Updates to the Top Rated Beers (Part Two)

Also, I got back the 20 I lost after the previous update! Now at 181. I’m going to get there!

 

I would agree with this - adding back the "BA Score" in between the "Score" and "Yours" would be helpful.

Given that all the scores are between 98 - 100 with the exception of 2 - it begs to question - how far can the list go on with this being the case? One thought is to add a decimal point - but this would probably be too messy to the eye. The other thought is to adjust your 1 - 100 scale - I think it's too liberal. Example - I drank a Trillium Pilsner a few days ago that rates a 3.92 based on BA's 1 - 5 scale; but on the 1 - 100 - it received an 85, or a "very good". That doesn't translate to me. A 3.92 isn't very good at all, I'd suggest it's something closer to something in the mid to high 70s. I'm sure there's some sliding scale that can easily correlate this. In effect, that would lower most of the ratings.

A problem with this - is that the BA scores, if and when they start getting taped up next to Untappd scores in liquor stores, might be seen to be across the board lower than Untappd scores - so liquor stores may avoid using BA scores if this is the case. Anyway, I'm sure I could carry this logic further but I'll let others do it in case my logic is flawed...or add to it if not. Thanks and cheers!

 

Looks good to me, cool that so many people added comments and allowed for this tweak in order to make it work for everyone.
Cheers

 

Awesome thanks for the work, Todd

 

Ability to quickly navigate 'top' lists to narrow into specific categories is much improved over the old. It's great to have the lists back as well.

Thanks for taking our feedback into consideration, @Todd .

 

Love having the lists back and the new navigation is way better. I've always thought having the beer listing show where the beer ranks would be nice and now it's there!

A side note- has Red / Amber ales always been listed under the Pale Ales category while Red / Amber lagers are listed under the Dark Lagers? Seems like an odd discrepancy.

Otherwise, thanks for the quick action on this. It shows how much you value the community's input.

 

So without clicking on each beer, how do you differentiate between two scores of 100? Beers on the old scale that have 4.52 and 4.7 are now essentially the same other than where they are on the list. I guess I liked the granularity of the old system and if a ton of beers are 100 how do you tell them apart?

 

I witnessed this happen over the years. So, I fully support your reason for re-adding it, but think that the average being a focus as well is more beneficial for users - which is ultimately more important for the longevity of the site/app.

 

Looks great, better than before for sure. You guys are really awesome, i appreciate the constant effort to improve and the engagement with feedback, including negative feedback. Thanks again for everything

 

Everything looks great! Thank you!