Beers Similar to Saint Arnolds DR12?

Discussion in 'Southwest' started by TakeFlight, Feb 17, 2013.

  1. TakeFlight

    TakeFlight Feb 17, 2013 Texas

    Does anyone know of any beers that are similar in taste to DR12? I would like to age it, but don't think I have the will power not to finish off my stash. Just wondering if there are any beers that are pretty similar that are readily available.
  2. champ103

    champ103 Sep 3, 2007 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Look for North Coast Old Stock. They are in four packs that can be found pretty easily. Also Great Divide Hibernation is another good one. Six packs of that should still be sitting around.
    mrkmrk, wsnich and pwsoldier like this.
  3. Cablejelly

    Cablejelly Sep 6, 2010 Texas

    Every now and then you can still find some 2011 Old Stock sitting around too. That'll give you an idea of what this should develop in to eventually. and maybe help you let it age a bit.
  4. Lutter

    Lutter Jun 30, 2010 Texas

    Comparing DR12 to Old Stock Ale is insulting to Old Stock Ale.
    tofuspeedstar, jsboots21 and lokieman like this.
  5. Cablejelly

    Cablejelly Sep 6, 2010 Texas

  6. champ103

    champ103 Sep 3, 2007 Texas
    Beer Trader

    I am not a huge fan of DR12 either, but come on, do people really have to diss on Saint Arnold every chance they get? The guy likes it, and wants other Old Ales. Not to hard to give a few recommendations.
    boogercrack, Ford and wsnich like this.
  7. Lutter

    Lutter Jun 30, 2010 Texas

    ... I'd say that was a recommendation for Old Stock Ale. ;)

    And I'll diss any beer I want to. :p

    Here's a recommendation that might be coming soon to TX: Founders' Curmudgeon.
  8. BruceBruce

    BruceBruce Dec 4, 2011 Texas

    Tried one yesterday, and it has started to develop quite nicely... Much better then when released
  9. Grendle

    Grendle Apr 11, 2012 Texas
    Beer Trader

    It clearly asked for similar beers to DR12 and yes you can diss any beer you want but why $hit on a beer someone likes?
    cfh64, HoustonZ33 and champ103 like this.
  10. pushstartnow13

    pushstartnow13 Nov 28, 2011 Texas

    Eel River Triple Exultation!! Their 2007 vintage version picked up gold at GABF this year in vintage ale category. But if you drink it now you will not be disappointed one bit.
    champ103 likes this.
  11. HoustonZ33

    HoustonZ33 Sep 10, 2012 Texas

    OP: Hello my friend lol - We're in the same boat. Old Stock Ale is not DR12, Not even close - It's wayyyyy stronger... Same with Hibernation Ale.

    I've done a LOT of the Legwork for you, Trust me lol - The closest thing I've had to DR12 is Real Ale Devil's Backbone however it's still not quite it but, I've heard that Founder's Curmudgeon Old Ale is a Dead Ringer for DR12 and I'm prolly gonna catch hell on here for saying this but, I've even heard some say DR12 = "St. Arnold's Curmudgeon"

    Problem is Founder's isn't sold in Texas (yet) and it's a Limited Seasonal Beer so it's gonna take some trades to get it until Founder's is sold in Texas around April - May of this year. Also, Curmudgeon is only sold March/April then it's gone - We'd prolly won't see it on shelves here in Houston till March/April 2014 sadly.

    I've had the Barrel Aged Version of Curmudgeon (called Curmudgeon's Better Half) and, I'm happy to report that it appears to be true. Tasted like a sweeter DR12 with Bourbon to me. As a fellow DR12 lover, let me know if you find anything in the meantime.

    For what it's worth Curmudgeon Old Ale will start hitting shelves up north in March, I'm from Cleveland, OH so I have friends that send me goodies from time to time. Once I try it I'll be happy to report my findings.
  12. rainerschuhsler

    rainerschuhsler May 17, 2012 Texas
    Beer Trader

  13. starkmarvelo

    starkmarvelo Jan 20, 2010 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Fullers Vintage Ale
  14. lokieman

    lokieman Jan 20, 2011 Oklahoma

    Isn't that a Tripel...? That tastes nothing like DR12...?
    blatherbeard likes this.
  15. Cablejelly

    Cablejelly Sep 6, 2010 Texas

    I was thinking the same.
    blatherbeard likes this.
  16. videofrog

    videofrog Nov 13, 2010 Texas

    They both have that chocolately goodness.;)

    Lutter likes this.
  17. HoustonZ33

    HoustonZ33 Sep 10, 2012 Texas

    It tastes similar to me lol
  18. TakeFlight

    TakeFlight Feb 17, 2013 Texas

    lol, yeah Devil's Backbone is not what I'm looking for. Thanks everyone for all the ole ale recommendations. Sounds like the first 2 suggestions are the most readily available, whether they actually resemble DR12 or not.
  19. NiceFly

    NiceFly Dec 22, 2011 Tajikistan

    The only reason I watched that until the end is because I was hoping he used one of those knives to impale himself in the neck.

    Back on track, I have to agree Old Stock and Old Crumbuttler are very good. Never had DR12 and unfortunatley the only other Old Ale I have had is Jasperilla, which is OK, maybe worth trying.
    blatherbeard likes this.
  20. mattisloco

    mattisloco Feb 13, 2007 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Is this years out?
  21. NiceFly

    NiceFly Dec 22, 2011 Tajikistan

    I do not know, I have not had it in a while.
    I did not see it at the Smith St Specs the other day, or I probably would have picked it up.
  22. lokieman

    lokieman Jan 20, 2011 Oklahoma

    I imagine it's probably last year's...didn't exactly fly off the shelf
  23. mattisloco

    mattisloco Feb 13, 2007 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Thanks. I kind of enjoyed the last one I had a year or so ago. Someone at Whip In told me to sit on it a year, I did and found it worth drinking... I didn't enjoy the fresh one as much.
  24. BlindSalimander

    BlindSalimander Aug 16, 2010 Texas

    I am insane now Chuck.
  25. mattisloco

    mattisloco Feb 13, 2007 Texas
    Beer Trader

    He really is something special
  26. Lutter

    Lutter Jun 30, 2010 Texas

    Hahaha, this guy is an awesome reviewer.
  27. HoustonZ33

    HoustonZ33 Sep 10, 2012 Texas

    I just cracked a 12oz DR12 open tonight, this is NOT the same beer I knew and loved anymore - it's getting really strong, really bitter and just rougher overall. (and, I think I was spoiled by Better Half)

    It used to have that nice creamy and buttery bread taste to it - That shit is gone. It's starting to taste more like all the other Old Ales and Barleywines out there.

    If Curmudgeon really is as good as I've always been told it is - I'm prolly going to unload my Stash here in a bit and replace it all with Curmudgeon.
  28. Cablejelly

    Cablejelly Sep 6, 2010 Texas

    I don't know if I loved it as much as you did when it was fresh but I had one about 3-4 weeks ago and it did take a turn for the worse. I figured it was at a stage that I just won't enjoy so I'd hold the rest for a few more months before sampling it again. It was known right off the bat that this was meant to age, SA released it with that recommendation... I was hoping to see this develop into something amazing throughout the years but this last one was sub-par at best.
    HoustonZ33 likes this.
  29. twiggamortis420

    twiggamortis420 Jan 4, 2006 Texas

    Paleo-pepperoni and pale ale is da bomb...punch you in the mouth!
    mattisloco likes this.
  30. tx_beer_man

    tx_beer_man Jan 22, 2013 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Not RA's Devil's Backbone.

    Haven't tried NC's Old Stock or GD's Hibernation.

    Just had Avery's Grand Cru and thought it was much better but very similar.
  31. TakeFlight

    TakeFlight Feb 17, 2013 Texas


    I have tried a couple of the recommendations here.

    Eel River - Triple Exultation
    This did not hit the mark for me. It is a decent beer, it just isn't very similar to DR12, and thus maybe not typical of the Old Ale style. Much heavier and darker. Has a roasted malt taste to it. Was just too heavy and dark for my taste.

    North Coast - Old Stock
    Tried 2011 and a 2012. This one is a winner. Very similar in essence to DR12. Similar fruity notes and fairly light body, but a little bit darker. Overall just has more depth to it than DR12. I tried a DR12 again and it just seems sort of one note in comparison. Found this at a couple different Spec's so it must be readily available which is what I was hoping for!
    mattisloco likes this.
  32. HoustonZ33

    HoustonZ33 Sep 10, 2012 Texas

    Add Founder's Curmudgeon to that list. I can now drink the rest of my DR12.
  33. TakeFlight

    TakeFlight Feb 17, 2013 Texas

    Thanks, do you know the status of finding this in Texas?
  34. corbey

    corbey Oct 22, 2006 Texas

    Agreed. I opened a bomber of DR12 on Saturday, as part of a tasting, and was surprised how well it's matured. Now I wish I had more of it!
  35. TakeFlight

    TakeFlight Feb 17, 2013 Texas

    Like I mentioned above, look for North Coast - Old Stock Ale. Will provide similar taste...better IMO.
  36. HoustonZ33

    HoustonZ33 Sep 10, 2012 Texas

    We won't see this in Texas till March 2014. I have a 4 pack left of this years batch if you wanna talk shop, BM me.
  37. DanzBorin

    DanzBorin Apr 11, 2012 Texas

    It's possible to see this sooner. Depends on how much they made and if any is scraggling behind. Was an easy find months after April last year.

    I've still got 4 2012s waiting until the mood strikes... :)
    HoustonZ33 and tx_beer_man like this.
  38. tx_beer_man

    tx_beer_man Jan 22, 2013 Texas
    Beer Trader


    Baseball season starts in 7 days.
  39. HoustonZ33

    HoustonZ33 Sep 10, 2012 Texas

    Trade you a 13 for a 12?
  40. TakeFlight

    TakeFlight Feb 17, 2013 Texas

    Another update:

    Tried a 2011 Independence Brewing Co. - Jasperilla

    Was good! Similar light body and light color as DR12. It is a little different tasting than DR12 and Old Stock, which have similar flavor profiles. This beer tastes like honey! Seriously. I can tell it is in the same ballpark as an old ale like the DR12, but it has a distinct flavor of honey. Would buy again.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer FestĀ® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • Free Trial Subscription

    Reside in the US? Interested in a free 1-month trial subscription to the print edition of BeerAdvocate magazine?

    Yes! Sign Me Up!