I am a huge fan of Paradox Jura. I did a side by side with regular BCBS and everyone who was at the tasting took Paradox Jura over BCBS. As for other brewdog beers - hit or miss. I thought Anarchist Alchemist was awful (OP - I still have a bottle if you want to trade for it) but thought their Bitch Please Islay was an amazing beer. Their core range is rather boring, as is GI's. I wouldn't say there is a winner. I think they are both decent breweries that have some great beers and some not so great ones as well. I think brewdog does push the marketing a bit though. Sometimes comical, sometimes annoying.