Dismiss Notice

Site Performance Updates: We're aware of the nightly site outage, and working on resolving the issue.

Follow our progress ...

Most underrated beer from a well-known brewery?

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by SteveB24, Mar 10, 2014.

  1. WarEagleJeep

    WarEagleJeep Savant (475) Alabama Jul 21, 2013 Beer Trader

    Great Divide Colette is a great spring/summer beer but I always think of Yeti (and different variations of Yeti) when I think of Great Divide.
    KS1297, fuzzylogic and utopiajane like this.
  2. EricTKole

    EricTKole Advocate (640) Michigan Jan 4, 2014 Beer Trader

    That's a steal for $10 nice score!!
  3. Boulevard Pop Up. Shit was good.

    I like big Eye more, honestly. I dont get the insanity over Sculpin.
  4. TheEpeeist

    TheEpeeist Savant (335) Pennsylvania Nov 5, 2008 Beer Trader

    i was thinking about trying to trade for one of these but the color of the label scared me off.

    i would suggest Lost Abbey Serpent's Stout. gets lost amidst all their sours.
    FCal79 and Clint_Yoho like this.
  5. Givemebeer

    Givemebeer Advocate (545) Vermont Apr 6, 2013

    Titan IPA. Love this stuff and Great Divide gets most of its attention from it's Yeti series.
  6. dennis3951

    dennis3951 Advocate (635) New Jersey Mar 6, 2008 Subscriber Beer Trader

    Either or both the Stout and porter from Sierra Nevada.
    HRamz3, Falcone, Roguer and 1 other person like this.
  7. tylerstravis

    tylerstravis Champion (965) Colorado Feb 14, 2014 Beer Trader

    Trumer Pils

    Honestly, my #1 Pilsner hands down and readily available.
    GR_Rick, PPOmaha and Redrover like this.
  8. tectactoe

    tectactoe Champion (880) Michigan Mar 20, 2012

    I've always been fond of Stone's Smoked Porter. I could live without every other Stone beer but that one. Plus, only 4-5$ for a bomber. Win!
  9. LMT

    LMT Savant (375) Virginia Oct 15, 2009

    Weihenstephaner Original (Helles Lager).

    Maybe not over-rated, but not mentioned all the often. So I think it's under-appreciated.
  10. michman

    michman Savant (335) Illinois Oct 14, 2005

    i really enjoy Bells Kalamazoo Stout.
  11. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    ok so in hindsight "underated" was poor diction on my part, as it is a main function of BA to literally rate beer and all the beers ive mentioned as well as others on this thread have high scores, a better term would be undermentioned or under hyped. it could be hop stoopid is very popular elsewhere, but here in new york ive never heard anyone mention or recommend it, even in the context of lagunitas.
    rustyeaton likes this.
  12. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    yes, as many pointed out "underrated" was poor terminology on my part, since BA literally rates beers and the beers i mentioned and many others have high scores, i definitly meant under mentioned or under hyped like most of you assumed.
  13. Drew88

    Drew88 Savant (305) New Jersey Sep 28, 2013

    I'm still pretty shocked how underrated Free Will Brewing Company's Coffee Oatmeal Brown Ale is. I'm a huge coffee beer fan, I'm sure everyone isn't but if you are just taking COB for what it is, it's up there. Also I think Kujo from Flying Dog is a little underrated too. But maybe this winter just has me really up on the coffee beers.
    Clint_Yoho likes this.
  14. beatenbyjacks

    beatenbyjacks Savant (490) Colorado Apr 17, 2011 Beer Trader

    I was going to say Odell 5 Barrel. IPA, 90 Shilling, and Easy Street kind of get all the publicity for their normal lineup-up along with Friek and Woodcut series for their bombers. Glad to see 5 Barrel win a Gold @ GABF this past year as this beer has been a favorite Pale Ale for quite some time.
    tylerstravis likes this.
  15. Hendrick24

    Hendrick24 Champion (965) Wisconsin Sep 6, 2013 Beer Trader

    Agreed, I just had Centennial in cans for the first time, it has been awhile since I'd last had it and it was even better than I remember. So well rounded and drinkable.
    brewlover517 likes this.
  16. APBT91

    APBT91 Savant (375) North Carolina Apr 12, 2013

    I haven't had the chance to try it in cans yet, I know its around it just hasn't been at my normal places. Its perfect timing for spring/summer!
  17. Shroud0fdoom

    Shroud0fdoom Champion (885) Maryland Oct 31, 2013 Beer Trader

    Came here to say this^.
    JohnCassillo likes this.
  18. I don't believe Free Will Brewing co would be considered "a well known brewery" which the OP indicated . However I agree ,COB is a nice brew.
  19. In the "under mention" category , Anchor's Old Foghorn comes to mind.
    djsmith1174 and SteveB24 like this.
  20. Harnkus

    Harnkus Savant (395) New York Oct 31, 2013

    Depends what you mean by "underrated". Do you mean not rated by many reviewers? Not rated highly? Rated below a 90 (because as we all "very good" is something to fear)? Or just a general feeling that contradicts what is otherwise rated highly because you feel people don't talk about it enough?

    I think these beers deserve higher ratings:

    Festina Peche (82)
    Kona Big Wave (80) Two Brothers Sidekick gets an 89, and this is in the same vain but much better
    Abita Strawberry Harvest Lager (79) yeah whatever, the shit is great
    Yards Brawler Pugilist Style Ale (83)
    Great South Bay Blonde Ambition (84) Not sure what the secret ingredient is, but this is liquid bikini
    Brooklyn Scorcher (80) By far my favorite pale ale
    The Shed IPA (81) Great EIPA, and like many others in the English vain, overlooked
    Otter Creek Vermont Lager (81)
    Kona Fore Rock Pale Ale (82) really a standout pale...and yeah, I think it really does taste Hawaiin
    Kona Longboard Lager (77) straight facing American lager doesn't get better than this for mindless quaff
  21. Jimsal27

    Jimsal27 Aficionado (160) New York Jul 30, 2013

    Troegs nugget nectar
    brewlover517 likes this.
  22. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    really? even in new york i thought that nugget nectar is very hyped, i mean its delicious, im not saying its over rated but definitely not under
  23. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    just tried ballast point big eye IPA and i thought it was fine, not an IPA id run to buyb again but solid, is sculpin better?
  24. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    try lagunitas cappuccino stout, just found it buy my local craft beer store and its really tasty, very drinkable too.
  25. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    i find that while many peaople widely consider SN to be a good brewery, people make a much bigger deal about more expensive, rarer beers when SN has a great, affordable beer in nearly every catagory.
    djsmith1174 and TychoNDC like this.
  26. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    i just tried ballast point big eye and i enjoyed it but i wasnt close to blown away, is sculpin better?
    Last edited: Mar 11, 2014
  27. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    yes, you are absolutely right, i meant under mentioned or under hyped.
  28. Valleyview06

    Valleyview06 Advocate (510) Pennsylvania Oct 13, 2012 Beer Trader

    Old Rasputin on nitro
    Vivified and M-14 like this.
  29. JohnCassillo

    JohnCassillo Advocate (625) California Mar 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    Assuming you mean you tried Big Eye? Sculpin is fantastic in my (and a lot of others') opinion. Definitely worth a try (or several).
    SteveB24 likes this.
  30. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    yeah i meant big eye, thanks.
  31. Bell's Double Cream is almost a wow for me.
    Lagunitas Dogtown isn't talked about nearly as much as it should be.
    Old Chub is probably one of the best scotch ales in this country.
    Schneider Edel-Weiss is almost never mentioned.
    Hop Ottin' by Anderson Valley is a sick IPA. Especially canned.
    Founders Double Trouble.

    I mean, I could go on. There are a lot of beers that don't get any hype at all.
    Last edited: Mar 11, 2014
    LutherBrau and BergBeer like this.
  32. Bsetz

    Bsetz Savant (330) Missouri Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    I've always loved Stone Cali-Belgique
    tylerstravis likes this.
  33. JamesTIA

    JamesTIA Disciple (70) Ohio Nov 29, 2012

    Too many to name. Here's the ones off the top of my head, and why.

    Dark Horse Special Reserve Black Ale - With all the hype over their numbered stout series, everyone seems to forget this amazing beer.
    New Belgium Snapshot Wheat Ale - Fat Tire overshadows everything this brewery does, and this beer's haze and tart finish is outstanding. Not kidding. I once heard someone refer to this beer as "Fat Tire Snapshot" because they thought that was the name of the brewery.
    The Bruery Hottenroth - With all of their crazy sour ales blasting your palate with acid, this amazing Berlinerweisse often gets left in the dust behind them.
    Lindemans Faro Lambic - Casual drinkers love their Framboise, lambic geeks love their Gueuze, but few people seem to talk about this very sweet lambic with awesome orange peel and black pepper notes to it.
    Southern Tier Harvest Ale - Overshadowed by Pumking.
    Three Floyds Pride and Joy - forgot it existed, didn't you? Want one now, don't you?

    Plenty more...the ones already mentioned that I would echo are Kalamazoo Stout (overshadowed by Expedition, Java, Cherry) and Big Eye (overshadowed by Sculpin)
    miwestcoaster likes this.
  34. Lagunitas New Dogtown Pale Ale

    Firestone Pale 31

    Just Outstanding IPA

    Jamaica Red

    Green Flash Double Stout

    Sea Monster (better than Victory at Sea IMHO)

    Bear Republic Big Bear Black Stout - High ratings, under-discussed
    Last edited: Mar 11, 2014
    beerFool28607 likes this.
  35. oldsailor

    oldsailor Advocate (680) Nevada Mar 18, 2008 Beer Trader

    I feel like a broken record throwing out Anchor's offerings, but their Christmas ale has always been great, yet last year's offering only scored an 83...I completely disagree with that and have to say that it's also been a gateway beer for a lot of friends of mine that weren't in to beer until I served it up at a Christmas party.
    Droopy487 likes this.
  36. TwoTrees

    TwoTrees Savant (420) Washington Oct 31, 2012

    I'm gonna throw out Sierra Nevada's Kellerweiss. I friggin' love that beer...
  37. JayCheG

    JayCheG Savant (380) Wisconsin Jan 27, 2014 Beer Trader

    Moon Man - New Glarus
    They're known for their fruit beers but they make a pretty good pale ale
  38. SteveB24

    SteveB24 Champion (775) New York Aug 29, 2013 Beer Trader

    a couple of people have mentioned ballast point big eye as under hyped. i tried it tonight and i thought it was fine but not a beer that particularly deserves lots of hype. i also tried firestone Union jack IPA and THAT is an a beer worth hyping over.
  39. gillagorilla

    gillagorilla Champion (935) Maryland Feb 27, 2013 Beer Trader

    I thought they were discontinued.
  40. beerwolf72

    beerwolf72 Champion (765) Ohio Aug 12, 2006 Beer Trader

    I second three Floyd's pride & joy. It's the session Sucks.
    GR_Rick likes this.