Tröegs Mad Elf - Tröegs Brewing Company
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 2,954 | Reviews: 1,149 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by nsheehan:
4.03/5 rDev +4.4%
12oz bottle to Duvel Tulip
Bottled 110719 (maybe?)
Given to me in December 2011
A – Poured medium strength into a Duvel tulip. One finger of head that dissipates quickly, I think it’s my soap’s fault. A lot of yeasties floating around, giving it a hazy look, like a strange snowglobe. Color is a dark amber with a tinge of orange. It’s quite opaque, but still has a slight warmth to it; light is getting through but my hand can barely induce a shadow.
S – A nice, sweet, earthy Belgian smell with some spice and dark fruit. Also some alcohol nip. The sweet Belgian smell is apparent, and paired up with other smells that don’t shirk away. I’d like to see it play a slightly larger role. It seems equal to the alcohol, spice, and dark fruit smell (part of which may come from the yeast, but still). For being a BSDA holiday ale brewed with spices and cherries, I think it’s very well done; so many holiday ales go too far. When I gently swirl the beer, I pick up banana, slight bubble gum, cherries, and dates, in that order, with alcohol wrapped around every one.
T – The Belgian flavor plays a slightly larger role in the taste than the smell, which is to my liking. The alcohol is the second flavor, which is OK, but not ideal. The fruit is apparent on the swallow, and I pick out some dark fruits, like cherry, and also cantaloupe. Weird, but welcome. The spices are there, but hang out in the back of each taste, which is great. Comes across as a good, boozy BSDA.
M – A light medium, which is surprising but OK. Makes it easier to drink on a day like today (though I’m currently inside). The carbonation seems to have kept well for about two years (what I can tell from swirling it), but high ABV BSDAs tend to be low on the carbonation spectrum. This one is soft and a tiny bit chewy, but as mentioned, has a slightly lighter than expected body. It sticks pretty close to the tongue, and the finish is pretty wet, except for your inner cheeks, where I think the alcohol has a drying effect.
D – I am looking forward to trying this fresh sometime, but for now I am happy I saved it for 1.5-2 years. It is soft and seems to have retained flavor without oxidizing.
4, 4, 4, 4.25, 4; ~4.04
08-25-2013 14:11:06 | More by nsheehan
More User Reviews:
4.25/5 rDev +10.1%
A nice find last night at the Spring House Drafting Room,pours a nice ruby red with a nice creamy,sticky head,aroma is spicey with a light smoky tinge to it.I got the flavors of spiced cherries with tha light smokey flavor with some alcohol note as it warms.Troegs is one of my favorite PA brewers and this offering reinforces that thought.
12-30-2003 20:15:05 | More by oberon
4/5 rDev +3.6%
Appearance Clear and bright orangish-red in color with a very shallow head, probably from the high ABV.
Smell Big mix of cherry and orange juice, mostly cherry, with a dash of cranberry and yeast. Theres a noticeable but very easy whiff of alcohol as well.
Taste The yeast comes out more at the taste and mixes well with the cherry juice and booze. This is a sipping ale in every sense. Some spices come out at the finish, making this one a very complex and interesting ale.
Mouthfeel This one is light for a BSDA but with a strong alcohol sting, probably too much for most. It is smooth as glass though, so watch out!
Drinkability I enjoyed this one, as did many of my BA Bros, but I wouldnt offer this to a friend unless they can appreciate the style interpretation. This is for the serious-minded only, but if youre up for it its one hell of an experience.
Comments OldFrothingSlosh sent this one to me out of the blue, and boy was I ever glad that he did. A big THANX for getting this one out to me BeerAdvocates rule!
01-22-2004 03:28:55 | More by RoyalT
2.2/5 rDev -43%
Mad Elf is dark maple colored brew with a thin tan head. It is strongly perfumed with an aroma of cherry-flavored cough syrup that quickly overwhelms faint wisps of hop.
Taste opens spicy with phenols, then sweet malt kept in check by cherry vapors and alcoholic burn. I get a slight tartness in the background and possibly a banana note. The mouthfeel is viscous, thick, flat and syrupy, but I was only able to feel that once my tounge had been numbed to the scorching alcohol.
This is a valient attempt at a new take on x-mas beer but I am not into it. I have been very impressed with the other Troegs beers I've tried, but find Mad Elf a little to close to Mad Dog.
11-28-2007 05:27:41 | More by JudgeRoughneck
3.63/5 rDev -6%
This one came to me from the great generosity of Hophead101. A holiday brew but I wanted to drink it tonight before the weather gets warm. One last look back at winter before I throw myself into the summer spirit.
A: Poured from a 12oz bottle, it didn't deliver much of a head. Dissipated almost immediately to a ring. Color is a lovely dark cherry amber.
S: I think I detect honey. Mostly, I catch a whiff of malt and a powerful mix of berry like smell. There is cherry there but it smells more of tart cranberry. Boozy smell too.
T: I was trying to pick out the flavors and there is definitely a mix of the things I smelled. The trouble was that I could help but focus on the the high alcohol manifesting itself in a sherry type taste that wasn't that appealing to me. The mix of sherry and diacetyl was just too much.
M: Light and clean body. Medium fine carbonation.
D: The finish and aftertaste is dry and makes you want to continue drinking this beer. Unfortunately, this one just wasn't for me at all. I'd like to re-visit it around holiday time but I think Great Lakes Christmas Ale is still my go-to festive brew.
05-22-2009 02:23:19 | More by sgoodship
3.6/5 rDev -6.7%
Review from BeerAdvocate Magazine Issue #47 (Dec 2010):
A cult classic among, beer geeks in the know. From the label to the ingredients it screams Christmas. Crystal-clear red color garners a thin white lacing. Yeasty phenols to cherries to ripe fruit to spice, an amazing nose. Creamy mouthfeel with a bit of crispness to lift the full body. Alcohol chimes in first with lots of warmth, spice and rose water. Cherry juice, candied fruit and faint medicinal flavors hit the middle with a small tartness within. Spice picks up middle to end, making way for the alcohol to really warm. Sweet, spicy finish. This is one of those slow- sipping nightcap brews--after a long day of holiday bustling, you'll probably need one of these.
03-08-2011 14:37:02 | More by BeerAdvocate
4/5 rDev +3.6%
A - Very clear amber with some ruby tones. Nice head that faded to a covering quickly, and low carbonation.
S - Belgian phenols and spiciness, cherry bubblegum, and a touch of red licorice.
T - Clean malt flavors up front, the dark cherry flavor then comes on but not overpowering at all, nor does it have the sourness of a lambic. It then ends with some light banana flavors.
M - Moderate body, was expecting it to be a touch lighter. Leaves a little coating on your mouth, would like a touch more carbonation to clean that up. The alcohol warmth is noticeable and nice.
D - For such a high alcohol beer this is pretty damn drinkable. Does NOT drink like a Stong Dark Ale, in fact, I don't think it is one. More of a Belgian Specially Ale. Not stellar, but certainly a good drinking brew.
11-23-2010 01:46:14 | More by steelerguy
3.78/5 rDev -2.1%
A: Redish amber with a small and quickly disappearing head
S: A fruity tone with a hint of spice
T: A strong cherry flavor with some honey taste coming through. Lots of spice on the back end. Lots of malt and very little hops. The alcohol hides alot.
M: Thick and sticky from the fruit but very smooth. Not much heat to speak of.
D: For 11% alcohol this is certainly very drinkable. A little too thick to want to drink outside of winter.
Having not read the reviews before trying this I was a bit surprised. It's a little too fruity, has a little too much spice for the fruitness, is a little too alcoholic, but has a little too little alcholic flavor showing.... yet it's a decent beer and one I'd drink again this winter.
01-13-2010 01:54:54 | More by tuckevalastin
4.3/5 rDev +11.4%
I've been hanging onto this one and can't wait to try it. Departs the bottle a wonderful golden red with hints of pink even along with a nice off white head. Sweet cherry Lifesaver aroma wafts up into my nose along with some earthy yeasty notes. Mmmm...lovely aroma.
First sip is a mix of honey/cherry sweet malty goodness along with a nice helping of barnyard/earthy yeast tones. There's a nice spiciness that's running through here too..maybe some nutmeg...I can't pick it out. A damn tasty belgian style winter brew!
Nice creamy, full mouthfeel with good carbonation. No complaints from me. Drinkability is good, as this is a tasty brew I could have a few of. Many thanks to blitheringidiot and merlin48 for hooking me up with some bottles of this!
01-08-2005 05:54:26 | More by orbitalr0x
3.4/5 rDev -11.9%
First real cold night of the year...pulled this out of the closet for a nightcap...one wiff told me that this one might definately put me out. This is last years version, so not fresh...
Appearance is a perfectly transparent caramel (not ruby red as the website says). Thin white head on the pour which disappeared to a small ring around the edge of the glass. Not the usual head of a belgian although I'm not sure if this is really true to the belgian style to begin with.
Aroma is a bit sweet with a little acidic funk to it. Alcoholic notes swirl readily from the glass. A slight cherry aroma comes around if you are really looking for it. A strong aroma, but somewhat non descript.
Again, I think the taste doesn't have much that really stands out, except for the alcohol. Taste is mainly malty with a touch of mildly sweet fruit in the background. I don't really detect any of the honey and cherries in any particular flavor. Although you can pick out the alcohol in this it isn't overwhelming, either in taste or effects of sitting on the stomach.
Mouthfeel is a little thin in my opinion, could be a bit thicker. Drinkability is okay for the high abv. The flavor or aroma doesn't really offer anything which I find particularly intriguing which would make me really desire this in the future. Maybe the flavors don't hold up for very long, I'm not sure. I have one more bottle to sample though.
11-11-2005 05:17:34 | More by blitz134
4.7/5 rDev +21.8%
Ive had this on tap, and bottles
A: Nice ruby color. Clear with thin white head
S: Banana and clove belgian yeast, Honey and cherries
T: Sweet honey and cherries, a little clovey yeast, little boozey finish
M: Light to medium body. Medium carbonation.
O: Great winter warmer Belgian beer, sweet and silky smooth, one of my favorites of the year
11-19-2011 02:22:29 | More by Outchillen
3.9/5 rDev +1%
Lucky me, I found Troegs Mad Elf in a store that lets you mix a six pack. I've heard a lot about this beer, and wanted to try it, but didnt know if I'd like it enough to buy an entire 6 pack.
Upon first whiff of this beer, you can definitely tell it is Belgian-style. The saison yeast is front & center.
The beer is a lovely reddish amber color with a good medium sized head. It leaves a small amount of lacing around the glass.
Wow, the taste. You'd be hard pressed to tell that this is an 11% beer. I would have guessed 6-7% if it hadn't said on the bottle. So obviously the strong alcohol is very well disguised. This has a very pleasant, almost mild flavor, considering it is a Belgian strong ale.
The mouthfeel is strong and outstanding as well.
I would happily have 2 more of Troegs Mad Elf (and I'm sure they'd make me even happier). I plan to pick up some more very soon.
11-11-2005 23:27:17 | More by chOAKbarrell
4.2/5 rDev +8.8%
12oz bottle from Corridor Wine and Spirits in Laurel MD. I picked up quite a few since Ive read such good things about this winter release.
Pours a beautiful clear reddish copper. Tiny head, little lacing, but staying power.
Smell is pretty perfect. Very surprised this small bottle of beer packs such a power boquet. Sweet, malty, fruit. Maybe raisin, cherry. Tough for my amateur nose to tell.
Yummy. Thin, with not much body. Does this beer need to cellar? Dried fruit maybe. Alcohol finish. The alcohol ending is really nice though. No bite really, solid alcohol flavor.
Solid carbonation. Sits nice. No real staying power, but the boquet does stay which is nice.
I voted pretty high on the drinkinability because I think this beers presentation and overall experience makes it very good to drink for a good period of time.
12-02-2006 01:50:18 | More by JasonA
3.55/5 rDev -8%
From notes: Bottle 8/19/10 consumed 12/24/10
A Christmas Eve treat? We'll see...
A - Pours a beautiful clear reddish brown with one and a half fingers of off white head. The head dissipates rather quickly.
S - A sweet cherry smell predominates, with some honey also coming through. A rather faint hoppy aroma is present as well, along with a decent amount of malt.
T - Sweet cherries up front. Some faint hop presence followed by malt and more cherries. Has some of the faintly medicinal taste on the finish that often comes with cherries.
M - Nice full mouthfell, but not overly heavy.
O - the ABV and heavy cherry presence reduce drinkability a bit, but still rather easy drinking. I saw someone taking down a 6-pack of this at the MSU-PSU football game last fall, which I definitely don't recommend, but I would have this again.
07-31-2011 03:33:59 | More by warnerry
4.22/5 rDev +9.3%
Great color - a bright/dark ruby with a thinnish tan head that left trails down the side of the glass. Definitely some cherries and alcohol joining in the aroma; the same could be said for Robitussin, but this one was thankfully different - very clean.
This one lets you know up front that it means business, as there's a pleasant, balanced warming surge o' alcohol throughout. Rather dryish, with cherries, some hints of spice, and chocolatey flavors that are more mildly tart than sweet - really interesting flavors going on. As it goes down, some of the tartness dissipates and an oak cask sort of flavor briefly appears. It gets even better as it warms, with the alcohol heading into the background even further. Medium bodied, with a more dry than sweet mouthfeel. A very tasty barleywine.
01-15-2003 10:04:07 | More by sponberg
4.4/5 rDev +14%
No dating on the bottle, but this is 2004 batch. Georgeous pouring with such a show! Everything is just shooting all over the place like fireworks! When that is done I am looking at a glass of clear amber topped with a think whitish, creamy, frothy layer. Scents of marachino cherries, so candy sweet! Bit of clove spiciness coming up from the glass. Can feel the carbination, even hear it when you swirl the glass a bit. But it is very well done IMHO, not too much at all, just a good amount without whacking you with froth. God this is just good stuff. The cherry flavor is not too strong at all, I mean, it is there, trust me. But it is not like you have a lambic in front of you. Bit of the honey sweetness left on your tongue after each sip. Very ripe bing cherries, more like dried bings actually, or dried cranberries, where you get that candied sweetnes from the fruit. Some port in the aftertaste. The sweetnes is not cloying, just very nice. The alcohol is very well hidden, can't taste the percentage in this, it is so nicely drinkable. Just another lovely one from the brothers.
Fun one in the case splitting extravaganza with Stingo, BrewAngel, and The BlitheringIdiot.
01-11-2005 02:06:17 | More by shapudding
4.85/5 rDev +25.6%
First off, I have to send out a huge thank you to Froggyfrog for providing this beer in trade. Not only did he give me a bottle of the 2007 Mad Elf, but he threw in a 2006 bottle as well.
What a great vertical tasting. This beer really benefits from a year of aging. My brother and I opened both bottles at the same time and were able to taste the difference immediately. We tasted the 2006 bottle first, and the complexity of flavor was amazing. It was hard to identify the cherries and honey flavors that are mentioned on the bottle, but we really thought it was a fantastic beer. When we tried the 2007 bottle, we were able to identify the flavors more easily, and the alcohol was much more evident, but it was still great.
This beer goes from great to fantastic in twelve months.
01-17-2008 06:13:13 | More by Svejk
Tröegs Mad Elf from Tröegs Brewing Company
87 out of 100 based on 2,954 ratings.