Highly acclaimed brews that underwhelmed you?

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by tectactoe, Nov 9, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. tectactoe

    tectactoe Champion (870) Michigan Mar 20, 2012 Verified

    Just had my first Double Jack. It was certainly good (4.19), but wasn't mind blowing. Maybe my expectations were too high. But I don't believe it's worth the price tag.
    dar482 and ThisWangsChung like this.
  2. caponeduke

    caponeduke Savant (325) North Carolina Jul 28, 2011 Verified

    Thank you sir. I enjoyed the beer but most of Alpines and Kern Rivers stuff blows this out of the water IMO.
    ToddThompson likes this.
  3. RR - PTE
    Nugget Nectar
  4. Sculpin.
    Had it on tap. Its good, dont get me wrong, but I dunno about it for 16 dollars per 6pack
    1up, Morey and Hopportunistic like this.
  5. CaptKirkles

    CaptKirkles Aficionado (185) New York Apr 7, 2010 Subscriber

    I went to Cali last year and had to see what all the hupla was about Pliny the Elder. I had it and it was a great beer but it didn't blow me away. I'll take a heady topper of it any day.
    DanH83 likes this.
  6. Gotti311

    Gotti311 Advocate (675) Wisconsin Mar 22, 2009 Verified

    Big Eddy Stout is one of the worst RIS I have ever had.

    That IIPA is really really damn good though
  7. It wasn't very highly acclaimed, but it was very over-hyped. Sam Adams Infinium absolutely sucked.
    1up likes this.
  8. Chazari99

    Chazari99 Aficionado (205) Massachusetts Mar 10, 2011 Verified

    Dark Lord = awful.

    BCBS = awful.
    BottleCaps80 likes this.

    CORKSCREWFISH Savant (325) Illinois Apr 22, 2011

    Even Wayne's in shock!
  10. Agreed. Certainly good, but I paid $13.95 for my sixer and still thought it was overpriced.
    1up likes this.
  11. jaxon53

    jaxon53 Advocate (745) Connecticut Mar 1, 2006 Verified Subscriber

    I was completely underwhelmed by Surly Darkness. I've had different vintages, aged and fresh. I just don't get the hype...
  12. rails

    rails Aficionado (205) California Nov 8, 2012 Verified

    Had this years Hop Slam no way should that have a score of 100 more like 80.
    Chelsea1905 and 1up like this.
  13. mecummins

    mecummins Savant (425) Illinois Nov 16, 2012

    Recently it was Deschutes Black Butte. It wasn't a drain pour, but for all the hype it received and the high score on BA, I was disappointed with what was in my glass. I found it shallow in depth and sort of artificial in taste. I so expected a WOW and got an eh?
  14. alucard6679

    alucard6679 Savant (305) Arizona Jul 29, 2012

    I definitely agree. In all fairness though there are only a couple of porters that I really like all that much.
  15. DanE

    DanE Savant (430) Connecticut Feb 24, 2012

    Smuttynose IPA, "Finest Kind." Rather average to me, especially when I can have a fresh NEBCO Sea Hag
  16. ChicagoNick

    ChicagoNick Savant (490) Illinois Nov 16, 2012 Verified

    I agree when poured in a glass. However, this is one of those few beers that I enjoyed ice cold straight from the bottle. Light and refreshing. This is something I could drink in the summer.

    For me, the best porters for the money are Firestone Walker's Reserve Porter and Central water's Mudpuppy porter.
    mecummins likes this.
  17. mecummins

    mecummins Savant (425) Illinois Nov 16, 2012

    A summer porter. I never considered this before. Sort of like the idea of iced coffee? I'm going to put a bottle away and try this in July.
    ChicagoNick likes this.
  18. Founders Breakfast Stout. Totally disagrees with my mouth :eek:
    Also, DFH Immort Ale. While not "hyped", it is however the first time I was ever disappointed with Dogfish.
    SomethingClever likes this.
  19. bound4er

    bound4er Advocate (505) Wisconsin Jul 4, 2007 Verified

    Easy one - BCBS. Hot, sweet gloppy mess of a beer.
    BottleCaps80 likes this.
  20. kcp85

    kcp85 Aficionado (210) Missouri Sep 7, 2012

    So far, it was Hop Stoopid. I actually love it but I expected more.
  21. I hereby revoke your ba card. (can I do that?, start a petition or something.)

    No really, Nugget Nectar? Impossible.
    1up, ryhayes and YogiBeer like this.
  22. Bell's Two Hearted for me... Everybody raves on this beer, and I guess my tastebuds just don't get it. I'm more in line with the "bros" tastes on here apparently than on ratebeer. The bros gave it a 78 (average) rating and I couldn't agree more. I like a little abrasive alcohol burn in my beers, but Two Hearted to me just tastes abrasive because it is imbalanced. I've also heard this beer doesn't age well at all, so I could have had a bad batch?
  23. Backwoods Bastard I find to be the least complex, least balanced, and least enjoyable I have thusfar had
    luwak likes this.
  24. themind

    themind Savant (485) New Jersey Mar 14, 2011

    You just named some of the greatest beers ever produced lol!
  25. rxeight

    rxeight Initiate (0) Illinois Feb 5, 2012

  26. loafinaround

    loafinaround Savant (415) New York Jul 16, 2011 Verified

    flower power
  27. williamjbauer

    williamjbauer Champion (830) West Virginia Jan 17, 2012 Verified

    Hopslam 2013, 2012 was fantastic and still one of my top IPAs.
    1up likes this.
  28. brian4beer

    brian4beer Savant (405) Indiana Jan 27, 2013 Verified

    stone brewery in general
    kustard, HopsintheSack, mp19 and 2 others like this.
  29. Dirtinabottle

    Dirtinabottle Savant (475) New York Aug 21, 2012 Verified

  30. Wookie Jack....smells way better than it tastes. Not that its bad but I was expecting much more. I tried it twice from two different bottle batches. Missed it on tap.

    1up and rgfellow like this.
  31. luwak

    luwak Savant (395) Arizona Mar 2, 2010 Verified

    yeah that beer sucks a lot of ass
    1up likes this.
  32. luwak

    luwak Savant (395) Arizona Mar 2, 2010 Verified

    ...weird ...some ppl just dont dig catpiss i guess
    in my world 2012 was okay but kinda boring; it was certainly more "balanced" which is a polite way of saying "impotent"
    2013 was bonkers stinky and therefore much more exciting to drink.
    1up and FriarTuckInLuck like this.
  33. luwak

    luwak Savant (395) Arizona Mar 2, 2010 Verified

    more than anything it just tastes like nothing...totally forgettable
    does it age well perhaps?
    cause it sure bores well when fresh.
  34. Smutty Finest Kind has "whelmed" me about as much as Bell's Two Hearted. Both decent at best, but I don't get all the love for them. For the same $, I can get many waaaaaaay better IPA's.
    DanE likes this.
  35. Founders Backwoods Bastard. The bourbon taste was entirely too overwhelming.
    hoppymcgee likes this.
  36. Neorebel

    Neorebel Savant (395) New Jersey Jun 29, 2005

    Anyone who says DFH, Westvleteren, or Hopslam.... GTFO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Rfunk and AstronautMikeDexter like this.
  37. luwak

    luwak Savant (395) Arizona Mar 2, 2010 Verified

    When you have aged the Abyss it becomes really awesome
    The last two years were kinda acidic and hot fresh but 11 is great now ....
    (and of course they dont compare to 2008 or 2010....)
    StoutChaser7D likes this.
  38. Nugget Nectar was the big one. I at least expected something that made me want to run back and buy more before it ran out. Nope. One sixer was enough.

    I do not understand that the words "Sucks" and "Sucaba" are appearing in this thread. There must be some kind of mistake.
    rgfellow likes this.
  39. brewtus

    brewtus Savant (400) Ohio Dec 29, 2012 Verified

    Nugget nectar
  40. RochefortChris

    RochefortChris Champion (805) North Carolina Oct 2, 2012 Verified

    Zombie Dust. I liked it but I think something more widely available like Stone pale is just as good.
    planbee and luwak like this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.