo of SpdKilz
4.16/5  rDev +6.9%

Came here with my brother-in-law and my sister.

Walked in on a Saturday night at about six and there were already quite a few people there. We were only going to stay for a bit so we took some seats at the bar. The vibe was quite nice and the bartender helped us out immediately. The place was very cool looking with some stone work and overall just a very well done bar. The bartender was quite attentive the entire time and helped us with any questions we had. My brother-in-law and I ordered a beer each and then some tasters while my sister just had the Vanilla Cream Ale (which I admit was not the best – vanilla seemed pretty artificial). Their saison stood out to me and I actually got a second glass of it. There was a good selection of house taps and the tasters allowed us to try quite a few beers which was nice. We did not get food here but the prices/selection seemed on par with what you’d expect. Overall, an enjoyable experience and I can’t wait to come back here again.

SpdKilz, Nov 06, 2011
Photo of 4DAloveofSTOUT
4.38/5  rDev +12.6%

Very clean and nice place for a beer. Excellant bar food, the pizza is my favorite. Vanilla Ale and Stout are stables and every now and again, they have a tastey BIG BEER too fron thier specialty list! The rootbeer is amazing also, they make it in house. One of the first bars I would go to on a regular basis when I first started to like craft brewski! Still is a favorite. Its easy to spend money in that place. They have a shuffle board in the back along with bumper pool. This place is always packed on the weekends.

4DAloveofSTOUT, Feb 09, 2011
Photo of phartzog
4.05/5  rDev +4.1%

One of my favorites. Especially since this is about the ONLY place my wife will drink beer- She's a martini gal but at Carlyle, she will drink the Vanilla, Stout or a Stanilla and occasionally a "Juan More" Mexican style lager.

Positives:
The owner did a great job of rehabbing an old building into a very cozy and inviting place to drink a few pints. The atmosphere is pub-like and is geared toward conversation. No blaring music, no scantily clad bubble-breasted bimbo servers, no TVs, just blues or sometimes jazz piped in softly as background music. The tables are rustic and low and the floor is made of stone tile complemented by bare brick walls and an impressive wooden bar. The crowd is a bit older and is very friendly and eager to talk beer.

One of my favorite touches is the chalkboard beer menu. It adds to the mystique of the rotating beer menu and every time I go, the first place I look is at the board to see what new malty or hoppy goodness awaits or to see which old friends have returned.

The beer quality is excellent and has far outpaced my original expectations. I have only had a couple beers I disliked and I tried them despite not liking the beer style to begin with. Friends confirm my suspicion that the beer is good and I am simply not a fan of Stouts or most Hefeweizens.

Negatives:
I hate to ding them for anything but here goes. Service tends to be slow. I am not a stickler for fast service so it doesn't bug me but I have gone with friends who are absolutely beside themselves when the server hasn't arrived just as they finish their last drop. On the plus side, servers are very knowledgeable and friendly.

Food- Food is secondary at Carlyle because it is not intended to be a restaurant. If you want a snack it does the trick but don't expect a gourmet meal. The pizzas are good but not great and they removed my favorite- Braunschweiger & Onion sandwich from their already limited menu. Go for the beer. Not the food.

Conclusion: Overall a fun and tasty place!

phartzog, Jan 06, 2011
Photo of Nurb
4.18/5  rDev +7.5%

For the last several years I've been visiting Carlyle Brewing Company in Rockford, and in my opinion, it's the best as far as atmosphere and beer is concerned for the city and for the entire area surrounding.

For astmosphere, I like the fact there are no TV's or sports related items nailed to the walls competing for your attention. There are enough sports bars in the Rockford area, so a more simple brewpub setting where you can talk to friends over a drink is a very nice change from chain franchises and hole-in-the-wall dives that overfill the city. They also have a selection of games behind the bar, which I find amusing. They have also recently expanded into the next building, which used to be a strip club, and into the area behind the building, now made into a beer garden.

When it comes to the beer, the selection is fantastic and frequently changing thanks to the owner, who likes to experiment and try different traditional and newer styles. The beer selection ranges from smooth and heavy, stouts to crisp ales, to high ABV IPAs, and everything in between. They will also feature seasonal beers through the year, and often will be different from the previous years themselves. One thing to note however; with the exception of some beer styles, Carlyle's does not over-hop their beer out of style or balance like many microbrews like to do. I've heard many a Hop-Head comment on the lack of hops punching them in the mouth, but they do have very hoppy beers to choose from, even though they aren't the bulk of their choices.

Despite everything, there isn't one beer they've produced I have felt was of low quality, bad, or "wrong" in taste, and I am a bit of a beer geek, even if I try not to be.

When it comes to the food and service, both are adequet, but the focus is all on the beer. The food menu is about par for the course when it comes to bar food, but their sandwiches and tortilla crust pizza are very good. The service can be hit or miss depending on the day, time, and the staff on hand. Some days it's busy but they'll always be around, and some days you'll wait an hour for food service. However, in either case, the staff is always friendly in my experience.

Overall, I'd have to say this is one of the only gems in the rotting hole that is Rockford.

Nurb, May 29, 2010
Photo of Mandark
3.93/5  rDev +1%

Stopped in with my wife and four year old daughter for dinner and a sample of their brews on 4/7/10.

First, I love the fact there is no television anywhere. This alone is enough to make me want to give it a 5 all around. Too many bars with too many TVs in this world, dadgummit. Anyway, there's a great large window in front from which to see the cool older buildings across the way, and the Rock River just down the road a piece. Ceiling is high, tables of solid wood, comfortable enough chairs, kind of dark, a handsome bar and brick walls. The brewery itself is visible through a gate and a glass window, and that's a nice touch. The music is present but unobtrusive---we heard Tom Waits, Natalie Merchant, Van Morrison, etc.---and like the clientele, it seemed like a lot of white folks with good taste.

Nothing wrong with that. The food menu is kind of sparse but not bad for pub grub: pizzas, basic sandwiches, etc. No wings or fried stuff. We had a sausage pizza and it was more than adequate. There were at least twelve beers on tap and we sampled eight of the twelve. That is one of the really nice things in terms of the beer: 5oz. samples go for between $1.25 and $2.50. You can choose what you want to try, and there is no set "flight" menu. That is a very nice touch.

We tried the APA, the imperial stout, the stout, the honey ale, the Irish red, the IPA, the English bitter and the double IPA. Each had its strengths, and each was tasty in its way, but there was nothing outstanding, or that will blow your mind. Of them all I thought the APA was the best as it was the most balanced, drinkable and memorable. Growlers cost $5, and the fill prices vary depending upon what style you get.

The service was competent but not aggressive. I wasn't expecting a whole lot, to be honest, but our waiter was nice and kept us in food and drink.

I liked the atmosphere, the food was serviceable and the beer was not bad. We got there at 4:30 on a Wednesday, and people were trickling in throughout the almost two hours we were there, until the place was pretty full by 6:00. I would definitely go back again, considering that this is the only place of its kind for miles and miles around. The best thing about this place is that it is an independent establishment run by someone who obviously has a love for beer and brewing it himself, and I value that commitment, especially in this city. If you're ever in Rockford, this is the place to go.

Mandark, Apr 08, 2010
Photo of Bellabananas
1.98/5  rDev -49.1%

We stopped by here because my parents live in Rockford. Boy were we disappointed. Based on the reviews, maybe we just happened by on an off night, despite being a Saturday night. The place just looked completely blah. People were coming in every once in a while, but they all migrated into a back room or something, very few people in the front with the bar. We sampled several different beers and didn't enjoy a single one. My overall impression of their beer is watered down. It was hard to believe that the beers had the ABVs the menu boasted. We didn't try any food and left as soon as we had choked down a beer and some samples. Prices were standard for Rockford, although nice to us since we're from the city. I doubt you could drag me there again.

Bellabananas, Jan 28, 2010
Photo of TripT
4.33/5  rDev +11.3%

As a life-long resident of this hard-luck city, I think Carlyle is a rare gem. This is the place that I proudly take folks who are visiting from out of town. As others have said, the atmosphere is inviting and the service is friendly. As far as the beer goes, I think most of their offerings are great. There have been a few that I did not care for, but by and large, the beer is very good. I'm guessing the most popular brew they offer is the Humulous Lupulus (sp.?), which is a classy IPA. The Scottish Ale is also noteworthy. They don't devote a lot of resources to food, but what they have is simple and good. Carlyle makes Rockford a better place.

TripT, Sep 25, 2009
Photo of homebrew311
3.14/5  rDev -19.3%

I am from Chicago but I visit Rockford frequently as my girlfriend's parents live there. I went downtown to seek out some good beer when I came across Carlyle's. Everything about this place was promising... the only brewery in Rockford, a nice atmosphere, a decent list of 12 beers that include some creative styles. The prices were also reasonable 3.75 for a glass (short of a pint) for most of their beers. The first beer I tried was the Bourbon aged cherry stout. This was served in a "goblet". The goblet looked huge (about 12-14 oz) but the glass was so thick that it only looked large perceptually. My guess is that it held 10 oz max. This beer was a huge disappointment. The appearance is thin and watery which for the style is a no no. The taste... water, bourbon, water. No cherry flavor and no roasted stout flavors. If I tasted this blind, I would have guessed it was AB's winter bourbon cask ale. I also sampled the Scotch ale which had a pleasant aroma and had a nice grain profile. Once again, this fell short on the taste. Very watery. It is as if they brewed all of their beer and then watered them down. Also sampled the vanilla cream ale... same story here. I will no go back here. As tempting and attractive as this place is, the product does not deliver.

homebrew311, Jul 19, 2009
Photo of hoosier222002
4.2/5  rDev +8%

Stopped in on a Thursday afternoon with some friends. This was the first time I had been in for quite a while. They had approx. 12 beers on tap with a nice range of styles. I enjoyed their Five Malt Ale, Scottish Ale and Imperial Stout. The only downside to the visit was that they were out of the Humulus Lupus (their IPA).

They have recently expanded their food for those interested. They now offer small sandwiches along with pizza and some small snacks.

The atmosphere is nice and relaxing while sitting at the bar and talking with friends. All in all, a very positive experience. Looking forward to going back and enjoying the beer garden for the first time.

hoosier222002, May 09, 2009
Photo of zebulon
3.43/5  rDev -11.8%

Pleasant bar atmosphere. A little dark but that just made it relaxing.

Not a lot of beer selection but most major types available. Had there IPA which was OK. Had their Triple which was like sweet liquid bananas, the alcohol was hidden in the sweetness - dangerous. More like a light bodied syrup than a beer.

Service was mixed one bar tender (that took care of me) was friendly and informative. The other looked through me like I wasn't there and spend his time with what seemed like regulars.

Lots of regulars in the place, both at the bar and at tables.

Very limited menu bar food brats etc.

A decent place for a snack and a beer. I like to support local breweries when I visit a town and I will be back if I come to Rockford. Not a great place, but certainly worth a stop.

zebulon, Mar 23, 2009
Photo of spointon
3.9/5  rDev +0.3%

Visited on 10/11/2008.

Being the only brewpub in town, we decided to visit while on a camping weekend at Rock Cut State Park.

This place is located near the river in downtown Rockford. Parking was easy to find on a Saturday afternoon, but I could see it being a problem at other times. Upon entering I was immediately liking the ambiance of the place. The brew house is all off to the right and visible through windows and an open (gated)doorway. The main bar room is to the left and is a long skinny room that has the bar situated on the right side and the tables and booths over to the left. Everything is dark stained wood and very comforting in an old, well-used pub sort of way. The beers are clearly listed on a giant chalkboard at the end of the bar along with the relevant ABVs. The beer garden was down a long hallway and out behind the building (in the alley). It was nicely done (stone wall around it with a gate in the corner) but I decided against it because, well, it was in the alley and hot as hell.

I was impressed to find 12 beers on tap at this little place! A nice assortment of brews including some standards as well as a few showing some creativity (i.e. vanilla cream ale). All but 2 of the beers were in the 4.5 to 5.5 ABV range. I had the American Strong Ale, the Festbier, and the Vanilla Cream Ale. All were what I would consider good and drinkable but nothing earth-shattering to note.

Service was friendly (we sat at the bar) and the bartender was willing to comment on some of the beers, pour free samples, and generally shoot the breeze on a slow Saturday.

The prices at this place were in my opinion very good. The day we visited, 10 of the 12 beers were just $3.75 per pint and the other two were $4.00 per pint. Price wise, my only complaint was that the 2 "expensive" beers were each $26 for a growler refill while the other 10 beers were just $9 per growler refill.

Overall, this is a solid good place to find fresh beer in the Rockford area. I will definitely visit again without reservations on my next trip out that way.

spointon, Oct 12, 2008
Photo of Hedeen
3.38/5  rDev -13.1%

Not expecting alot of greatness in Rockford... I love the town... and Cheap Trick... but being a visitor in that town for over 15 years to see family... I've never had a great brew experience there until recent years.

The Carlyle is good. The food is typical brew pub choices and the beer is OK. A bit flavorless at times... but good enough.

I think they need to embrace the wonderful brew mentality that is just up the road in Wisconsin. More classic retro brewing recipes...and homages.

In Rockford, The Carlyle is a safe bet.

Hedeen, Sep 24, 2008
Photo of Contagion
4.38/5  rDev +12.6%

This is one of my favorite places to go in Rockford. The interior of the building is very rustic from the exposed beams to the the 18th century style tables along the walls. The center tables are more modern. You can see the brew kettles from your seats through a gated doorway or windows. There is a slight Scottish theme.

The staff is generally very nice and helpful. However, when it gets busy it can be a while before visits. The owner is frequently in the bar and will sit down and talk with you if invited. In fact just last Saturday night he joined some friends and I for pint.

The food menu is not extensive, but everything on there is excellent. They probably have one of the best reubens in the city and the beer brat is also excellent. Their beer menu does change with the seasons. There are some staple favorites on there all year round.

If you are in the Rockford area and like good beer, you would be remiss not to visit.

Contagion, Jun 24, 2008
Photo of emerge077
4.28/5  rDev +10%

Glass façade with the brewkettles in full view from the street. Once inside the double doors, there was a preliminary board listing the current specialty brews. It was December, and I was happy to see an Imperial Stout and Christmas Ale listed.

The first thing to draw my eye after stepping in was the colorful "Lion Rampant" flag of Scotland high on the back wall. Brewery area was gated off by Tim Burton style iron gates, right out of the Nightmare Before Xmas. Deep red and blue hues on some walls, with a large exposed brick wall to one side, with 5 educational banners about the brewing process. All house taps at the bar, dark wooden tables and benches in the small seating area.

We sat down and decided to order a pizza, but waited a while for service. Once the server got to us, I could see that he was also working the bar with one other staff member. We probably showed up between shifts, because the service was great once we ordered. They brought several samples over the course of the evening. Didn't get a growler, but the Imperial Stout was the highlight. Pizza was ok, it was ultra thin and employed a flour tortilla as the crust. The other menu items sounded good, deli sandwiches and soft pretzels.

Worth a detour off of I-90, this seems to be the best beer stop Rockford has to offer (in 2007). Also of note in town is Toad Hall, an emporium of collectibles, mostly records, books, and odds & ends.

emerge077, Dec 27, 2007
Photo of ultralarry2006
4.8/5  rDev +23.4%

This brewpub is located near the Rock River in downtown Rockford. It is in an older brick building, and has exposed brick walls on the inside, very charming. The brewing area can be seen from the outside, off to the rightside, and from inside, it can be seen behind glass behind the right side half of the bar. The physical environment combined with the indie rock, jazz, and lounge music piped in on the satellite radio renders a very urbane, even hip ambience. They have only their own beers here, all on-tap, and roughly a dozen or so. The beer here is excellent ! I had one of the best quad's I have ever had, and a really good tripel, as well. I also had some 4 oz. sample sizes of an excellent strong ale ( which is what they called it, I think it was a barleywine ), as well as an excellent hefe-weizen, and a really good scottish ale. The servers here were very friendly, and helpful, and knowledgible. They have food, apparantly of the pub-food variety, but I did not have any since I had just come from having had a huge dinner previously, but maybe next time I will. Anyway, this place is excellent, and has excellent beer, and I would come here often if it was in Chicago, or if I lived in Rockford.

ultralarry2006, Aug 27, 2007
« first ‹ prev | 1-25 | 26-50  | next › last »
Carlyle Brewing Co. in Rockford, IL
88 out of 100 based on 31 ratings.