Discussion in 'US - Great Lakes' started by BB1313, Feb 6, 2013.
I had high hopes going into this one, and while it is very tasty, didn't quite do it for me. I'd gladly drink it again, but it isn't something I'll seek out or buy much of again.
I revisited this at the brewery again last night and came to the same conclusion. Solid, but nothing mind blowing.
One mans trash is another mans treasure. A beer so freaking dry it feels like they are scraping the skin off my tongue sounds delicious!
Alchemy Hour is just a shade off, for me. A bit too sweet, not bad but definitely not great. Lake Erie Monster is much more to my liking.
I didn't say it was trash, just really freaking dry! I love dry IPAs.
I really need to try this IBUsive. I hear it's doing really well in the Brewing News National IPA Challenge..
Is Great Lakes alchemy hour a year round deal or what's the word?
Awesome thanks! Heard its goo stuff grabbing four tmw.
I agree that probably isn't the right quote. What I meant to say is that the things you found that perhaps made it a shade less appealing to you sounded really, really appealing to me.
Every time I hear someone describe an assertive DIPA that is really flavorful and then the finish by saying the words "nice malty backbone" or "with a hint of sweetness to add balance" I sigh, every so slightly.
We had a bottle tonight, my wife really liked it. I thought it was a bit sweet. Reminded me of Hopslam from several years back. Not bad, I'd like to drink a few of them and see where that goes.
Grab 2. It's freakin' awesome. Best IPA we had blind last week.
Picked up a four pack here for $10.99. Havent opened one yet, but looking forward to it based on the reviews here.
when in rome...im going to get two
Haha, I agree! I also hate when people say, "it's a nicely balanced IPA". When I hear that, it's pretty likely I will hate the brew. I like my IPA very unbalanced, thank you very much.
Wasn't there another thread devoted to this beer? I thought it was 2-3 pages long. Did Vav post that Harlem Shake video in that thread, too? He's going to wind up nuking every other thread here!
Anyone that lives on the east side of Cleveland and is looking to fill a growler. Save On Tobacco & Beverage in Mentor has it for $9.99/growler.
Anyone seen this in the north Chicago burbs? Skokie Binnys didn't have it, wasn't sure if they were getting any either.
I've seen it a few places around Evanston, picked it up for $12.50 at D&D Finer foods in Evanston, not sure if they still have it though.
Got it in charlotte today. Its good but has a bit too much honey
Maybe a bit too far out for you but I know the Buffalo Grove Binny's tweeted that they had it on Wed (2/27)
Wow, finally had some for the first time last night. Very impressed. I fucking love Great Lakes.
I picked up a bottle at Steve's liquor on University yesterday.
Grabbed a pack of this the other day. Loved it, fantastic stuff.
I agree for the most part on liking the unbalanced extremely hopped IPAs, but I can't say I've ever hated an IPA due to it being balanced. Isn't that a little harsh? I know it's open to interpretation but an American IPA style beer always should have a slight malt backbone. Otherwise it will taste like a vegetable boozy mess after a month.
From what I understand, DIPAs should have less of a malty backbone and more abrasive hoppy bitterness.
Anyway, I just found it funny that someone would "hate" a brew for being too balanced. I can think of plenty of beers I hate, and none of them are balanced IPAs.
Back to topic, it has been nice to enjoy the flavor ride on the Alchemy so far. The intense tropical pineapple and mango flavors have already disappeared from this beer. Now it is more of a citrusy grapefruit pine bomb. The honey came out better when this beer was super fresh, making the perceived sweetness pretty intense. When I have revisted this beer a second, third, fourth time, it has seemed less sweet to me each time (though still fairly sweet for a DIPA, I think I calculated the final gravity of this is roughly 1.020 based on the plato they list on their website). I still think Alchemy is awesome either way.
"Hate" is a word I don't use much, especially when it comes to beer. So, yea, it was a bit hyperbolic. What I meant was, when most people think an IPA is "balanced", I will think it's malty.
Double IPAs do tend to have less malt backbone, but I like fewer of them because they are too often under attenuated and sweet/boozy. It's a hard style to nail, but when they are good(Hop Juju, Enjoy By, Pliny, etc.) I can't get enough.
Thanks, was in the neighborhood today and grabbed a 4 pack. Much appreciated.
It's no Lake Erie Monster...
That's ChiTown...here in C-Town picked my 4 up for $9.99. Great stuff & not like Commodore Perry or Lake Erie Monster are slouches in the least. Abv is very well hidden in this, in fact I dare say I could have 2 or 3 in an evening.
Had it at the brewpub yesterday and liked it, but didn't love it. Solid hop profile though!
Separate names with a comma.