Beers from just 10 breweries - which do you choose?

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by Rochefort10nh, Mar 24, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. LIQUORBARREL

    LIQUORBARREL Initiate (0) Oct 16, 2009 Minnesota

    Surly
    CCB
    RR
    3F
    Cantillon
    Goose Island
    Big Sky
    Bruery
    Toggling Goliath
    Sierra Nevada
     
  2. Lantern

    Lantern Initiate (0) Feb 27, 2011

    Dogfish Head
    Founders
    Stone
    Oskar Blues
    Avery
    Lagunitas
    Firestone Walker
    Russian River
    Three Floyds
    Great Divide
     
  3. savagepm

    savagepm Initiate (0) Dec 12, 2011 Pennsylvania

    Cantillon
    Crooked Stave
    The Bruery
    Russian River
    Hill Farmstead
    Allagash
    Cascade
    Funky Buddha
    Jolly Pumpkin
    Firestone Walker
     
  4. jreindl

    jreindl Initiate (0) Apr 14, 2013 Wisconsin

    Surly
    Mikkeller
    Founders
    Jolly Pumpkin
    Toppling Goliath
    Goose Island
    Half Acre
    FFF
    21st Amendment
    Lagunitas
     
  5. Groomsy

    Groomsy Initiate (0) Sep 23, 2010 Kentucky

    In no order...

    1. Stone
    2. Dogfish Head
    3. West Sixth
    4. Sierra Nevada
    5. Bell's
    6. Great Lakes
    7. Goose Island
    8. Unibroe
    9. Oskar Blues
    10. Warsteiner (seriously, could drink Premium Verum all day every day)
     
    ZachKelly likes this.
  6. striker2160

    striker2160 Savant (1,172) May 5, 2013 Minnesota
    Trader

    Goose Island
    Bells
    Toppling Goliath
    Surly
    Founders
    Central Waters
    Actually 6 is plenty for me. I am not greedy.
     
  7. Quantum_Dong

    Quantum_Dong Initiate (0) Apr 18, 2013 Wisconsin

    1. New Glarus
    2. Surly
    3. Central Waters
    4. Sierra Nevada
    5. Stone
    6. Lagunitas
    7. Cigar City
    8. Revolution
    9. Bent Paddle (Local brewery that opened up about a month ago. Fantastic stuff)
    10. Pabst ( I need my PBR from time to time)
     
  8. BeerKangaroo

    BeerKangaroo Initiate (0) May 30, 2011 Alaska

    The top 5 mentioned on my profile, and the following honorable mention:

    DFH
    Stone
    Rogue
    Ommegang
    Sierra Nevada

    Tough time leaving off Rising Tide and Great Lakes, sigh....

    But I've never had anything by HF, Surly, Central Waters, Toppling Goliath, Lawson's or Cantillon, so I can't give 'em any love yet.
     
  9. rgfellow

    rgfellow Aspirant (287) Feb 9, 2013 New Mexico

    No order...

    1. Surly
    2. Russian River
    3. Weihenstephaner
    4. Hill Farmstead
    5. Toppling Goliath
    6. Founders
    7. FFF
    8. Prairie Artisan
    9. Great Lakes
    10. La Cumbre
     
  10. dgeebs07

    dgeebs07 Initiate (0) Aug 6, 2011 New York

    Stone
    DFH
    Ommegang
    Jolly Pumpkin
    Captain Lawrence
    Troegs
    Lagunitas
    Sierra Nevada
    Unibroue
    Southern Tier
     
  11. SortaAmbivalent

    SortaAmbivalent Pundit (871) Sep 11, 2005 Minnesota

    Surly
    Bells
    Stone
    Sierra Nevada
    Lagunitas
    Tallgrass
    Toppling Goliath
    Central Waters
    New Glarus
    Steel Toe

    Of course, no particular order.
     
  12. RaggaD

    RaggaD Initiate (0) Jun 29, 2013 Florida

    In no particular order...

    Funky Buddha
    Stone
    Southern Tier
    Dogfish Head
    Ommegang
    St. Bernardus
    Cigar City
    Russian River
    New Glarus
    Victory
     
  13. PorterLambic

    PorterLambic Initiate (0) Nov 26, 2003 Florida

    Wow, how to sum it all up in just 10. Let's see if I can. In no order at all.

    1. Unibroue
    2. Cigar City
    3. Founders
    4. Avery
    5. Three Floyds
    6. Verhaege and every other Belgian brewery
    7. Southern Tier
    8. Dogfish Head
    9. Funky Buddha
    10. Kostritzer, Great Lakes, Left Hand, Bell's, Stone, Goose Island, Brooklyn, St. Somewhere & about 47 others plus all those I haven't had yet.
     
  14. youngac

    youngac Crusader (496) Jul 14, 2005 North Carolina

    Toppling Goliath
    Founders
    Three Floyd's
    Ballast point
    Alpine
    Russian river
    Cantillon
    Goose island (just for BCBS and variants)
    Odells
    Firestone walker
     
  15. Hanby

    Hanby Initiate (0) Jun 1, 2011 Michigan

    1. Bell's
    2. Founder's
    3. Oskar Blue's
    4. Dogfish Head
    5. Short's
    6. New Glarus
    7. Samuel Smith
    8. Goose Island
    9. Frankenmuth Brewery (because it's near by)
     
  16. Hopsiam14

    Hopsiam14 Initiate (0) Jan 23, 2013 Minnesota

    Surly
    Hill Farmstead
    Goose Island
    Alchemist
    Cigar City
    Russian River
    Lost Abbey
    Founders
    New Glarus
    Toppling Goliath
     
  17. Doc_Hops

    Doc_Hops Initiate (0) Feb 5, 2013 Pennsylvania

    Dogfish Head
    Goose Island
    Firestone Walker
    Lagunitas
    Russian River
    Cantillon
    Victory
    Sierra Nevada
    Founders
    Ballast Point
     
  18. agman05

    agman05 Initiate (0) May 21, 2009 Texas

    For my first post(as a long time lurker)...while I'm drinking a Pliny the Elder after a trip to Colorado I have to start with

    Russian River (Everything)
    Stone (Everything)
    Firestone Walker (Any Jack)
    Victory (Prima Pils and Tripel)
    Odell (IPA, St. Lupulin)
    St. Arnold's (from Texas and love Endeavor IPA)
    North Coast (Old Rasputin)
    Oskar Blues (Everything)
    Founder's (just started distributing to TX so have only had a couple so far...Centennial IPA is really good)
    Lagunitas(Lil Sumpin Sumpin & Hop Stoopid)
     
  19. josephwa

    josephwa Maven (1,342) Jun 4, 2012 Minnesota
    Trader

    1. Hill Farmstead
    2. Founders
    3. Toppling Goliath
    4. The Bruery
    5. Surly
    6. Goose Island
    7. Bells
    8. Firestone Walker
    9. Fitger's Brewhouse
    10. Town Hall
     
  20. VictorWisc

    VictorWisc Maven (1,379) Jan 2, 2013 Massachusetts

    Quick summary of the current count as of 12:30 AM EDT (last included agman05). I threw the rankings into a spreadsheet and tabulated the count. Note that some people did not exactly "play by the rules" and gave either more or fewer breweries. Some named specific beers rather than brewers--that's fine, as I knew which breweries were implied. Side note on Three Floyds: I was not sure how to interpret the notation 3F that appeared half a dozen times. Given that it could represent shorthand for one of three breweries (fff, Three Floyds and Drei Fonteinen), I was not sure hot to count them. Given, however, that the three breweries ended up in different clusters, I chose to interpret 3F to represent Drei Founteinen and FFF to be fff Brewery (UK). Three Floyds got none of those votes, so if it's not what you meant, my apologies. Even moving the 3F and FFF numbers to Three Floyds would not move it up to the next cluster. The numbers otherwise are as close as I could keep them, but might be off by one or two in either direction--this is essentially a computer-aided hand count.

    Exactly 300 breweries got mentioned. Only two breweries have been mentioned, so far, more than 100 times: Founders (133) and Russian River (104). No other brewery came close!

    Next cluster had between 78 and 81 mentions (in descending order):
    Lagunitas Brewing Co.
    Sierra Nevada Brewing Co. (a.k.a. SN)
    Stone Brewing Co.

    The next cluster is from 71 to 67, followed by the cluster from 59 to 52:

    Bell's Brewery (a.k.a. Bells, Bell, etc.)
    Firestone Walker Brewing Co. (also listed as Firestone)
    Goose Island Beer Co. (GI)

    Brasserie Cantillon (mostly listed as Cantillon)
    Three Floyds Brewing Co. (also 3Floyds, but not 3F or FFF)
    Cigar City Brewing (CCB)
    Hills Farmstead Brewery (HF)
    Dogfish Head Brewery (DFH)

    That is it. The rest of the breweries got mentioned fewer than 40 times. Those getting at least 15 mentions were:
    Deschutes, Surly, New Glarus, Drei Fonteinen (including 3F), Ommegang, Victory, Great Lakes, The Bruery, Weihenstephaner, Great Divide, Alesmith, Troegs, Ballast Point, Southern Tier, Allagash, The Alchemist, Lost Abbey, Green Flash, Oskar Blues, Alpine, Toppling Goliath, Boulevard, Samuel Smith.

    That's 36 top-mentioned breweries, in order. This is followed by about 120 that had more than one mention (with top three missing out being De Struisse, New Belgium and Odell), and another 150 or so that got only a single mention. If there's a call for the full spreadsheet (not exactly a work of science), I can post a Google Drive link. But I would just as well skip the complete list.
     
    Rochefort10nh, HOMEPL8 and utopiajane like this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.