Schlafly Christmas Ale - The Schlafly Tap Room
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 338 | Reviews: 156 | Display Reviews Only:
1.98/5 rDev -45.9%
I've been to Schlafly's, I know they make good beer. I also know that this is not one of the one's that i like. Yeah, i know its a Christmas ale, and i know that some people like to put some spices in their Christmas drinks, but come on guys....this was just they dumped in a bunch of cloves and nutmeg and orange rind and figured that if you could taste all of that crap in the beer it would make it a good beer. I've all for those flavors in beer, now, dont get me wrong; but to the extent that they were all right up there hitting me in the tongue? and it was so muddled and unbalanced. Its the worst tasting spiced beer i've had since that Buffalo Bill's Pumpkin from 2 yeaers ago. way too many spices and it was a bit thin too. looked ok, and actually smelled fine, but yeah, downhill from there.
12-13-2006 19:43:03 | More by aforbes10
2.2/5 rDev -39.9%
Poured from a bottle, crystal clear and deep copper color. Smells like a nice Christmas ale, cloves and other spices. Tastes like a bad beer gone sour and tried to mask the flavor with spices. Not a fan of this one. Has a slick body to it and tastes sour at the end of the taste. Not sure if it was a bad bottle or what.
11-27-2011 23:51:16 | More by EmergingZymurgy
2.55/5 rDev -30.3%
Pours a coppery color without much head.
Very subdued aroma with subtle spice, a little funk, and candied tangerine.
There isn't much going on as far as flavor, clovey spice and maybe some citrus. The body is smooth but watery. Lacks depth and the 8% is creepy considering how little flavor it has.
I haven't had a beer I liked less than this in a while and I could easily pour it down the drain but i'll finish it. If you're looking for a strong beer without much flavor and a thin body, this might be for you.
12-27-2009 18:08:09 | More by brownbeer
2.6/5 rDev -29%
My roomate brought me back some of this from a trip to St.Louis, which I shared with beer club.
It was not too good; I didn't think it was as bad as some others (aforbes) did, but the taste pretty much kills this beer. It pours a deep clear red brown, looks ok so far. Smells like christmas. Piney, nutmeg, cloves. Not bad. The taste is overload of ginger, nutmeg, cloves, orange, pine... pretty much tastes like a christmas air freshener in beer form. On the plus side, the alcohol is very well hidden (errr... covered-up?). Mouthfeel is ok, a bit dry. Drinkability is hurt by the taste. But I bet if you simmered this stuff on the stove it would make your house smell really good.
12-19-2006 05:24:31 | More by shivtim
2.65/5 rDev -27.6%
This beer pours an orange color with a thin white head. No lacing, no head retention. Average carbonation.
Smells of anise, cinammon, cider, and malts.
The taste reminds me of a Czech herbal lliquor, Becherovka. Herbs, a touch of liquourice, malts, a little sweet fruitiness in the aftertaste. There's a lot going on, and it's interesting, but not something I love. And as I drink the beer, I like it less and less.
11-21-2011 02:39:42 | More by jar2574
2.78/5 rDev -24%
Serving: 12 oz bottle into Rogue Yellow Snow IPA pint glass
A: A clear reddish brown, with a thin off-white head
S: Malty aroma, slight hoppiness, definite ginger, "farmhouse ale" scent as well
T: Sweet all the way through, woody, slightly fruity, very thin (not subtle) flavors that could benefit from being slightly more pronounced, slight orange flavor
M: prickly carbonation, almost undetectable finishing bitterness, watery
D: Drinkable, this is #1 of the 6-pack I bought. This one served after being in fridge for one hour- lets see how it changes at cooler temps.
Overall: 25% through this one I'm not overly impressed. It seems just a bit too cloying for 8.0% ABV.
12-06-2009 03:03:21 | More by jmw141
2.8/5 rDev -23.5%
It's that time of year, right? Considered taking a six with me to festivities to share, but having not had this before I decided to test one from a mix'n'match section first. I am guinea pig...
Pours a deep but clear amber with tons of visible carbonation, lacing and a significant white, hollow but short-lived head. Smell orange immediately (though not in annoying proportion), with honey and a bit of cinammon I assume is from the clove. Hop character doesn't come up on the nose at all, if it's there it's all taste. Speaking of which...
The orange continues while the honey disappears & the spice comes forward. No real bitterness, yet oddly little residual sweetness either (the malt character is pretty anonymous as a result). Goes down thin. The 8% is super well hidden -- TOO well hidden to be honest.
I wouldn't call it a total loss, but the richness I expected for a big winter ale wasn't there. Schalfly let the additional ingredients do too much of the work.
11-24-2011 07:38:18 | More by longbongsilver
2.85/5 rDev -22.1%
Poured into a standard pint glass. The beer is a hazy copper color. The head dissipates quickly leaving nothing, and no lacing at all. The beer smells boozy with lots of different spices. I was hesitant to buy this, and the taste confirms why I shouldn't have: it's just over-the-top with flavor, like most of the Schlafly beers I have tried are. Sweetness and spices just blow your taste buds into defensive mode. There's a lot of cinnamon, clove, nutmeg and the likes in this. It tastes like Chai tea, and almost could pass for a Pumpkin ale. And just like their Pumpkin ale, this beer is loaded at 8% ABV and goes down too smooth, so watch out.
Overall, I just don't like the sweetness overload on top of the high alcohol content. Plus, the spices are in overdrive, so this beer is just a bit too much, all the way around. This might be the last Schlafly beer I ever try.
12-24-2011 20:49:56 | More by JuicesFlowing
2.93/5 rDev -19.9%
I know it ain't Christmas no more, but I got theis beer and it needs to be drunk.
A- pours a light amber with a slight haze.
S- has a malty nose and you can start to smell the spices up front.
T- Very malty and a ton o fclove flavors, almost too much. not digging it at all.
M- Sticky, syrup, somewhat thick.
D- Not gonna drink many of these.
01-06-2010 23:03:32 | More by jbone78
2.95/5 rDev -19.4%
A: a light brown color with very good clarity. not much head or hold making it almost look like a soda.
S: brown sugar, caramel, toffee, a slight peppery note, some herbal zesty hops. some pine notes.
T: Peppery with some pine tree notes. hints of cinnamon and all spice. lots of brown sugar and a touch of nut meg. the spices arent all that powerful but the all spice note sticks out the most and overwhelmed at times
M: Slightly hot and a bit chalky due to the spices. i would have liked a bit more of a creamy feel
D: Not my favorite of this style but a nice one to try. glad i did not buy a six pack
12-10-2010 21:57:07 | More by mikey711
2.98/5 rDev -18.6%
Poured from a 12oz bottle with bottled on date: 11/12/2009. Sampled 2 for a fair tasting.
A: Pours a crisp, clean amber to toasted caramel with a dense but short off white head. Very little head retention or lacing.
S: Smells of caramel, subtle oranges, fruit (pumpkin?), vanilla, malt, and clove.
M: Moderately carbonated but not overly so. Light to medium-light body with a syrup backbone. CO2 evaporates halfway through the glass leaving a syrup overload.
T: Front: Mild clove and citrus, toasted malts Middle: Floral hops Finish: metallic, oxidized fruits and vegetables, malt, and alcohol.
D: Drink it cold and drink it quickly on a cold night and you'll enjoy yourself.
I've had better examples of this style but I wouldn't hesitate to drink this again next year, maybe a little fresher or on tap?
02-25-2010 03:46:17 | More by dropout86
Schlafly Christmas Ale from The Schlafly Tap Room
83 out of 100 based on 338 ratings.