Gritty McDuff's Black Fly Stout - Gritty McDuff's Brewing Company
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 336 | Reviews: 190 | Display Reviews Only:
Reviews by luvND:
3.28/5 rDev -15%
P: 12 oz bottle
A: I thought the review before mine a fluke, but I had a HUGE head as well despite gentle pour. Entire case is like this. Over half the glass is foam and it takes quite a while to settle. Other than that, color is black.
S: Roasty, coffee. Nice.
T: Malty and roasted up front. Not much in the hop dept. Overall, good but average.
M: Very light, watery.
D: Due to above, very drinkable, except that it would take me hours to drink a few waiting for all the heads to die down. Pour 2 at once?
Notes: Saw this case and got excited. Had it on tap years ago at the brewery while in Maine. This bottle does not do the tap version justice. As far as the excessive head, ? problem at the brewery?
08-15-2008 21:06:23 | More by luvND
More User Reviews:
3.9/5 rDev +1%
My wife actually drank this while there in Portland and I tasted a little o it and here is what I got from it.Pours a deep black with red highlights showing thru a deep almond colored light creamy head.I noticed somebitterness in the aroma with some dark roast coffee,flavor is of unsweetened chocolate and some earthiness with that bitterness I got in the aroma popping up in the finish.All in all seemed to be a pretty solid stout.
11-14-2003 23:16:14 | More by oberon
3.38/5 rDev -12.4%
Appearance: Wonderful deep brown, almost black color with very little light penetrating. Poured from a bottle, I got very little head at all & what head there was disappeared very quickly which surprised me for a stout. Also, it was visibly highly carbonated which also surprised me for a stout.
Smell: Nice, subtle coffee-like aroma. Slightly roasted malt smell in the background.
Taste: Good roasty, smoky flavor with slight coffee hints. A bit on the watery side compared to other stouts in the class, but ok. Flavor lingers just long enough & ends fairly crisp. Bitter hop finish balances roasty, smoky flavor.
Mouthfeel: Thin, watery, crisp & dry. Not as much body as I would like in a stout. The high carbonation also makes for a slightly different mouthfeel than with other stouts.
Drinkability: This is fairly drinkable as it is not as heavy & rich as some other stouts. The high carbonation also lends to its drinkability, but wasn't really what I expected from a stout.
Comments: This was an average stout, but not my favorite. The high carbonation & thin, watery body makes for a slightly different twist on a regular stout. I did like the flavor & drinkability, but would choose a smoother, less carbonated stout in the future if looking for a beer in this style.
03-16-2006 15:55:26 | More by JMD71
3.03/5 rDev -21.5%
Note: This is brew from last year that has been in my fridge for quite a while. Might be past its prime.
Pours a light black, little to no head. Not much carbonation.
Smells a roasted malt
Roasted malt, dry buscuit. Drying finish. No real bite. might be something unnatural left.
Sits. Just sits, no real action out side of roasted dry malt.
Nothing special. Wont actively seek this brew again.
10-11-2008 17:54:36 | More by JasonA
3.15/5 rDev -18.4%
This was a black, black color with a thick coffee-colored head. It had a predominately coffee aroma, with a little bit of roasted grain. Taste was all coffee, but maybe a little chocolate snuck in. I thought it was a little thin in the mouthfeel department, but still very drinkable. If you like stout, you'll like this beer. If you're not a big stout fan, forget it.
06-21-2006 17:40:29 | More by lordofthewiens
4.5/5 rDev +16.6%
Presentation: 12 oz brown long neck twist bottle with a “best enjoyed before” freshness date clearly notched.
Appearance: Opaque black coloured brew with a big towering head after a hard pouring then very slowly settling into a thin tiny bubbled light brown lace, this is one of those heads that leaves rings all the way down the glass.
Smell: Brownies and fudge come to mind off the first whiff, underlying black currant fruitiness with a laid back alcohol. Smooth and clean to the nose.
Taste: Creamy smooth mouth feel, moderate carbonation and a medium to full malt body. First is a rush of mild roasted malt and subdued black currant fruitiness, then the roasted kicks things up a notch by unleashing an even burnt charcoal bitterness. Malt sweetness holds this brew together in the beginning then the dryness sets in to make the mouth beg for more. Hops are a tad bitter and pungent with a quick snappy hop oil twang in the back ground. Touch of acrid to the roasted character to pleasantly pucker the palate for a brief moment, lingering suggestions of espresso and vague chocolate flavour make up the end.
Notes: One of the top stouts brewed in the US, very well balanced and is even more heavenly on nitro-tap. Certainly a stout lovers stout.
03-21-2002 16:58:58 | More by Jason
3.98/5 rDev +3.1%
On tap at Beale Street Barbeque, in Bath, Maine, on 7/21/04, and enjoyed with a pulled pork sandwich. This glass arrives with an opaque, deep and dark body, with a large, tan head that lasts forever. Profuse, patches of lace decorate the glass.
Aroma begins with burnt, roasted, coffee, with hints of chocolate and grassy hops in the background.
Mouthfeel is rich and coating, but is medium bodied, lighter than I was expecting.
Taste features lots of roasted malts, plenty of coffee flavor here. Very smooth and enjoyable, but not very complex. Grassy hops provide a nice dryness. Nice, bitter coffee finish.
Smooth and tasty, with very good drinkability. A must try, American dry stout.
07-28-2004 11:01:00 | More by merlin48
3.7/5 rDev -4.1%
Appearance: huge head, dark black color
Smell:burnt malt, wood, expresso
Taste: burnt malt, black coffee, and dark chocolate
Mouthfeel: dry, almost chalky, medium heavy body
Drinkability: I could have a couple of these again. It is very dry and solid.
03-31-2009 03:43:38 | More by tigg924
3.85/5 rDev -0.3%
Pours with a nice khaki colored head, moderate lacing. Inky black color.
Smoky in the nose, and some underlying earthyness.
Roasted barley up front, even tastes a bit like oats. Follows up with a bitter expresso finish.
Mouthfeel is pretty nice, but I would prefer a bit more body/creaminess. I can imagine this being great on nitro.
Pretty solid overall and I'm glad I picked it up.
05-28-2012 01:37:03 | More by RTEdmunds
3.9/5 rDev +1%
Smells deep and earthy, as if smelling fresh peat moss, with additional heavy emphasis on chocolate malts, and the wholesome aroma of spent grain bread.
The darker flavors are the first on the tongue, and dominate most of the mouthful, bringing notes of burnt grains and chocolate malts, tobacco, dark toffees, black coffee, caramelized brown sugar, and dark fruit esters. The tobacco and burnt-black grains came on stronger near the end of the mouthful for me, and stuck around on my soft palate for quite awhile after I'd swallowed. Hops add a nice background bitter fuzz, but manage to avoid the grapefruity, floral notes that can come along with that--notes which would be unwelcome in a beer such as this. I was surprised, however, that the brew lacked the viscosity that I'd expected, given the massive number of ingredients, and the mouthfeel came across as even thinner than a soda. This was slightly unsatisfying, but the fullness of the flavors went a long way towards making up for it.
08-13-2011 19:23:49 | More by jondeelee
4.25/5 rDev +10.1%
It's really black. Light doesn't get through at all. Big, fat, lumpy, brown, foamy head. Starts out an inch high and settles out a bit, but never really leaves. The inside of the glass is coated as the head slides down. Aroma is full of different smells - roasted malt, chocolate, bits of coffee and raisin, and some hops. Smooth and creamy mouthfeel, moderate to low carbonation. Bitter chocolate and coffee flavor, roasted malt, and raisin. Bitter tingly aftertaste sits in the roof of my mouth. Flavor gets bigger and rounder with each sip. Great stuff.
07-19-2003 01:18:18 | More by far333
4.22/5 rDev +9.3%
Pours jet black with a beautiful tan/espresso colored head. Great retention and lacing. Smells of dark malts, coffe, chocolate, all the good stuff. The taste just envelopes your palate. Dark malts, followed by slightly dry malt, no bitter finish, just wonderful. Mouthfeel is what you'd expect from a stout, thick and hearty. Highly drinkable. The draught version is definitely superior to the bottle IMHO. A must drink brew when you can get some.
08-03-2003 18:23:57 | More by yankeeheel
4.03/5 rDev +4.4%
Gritty McDuff's Black Fly Stout is a very enjoyable version of an Irish Dry Stout. I must confess, that initially, I was not enthralled from my first exposure. However, this is worthy of giving a go. As subsequent samplings (perhaps unintentional aging is a factor here). It pours a nice dark color with a monster sized head. The smell is malty. The taste is a very nice balance of sweet malt and slight burnt coffee bittering. It has a nice dry mouthfeel indeed. A nicely drinkable stout.
10-12-2006 23:20:08 | More by BadBadger
3.73/5 rDev -3.4%
Pours a huge chunky mocha head over a black-as-night body. I had trouble getting this into the glass due to the amount of carbonation and the expanding head. Once I did, it had decent head retention and lace. Aromas of coffee and roasted maltfairly clean. Crisp in the mouth, with a mineral/cola like character. Flavors of roasted grain, a bit of vinous fruit and a light coffee presence. Medium-full bodied, a tad on the lean side for a stout. True to style, it's drying.
This beer is definitely superior on draught. This was one of my favorites at the pub when living ME in the 90s, but from the bottle it didnt have the same complexity of flavor or creamy mouthfeel from the nitro. The abundance of carbonation may have really thrown things off, but his is still a tasty dry stout. Certainly more complex than the most common Irish versions of the sample I've tried. I'll try to review it on draught the next time I'm in ME.
12-17-2005 23:43:28 | More by Shovelbum
4.1/5 rDev +6.2%
Nitro at Bukowski’s in Boston.
Pours black with dark brown highlights and a thick off-white head that leaves solid lacing.
Smells of muted roasted malts with good amounts of dark chocolate and hints of smooth coffee. Also present are slight amounts of leafy hops.
Tastes similar to how it smells. Smooth roasted malts up front are joined quickly by semi-sweet chocolate flavors. Midway through very light amounts of coffee and lighter still hints of char come into play, fading out into a moderately bitter ending. Mouthfeel is good, with smooth carbonation.
Overall I enjoyed this beer and thought it was well done, although I think it would benefit from CO2 as opposed to nitrogen. Still, it’s worth a shot however you find it.
08-14-2011 20:55:11 | More by glid02
4.58/5 rDev +18.7%
Enjoyed at the Great Lost Bear in Portland.
A- jet black with a coffee head and tons of lacing the coats the glass with every pull.
S- roasted malts through the nose , very nice
T- roasted malts with some charred hops with a slightly bitter finish
M- creamy and balanced with just the right amount of carbination
D- the best irish dry stout I have tasted to date and one I will have again and again
05-29-2007 13:49:03 | More by mcarroll10177
4.5/5 rDev +16.6%
This is a very nice full bodied stout with a thick head when poured. It has a dark color with a nice balance of malt and hops. The taste is rich and full, rich taste with a hint of sweetness and cocoa. I could make this a regular in my refrigerator. A very nice stout.
11-08-2008 22:23:24 | More by DVTO2
Gritty McDuff's Black Fly Stout from Gritty McDuff's Brewing Company
87 out of 100 based on 336 ratings.