Best Scotch ale?

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by Ant7780, Feb 16, 2013.

  1. jmw

    jmw Feb 4, 2009 North Carolina

    Not really odd as the two have nothing to do with each other

    I doubt that marquis finds something new every day that he was not already familiar with. Thanks though for the treatise on what is a common misconception: peated malt or peat-anything was not used in Scottish made beers--that is an American anachronism.

    One of my favorite 'scotch' ales--Harviestoun Old Engine Oil
     
    seakayak likes this.
  2. RobertColianni

    RobertColianni Nov 4, 2008 Pennsylvania

    No problemo.
     
  3. GodlessWatermelon

    GodlessWatermelon Apr 12, 2012 Maryland

    Old Chub, GD Claymore, Skullsplitter
     
    RobertColianni likes this.
  4. SnowFlowMfg

    SnowFlowMfg Dec 13, 2011 California

    Definitely want to go try a claymore now. I have only had old chub and local brews but I love this style as well!
     
    RobertColianni likes this.
  5. macandrewsRIP

    macandrewsRIP Oct 28, 2007 Massachusetts

    What a great thread!!!

    Broughton Old Jock passable but Traquair House Ale and Jacobite are my hands down favorites now.

    Who remembers MacAndrews Scotch Ale (imported by Merchant du Vin, last shipment 1998) ? A deep, smooth yet spicy Scotch with multiple layers of malt flavor. Originally imported as Caledonian Strong Ale and then rebadged as MacAndrews. God i loved that stuff, i used to buy it by the case. For some reason they stopped importing it, plus the gravity was slowly going down over the years, it was the highest when it was in the 12 oz bottles but was lowered when they shipped in the 16.9 oz bottle. Still was a great Scotch Ale. (I'm not crying I just have something in my eye....)
     
    Rochefort10nh, Bitterbill and ColdOne like this.
  6. JohnSnowNW

    JohnSnowNW Feb 6, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Belhaven Best, without question.
     
  7. Lethal04

    Lethal04 Sep 3, 2009 Missouri

    Backwoods Bastard is the best that I've had. Last year found a Dirty Bastard on the shelf that was bottled in '09 and that was good too. Never had it fresh before so can't compare it aged unfortunately.
     
  8. lic217

    lic217 Aug 10, 2010 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    Not sure if it has been said, but Ten Penny is a great scotch ale. Not sure how hard it is to get outside of CT though.
     
  9. macandrewsRIP

    macandrewsRIP Oct 28, 2007 Massachusetts

    they put Belhaven Wee Heavy in a clear glass bottle, not brown, clear. Some marketing genius at either Greed King or Belhaven spent too long on a beach in Mexico, supping Corona, and came back with the stupidest idea since new Coke and yet was not given their redundancy notice (i.e., fired).

    Clearly a crime against humanity.....
     
    tronester and SnowFlowMfg like this.
  10. dmeadows

    dmeadows Aug 6, 2002 New York

    How I miss both McEwans and MacAndrews.

    Someone give me a Tassgall Ale from Highland Brewing, please!
     
  11. Zimbo

    Zimbo Aug 7, 2010 United Kingdom (Scotland)

    Christ John, are you taking the piss?
     
  12. FourBetter

    FourBetter Nov 12, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Gateway: McEwans (miss you)
    Best: Backwoods Bastard
    Runner up: BA Big Sound
    Up 'n Coming: Steet Toe Wee Heavy, Central Waters Wee Heavy
     
  13. JohnSnowNW

    JohnSnowNW Feb 6, 2013 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Hehe, a bit. I do miss it, since it doesn't make it's way over the pond...but no that would not be my choice for the "Best."
     
  14. Zimbo

    Zimbo Aug 7, 2010 United Kingdom (Scotland)

    Quality.
     
  15. dcbdc1

    dcbdc1 Jun 23, 2012 Virginia

    Greatest beer name ever!! Well done!
     
    Pelican5 and mecummins like this.
  16. GFG

    GFG Oct 24, 2012 North Dakota

    Town Hall Hope and King Scotch Ale
     
  17. SteelersX

    SteelersX Jan 30, 2011 New York
    Beer Trader

    My favorites are Backwoods Bastard and Alesmsith Wee Heavy.

    I used to love Skullsplitter and Scotty Karate but both had recipe changes and I just dont like them as much
    Scotty is still good but Skullsplitter is a shell of what it used to be.
     
  18. dirtyfab

    dirtyfab Oct 21, 2004 New York

    Having a Belhaven wee-heavy right now.
     
    Rochefort10nh and Mediczod like this.
  19. MortalKombat14

    MortalKombat14 Oct 2, 2012 Michigan

    I can't believe this is even a debate. Backwoods Bastard hands down. Many beer reviewers who don't even like Scotch Ale or Wee Heavys love this beer
     
  20. Billz187

    Billz187 Oct 2, 2011 Ohio

    Scotty Karate
     
  21. dwoolley1

    dwoolley1 Dec 16, 2009 New York
    Beer Trader

    Dirty Bastard
     
  22. Beefytits4

    Beefytits4 Nov 2, 2011 Illinois

    Backwoods Bastard
     
  23. robwestcott

    robwestcott Nov 3, 2008 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    sun king wee muckle
    backwoods bastard
    NEBCO wet willy
    ccb rum barrel big sound
    and
    +1 for scotty karate
     
  24. JohnQVD

    JohnQVD Jan 23, 2011 New York

    I never intentionally age Scotch ales. I, too, miss McEwan's and rate Big Sound and Backwoods Bastard. There have been a few things mentioned in this thread I'm going to have to search out.
     
  25. mellowmark

    mellowmark Mar 31, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    My favorite is Dirty Bastard, no doubt. I actually prefer it over Backwoods.
     
    JxExM likes this.
  26. keithmurray

    keithmurray Oct 7, 2009 New York

    Rohrbachs Scotch Ale - Dear Rohrbachs, please start bottling this heavenly goodness
     
  27. AlTrombley

    AlTrombley Dec 25, 2012 Connecticut

    Bellhaven Scottish ale. I used to sell it years ago and always enjoyed it. The same brewery brews a beer named St Andrews ale that is also real tasty.
     
  28. JohnQVD

    JohnQVD Jan 23, 2011 New York

    This. I didn't even mention it because it's not that available outside Western NY and you have to get it in growlers. I've only had it once, when I brought a growler back from Rochester and took it to a gathering. It was quite popular and went quickly.
     
    ColdOne likes this.
  29. patto1ro

    patto1ro Apr 26, 2004 Netherlands
    Subscriber

    I'll be brewing* a Younger's No. 1 on Tuesday. I'm so excited.


    * To be more accurate, hanging around the brewery watching professionals brew and trying not to get in the way too much.
     
  30. 19etz55

    19etz55 Aug 12, 2007 New Jersey

    Don't care for the style much but I do like Founders Dirty Bastard. Haven't had the Bacxkwards Bastard yet but would like to try it.
     
  31. RobertColianni

    RobertColianni Nov 4, 2008 Pennsylvania

    It's a debate because guys like me, that have such a love for Scotch Ales that you don't even want to begin debating, can name three Scotch Ales every hour for two days that will make you forget Backwoods Bastard even exists. Infact, I've had Backwoods Bastard sitting on shelves around here and laughed, walked away, and said to myself "some poor sap will actually buy that shit." I don't mean to belittle you, and I know I'm young, but until you start brewing and seek out style examples that literally do not even exist anymore, don't put Backwoods Bastard too far up that flag pole of yours. It's good, but it ain't great and it's really not even an honorable mention.
     
  32. UCLABrewN84

    UCLABrewN84 Mar 18, 2010 California

    AleSmith Wee Heavy and Founders Backwoods Bastard are my two highest rated of the style.
     
  33. bayareahustla

    bayareahustla Jul 13, 2012 California
    Beer Trader

    drinkin a Deviils Canyon Full Boar.....its pretty tasty
     
  34. deuce9259

    deuce9259 Dec 28, 2011 Ohio
    Beer Trader

    I hope some people realize there is a difference between Scotch Ale and Scottish Style Ale.
     
    Rochefort10nh and NHcraftbeer like this.
  35. jmw

    jmw Feb 4, 2009 North Carolina

    Now we're on the flame. MacandrewsRIP has been waiting for 5 1/2 years for just this thread, and dmeadows has a rare cap in more than 10. I wish I could try this MacAndrews.
     
  36. jbertsch

    jbertsch Dec 14, 2008 Massachusetts

    Cambridge Brewing Bannatyne's scotch ale is my local favorite... or perhaps my favorite regardless of locale.

    I do really enjoy Old Chubb. I like Scotty Karate and Backwoods Bastard, but don't love them.
     
    CypherEnigma likes this.
  37. jmw

    jmw Feb 4, 2009 North Carolina

    Leant toward arrogant, but the first part had me with the passion.
    Then you said
    and I realized that you really are young, and the arrogance comes from a lack of experience rather than a passion.
    Calm down Robert.
     
    breakingbland, ncaudle, teal and 2 others like this.
  38. jmw

    jmw Feb 4, 2009 North Carolina

    do tell
     
  39. lucas1801

    lucas1801 Apr 5, 2012 Massachusetts

    Boiling dow the thick first runnings adds a nice layer of complexity to a Scotch Ale as well.
     
    RobertColianni likes this.
  40. MortalKombat14

    MortalKombat14 Oct 2, 2012 Michigan

    Then why have some of the most respected beer reviewers on the internet have said it's the best they have tried? It's not even just me saying it, it's people that have been drinking beer for decades
     
    Mediczod likes this.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer FestĀ® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • Free Trial Subscription

    Reside in the US? Interested in a free 1-month trial subscription to the print edition of BeerAdvocate magazine?

    Yes! Sign Me Up!