Dismiss Notice
We're celebrating 10 years of BeerAdvocate magazine with $10 print subscriptions for US residents.

Subscribe now!

Canada Best beer from a crap Canadian brewery?

Discussion in 'Canada' started by canucklehead, Nov 27, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. canucklehead

    canucklehead Mar 7, 2003 British Columbia (Canada)

    I have to say that Fearless IPA from Deadfrog is amazing eventhough they mostly have pretty terrible beers. Any thoughts on a great beer from a brewer that is mostly meh?
  2. iguenard

    iguenard Jan 30, 2006 Quebec (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    Hmmm... interesting question. A canadian one-hit wonder of sorts?

    I really liked Brasseurs de Montreal's Ghost town despite the rest of their bottled stuff being under par. You really have to like anise though.
  3. kjyost

    kjyost May 4, 2008 Manitoba (Canada)

    Fort Garry Munich Eisbock was nice...
  4. canucklehead

    canucklehead Mar 7, 2003 British Columbia (Canada)

    I thought that was a good beer also plus the Kona coffee stout was decent .

    Also Pacific Western makes a nice 9% Doppelbock in tall cans which is their only decent beer.
  5. matthaslaservision

    matthaslaservision Aug 18, 2012 British Columbia (Canada)

    whoooaaaaa that's a bit of a stretch to call dead frog a crap brewery...
  6. Rutager

    Rutager Oct 18, 2010 British Columbia (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    They aren't crap, but I completely agree they are "meh" for the most part, along with many others.
    I did pick up Fearless, purely based on canucklehead's recommendation. I keep hoping they'll bust out with something great, Citra IPA was almost there.
  7. canucklehead

    canucklehead Mar 7, 2003 British Columbia (Canada)

    Should have retitled the thread Best beer from a Meh brewer in Canada.

    has anyone tried the IPA from Cariboo aka Pacific Western? I only wonder if it is better than Bowen's IPA which is a good value for under $9 a six pack
  8. andrenaline

    andrenaline Nov 14, 2009 Ontario (Canada)

    Agreed on the Bowen IPA... Definitely a great value play! :). Unfortunately don't have access to it now that I live in Ontario, but definitely tossed back a few 6-er's when I lived in Alberta.
  9. montrealbcr89

    montrealbcr89 Oct 31, 2011 Quebec (Canada)

    I have never been impressed with what Boreale has put out. Their dark is ok, but all else I have tried is a mediocre at best. However, they recently made an unfiltered IPA. I was skeptical, but I tried it and it was really good. Have gone though several six packs in the last few weeks!
  10. rodrigueZflyingf0x

    rodrigueZflyingf0x Jun 11, 2012 British Columbia (Canada)

    I tried Fearless based on this thread and really enjoyed it.

    Granville Island's Chocolate Imperial Stout is good, as well. I don't think it's brewed in the same place as all of their crap beers, though.
  11. tbadiuk

    tbadiuk Feb 9, 2009 Manitoba (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    The Granville Island Hef. fresh on tap was mighty nice. I can't honestly say I've had enough of their beers to think of them as 'crap', but I do lump them into the 'macro' catagory in my mind.
  12. Hornet2003

    Hornet2003 Jan 26, 2006 British Columbia (Canada)

    GIB's Imperial Chocolate has been hit or miss to be honest. The first year (when it wasn't an Imperial), it was fantastic...A lot like a nice dry Irish stout with a solid chocolate infusion. However, I recall a couple years ago buying several bottles that were infected (sour/nasty flavour). I have a feeling they have figured out that issue and am pretty excited to try their Chocolate Imperial this year.

    I have a feeling that this is brewed by Vern at the original Granville Island brewhouse. Please, anybody correct me if I'm wrong.
  13. Hornet2003

    Hornet2003 Jan 26, 2006 British Columbia (Canada)

    The GIB Hefe is absolutely a great beer. It's been around for a while and, like their Lions Winter Ale, is a kind of a staple in my fridge. It may be a Molson product deep down, but damn it's tasty.
  14. Stocean1

    Stocean1 Apr 5, 2011 Ontario (Canada)

    nicklebrooks headstock is surprisingly good
    beerluvr likes this.
  15. thehyperduck

    thehyperduck Feb 26, 2006 Ontario (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I must strongly disagree, GIB's hefe is one of the weakest, wateriest hefes I've ever had, but to each their own. I haven't had Lions Winter Ale in years but I recall liking it, I guess I'd need to try it again to see if it's changed in the last half decade.

    I guess I'll have to go with Headstock as well. Nothing else I've had from NB has been very impressive but I really liked this one.

    And I'm saddened by all the Dead Elephant dissing. In the grand scheme of things yeah, it's not a very good IPA, but it's one of the first IPAs I ever had (and the only one reliably available in my hometown up until ~a year ago), and I probably never would have gotten into the style without it around. Because of its relatively mild hoppiness, it's perfect for people who would rather get into the style by wading into the shallow end (although I recognize that this same trait is precisely why seasoned craft beer drinkers think it's so mediocre).

    EDIT: I guess the DE bashing was in another thread. Oh well, it still applies since Railway City doesn't really make anything especially good. That's what I get for posting at 8 AM before my brain is turned on
    Stocean1 and FEUO like this.
  16. rodrigueZflyingf0x

    rodrigueZflyingf0x Jun 11, 2012 British Columbia (Canada)

    Tried Hop Therapy from Russell last night and was blown away. I know they're not a crap brewery by any stretch of the imagination, or even a 'meh' one, but they don't get the same level of recognition as many BC brewers so I figured I mention them in this thread. If you like Imperial IPA, you need to try this one. I'd go as far as to say it ties Central City Imperial as the best Canadian DIPA I've had. Quite similar to Green Flash's Palate Wrecker.
    matthaslaservision likes this.
  17. canucklehead

    canucklehead Mar 7, 2003 British Columbia (Canada)

    Russell has come a long way from being strictly meh but they need to overhaul their basic lineup much like Lighthouse has done in the last year.
  18. FEUO

    FEUO Jul 24, 2012 Ontario (Canada)

    I will put another vote in for Dead Elephant.
    ;) :hide:
  19. bumchilly25

    bumchilly25 Aug 3, 2009 British Columbia (Canada)

    I'll second that recognition for the Hop Therapy. I'm not a huge Russell fan, but it really shocked me as well. I found it had some similar characteristics to Central City's Imperial, and it really gave the 'ol palate a workout.
  20. Rutager

    Rutager Oct 18, 2010 British Columbia (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I keep hearing how good this Hop Therapy is! Hope there's some around still.
  21. tom10101

    tom10101 Nov 21, 2010 Quebec (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    Belle Gueule Hefeweizen from Brasseurs RJ. Very solid brew and right on style... which was really surprising from them.
  22. matthaslaservision

    matthaslaservision Aug 18, 2012 British Columbia (Canada)

    I've got lots of Hop Thearpy in stock! And yes, it's a pretty damn good dipa. Up there with CC and Maximus
  23. LarryAppleton

    LarryAppleton Dec 1, 2012 Quebec (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I really like the d'Achouffe beers from RJ, especially the Brune. I guess they have a moderately high rating here on BA too
  24. oldp0rt

    oldp0rt Feb 24, 2011 Quebec (Canada)

    Definitely not crap, but not the best BC has to offer
    matthaslaservision likes this.
  25. TheSevenDuffs

    TheSevenDuffs Jan 20, 2010 Ontario (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I am somewhat inclined to enter Cameron's Rye PA in to this cateogry. Everything else I have had from Cameron's is terrible, including their attempts to barrel age.
    hoser likes this.
  26. liamt07

    liamt07 Jul 26, 2009 Ontario (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    Might as well throw their Deviator in there as well for Camerons, a really good doppelbock. Bourbon barrel version ain't too bad either.
  27. TheSevenDuffs

    TheSevenDuffs Jan 20, 2010 Ontario (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    That is why I said "somewhat". That said, the Deviator is nothing I would go out of my way for, depsite it not being a bad beer. I have yet to have the barrel aged version yet, so the jury is still out on that one from my point of view.
  28. peensteen

    peensteen Apr 3, 2010 Ontario (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I found the BA Doppelbock a bit off putting, way too much bourbon IMO
  29. ZiggyPop

    ZiggyPop Jan 8, 2013 Alberta (Canada)

    I really enjoyed the French Oak Stout from Dead Frog. ONe of my personal favorite stouts, to be honest, but yeah, everything else was quite a let down. Hoptical Illusion from Flying Monkeys was another one that I really love, but I can't back up the rest of the selection.
  30. Dennoman

    Dennoman Aug 20, 2011 Belgium

    I heard some good comments about Labatt Porter. I'd like to try it if only international shipping didn't cost a bazillion dollars to AND from Canada.
  31. Groulxsome

    Groulxsome Apr 9, 2010 Ontario (Canada)

    Is that even still being brewed? I've never seen it in Ontario or Newfoundland.

    On the porter note, I remember years ago liking Sleeman's Porter. Mind you, this was the first porter I ever had because it was the first and only "plain" porter (there is Storm's Coffee Porter) in Newfoundland for a very, very long time. I've always wanted to revisit it, but I cannot justify buying a 12 pack to do so!
  32. TheHammer

    TheHammer Feb 15, 2009 Ontario (Canada)

    I'm coming completely out of left field on this one, but Trafalgar Maple Bock. It's a terrible beer, make no mistake but it's not worthy of it's spot on the bottom 100, and the concept of brewing a Maple Bock does not seem flawed to me.
  33. WilderPegasus

    WilderPegasus Dec 16, 2012 Ontario (Canada)

    It's available in Quebec. I saw it last night at Depanneur Rapido in Aylmer.
  34. thehyperduck

    thehyperduck Feb 26, 2006 Ontario (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I agree with the basic gist of your argument (that Maple Bock is bad, but not "Bottom 100" bad), but if I had to pick 'the best' beer from Trafalgar, I don't think the bock would enter into consideration.

    I'd go with their India Ink, which, while completely inferior to every other black ale I've ever had, is at least a halfway decent drink for the most part. Their 2011 Hop Nouveau wasn't entirely awful either - didn't try this year's though, because I've vowed not to risk wasting any more money on their beers. That Cherry Ale I tried last summer was sort of the last straw.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer FestĀ® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • 10 Years of BeerAdvocate Magazine

    We're celebrating 10 years of BA mag with $10 print subscriptions for US residents!