Dismiss Notice
Sneak peek! BeerAdvocate magazine #104 (September 2015) featuring Leah & Oscar from Highland Brewing in Asheville, North Carolina. Learn more ...

GL Edmund Fitzgerald vs. Founders Porter

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by tectactoe, Nov 20, 2012.

?

Would you choose GL Edmund Fitzgerald vs. Founders Porter as the better American porter?

  1. Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald

    282 vote(s)
    50.5%
  2. Founder's Porter

    276 vote(s)
    49.5%
  1. tectactoe

    tectactoe Champion (870) Michigan Mar 20, 2012 Verified

    A buddy of mine and I were having a discussion about our favorite and most drinkable American porter. For each of us, it came down to Edmund and Founder's Porter. Personally, I choose Founders just by a hair. But Edmund is close behind. These seem to be two highly touted porters among BA's, so I was just curious as to what you guys think.

    If you HAD to choose one of those two, which would it be?
     
  2. HF Everett blows them both away, and it's not even close.
     
  3. pmarlowe

    pmarlowe Advocate (720) District of Columbia Nov 27, 2010 Verified

    Edmund Fitzgerald. They should barrel age that shit.
     
    whitenads, Lordhelmit, spry and 5 others like this.
  4. Beertsipper

    Beertsipper Savant (390) New York Nov 18, 2008

    Close call, but the winner by a split decision goes to Founders.
     
    AdmiralOzone likes this.
  5. CircusBoy

    CircusBoy Savant (330) Ohio Mar 10, 2008

    Love both of these beers. It's pretty much a tossup but I think Edmund slightly eeks out Founders.
     
    shadwow13 likes this.
  6. BeerFan

    BeerFan Savant (365) New Jersey Feb 11, 2003 Verified

    She lives in MI and HF is only available to VT, so why mention a beer she didn't ask about (and can't easily purchase).

    I prefer Founders, but plan to do a blind tasting with those two plus Smuttynose Robust Porter with a few friends over the weekend. I'll report the results.
     
    swolepeer, tlema1, Hrodebert and 12 others like this.
  7. terryg75

    terryg75 Zealot (80) Sep 23, 2012

    Eddy Fitz all day long...
     
  8. Put me down for Founders.
     
    AdmiralOzone likes this.
  9. smutty33

    smutty33 Advocate (705) Connecticut Jun 12, 2009

    I want to side w/ Founder's here as I have in the past.

    But I am gonna hold off cuz, its been a long while since I have had Edmund Fitz.
    I'd love to revisit sometime soon,as I've only had a few.

    I'm gonna leave this as a draw for now.

    Cheers All.......
     
    Thickfreakness likes this.
  10. stakem

    stakem Champion (965) Pennsylvania Feb 20, 2009 Verified

    I am glad we get both and dont have to pick one over the other. Sitting here thinking about it, I cant really claim to like one significantly over the other. However, my reviews show I rate Fitzgerald higher.

    now thats just silly
     
  11. Well, it's posted on the national forum and I can't buy Edmund Fitz locally either. Plus this is going to turn into another "best porter" thread anyway...

    (OP is a male, by the way)
     
  12. socon67

    socon67 Champion (760) New York Jun 18, 2010 Verified

    I had the Edmund Fitz on tap and thought it was by far the best american porter. It really is close as the Founder's Porter also a great example of the style.
     
  13. ChanChan

    ChanChan Advocate (610) California Dec 12, 2009 Verified

    Was this one of the choices?
     
  14. They are both so good! Why do I have to choose?? lol How about instead of picking one, when I want a good porter I'll drink one of each!
     
    chanokokoro likes this.
  15. It's really not though. Don't take my word for it - try them both blindly side by side. I just did it in the most recent Blind BIF and was blown away at the results.
     
  16. jamescain

    jamescain Advocate (720) Texas Jul 14, 2009 Verified Subscriber

    I personally prefer Founders, but I'll throw another porter into this debate that is often overlooked, Smuttynose.
     
    SammyJaxxxx, mhenson42 and n2185 like this.
  17. hctap00

    hctap00 Aficionado (195) Maryland Nov 2, 2012

    Founders for me. I like the creamier mouthfeel.

    Had both last night side by side, though not blind. This may have been an issue considering my bias toward Founders
     
    AdmiralOzone likes this.
  18. Really have to do this side by side, going by memory I'm siding with founders because of the fuller mouthfeel.
     
    AdmiralOzone likes this.
  19. I'm in the minority but Edmund Fitzgerald never wowed me. Easy choice for me.
     
    SLewis, AdmiralOzone and MichPaul like this.
  20. digdug1810

    digdug1810 Savant (250) New Jersey Mar 1, 2011 Verified

    i'd pick up the founders 3 out of 4 times when picking between the two.. the 1 out of 4 would b/c i hadn't had the edmund in awhile.. then after having it.. i'd probably go... wow this is some good stuff.. then go... eh... probably would have like the founders... haha

    they are both great and available so it's a win win for us the consumer! Drink both.. mix them if you want.. just drink up!
     
  21. thebigredone

    thebigredone Advocate (645) Wisconsin Dec 19, 2011 Verified

    I second this. Everett by a mile, Founders second, GL EF third.
     
  22. Hanzo

    Hanzo Champion (965) Virginia Feb 27, 2012

    Even though I am a huge Founders fan I have to give this round to Eddy Fitz.
     
    EricTKole and gpawned like this.
  23. whiterabbit

    whiterabbit Savant (290) Ohio Jan 24, 2010 Verified

    6 of one and a half dozen of another.

    Slight lean to Edmund, but am local and was served this recently on draft at GLBC by an incredibly cute low cut blouse young female server, so for some reason that MIGHT have caused the lean.......


    Great question. Both are excellent, and a solid debate. Cheers!
     
    jglowe77 and hctap00 like this.
  24. EricCioe

    EricCioe Savant (460) Montana Aug 7, 2010

    Edmund Fitzgerald has the coolest classic beer name.

    Founders is creamier. I like them both a great deal. Would love to do them blind up against the two top finishers of our last local blind porter tasting, Big Sky Bobo's and Black Butte.
     
  25. MikeCactusGordon

    MikeCactusGordon Advocate (665) Ohio Feb 20, 2011 Verified

    I'm a huge fan of both.

    Eddy Fitz
     
  26. I have to say Everett/FP/fitz are quite evenly matched. i love them all. But i have to travel far to get all of these beers, Robust porter is always on the shelves at my locals and that counts for a lot...
     
  27. Eddy Fitz all the way
     
  28. Brew33

    Brew33 Advocate (680) Ohio Oct 24, 2007 Verified

    Eddie Fitz > Black Butte > Founders > Upland Bad Elmers

    imho
     
  29. Grohnke

    Grohnke Savant (395) Illinois Sep 15, 2009

    im going with eddy fitz on this one because of the subtle smokey characteristic.

    Forgive me if FP has smoke as well, i cant recall, but i dont think it does
     
  30. AJacob81

    AJacob81 Savant (280) Illinois Mar 15, 2010

    Eugene > Ed Fitz > Founders > Smutty Robust > Walker's Reserve

    Haven't had Everett or Black Butte yet. All of the 5 above are pretty regular purchases for me (and I imagine BB will be too in a couple months or so). Love a good porter.
     
  31. miketd

    miketd Advocate (530) Ohio Mar 2, 2006

    I don't agree, but that's what this site is all about.
     
  32. Tilley4

    Tilley4 Advocate (615) Tennessee Nov 13, 2007 Verified

    Man, this is a close one... I love both porters... Maybe Founders by a nose... but it's damn close...
     
    AdmiralOzone likes this.
  33. Keffa

    Keffa Advocate (605) Ohio Jan 8, 2009 Verified

    You should send me one so I can be the judge of that.

    Edit: Edmund Fitzgerald, all day long.
     
  34. GameFreac

    GameFreac Savant (455) Georgia Apr 8, 2011

    Edmund Fitzgerald

    Founders Porter is good but overrated, IMO
     
  35. fiver29

    fiver29 Advocate (500) Ohio Sep 18, 2007 Verified

    Ed Fitz. Because I like it better. I'm not the only one. Here's the hardware it has:

    Gold Medal, 2012 World Beer Championships Gold Medal, 2011 World Beer Championships Gold Medal, 2008 World Beer Championships Silver Medal, 2007 Great American Beer Festival Gold Medal, 2006 World Beer Championships Bronze Medal, 2004 Great American Beer Festival Gold Medal, 2003 World Beer Championships Gold Medal, 2002 Great American Beer Festival Gold Medal, 2002 World Beer Championships World Champion, Gold Medal, 2001 World Beer Championships Gold Medal, 1998 World Beer Championships Silver Medal, 1997 World Beer Championships Gold Medal, 1996 World Beer Championships Bronze Medal, 1996 World Beer Cup, Colorado World Champion, Platinum Medal, 1994 World Beer Championships Gold Medal, 1993 Great American Beer Festival Gold Medal, 1991 Great American Beer Festival

    And yours?
     
    gpawned likes this.
  36. Wish Edmund Fitz was distributed to MA so I could try it. I know I could trade for it, but I'm not really into trading. So my vote goes to Founders for now.
     
  37. Stouttyme

    Stouttyme Savant (315) Nebraska Nov 17, 2011 Verified

    I prefer founders by a mile.
     
    AdmiralOzone and Brunite like this.
  38. jmw

    jmw Savant (440) North Carolina Feb 4, 2009

    One of the closest matchups I've seen trotted out. Good call.

    Founders by a short and curly.
     
    tlema1 and AdmiralOzone like this.
  39. stakem

    stakem Champion (965) Pennsylvania Feb 20, 2009 Verified

    I dont want to distract too much from the topic at hand but since you bring it up, ill play along.

    It wasnt a blind tasting but I did get to drink founders porter, edmund fitz, fresh and aged everett along with barrel aged everett all within a span of 2-3 days. Everett and the BA version were not something I would pay to drink again. I like dark roasty grain flavors in my porters with hops and dark fruity alcohol being a secondary trait. All 3 bottles of Everette were mineral-filled tasting metallic and carbonic. Not horrible mind you, just not all that desireable either.

    Thats the beauty of individual taste. While everyone gets their shit up in the air over HF, ill quitely refuse to pursue anything else by them and drink whats more readily available to me (I retracted that statement when/if they brew a berliner.)
     
    ehammond1 likes this.
  40. I'd like to contribute to this poll so if someone could send one of each my way, that'd be great. Kthx ;)
     
    tectactoe likes this.