Extra Vanilla or "Extra anything" is hard to quantify.. and really something.. as far as a beer database standpoint.. that really opens a big loophole that any site should try to avoid. The beer is the same in ingredients.. it just has some "extra" of something. Sounds like an alt, fwiw. But then again, everyone has their own opinion. The way I think of it is it's like saying "This batch of Coffee BCS has EXTRA Coffee".. would that really be a new beer? No.. it's essentially a tweak to a batch. I'm sure it tasted great.. but from an organizational approach, it would be hard to seperate that specific beer out. Certainly if it were an entirely different adjunct, treatment, or ingredient.. then ok, let's seperate that out. But I don't think it's as cut-and-dry here as some may think.