1. Looking to trade some beers? Check out How to Get Started with Beer Trading.
Dismiss Notice
Save $5 when you subscribe to 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine by selecting auto-renew.

Subscribe now →
Dismiss Notice
Join Our Email List →

And we'll send you the latest updates and offers from BeerAdvocate, because knowing is half the battle.
Dismiss Notice

Pre-order your Respect Beer "Hipster" Hoodie today!

Plus: Free shipping (US only) on orders of $25 or more until 12/18/15. Just select "Free Shipping" at checkout.

Shop now →

"Extras" poll

Discussion in 'Beer Trading Talk & Help' started by cavedave, Aug 7, 2012.


What do you send as extra

  1. I always send extras, average more than two bottles

    155 vote(s)
  2. I always send extras, average one or two bottles

    89 vote(s)
  3. I always send extras but the quantity varies greatly

    80 vote(s)
  4. I sometimes send extras, average one or two bottles

    13 vote(s)
  5. I sometimes send extras but the quantity varies greatly

    5 vote(s)
  6. I don't usually send extras

    3 vote(s)
  7. I never send extras

    1 vote(s)
  1. cavedave

    cavedave Poobah (1,060) New York Mar 12, 2009 Verified

    I always send extras, usually two or more bottles, but sometimes only one, or sometimes many. I have gotten extras in over 90% of the trades I have made, they vary from one bottle to as many as six bottles. Extras are just that, extra, and if I don't receive it is no big deal, but I admit sometimes I have been stupidly outdone with extras in a trade, and in other trades I have sent a few good'uns and received none.

    Now that we can poll, I thought this oft-covered topic might be ripe for polling.

    What are your experiences and thoughts?
    OtisCampbell likes this.
  2. franklinn

    franklinn Savant (440) Vermont May 29, 2012

    I only didn't send an extra on my first two trades, but since then I've always included some. The number varies greatly, based on what I have at home/readily available and the size and scope of the trade
  3. ehammond1

    ehammond1 Champion (790) Jul 4, 2008

    As far as I remember, the only time I didn't send extras was when I was sending 12 agreed-upon bottles in a 12-bottle shipper, and we explicitly increased the size of the trade to fill the shipper.
    FUNKPhD and FosterJM like this.
  4. kzoobrew

    kzoobrew Champion (860) Michigan May 8, 2006

    I always send extras though how many largely depends on who I send to and the trade that was worked out. If it is one of my regular trading partners in a neighboring state which happens to share a lot of distribution I throw in what I can but is may be minimal due to options. Someone outside of the distribution of my locals with a lot of wants I can hit is in for a fair number of extras. If I am sending a rather large box I will send what extras I can but am not going overboard due to safety and financial concerns. If I am trading just a sixer I have often included 6+ extras to make the box worth shipping.
    FosterJM likes this.
  5. FosterJM

    FosterJM Champion (870) California Nov 16, 2009 Verified

    All varies really. Depending on rapport with the person, depending on the wants I can hit, depending on size of the original trade. Always generally more than 2 though. I just sent a 6 pk shipper and I included 4 extas. Was only a trade for 1 beer and a glass. Seems fair to me. Sent 2 22oz, 1 16oz can and a 12oz IPA, not in his distro area.

    ehammond1 likes this.
  6. MaxSpang

    MaxSpang Advocate (515) Ohio Jan 28, 2011

    The more the merrier. I throw in at least 3 bottles for most of my trades, but if it's a regular trading partner then I'll throw in all kinds of crap.
  7. NiceFly

    NiceFly Savant (395) Tajikistan Dec 22, 2011

    I do not trade much, but when I do it is an event for me.

    I like to send a box that the receiver is really happy with when the open it. Since my cellar is as deep as a rain puddle that means a bunch of extras.

    Not that is should be a contest, but I like to send better than I get. Otherwise I get pissed off and some of you have really pissed me off in a past life;).
    ehammond1 likes this.
  8. i usually send extras i can and i include stuff from my area like candies
  9. Ungertaker

    Ungertaker Advocate (540) Minnesota Apr 30, 2010 Verified

    I didn't include extras on my first trade (but shipped them ten months after). Since then, I have always included a couple. Regular partners seem to get borderline ridiculous with the extras we end up including (I always shoot for wants in the extras with them).
  10. Pahn

    Pahn Champion (850) New York Dec 2, 2009 Verified

    if it's a small trade i might send 1~2 extras, but usually more.

    i'm not sure what i'd do if i was trading lots of main trade bottles... but it's also unlikely that i'd do that, since most of my trades are built around 1 particular beer on 1 side of the trade.

    at the moment, most of my trades are like, "i'll send an X and some other stuff, you send some stuff," so the idea of something being 'extra' is a bit of a stretch anyway.
    libbey and MarkIntihar like this.
  11. RC0032

    RC0032 Aficionado (240) Illinois Mar 10, 2009 Verified

    Is it that time of the month again? An extra thread!! Ya!!!!!
  12. I do international trades, so it is usually agreed to not send extras. If shipping cost was not an issue however, I would always through in a few nice extras!
    mattsander likes this.
  13. match1112

    match1112 Initiate (0) Illinois Mar 2, 2011

    The amount of extras I send depends on the person I'm trading with and the box I have on hand to ship in. I don't like to pay to ship air so I pack it full of beer. Also I don't always have access to heavily sought after beers so I try to kill them with quantity.
  14. dvelcich

    dvelcich Savant (360) Illinois Feb 6, 2008

    I definitely average more than two extras. I even throw in one or two when we agree to no extras (this means you Foster). The only trade I can remember not including an extra was an in-person with cadaugherty. I rushed out of the house without grabbing something, and I regretted it because, not only did he hook me up on the trade, he remembered to bring an extra. :rolleyes:
  15. FosterJM

    FosterJM Champion (870) California Nov 16, 2009 Verified

    You bastard!!! Now I look like a schmuck on the interwebz! At least you have me in person and know how awesome I am! At least not as handsy as Jeff though.

    shutyourface and AleWatcher like this.
  16. cavedave

    cavedave Poobah (1,060) New York Mar 12, 2009 Verified

    I couldn't find it, so perhaps you could put a link into this thread so we could compare that poll with this one. It might be fun to see the different results with time factored in. Thanks.

    Haha yeah I guess it is "that time of the month" again;)
    NiceFly likes this.
  17. thebouch01

    thebouch01 Savant (480) Pennsylvania Jun 26, 2008 Verified

    I probably average 3-4 extras per trade. I always include 1-2 solid locals and then try to hit wants as best as possible. In a recent trade I was able to add 4 wants with little effort, so they went in the box. If everything doesn't fit in the box, I grab a bigger box...
  18. cavedave

    cavedave Poobah (1,060) New York Mar 12, 2009 Verified

    >copying thebouch01 into list of people I really want to trade with<
    franklinn likes this.
  19. I always shoot for 3-4 extras. Sometimes more.
  20. ablackshear

    ablackshear Savant (345) Colorado Sep 17, 2010 Verified

    Not a frequent trader, but I try to include local stuff from small breweries that the trader would probably never otherwise get, and I'll take a look at wants and either include one of those or something that I think they'd want based on those
    RochesterAaron likes this.
  21. mikecharley

    mikecharley Advocate (545) Pennsylvania Nov 6, 2008 Verified

    I generally try to include one extra for every 2 agreed upon bottles. Sometimes a little more, sometimes a little less
  22. DaveHack

    DaveHack Advocate (625) Pennsylvania Mar 28, 2011 Verified

    I always send extras....I usually hook up regular partners as best as I can. If someone makes a very fair trade, or if i feel I'm getting 'the better end of the deal' and even it with extras. I always take the time to see their wants, distribution, and favorite style. This ensures I don't send things my partner hates that are also sitting on their local shelf
    cfh64 likes this.
  23. ejeffer11

    ejeffer11 Savant (360) New York Feb 15, 2008 Verified

    typically a couple, but sometimes I only include one really good extra. most trading partners have been very generous, but if I don't receive any extras, no big deal.
  24. MordorMongo

    MordorMongo Initiate (0) Jul 19, 2009

    What the hell are *extras*?
    EasyReader, cavedave and harrymel like this.
  25. dvelcich

    dvelcich Savant (360) Illinois Feb 6, 2008

    Shut up and take it, and btw, you looked like a schmuck long before I came along. ;)
  26. pschul4

    pschul4 Advocate (660) Illinois Jan 7, 2011 Verified

    I've always included at least 34oz of extras (1 bomber + 1 12oz, or more) But for pretty much all of my future trades I'm going to be sending out 2 pipeworks bombers as extras until everyone realizes how delicious their beers are
    jaminjohnson and pmoney like this.
  27. FosterJM

    FosterJM Champion (870) California Nov 16, 2009 Verified

    Well played sir. Well played.
    What is this a porn? "Shut up and take it" You Nappy guys scare me....;)

  28. boogercrack

    boogercrack Savant (460) Texas May 24, 2012 Verified

    Fairly newish trader here, and I seem to find selecting extras more fun than actually setting up the trade.

    It's so much more interesting than actually agreeing on "you send this, i'll send that".

    I'll ponder their wants list, highly rated hads list, and local distribution charts, and try and hit their wants or drill them with something that i'm making an educated guess on that they'll like based off of their reviews that they might not have heard of before.

    I've had a couple of small trades that I sent more in extras volume wise than the trade. I've been destroyed with extras before on some trades.

    It's a pretty awesome community.
    jp7161, FTowne and pschul4 like this.
  29. Mine really depends on the trade at hand if I send or not. I usually do, but not always. I did just send 4 extras with a trade headed to Arizona though...
  30. dmeadows

    dmeadows Savant (310) New York Aug 6, 2002

    I always include extras and do my best to see that at least one is from the recipient's want list.
  31. BigTomZ

    BigTomZ Savant (325) Virginia Apr 14, 2009

    The number of extras I send depends on the space left in a shipper and quality of the extras. at 1 bottle. If I am sending 1 bottle I try to make it something really good or limited. If I have room for more I might send several locals.
  32. Sarlacc83

    Sarlacc83 Advocate (630) Oregon Mar 2, 2008

    Unless I agree not to do extras with the other trader, I include enough to fill the styro. From there, if I've only got a spot or two, I try to include something really nice. If I've got a couple spots, I try to get some new bottles from new breweries in there.
  33. Allsmoke

    Allsmoke Aficionado (175) Virginia Aug 11, 2007

    I usually do about 3 extras. That seems like a doable amount without jacking up the shipping too bad. But reading through this, I usually just look at the shipping address, then hit up seekabrew to see what I can get them that I think is good but they can't get there (with a preference to my local brews here)

    I never look at wants lists. Not because I'm being a dick, but because I haven't taken the time to set up my own wants/gots stuff so I never think about that.

    Does that make me an unintentional trading douche-bag?
  34. back when I traded I tried to throw in some goooood extras, but sometimes due to time, space, or budget, it was knocked down to good locals. Usually more than one or two, but varies wildly. I've traded out with some regular partners where we're throwing 8-12 extras in each box. Gets exhausting, but the payoff is worth it.

    I used to send cantillon as extras. What an idiot.
    HopsJunkiedotcom likes this.
  35. quirkzoo

    quirkzoo Initiate (0) Colorado Jul 7, 2011

    HopsJunkiedotcom likes this.
  36. miketd

    miketd Advocate (530) Ohio Mar 2, 2006

    I always send them, unless it is agreed upon before the trade "no extras"(I still might send a couple). For me it's a good way to send out local favorites or just good stuff I have sitting around that I've had before. Don't really care if I get extras back, but they are appreciated.
  37. I always try to include extras, hitting wants if possible. My usual goal is to include either one bomber and one small bottle, or three small bottles. If I have some homebrew laying around that I'm happy with I'll throw bottles in as well (not counting that towards my target amount for extras). I'll also throw in more extras if the trader is helping me out in some way (agreeing to wait until we ship, putting in legwork around town to find beers, taking a hit on rarity end of the trade).
  38. EasyReader

    EasyReader Savant (435) North Carolina Mar 30, 2009 Verified

    Like most who have posted, I always send extras. I usually send a few; if I have something nice handy, I'll send it. I try to always send a good local or two, and always enjoy receiving them as well. I've gotten some well selected locals that have turned out to be the real gems in the trade.
  39. harrymel

    harrymel Initiate (0) Washington Dec 15, 2010

    Second this motion. Please place to a vote.
    cavedave likes this.
  40. cavedave

    cavedave Poobah (1,060) New York Mar 12, 2009 Verified

    I too have done the same as you and Mr. Kawada based on the advice I was given by a great BA who shall remain nameless that if you don't know what to extra, "You can't go wrong with a Cantillon."
    pschul4 likes this.