Freedom Of '78 - Short's Brewing Company
Displayed for educational use only; do not reuse.
Ratings: 383 | Reviews: 119 | Display Reviews Only:
4.45/5 rDev +9.1%
A - body is a very nice orange color, hard to see through, with a sizable frothy white head.
S - You can smell the guava from feet away. That's complimented nicely by citrus and piney hops.
T - strong hops up front, mostly grapefruit, and then a touch of guava sweetness on the back. bitterness lingers in the aftertaste. Really well balanced, nothing too fancy.
M - a good body, not hugely robust, but not thin, somewhere in the middle. It's hard to keep this in my mouth long enough to figure it out. I wouldn't call it creamy, but its good.
D - I think this is crazy drinkable. It tastes great, and isn't too big or anything.
01-16-2011 19:09:13 | More by ColdPoncho
3.23/5 rDev -20.8%
Picked up a bottle of this while visiting Northern Michigan. I'm always interested in collaborations.
Poured out into a pint glass. It's mostly clear orange/yellow. Medium sized off-white head. Visible carbonation.
The nose is a wonderful fruity hop blast. The guava really comes through. Pure and tropical. Pine resin.
Taste is a bit awkward. While the tropical/hops combo worked very well on the nose, it's a bit weird on the palate. Strong grassy hops and sticky sour guava mingle tenuously. Interesting, but not really successful.
Solid mouthfeel, but I just can't get over the weird intersecting flavors. I don't think guava was meant for beer.
01-13-2011 18:38:30 | More by shivtim
4.05/5 rDev -0.7%
12oz bottle drank in my Orval glas...A clear gold, decent carbonation...Sweet aroma of pineapple, mango, a touch of the guava, less than the Half acre...Taste starts off like fruit juice, acidic, a bite, and finally a little hops. The more you drink the hops come through. Not the best ipa but decent and worth a try.
01-13-2011 17:21:06 | More by jrallen34
3.6/5 rDev -11.8%
Thanks to gnemesis for filling my mailbox with shorts beers this evening. This was my second taste from the box.
a-Poured a foggy orange with a frothy white head that left milkshake-like trails on the glass.
s-Very bittery hops. Sweet guava, almost smells like papaya juice. Very grapefruit forward too, super tart.
t-Overly bittered hop flavor. Drinkable but pretty intense. Candied guava and grapefruit is there, but mostly leads with the hops. I like a bit more balance.
m/d-Cooling, but extremely bitter. Nice carbonation and not too thick. Rich in flavor, easy to drink. I would prefer a bit less bitterness but enjoyable.
01-13-2011 03:05:24 | More by cosmicevan
4.18/5 rDev +2.5%
Bottle poured into a Duvel tulip.
A- A normal pour left a 1-finger, off-white head that drops to a bubbly, thin film a little too quickly. The body is a hazed, golden-peach color with light carbonation. There are great sticky spots left all over the glass. The head development and retention is my only concern on this one.
S- Throughout I picked up a lot of tropical fruit mixed with lighter, earthy hops. It isn't overly complex, but interesting all the same.
T- Quite interesting. Grapefruit hops hit me up front, tropical fruits came in through the middle, and more hops clean up and dry (bone dry really) the finish. Pleasantly sweet, grainy (cereal-like) malts come out a little later. Hopping also has an herbal flavor at points.
M- It's quite clean compared to the visual with moderate viscosity. Lightly carbonated with a solid tingle from the significant hops.
D- Quite good, especially for a fruited beer. Hops balance the sweet flavors to make this more than a one-and-done (though not a session drinker). It's definitely something I'd suggest to a friend looking for a unique IPA.
01-09-2011 21:43:58 | More by GRPunk
3.75/5 rDev -8.1%
Huge thanks to browna71 (Alex) for a sixer of this fine brew in a recent trade! 12oz bottle poured into a chalice.
Pours a faintly hazy dark copper/orange with a thin half-finger width white head on top. Some spotty lace clings to the glass. The nose is bursting with scents of fresh-squeezed oranges, pineapple, guava. Slightly peppery, with a faint alcohol singe on the back end.
Good full-bodied IPA with plenty of carbonation zip. There's plenty of bitter hops to go around with this beer, but my overall impression is pepper and spices. I expected more of a fruity-tasting IPA, but this one is herbal, earthy, and spicy. Part of this reminds me of Saison Du BUFF (any version) with the herbal notes, but it is definitively an IPA. Some citrus sweetness rounds it out, and there's a crisp bitter finish. As far as drinkability is concerned, the spiciness may wear on me after awhile, but it is a pleasure to sip one. A good bitter beer that will cure my hop-fix any day.
01-07-2011 19:47:32 | More by Onenote81
4/5 rDev -2%
I was totally unaware that Short's bottled a version of this as well - Thanks to Erik for sending me one of these! Poured into pint glass, color is a slightly hazy apricot golden with a one finger white head that leaves a good amount of lacing. Smell is a lot different from the Half Acre version - much spicier, lots of fruity hops, bread dough, and a slight malt sweetness in the background. Taste is similar, but much fruitier. Guava stands out in a big way, tropical fruit hops, bread crust maltiness, bitter aftertaste. Mouthfeel is medium bodied with a medium/light carbonation, slightly coating and semi dry. Overall a great beer. I prefer the half acre version to this, but it is always fun to taste the regional differences in ingredients. Hopefully each brewery will brew this again next time Ween is in town.
01-06-2011 02:26:36 | More by nkersten
3.93/5 rDev -3.7%
A- poured a hazy copper color with a nice frothy white head. medium lacing.
S- grapefruit hops dominate. what an ipa should be. not too crazy or over the top but good.
T- the bitterness is what an american ipa should be. the grapefruit hops come out alil but more of some piney notes hit ya unlike the smell. the guava doesn't hit you at first but once you drink this brew day after day the guava tends to be abit much.
M- medium bodied. good carbonation.
D- i hope my beer store has more of this!! once again tho.. great brew but after awhile the guava starts getting to you.
Overall- a solid ipa built for a guava lover.
01-03-2011 07:12:30 | More by claminat420
4.33/5 rDev +6.1%
A_Pours amber/gold in body with a frothy bone white head. Splotches of lacing cling to the glass.
S_Pungent hops,grapefruit and the guava is pretty noticeable.
T_Same as nose. Good combination of bitter and sweet. The guava is fairly easy to pick up and pairs well with pine and citrus flavors of the hops. Overall pretty damn hoppy.
M_Mouthfeel is a little thin,slick and sticky on the lips.
D_Very enjoyable. I've been finishing these fairly quickly.
01-03-2011 03:52:46 | More by nickadams2
4.08/5 rDev 0%
Pours a peachy light amber color without much of a head at all. What little head this beer possesses is pure white. This brew leaves a tiny amount of lace, but nothing too spectacular.
The aroma is super fruity with tons of tropical notes. It smells like grapefruit and pine mixed with what I am assuming is guava and some sugary malt. This beer has an amazingly fresh aroma to it and while it is familiar, it is also quite unique.
The flavor is also very potent and fresh. Grapefruit, orange, pine, tropical fruit and guava mix together to make a very tart explosion of acidic flavors. The malt has a bit of a caramel character to it, but is mostly just sweet. My biggest complaint with this beer is that it seems a bit too bitter and the bitterness manifests itself in a very harsh and sharp matter.
The body is medium and the mouthfeel is a bit on the sticky-icky side. It finishes so dry and tart acidic fruits linger long on my palate. This is perhaps contributed to from the very low carbonation.
I think this would be a bit more drinkable if it was a little less bitter, or the bitterness was a bit smoother. Don't get me wrong, this is a pretty tasty beer, but for me it misses the mark in a couple places. Definitely worth trying out.
01-03-2011 01:52:45 | More by zoso1967
4.18/5 rDev +2.5%
A- Pours a slightly hazy golden amber color with a fairly thin white head. Head has good retention, forms a layer of bubbles on the top and leaves some spotty lacing.
S- The aroma of this beer is like no other IPA. Tons of tropical fruits, a bit of pine and caramel malts too. The guava is pretty crazy smelling and outstanding.
T- Again this is completly different than most IPAs. Tropical fruits are no joke and up in your face. A bit of pine and a good malt back bone. There also seems to be some sort of spice here too that I can't make out. Very good and different at the same time.
M- Medium in body and carbonation.
D- This is a very interesting brew and incredibly easy to drink.
01-02-2011 05:32:48 | More by nrbw23
4.43/5 rDev +8.6%
A- An ever so slightly hazy bright orange liquid with a creamy white head that has some pretty good retention.
S- Guava, honey, pine, citrus, and mint. Very aromatic. Stunning.
T- Guava, pine, mint, and some citrus. There is enough sweetness to keep the bitterness from becoming overbearing. Unique and very tasty.
M- The body has some bite to it, both from the bitterness and carbonation. The finish is a tad oily and mostly dry.
D- A delicious take on an IPA. Very enjoyable.
01-01-2011 05:41:39 | More by david131
4.43/5 rDev +8.6%
Served in Stone IPA glass- thanks kzoobrew for the chance to try the other version.
Appearance- Slightly cloudy copper, 3 fingers of off-white head. Great lacing.
Aroma- Wow the guava just pops with a lovely sweetness. The hops are there too but that fruit is front and center.
Taste- Fruit juice with a slightly bitter finish. The guava really is the centerpiece here (as it should be), and you can almost feel the rind in your mouth. There is some taste here that is reminding me of something I drank as a kid, can't put my finger on it though.
Mouth- Nice. Good carbonation not too thick or thin.
Drink- I mean seriously you can put this down like fruit juice. I feel like they hit exactly what they wanted to here and I am not complaining. I can't find my notes on the Half Acre version but I am certain that I like this one better.
12-30-2010 04:14:59 | More by cadaugherty
4.45/5 rDev +9.1%
Pours a slightly cloudy golden pee color not to different from a macro american pilsner with a small to non existant head and a good lacing all the way down...
It smells of the guava and mellon like sugars, delicious to me, with a tinge of really sweet floral hop...
god, it doesn't taste like anything I have ever had, the guava really comes through in the beginning with a really rich sweetness then as you swallow the hop comes through and dries out the palate and leaves a really nice and dry floral IPA taste in your mouth, all and all the beer is very well balanced and interesting to drink, an adventure in every sip...
It has a light carbonation that isn't abrasive and is crisp which really adds to the flavor and over all drink of the beer but the consistency is like tonic so a little thin for me...
It drinks well and is a very intriguing one of my more preferred fruit beers thus far.
12-29-2010 20:27:29 | More by masey222
4.43/5 rDev +8.6%
Bottle poured into a pint glass. This is a golden copper color with a decent half inch of head. Smell is a nice mix of citrus-hops and guava, making for an interesting balance. Taste is crisp mix of hops and guava, well balanced between the bitterness of the hops and sweetness of the guava. This is like a tropical take on an IPA, something you can imagine sipping outside in the summer. Excellent drinkability.
12-27-2010 00:13:48 | More by webmanspidey
3.13/5 rDev -23.3%
Pours a semi-cloudy dirty gold color with a loose and settled 1/4" off-white head. Even though I can see through the liquid, there is no visible uprising carbonation whatsoever. Lots of smattered splotches of sticky lace all the way down.
Evenly balanced tropical fruits are very up front. Because I'm not acquainted with the precise smell of Guava, and this IPA is made with pure guava, I'll conceed that it smells exactly like guava. This fruitiness, mixed with the earthy prevailing hoppy notes, eminates a sensual female odor.
A funky, fruity and hoppy combination greets the palate with a white peppery lining. An interesting salty undercurrent finishes this peculilar and flavorful experience. Another gulp or two and I perceive more of a pronounced salt and pepper backdrop. This is a very perplexing melding of flavors here.
Mouthfeel is almost medium bodied with a cask-like texture. Not a lot of carbonation, but what's there is prickly and welcomed.
Drinkability is okay. I'm trying to keep an open mind while drinking this, but mind is somewhat reeling from these odd and quirky flavors.
To say Shorts is 'at it again' is an understatement. I get the fruit and hop combo, but this salt and pepper element is downright interesting. I can't say I'd run out and buy more, but I would try it on tap. The smell on this thing is fun and funky. Good job on an interesting fruity tweak on an American IPA.
12-26-2010 22:09:57 | More by malty
4.43/5 rDev +8.6%
Pours a golden, almost light amber, with a white sticky head that laces down the glass. There is just a hint of haze peering through it. The smell is wonderful..tropical guava, pineapple, grapefruit and floral hops dominate. Taste is hop forward with grapefruit first untill the guava sweetens midway followed by pine. The malt bill is present but in the background nicely. Mouthfeel is fine with a dry finish. Very refreshing and drinkable.
12-26-2010 21:51:18 | More by sculls65
4.3/5 rDev +5.4%
This review is going to be largely lifted from my review Half Acre version, with only minor changes to highlight differences. Served in a Goose Island taster pint glass.
A - Pours with a finger and a half of soapy white foam that settles to a thin cap and leaves spotty lace. Body is a lightly hazed transparent golden color.
S - I find the Short's version to have far more grapefruit and citrus character. The guava is more of a supporting flavor that imparts a bit of fruity muskiness. There's a bit of light sugary malt in the periphery.
T - Tastes like guava juice. No, really. Starts with fruit juice flavors, and ends like juice - slightly bitter and acetic. As I drink more, I get some hop flavor coming through with citrus zest, but there's almost negligible malt character - perhaps a touch of sugar in the finish as it warms up. Strangely compelling.
M - Very juicy, with low carbonation, and a sticky finish. Could use a bit more dryness.
D - Absolutely crushable. I went through my 6oz in under five minutes. Hope Short's makes this in the summer, or Half Acre puts it into cans, as it's really refreshing. I think the Short's version is a mild improvement - I'm guessing they learned from Half Acre's attempt and subsequent challenges.
12-26-2010 18:08:34 | More by MasterSki
4.15/5 rDev +1.7%
A - Kind of a darker amber hue with a decent head.
S - I just got back from Costa Rica. This beer smells like a Costa Rican breakfast. The guava is so prominent, which a back of of earthy hops. This smell is amazing and unique.
T - It isn't much of a let down, but it can't live up to the smell. The guava is still there, but it not as up front as in the nose. It imparts a bit of sweetness, but not a sweet beer by any means. The middle and back are hops, with the bitter and pine expected.
M - Not a full mouthfeel and finishes a tad dry. Would have wanted a bit more fullness.
D - Yes. More. Though with the abv, which is nicely hidden, the bad idea pants could be put on a little early in the evening.
12-25-2010 01:28:31 | More by decadance
4.58/5 rDev +12.3%
Poured from a 12oz bottle on 12/23/10
Appearance - fantastic copper color, white head, and some nice lacing on the glass
Smell - this is where this beer really stood out for me, awesome scent of tropical fruit, you can really smell the guava, and piney hops.
Taste - this is a very unique IPA, tropical fruits shine through with an almost pine like aftertaste and dry finish, very tasty indeed, and unlike any IPA I have had before.
Mouthfeel - fantastic bubbles that compliment the style.
Drinkability - I could easily drink many of these in one session, the tropical fruit and hops are not overly ruinous on the pallete.
Overall this is a truly unique take on the style, and something I hope these breweries continue to brew. Truly great collaboration.
12-24-2010 17:19:57 | More by pmoore311
4.08/5 rDev 0%
12oz. bottle poured into an imperial pint.
(A)- Pours a clear orange color that produced a small off-white head with decent retention. Minimal lacing.
(S)- Wow, a huge burst of tropical citrus. That guava is really evident; bringing with it a peach, pineapple, and lime accent. Some minimal pine in there too. What a fresh and vibrant aroma. Unique for the style.
(T)- Very similar to the smell, only with more malts showing themselves in the form of light caramel. Very piney with pine-needle all over the place. The citrus takes a backseat to all this.
(M)- A good carbonation level and balance. Has a sharp dry piney bitterness, but is counterbalanced well with a good malty backbone and tropical citrus.
(D)- I always enjoy how Shorts pushes the envelope on what you can expect from a beer style. This is no different. A refreshing take on an overproduced style.
12-23-2010 02:48:39 | More by sweemzander
4.53/5 rDev +11%
Just received fresh from regular trading partner erikkoppin. Thanks Erik, had the Half Acre version beyond excited for the Short's version. Love everything they do let's see how this one is...
A- A very sexy and appealing light amber color with a pale golden hue. Simply spectacular looking, but is missing an expected head. It's a very thin white head that has almost no fluff to it. Even so I can hardly wait to dive in.
S- Wow! God Damn I love the smell of this one it's simply amazing. It gives off a very sweet aroma of guava, kiwi and strawberry. It's making me drool and reminds me of a mild summer day on a beach. The tropical aromas have transported me. As it warms I am getting more and more strawberry, guava, kiwi and fruit skins with a light lemon rind followed by some subtle piney hops and a touch of caramel malt. Unbelievable smelling concoction.
T- An explosion of guava is spectacular and loved the whole way through. It's an undeniable tropical take and Short's has nailed it. The guava is right in your face and has a great sweetness reminiscent of succulent strawberries and kiwi fruits. At the finish I pick up a great bitter hop taste that is piney and detectable. After some warming I get a touch of caramel sweetness that melds with the tropical/citrus and piney hops to create a knock out beer from the masters of fruit.
M- Has a nice stickiness to it and and a great all around coating that isn't syrupy, but smooth. A great tongue sitter that lets you taste all of the nuances of this one. Love the feel and it has a nice faint tingle, but I would have liked a little more it's a little on the light side.
D- Absofuckinglutely! It's astonishingly smooth and light enough to session. The abv is masterfully hidden and gives off no heat. All day and night and twice on Sunday.
A home run in my opinion from a very under rated brewery that catches shit for no reason. They brew some killer beers and continue to push the envelope each time they bottle a new one. Come on agave wheat 12ozs! Thanks again Erik.
12-23-2010 00:47:34 | More by StormKing47
4.15/5 rDev +1.7%
A nice transparent copper tone with a pure white big bubbled head. A tiny ring of sediment around the bottom of the bottle. Smell is so sweet and bitter, full of hop and guava aroma. The taste is very much the same hops up front with a growing guava aftertaste leaving the flavor of fruit mentos on the taste buds. A very tangy bitter citrus bite to it that seems to be a little overpowering and taste like lemon peels. I like the way this ale disperses along my palate it seems to mellow itself out. A great ale that could use a little less citrus bite.
12-22-2010 06:38:27 | More by JordanEllwanger
4.33/5 rDev +6.1%
poured into my duvel tulip
appearance - golden orange with mild to moderate visible carbonation, a head of about a finger and a half
smell - strong citrus fruit up front with a slight hoppy aroma at the end
taste - starts off with a nice sweet fruity flavor similar to kiwi(ill assume this is the guava because i havnt had guava nectar without vodka in it) then it moves into a mixture of bitter hops and sweet citrus fruit, finishes with citrus kick and a nice bitter hop flavor that lingers
mouthfeel - thin, not as water but far thinner than i had anticipated, carbonation lightens this up a bit, very drinkable but i would have liked mine a bit thicker
drinkability - very easy to drink, nice sweet citrus, the bitter hoppy finish leaves you wanting more, would be very nice on a hot summer day, if this was released as a year round or summer offering it may replace soft parade as my go to shorts summer beer
over all this is a pretty decent brew, better than shorts year round offerings, as stated if re released i would buy it again
12-22-2010 05:44:30 | More by SeaUrchin
4.3/5 rDev +5.4%
The short's version...poured from a 12 ounce bottle into a snifter
A: I would have liked a little more head on this beer and a little better retention. The beer is light amber in color and has a white ½ finger head.
S: There's not too much to the smell here. I get a little bit of kiwi and some other piney hops.
T: The guava in this beer actually comes through in the citrus hop taste better than I had expected it to. The bitterness at the finish of this beer is very nicely balanced and gives it a crisp clean finish.
M: Near perfect for this style. This beer sits on the tongue nicely and has a perfect viscosity. The beer also has a perfectly balanced aftertaste.
D: I thought this was a very easy drinking, good tasting IPA. I'm really glad it comes in 6 packs of 12 ounce bottles.
12-21-2010 02:39:58 | More by glazeman
Freedom Of '78 from Short's Brewing Company
91 out of 100 based on 383 ratings.