Best Scotch ale?

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by Ant7780, Feb 16, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Ant7780

    Ant7780 Dec 2, 2012 Michigan

    A bit of a two part question:
    1.What is your favorite Scotch ale?
    2. What is your favorite Scotch ale to age?

    For me it's Founder's Dirty Bastard for both. It doesn't need much age though. If you let it sit for more than a month it becomes real smooth and malty. What else do you recommend?
    BeerLover99 and Chickenhawk9932 like this.
  2. notchucknorris

    notchucknorris May 28, 2010 California
    Beer Trader

    I really like Dieu du Ciel's Equinoxe du Printemps.
  3. Mothergoose03

    Mothergoose03 May 30, 2005 Michigan

    Dirty Bastard is a good one but I like Backwoods Bastard better if a BBA beer fits in as an answer to your question. Arcadia's Loch Down is also a good one.
  4. Mitchell57

    Mitchell57 Jan 8, 2013 Wisconsin
    Subscriber Beer Trader

    Old Chub is one of my favorite beers
  5. TychoNDC

    TychoNDC Jan 7, 2013 Colorado
    Beer Trader

    I'd have to agree with you on Dirty Bastard (fresh), though for #2 I'd shade towards Backwoods Bastard. I know some people have had mixed experiences cellaring their backwoods, but I find it a bit too hot when fresh, at least the most recent release.
    MichiganHammer likes this.
  6. ricochet173

    ricochet173 Jul 6, 2011 Quebec (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    I have a 2-year old bottle in my cellar... so good. I couldn't resist and drank all my others :p Another great one from Quebec that I tried recently is Le Castor's "Wee Heavy Bourbon". If you like a lot of barrel flavor, this one does the trick.
    unibroue4ever likes this.
  7. Beer-A-Lot

    Beer-A-Lot Oct 4, 2012 Virginia

    More love for Founders Dirty Bastard. I really enjoyed that one. Also, Old Chub was nice.
  8. MarioM

    MarioM Sep 13, 2009 California

    Not a style I drink to often but one of my favorite beers is Alesmith's Wee Heavy, great great beer that I'm sure would age very well, although I've never tried it my self.
    Chaney, LSUPT, ChrisMon02 and 5 others like this.
  9. Nectar

    Nectar Jan 17, 2013 New Jersey

    Backwoods Bastard for me, also Arcadia's loch ness is pretty good. But BB is one of my favoeite beers, period.
    watsonmd, SteelersX and Horbar like this.
  10. RobertColianni

    RobertColianni Nov 4, 2008 Pennsylvania

    Finally, a fucking thread right up my alley. I'm so tired of BCBS, Heady Topper, Pliny bull shit around here...
    My favorite Scotch Ale is Great Divide's Claymore. I think it's a really spot on example of what a Scotch Ale should be. I've yet to age any Claymore, because it's too good to ignore drinking. I've aged an Old Chub, Bagpiper's, and Dirty Bastard and really only found that the Bagpiper's (Pennichuck c.2007: retired; brewery closed in 2009) was the only one that actually got better for the real value of a Scotch Ale. The others just sort of mellowed out from the insane levels of maltiness. The Bagpiper's (which was aged for 5 years) exploded with peat and smoked, sprouted barley which is what a real Scotch Ale drinker wants. God damn fan-boys these days don't even appreciate Wee Heavy's anymore.
    Dark Horse Scotty Karate is really awesome, too. It basically tastes like whiskey, which is cool. Really smooth with no bite at all.
  11. notchucknorris

    notchucknorris May 28, 2010 California
    Beer Trader

    Wee Heavy does age very well. I tried a 2 year old one a while back and it was money.
    guyinchicago likes this.
  12. ricochet173

    ricochet173 Jul 6, 2011 Quebec (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    You sir... you are a great man.
  13. MarioM

    MarioM Sep 13, 2009 California

    I might have to try that, not sure if I can wait two years but better to start aging it sooner than later. Definitely will do...
  14. ElGallo

    ElGallo Sep 26, 2009 New Hampshire

    Traquair House Ale is my favorite. Smuttynose Scotch Style Ale and Equinoxe du Printemps would be my other faves. All age well.
    Tmappin likes this.
  15. BB1313

    BB1313 Jul 16, 2009 Ohio

    Dark Horse Scotty Karate >>>>
  16. Boilerfood

    Boilerfood Jun 5, 2012 Indiana

    This happens to be my fiancee's favorite style and therefore I have had a lot of them. Backwoods Bastard, Bellhaven's, Wee Muckle and Robert the Bruce are all house favorites.
    creepinjeeper likes this.
  17. BMMillsy

    BMMillsy Feb 16, 2012 Florida
    Beer Trader

    Wee Heavy was life changing for me
  18. BMMillsy

    BMMillsy Feb 16, 2012 Florida
    Beer Trader

    Alesmith in case that wasn't clear
    guyinchicago and TwelveOunces like this.
  19. Ri0

    Ri0 Jul 1, 2012 Wisconsin
    Beer Trader

    As unimpressive as Lake Louie's beers are, their Reserve Scotch Ale is some of the best I've had. It is awesome.
  20. JohnnyHopps

    JohnnyHopps Jun 15, 2010 Indiana
    Beer Trader


    Scottish Ales don't get a lot of love, but they are one of my favs.

    Did a blind test recently with Scotty Karate, Dirty Bastard, Robert the Bruce, and Tyranena Sheep Shagger. Scotty was the consensus winner.
    mcrago and RobertColianni like this.
  21. drrone

    drrone Dec 18, 2011 Utah

    Yeah, I would have gone with the same, but the reverse. Backwoods Bastard followed by Dirty Bastard. Although, I would like to try some of the Wee Heavy and the Scotty Karate that Ricochet173 mentioned. I'll keep my eyes out for it.
  22. champ103

    champ103 Sep 3, 2007 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Third question: What do you consider a Scotch Ale? Considering this has been bastardised in America for a long time. When you actually go to Scotland you you realize that Scotch ales can be hoppy, stronger, weaker, bitter, roasted, chocolaty, etc. Anyway, my favorite beers from Scotland:

    Anything from Traquair
    Harviestoun Bitter & Twisted
    Harviestoun Ola Dubh (all are excellent, and age great)
    Inveralmond Ossian, and Thrappledouser
    Deeside Talorcan
    Anything from Orkney
    And plenty more...
  23. fullmetal1381

    fullmetal1381 Jul 30, 2011 Florida

    Cigar City BA Big Sound. Really hope this thread doesn't make me want to drink my last bottle...
    ncaudle, DIM and cyrushire like this.
  24. Drew26

    Drew26 Nov 2, 2012 Wisconsin
    Beer Trader

    Old Chub, Scotty Karate, and Dirty Bastard are my regulars...Backwoods Bastard being the best, though not as easy to come by.
    Blueribbon666 likes this.
  25. sm0key

    sm0key Apr 24, 2009 Michigan

    Everytime this comes up, I mention arcadia's loch down ale.
    Dirty bastard is good too.

    I just came across two year old old chub in a cooler in Podunk TN, and it kicks ass! It reminds me of Old Curmudgeon... Tastes like an old ale instead of a scotch ale.

    Gonna need to give Scotty Karate another try, last time I had it, it was terrible, maybe it was skunked or something...
  26. Ant7780

    Ant7780 Dec 2, 2012 Michigan

    Love Scotty Karate. Fresh or with a few months on it. It's a totally different beer. There's something about a Scotch ale that has sat for a few months. I know it sounds weird but in that short time they seem to completely change. By the way I have a Kuhnhenns A Few Shillings Too Many sitting in my cellar right now. Fresh it was amazing, but I'm going to sit on my last one for at least a year.
    CubsJedi, BB1313 and SometimesIfart like this.
  27. ricochet173

    ricochet173 Jul 6, 2011 Quebec (Canada)
    Beer Trader

  28. fujindemon74

    fujindemon74 Nov 7, 2012 Pennsylvania

    Backwoods Bastard
    Alesmith Wee Heavy
    Smuttynose Scotch Ale
    Oskar Blues Old Chub
  29. Ant7780

    Ant7780 Dec 2, 2012 Michigan

    Didn't I see a thread that BWB was coming out soon?
  30. bunique686

    bunique686 Jan 31, 2013 Michigan

    Backwoods for me.
    thousandfoldthought likes this.
  31. SometimesIfart

    SometimesIfart Jun 4, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Dark Horse Scotty Karate is my favorite. I haven't aged one, but I'm sure it would be even better aged!
    mcrago likes this.
  32. sponas

    sponas Jul 27, 2009 Arizona

    Founders Dirty Bastard is very good, Robert the Bruce very good too but not as good as DB and Scotty Karate the best Scotch Ale I've ever had
    mcrago likes this.
  33. Chickenhawk9932

    Chickenhawk9932 Jul 19, 2010 Pennsylvania

    Dirty Bastard is awesome fresh - with a couple of months it seems to drop off a bit - maybe it comes back I will have to experiment. Backwoods Bastard with a year on it is a little better than it is fresh, but the vanilla did not drop off at all like I thought it would.
  34. ThirstyFace

    ThirstyFace Jan 11, 2013 New York

    Scotty Karate for me, in the US

    I don't age Scotch Ales intentionally.

    Skullsplitter overall.

    All of that said, I've only had about 8 different ones.
    seakayak likes this.
  35. LiquidDegenerate

    LiquidDegenerate Nov 22, 2011 Florida
    Beer Trader

    CCB Big Sound followed by Scotty Karate
  36. dap325

    dap325 Apr 2, 2009 New York

    Although not considered the best of the best, I really enjoy Olde Burnside Ten Penny ale when I go to the Pipes in the Valley Irish fest every year in Hartford, CT.
  37. craigo19

    craigo19 Oct 12, 2009 Michigan

    My favorites are Erie Brewing's Railbender Ale, Dirty Bastard and Scotty Karate.
  38. papaholmz

    papaholmz Nov 7, 2012 South Carolina
    Beer Trader

    Hands down Founder's Backwoods Bastard for me. I had a bottle last night; amazing!
  39. haddon

    haddon Jul 13, 2009 Kentucky

    Just drank an 18 month old Dirty Bastard last night. It was goooood. I like Old Chub but doesn't age that well IMO.
    YogiBeer likes this.
  40. mecummins

    mecummins Nov 16, 2012 Illinois

    Robert the Bruce to drink right now. But my favorite to age is my own homebrew. After letting it age for 8 months, it's really quite good. We called it "Piper Down" after a bit in the movie So I Married An Axe Murder. I'm pretty damn proud of it.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer FestĀ® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • Free Trial Subscription

    Reside in the US? Interested in a free 1-month trial subscription to the print edition of BeerAdvocate magazine?

    Yes! Sign Me Up!