1. Extreme Beer Fest. March 20 & 21, 2015 in Boston, Mass. Join us!
  2. The wait is over! Download the BeerAdvocate app on iTunes or Google Play now.
  3. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for only $9.99!

Portland brewery apologizes over Hindu reference to beer

Discussion in 'Beer News' started by BeerSingh, May 14, 2012.

  1. BeerSingh

    BeerSingh Savant (415) India Jul 25, 2009

  2. Spider889

    Spider889 Advocate (650) Ohio Mar 24, 2010

    I wish someone from the Hindu community would explain what, if anything, Kali-ma means. I bet if the brewery just redid the art to something more generic/closer to the actual movie reference that the name wouldn't be that much of an issue. As it stands they might as well change it all though.

    Not to make light of anyone's convictions, but the whole thing reminds me a bit of the South Park episode where Terence and Phillip want to show the image of Mohamed.
     
    seanluvsbeer likes this.
  3. BeerSingh

    BeerSingh Savant (415) India Jul 25, 2009

    "Kali ma" literally means "Black Mother" - she is an incarnation of Goddess Durga. This particular incarnation is a symbol of power, destruction of evil and woman power. Kali Ma is highly revered in India, including me.
     
  4. Spider889

    Spider889 Advocate (650) Ohio Mar 24, 2010

    Including by you??

    Anyways, gotcha. The article only mentions "Kali" I believe so I wasn't sure if there was a difference or if there was a chance that the phrase in its entirety was meaningless.
     
  5. IpeeA

    IpeeA Savant (365) Missouri Jan 22, 2010

    Ridiculous. Yet another example of people being overly sensitive to every little thing. I guess Lost Abbey has a lot of apologizing and name/label changing to do as well!? Maybe they should just disband their whole brewery and start over to make sure no one is offended and they don't continue "selling beer for mercantile greed." God forbid... Oops, I better apologize for that one. o_O
     
    Horbar, ZX6Chris and oreo like this.
  6. Im not up on my religions but what about Shiva IPA? That's been around for a while with no problems?
     
  7. Celebrate Diversity, Just Don't Point Out The Differences.
     
    Horbar, Mavajoo and ZX6Chris like this.
  8. Chaz

    Chaz Champion (815) Minnesota Feb 3, 2002

    Some years ago, Lost Coast ran into some controversy over their "Indica" label, but since we no longer had access to their brands in Minneapolis I forget what happened next.

    File it all Under: "Craft Beer and the Global Market", eh?
     
  9. Mebuzzard

    Mebuzzard Poobah (1,030) Colorado May 19, 2005

    While agree there is a lot of over-sensitivity out there, including in the beer community, there is more to this than the name. While the brewery was referencing Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, they overlooked (or didn't know) what Kali Ma is/represents. The image on the label certainly doesn't portray it accurately.

    Does this mean people should get bent all out of shape? I don't think so. But it also doesn't cleanse the brewery of being ignorant. It happens. Apologize (for the right reason). Accept apology. Move on. Have a beer.
    We'll see how far the Bharatiya Janata Party pushes this...for votes, I'd assume.
     
    ZX6Chris and BeerSingh like this.
  10. maltmaster420

    maltmaster420 Savant (450) Oregon Aug 17, 2005

    On the one hand Rajan Zed strikes me as a Hindu version of Jesse Jackson in the sense that he's just looking for things to be outraged about. On the other hand, there's no point in offending potential customers, so I can see why Burnside is acquiescing.

    Frankly, I bet there are now hundreds (or thousands) of people that have now heard about this beer (and brewery) due to this controversy, and Burnside handled it well, so if anything this was a good dose of PR for them.
     
    Horbar and ZX6Chris like this.
  11. Sneers

    Sneers Savant (385) New Jersey Dec 27, 2009

    edit: Eh, nevermind. I don't really feel like having this debate again.
     
    ZX6Chris and halo21 like this.
  12. LostTraveler

    LostTraveler Savant (375) Maine Oct 28, 2011

    Release super limited release unannounced- irritate the ultra sensative, pull from shelves..... BOOM insta whale.
     
  13. Classy response by Burnside.

    Dumb response by those people who are demanding an apology from the US Ambassador. Yes, we can make fun of your god and all of the other religions gods and characters in this country, get over it. I do find Rajeev Shukla's comment interesting though and believe that it really shows that this is just a political game for the other political party.
     
  14. They still sell this with the same label so I guess nothing happened.
     
  15. Pahn

    Pahn Advocate (695) New York Dec 2, 2009

    the right way to respond to things like this. they meant no harm, and when they found out they were trivializing someone's religion, they pulled it. everything working as it should.
     
    halo21, Sneers, NWer and 1 other person like this.
  16. Nobody has mentioned it yet, but Burnside did send a keg last weekend to the Breakside Brewery 2nd Anniversary; the beer formerly known as "Kali-Ma" was redubbed "Bad Karma"... :)

    Regardless of what they called it I thought it was pretty awesome, a super-strength version of their pepper/apricot favorite of mine, "Sweet Heat".
     
  17. sacrelicio

    sacrelicio Initiate (0) Minnesota Feb 15, 2005

    It's not just the use of that deity for a label, it shows a revered deity surrounded by the heads of her victims. As Beer Singh states, the deity represents feminine power and destruction of evil. I can see it being disrespectful portraying her as an evil cartoonish figure committing violent acts. What if instead of a Hindu figure they had Jesus with a machine gun mowing down people covered in blood? If they did, Christian groups would be angry, and no one would fault them.
     
    ZX6Chris and buffs9 like this.
  18. Spider889

    Spider889 Advocate (650) Ohio Mar 24, 2010

    I agree that the label (esp the art) was in poor taste. And I think the brewery has done a stand-up job in dealing with the initial backlash that came out of it. But things are getting phenomenally out of control now that they are demanding a formal national apology from a political official. No one has said that the Hindu followers are at fault or in some way not entitled to be offended - that's a given.

    This would be like the Republican Party asking India to force its US Ambassador to apologize to the US because the "offensive" Jesus label you describe was being used at some tiny unknown local business. Does that make the use of the label ok? No. Does it make the request for a State apology an insane overreaction? Hell yes.

    I mean, if we really tried we could likely find some similar situation going on in virtually any country that we could claim was offensive. Let's start asking every nation to waste their valuable time and money on public apologies for the largely unknown (and fully innocent) actions of small segments of their population.
     
  19. Keith238

    Keith238 Savant (290) New Jersey Jul 31, 2007

    That is the issue and the point that should have been made Rajan Med. Free speech is one thing, being disrespectful simply because you can is quite another. It was the right move to change things up.
     
  20. IpeeA

    IpeeA Savant (365) Missouri Jan 22, 2010

    ISO: the beer with this label!!!!!
     
    suspect likes this.
  21. BeerSingh

    BeerSingh Savant (415) India Jul 25, 2009

    The normal rendition of kali - ma is

    [​IMG]

    That is kali ma with severed demon head(s) in hand and around neck, with weapon, and accidentally stepping on Lord Shiva her husband. This portrayal of Kali Ma is the most common, as I pointed out before signifying feminine power, destruction of evil and power. The Burnside rendition, although animated seems to be pretty ok.
     
  22. Spider889

    Spider889 Advocate (650) Ohio Mar 24, 2010

    LOL now I am even more confused about the situation...
     
    IpeeA likes this.
  23. BeerSingh

    BeerSingh Savant (415) India Jul 25, 2009

    Well thats just normal Hindu "intolerance"....I think i should not write more. Need to stick to beer on these forums.
     
  24. Spider889

    Spider889 Advocate (650) Ohio Mar 24, 2010

    Good idea.

    I still get that the use of Religious symbols by non-believers to sell beer could easily offend the right people (the article on the apology mentions the conservative party). Hopefully this just blows over before starting some sort of unnecessary rift between governments.

    But no one has even mentioned the most important part in this whole story yet - what happens to all those bottled beers?!? Please think of the beer! If the brewery had to re-label hundreds of bottles at expense or if the issue delayed the beer past its freshness tolerance then that would truly be a sad day! ;)
     
    ZX6Chris and BeerSingh like this.
  25. PhilLesh

    PhilLesh Initiate (0) Massachusetts Jul 30, 2007

    Either way, that is a cool label.
     
    IpeeA likes this.
  26. IpeeA

    IpeeA Savant (365) Missouri Jan 22, 2010

    I actually really appreciate you putting up this image. It's quite informative for those of us who are completely ignorant on the subject. And I appreciate you saying that the Burnside rendition is "pretty ok."
    So now my even more invigorated response to this whole thing is just as it was before: SO IT REALLY DOESN'T EVEN MATTER!!!???
     
    ZX6Chris likes this.
  27. BeerSingh

    BeerSingh Savant (415) India Jul 25, 2009

    It actually doesn't matter at all.
     
    ZX6Chris likes this.
  28. Nor has Avery had any issues with their Maharaja IPA. The world of political correctness allows you to pick and choose what offends you.
    I'm Buddhist and this doesn't offend me in the slightest. Then again, I have nothing to gain by it offending me.
     
    Beerandraiderfan likes this.
  29. sacrelicio

    sacrelicio Initiate (0) Minnesota Feb 15, 2005

    Maharaja is not a religious figure, it just means "great king".
     
  30. Thank you Google, but I'm well aware of what the term means. I was pointing out that Maharaja (name and label picture) is taken from Hindu culture and used for commercial use without any backlash.
     
    Beerandraiderfan likes this.
  31. Spider889

    Spider889 Advocate (650) Ohio Mar 24, 2010

    But you seem to fail to appreciate that there is a difference. This would be like the difference between them depicting an image of Jesus vs depicting an image of George Washington. Even the conservatives wouldn't likely blink an eye at the GW image, but the Jesus one would likely ruffle a few feathers.

    You could always argue that the opposers of this label are unaware of the others like Maharaja, but either way, I think there is enough of an appreciable difference to explain away this comparison.
     
  32. I find it fascinating that this subject has been broached so rationally on this forum. Color me shocked. That said...if the most recently depicted image is an actual portrayal, I really don't see why there'd be such a fuss over the label.

    People need to cease taking life so seriously. It's way too short to go apeshit because someone depicts your idea of god in a manner not according to Hoyle. That's all this world has become. Figuring out how to successfully navigate your day without pissing in someone else's Cheerios. The world is so insanely sensitive, I'm surprised people don't get upset when you say the sky is blue.
     
    ZX6Chris, AnchorBaby, IpeeA and 2 others like this.
  33. kevanb

    kevanb Advocate (680) Illinois Apr 4, 2011

    Best beer label ever?
     
  34. Hands22

    Hands22 Aficionado (240) Florida Oct 14, 2011

    [​IMG]
     
  35. Lol this picture should've been the label, it's hilarious. She's got her tongue sticking out, a necklace made out of all the Mario Bros, while standing on top of Shiva who looks like he's having a pretty good time down there.
     
    ZX6Chris, ShogoKawada and vkv822 like this.
  36. You really think the brewery was "being disrespectful simply because [they] can"? Don't you think that notion is kinda debunked by the fact they changed it?

    Furthermore just because a Christian group tends to protest because IMHO they're crazies, doesn't mean we all subscribe to such ill sighted outrage. The Westboro Baptist Church, nuff said. I'm constantly reminded not to judge Islam as a whole every time someone explodes something in the name of Islam. . . it makes sense, so shouldn't that rationale apply otherwise as well?

    I've never heard any recalls or outrage over, nor would I support any of the Helen Lovejoy "Won't someone think of the children/people's feelings" when it comes to:

    Ten Commandments, Serpent's Stout, Back Hand of God, The Reverend (and about a dozen more God, Christian or Jesus named beers). . . much less that label with the priest getting blown by the kid.
     
    teal, bushycook and glitchedmind like this.
  37. sacrelicio

    sacrelicio Initiate (0) Minnesota Feb 15, 2005

    Oh I agree, but then again I'm not Christian or religious at all.
     
  38. Kwatt99

    Kwatt99 Aficionado (155) Louisiana Mar 27, 2010

    This label is pretty badass! I think it silly that burnside gave in and changed their label. Such a delicate situation in this country which is ridiculous IMO. I find Halloween offensive, we should have Jolly Pumpkin (and all others) change their label to, and so on.
     
  39. Jason

    Jason Founder (1,330) Massachusetts Aug 23, 1996 Staff Member

    South Park should do a short clip about this.
     
    ZX6Chris, Dunkelhund and Spider889 like this.
  40. RedMedicine

    RedMedicine Savant (340) Oregon Jun 3, 2005

    You mean the label, or the beer experts on the Internet pretending they know what someone should or shouldnt be offended about?
     
    Chaz likes this.

Share This Page