1. Rating beers by attributes (look, smell, taste, feel, overall) is back! Read the latest update ...
  2. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  3. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Founders Red Rye vs Sierra Nevada Ruthless Rye

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by BerlinBomber, Jan 6, 2013.

  1. Thoughts on these 2 beers - my two cents they are very different, but to me Founders is the better beer
     
  2. strangebrew321

    strangebrew321 Savant (370) Indiana Feb 18, 2009

    Founders for the win. Too bad they won't be bottling anymore of it. I've been getting my fill of Red's before it's gone.
     
  3. Roger85

    Roger85 Savant (490) Illinois Aug 24, 2012

    They're still going to bottle it- it's just going to be a seasonal release now.
     
    strangebrew321 and dfillius like this.
  4. Founders
     
  5. beaker30

    beaker30 Aficionado (120) Indiana May 22, 2010

    I haven't had the Founders. But that Ruthless Rye...yummmmmmmm. I'll try the Founders this year too.
     
  6. I'm s huge fan of both, but Red's is fantastic. So balanced. It will now be available seasonally in 4 packs.
     
  7. Ruthless has an weird after taste
     
    Blueribbon666 likes this.
  8. Founders. Drinking an 11/28/12 bottling as I type this (last batch until September?)
     
  9. jminch

    jminch Savant (400) Ohio Jul 17, 2011

    I prefer SN, guess I'm in the minority here. I only tried Founders once, maybe it wasn't a fresh six pack.
     
    Stormfield and Providence like this.
  10. deuce9259

    deuce9259 Savant (310) Ohio Dec 28, 2011

    Founders. All day.
     
    BeerLover99 likes this.
  11. brewtaster

    brewtaster Savant (310) Indiana Sep 20, 2008

    What! they are not bottling it anymore? Founders Red's Rye PA has got to be one of the best brews ever. Why are they discontinuing bottling? Sierra Nevada Ruthless Rye is good but Founders in my opinion is definately the winner.
     
  12. My batch Is 12/5/12
     
    incapacitant likes this.
  13. Founders.
    Red's Rye is going to be seasonal?
    Deuce9259, I saw what you did there, well played sir.
     
    deuce9259 likes this.
  14. Can't you just say that you prefer Founders? Is one really "better" than the other?
     
    gillis likes this.
  15. hardy008

    hardy008 Champion (760) Minnesota Jan 12, 2008

    Founders.
     
  16. BMMillsy

    BMMillsy Advocate (635) Florida Feb 16, 2012

    Please see profile picture.

    I think I got a bad bottle of Ruthless when I had it, though...so maybe not fair. It honestly tasted like licking a dusty car seat bottom.
     
  17. rolandboy

    rolandboy Savant (250) Michigan Oct 11, 2012

  18. ja1022

    ja1022 Aficionado (210) Indiana Sep 27, 2009

    Honestly, not even close for me. In fact I think Red's Rye is very under appreciated for how good it is.
     
  19. CUE45

    CUE45 Aficionado (215) Virginia Jul 29, 2008

    +15 on the Founders. I really wasn't a fan of Ruthless other than the art work for the bottle/packaging.
     
    1Sundown2C likes this.
  20. Roeters

    Roeters Savant (290) Michigan Jul 4, 2007

    I have to say Founders Red's Rye, one of my favorite beer from them.
     
  21. This kind of thread again? :p

    Anyhoo, Red's Rye easily. Ruthless Rye tasted like little more than Torpedo with a bit of spiciness to it.
     
  22. I liked both about the same. I found the Founders was more sessionable, though less interesting than Sierra's Ruthless. Of course, we're talking a Rye PA vs a Rye IPA, so while it's not quite apples to oranges, it's at least grapefruits to tangerines.
     
    omniscientcause and wiscokid920 like this.
  23. wiscokid920

    wiscokid920 Savant (420) Maryland Apr 27, 2011

    I'd have to go with Ruthless Rye based on the wow factor I had after first having it....mabye that's because it was early on in my craft beer experience but I distinctly remember being blown away by it! I have had Red's Rye as well, phenomenal, but as far as a beer I distinctly remember the edge goes to Ruthless!
     
  24. wiscokid920

    wiscokid920 Savant (420) Maryland Apr 27, 2011

    As TheSixthRing points out, We are dealing with Rye PA vs Rye IPA and as far as my tastebuds go I prefer IPAs thus Ruthless!
     
  25. I am with you. Red Rye is great for sure, but Ruthless Rye is a excellent.
     
    jminch likes this.
  26. sullenbee

    sullenbee Savant (340) Michigan Jan 15, 2010

    [​IMG]

    Straight from the source, and oh so delicious. The winner in my book.
     
    blckout20 and beergorrilla like this.
  27. Fresh Founders RR for me. Not that I am dogging Ruthless.
     
  28. I thought Ruthless Rye was pretty good, but not spectacular. There is something about Reds Rye that just completely turns me off. I have tried it on several occasions and have never been able to get through a bottle, just not for me I guess. As far as rye beers go Cane & Ebel is my favorite...
     
  29. litheum94

    litheum94 Initiate (0) California Dec 29, 2008

    Have to say Ruthless Rye.
     
  30. Alextricity

    Alextricity Advocate (700) Michigan Jun 18, 2012

    How did I know you'd be from California. ;)
     
  31. klaybie

    klaybie Savant (275) Illinois Nov 15, 2009

    Founders. But I will be buying Ruthless Rye, it's good and will be more available than Founder's until September.
     
  32. Bblumoehr

    Bblumoehr Zealot (80) New Jersey Jun 26, 2012

    Founders is just so good
     
  33. willbm3

    willbm3 Savant (380) Massachusetts Feb 19, 2010

    Ruthless by a mile. I really wanted to like Reds Rye but just didn't. I only had one 6 pack of it compared to many Ruthless Ryes and I found it to have a not great aftertaste. It was a fresh batch, but maybe there was something else wrong with it. Long story short, Ruthless was perfect and delicious every time
     
  34. litheum94

    litheum94 Initiate (0) California Dec 29, 2008

    So by your logic I guess I can assume you vote for Founders?
     
  35. elNopalero

    elNopalero Advocate (665) Texas Oct 14, 2009

    I'm not often in Michigan but when I am I drink Red's Rye.

    That said, I drank my fair share of Ruthless while it was in season last year and I have a feeling I'll do the same again.
     
  36. Neither, both leaving me wanting more.
     
  37. BB1313

    BB1313 Champion (780) Ohio Jul 16, 2009

    Founders by a landslide, IMO. Ruthless Rye isn't bad, but Red's Rye PA is very special..
     
    deadonhisfeet, JimKal and jmich24 like this.
  38. Alextricity

    Alextricity Advocate (700) Michigan Jun 18, 2012

    Never had Ruthless Rye.
     
  39. litheum94

    litheum94 Initiate (0) California Dec 29, 2008

    You should try it. It's good. :)
     
  40. dcloeren

    dcloeren Savant (460) Texas Sep 15, 2010

    Wasn't a big fan of Ruthless.... Reds Rye PA is fantastic! Wish I could get some on the reg.
     

Share This Page