Dismiss Notice
Hello, is it beer you're looking for?

Learn more about beer. Get 12 issues / year of BeerAdvocate magazine for as low as 68% off the single issue price.

Subscribe now →

The Guinness drinker

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by flyingtoaster, Mar 29, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Have you ever met someone who drinks Guinness exclusively? They belong in the same insane asylum as people who buy nothing but Apple products.

    The other day, after the gym, I was looking for a place to sit down and have a beer before my girl got off work. I went to Boston's Pizza because it was nearby and they have some okay beers on tap. The bar was pretty empty except for an older couple watching the game, and I took a spot near the end and ordered a Lagunitas IPA. A guy sat down next to me, older, heavyset, wearing a baseball cap with a shamrock on it. And he looked like a talker. I heard him grunt in distress over something. Then I felt his face looking at me. He said, "Can you believe that?" pointing at a small Guinness poster advertising a Black and Tan. I told him, "Yeah, I don't like to mix my beers either. I can't believe a brewery would encourage it." I thought, hey, theres nobody else here to talk to and this guy probably knows a thing or two about good beer. I never find people I can talk about beer with. Then he ordered 5 Guinness stouts. Holy crap, he's buying a round for everyone. Or so I thought. Then he told me "That way, if happy hour is almost over, your drinks are already in the system." Nevermind that happy hour was over at 7 and it was only 5:30. This guy only had an hour and a half to get his drinks in. I asked him, "So you must really like Guinness, huh?" That was my first mistake. He went on a long tangent about how what you could drink is determined by your ethnic decent, and since he was part Irish, he was naturally able to drink Guinness. I was bored, so I decided to push all his buttons. I told him American Guinness tasted like water. He explained that was because of how it was poured when I had it, and it tastes completely different when the bartender does the "perfect pour." Then he called over the bartender and told her that his Guinness did not taste right because she did not pour it correctly. They went back and forth, and ultimately, he did not get a free drink out of it. Then he told me that my beer was actually watered down compared to his Guinness. I said, "Laguintas is pretty watered down for an IPA. It pretty much has the minimum legal amount of hops and alcohol to be considered an IPA. Still, it is an IPA and it is a more substantial beer than Guinness in spite of being lighter in color. Yours, however, is not a stout. The only Guinness Stout I have ever had was Foreign Extra and it was good. Then he explained how nitro tap is superior and how in Ireland, that is how they serve Guinness, and that if you need a stronger or hoppier beer, your taste buds are just craving more of a certain thing and cannot appreciate a refined beverage. I took my check and bid adieu. His next Guinness was not a perfect pour either.
    Jake1605 and darky like this.
  2. billandsuz

    billandsuz Savant (460) New York Sep 1, 2004

    you might be putting too much mental effort into who drinks what. it's just beer.
    that's just my opinion anyway.
  3. Nectar

    Nectar Savant (310) New Jersey Jan 17, 2013

    Not sure what it is about some people and thier Guinness, but its crazy.I watched a ~80 year old man go absolutely apeshit over the way his guinness was poured in a dive bar more than once.

    Not a big craft community here though, so hard to say if someone would do the same for an IPA...
    Zimbo likes this.
  4. HomeBrewed

    HomeBrewed Savant (425) Minnesota Dec 10, 2006 Verified

    Alrighty then...

    P.S. If you didn't read this in an Ace Ventura voice, I feel sorry for you.
  5. Guinness is the Bose of beer.
    ant880, ufmj, audioserf and 3 others like this.
  6. Maybe I'm overreacting, but I needed to explain this insanity to people who would understand.
  7. darky

    darky Savant (270) South Dakota Apr 16, 2010

    I fail to see the distinction between someone who drinks Guinness exclusively and someone who drinks Bud Light exclusively. Both have their mind made up that 'X' is the is THE beer and don't entertain the possibllity that any other brew will bring them greater satisfaction. I appreciate your post and enjoyed the story, however I've come to the conclusion that people of such a mindset will only change their opinion when they are ready.

    P.S.- I am a total Apple fanboy and buy Apple products pretty much exclusively when it comes to personal computing products. Are 'Apple people' crazy? Yes, we are... but happily so.
  8. I dig myself a Guinness every now and then for sure, especially when mixed with a Cele - but I gotta say the best Guinness I ever had was poured into a paper cup. It was phenomenal. ...I was also baked, though...just thought I should throw that in there...
    jcreegan likes this.
  9. yeah, some people tend to make too much of a big deal of brands of beer - I went to a house party once celebrating an exclusive guinness drinker's birthday. I got him a craft-brewed coffee porter that I like, and thought he'd enjoy, and he ended up giving it to another guy. To each their own I suppose, beer is beer is beer, and I've been known to have, and sometimes even crave, a guinness every now and then.
  10. OneBeertoRTA

    OneBeertoRTA Advocate (640) California Jan 2, 2010 Verified

    I've never thrown on a grammar police uniform before, but a couple of paragraphs would have really helped there.:confused:

    I've had the Guiness draught drinkers make the snide comments about my weak IPAs before more than a few times. It hasn't happened lately since the taps have changed greatly in the past 2 or 3 years but I always say the same thing. If I wanted a low abv, low cal, tasteless hype brew I would choose Guiness Draught, fortunately i'm not on a diet and I drink for taste.
    steveh likes this.
  11. Frankinstiener

    Frankinstiener Savant (405) Illinois Jul 28, 2009 Verified

    "I told him American Guinness tasted like water" "The only Guinness Stout I have ever had was Foreign Extra and it was good." Hmm so the only Guinness you have ever had was good... but tasted water? Or are you saying a beer that you have never had tastes like water?
    If the only Guinness Stout you have ever tried is the Foreign Extra than why do you think that "Guinness is not a stout"? Foreign extra is a pretty good stout and Guinness Draught is a classic Irish Dry Stout. If you haven't tried it then how do you know that Lagunitas IPA "is a more substantial beer" than it. In no way is Lagunitas IPA watered down either. "It pretty much has the minimum legal amount of hops and alcohol to be considered an IPA." This isn't true either, it's pretty much middle of the road in both. I think you spewed more false information during your guys' conversation then he did.
  12. willbm3

    willbm3 Savant (380) Massachusetts Feb 19, 2010

    I don't see what the big deal is here. Just a guy who only wants to drink one thing. I'd rather be friends with people who only drink Guinness than those who only drink Bud Light, but I'm not drinking it so I don't care.

    The only thing that kills me is the people that insist Guinness is SO heavy and SO filling. I understand arguing about taste and stuff, but how can you just objectively be wrong about something you're consuming? It's like claiming a side salad is more filling than a crock of mashed potatoes.
  13. Vitacca

    Vitacca Advocate (725) Montana Sep 15, 2010 Verified

    I appreciate the perfect pour, however, I do not understand people that go crazy if it's poured incorrectly. It all tastes the same in the end.
  14. " minimum legal amount of hops" ??
    when was hop content of IPAs entered into the criminal code?
    BJCP lists IPA as 40-60/70 (english/american).
    If you are going to flex your beer knowledge and talk down to someone no matter how ignorant of their own facts, at least drop some factual knowledge.
  15. BILF

    BILF Advocate (725) Israel Jan 9, 2010

    Part Irish. Ordering five beers at a time. And you decide to push his buttons. Lucky you did not cop a knuckling.
  16. paulys55

    paulys55 Advocate (735) Pennsylvania Aug 2, 2010 Verified

    I used to drink Guinness almost exclusively...this was 15 years ago when most bars in the area had Guinness, Bass and a bunch of adjunct lagers on tap. But if someone wants to drink whatever, who am I to care. Live and let live.
  17. raynmoon

    raynmoon Advocate (620) California Aug 13, 2011 Verified

    Just stop, stop right there.
  18. fx20736

    fx20736 Advocate (590) New York Mar 7, 2009 Verified

    thank you for that amusing story. I would have been quite tickled had I been in your situation.

    Beer should make you happy. Crazy ignorant people are funny when you have a beer buzz.

    good presentation, tho. Well written.

  19. Jake1605

    Jake1605 Initiate (0) Missouri Nov 24, 2009

    I love dumb guy stories. Keep em' coming!
  20. An Irish guy in a bar in Boston, where there is a Guinness poster on the wall, and the happy hour special is Guinness Draught. You were surprised by his affection for Guinness?
    CwrwAmByth likes this.
  21. Guessing OP had this conversation in his head while only managing a brief glance and head nod at this supposed offender. That and the facts are probably at least 50% inflated. 2 beers at once, complained about the pour - probably end of story
    Frankinstiener and RBCORCORAN like this.
  22. That was a bad story and you should feel bad.

    Oh my god there's an old Irish alcoholic talking about Guinness myths. That's a really interesting and surprising thing, which probably never happens.
  23. steveh

    steveh Champion (895) Illinois Oct 8, 2003

    What do you suppose the other "part" was, and why couldn't he drink from that lineage as well?
  24. steveh

    steveh Champion (895) Illinois Oct 8, 2003

    If you double-check, the OP is in California, and a quick search of Boston's Pizza reveals they don't even have locations in Massachusetts. Never assume.
  25. Hanzo

    Hanzo Champion (965) Virginia Feb 27, 2012

    While we're telling stories, Guinness almost scared me off of "stouts" when I first got into drinking beer because I thought it was the quintessential representative of the style, and if that were the case, stouts weren't for me.
  26. brikelly

    brikelly Savant (470) Massachusetts Apr 11, 2010 Verified

    Sissification, Guinnessication, it's all the same at this point.
    5thOhio likes this.
  27. steveh

    steveh Champion (895) Illinois Oct 8, 2003

    Which Guinness? As has been reported by many in the past (almost ad nauseam to blinder-wearing BAs who don't want to learn it), Guinness is available in many different forms of stout.
  28. Hanzo

    Hanzo Champion (965) Virginia Feb 27, 2012

    dachshunddude86 likes this.
  29. Ericness

    Ericness Savant (255) Massachusetts Nov 21, 2012

    Sadly Boston isn't allowed to do Happy Hours....or drink specials of any kind. It's what the locals refer to as "one of those stupid Massachusetts things."

    I like a good Guinness every now and then myself, and was even a semi-regular drinker of the beer myself in my later college days. It's now my fall back option if I'm out and the beer and scotch menus don't have anything I want more. In the spirit of this post though, I went to a Dropkick Murphys show last St. Paddy's day in Boston and felt obligated to drink solely Guinness over the Harpoon offerings.
  30. He should have slapped you in your goddamned face.
  31. steveh

    steveh Champion (895) Illinois Oct 8, 2003

    I don't think there's a "regular" kind listed at the Guinness web site (or BA). That would be the draught. Probably more specifically, the nitro draught. But thanks for confirming that there are definitely a few to choose from without just saying "I don't like Guinness."
  32. Hanzo

    Hanzo Champion (965) Virginia Feb 27, 2012

    So is Guinness Draught not the most commonly available version in American bars? (honestly asking) because where I am it is, which is why I called it "regular".
    dachshunddude86 likes this.
  33. I have had both Guinness Draught and Foreign Extra. I was saying that Laguinitas still qualifies as an IPA, but I would not consider Guinness Draught to be a Stout. I can see why some people would, so I'm not going to get into an argument about it.
  34. Actually, there was more to it. I decided to forget some of the more ignorant comments.
  35. Perhaps you can explain this scale and maybe how Scoville units work too. Or maybe IBUs are a qualitative guesstimate of how bitter a beer is, usually from the brewer. Off topic, but Lagunitas IPA tastes more like every Pale Ale I have ever had than a few of the IPA style examples that I drink regularly. Whether you agree, I don't care.
  36. ktblue22

    ktblue22 Aficionado (230) Vermont Feb 15, 2013

    I read everything in an Ace Ventura voice...
    HipsterBrewfus and dwagner003 like this.
  37. Guinness isn't a stout?? thats just plain ignorant. why not?

    Why do you care so much about what some other guy you don't even know is drinking?
    kingofhop and steveh like this.
  38. you're lucky you didn't catch a brogue kick to the domepiece
  39. ktblue22

    ktblue22 Aficionado (230) Vermont Feb 15, 2013

    Also how funny is it that in Boston they have California Pizza Kitchen but in California they have Boston's Pizza???
    Horbar and nickfl like this.
  40. steveh

    steveh Champion (895) Illinois Oct 8, 2003

    Now we're singling out bars only? I have bars near me that carry all 3 (now), and just about every store I go into will have at least 2 of the 3, if not all 3.

    How about the fact that Guinness Extra was the only Guinness available in the U.S. for a very long time?

    To my original point, you can't single out the Draught as Guinness. Guinness has a larger portfolio than that.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.