These lists come up often, but I recently had a porter that shook my current list. A friend brought me a porter from Mayflower Brewing, and holy shit. lots of bitter powdered chocolate and amazingness. I had to rethink my best porter list (which is that style I hold close). 1) Edmund Fitzgerald (it would take more than God to dethrone this) 2) Mayflower Porter 3) Founders Porter 4) Thirsty Dog Old Leghumper 5) Highland Oatmeal Porter 6) Slumbrew Square Porter 7) Deschutes Black Butte Im wondering If im crazy or whatnot.