Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Other Beverages' started by Leftofthedial, Apr 21, 2019.
I remember those statements
Basil Hayden is a tie for my favorite bourbon next to Woodford. Both of which are highly rated bourbon in general. Both under 100 proof.
One of the liquor stores where I trade ($1 to Fred Sanford) had a killer deal on these 375-ml bottles of Woodford Reserve. For 15 bones, I'm in all day long.
Jing Chi Vinnie Colaiuta Robben Ford Jimmy Haslip 2001 Tone Center Schrapnel Records
Jing Chi Live Jimmy Haslip Robben Ford Vinnie Colauita 2003 Tone Center Schrapnel Records
For the price hard to beat that McKenna, love it.
Getting tougher to find though
Yeah , I snagged a few bottles the other week. A friend who drinks it as well said they jacked the price up where he lives which is 30 minutes from me.
Im a whiskey novice and spend too much time and money on beer for my wife to let me buy high dollar stuff. I like Jim Beam Devil's Cut a lot, as well as Jeffersons. I went to buy a bottle of Elijah Craig 12 year after reading the praise for it in this thread, but couldn't find it at my store. So instead I bought a bottle of Old Grandad bonded 100 proof - what should I expect? Any recs in the 20-35$ range for someone that likes Devil's Cut?
I think you made a decent selection with GrandDads ... About a year ago I was pretty much in the same boat as you. Didn't know much about whiskey, most disposable income went towards beer, didn't want to spend too much. My advice is don't overthink this ... just purchase the occasional bottle in your price range and go from there. Maker's, Buffalo, Turkey, Evan Williams, etc ... Enjoy the fun !
Eagle Rare, Buffalo Trace, Basil Hayden.
Did someone say bourbon??
Looks like I have some catching up to do.
Luuuvve rye. Obviously prefer higher rye bourbons, but also prefer 100 proof+ for most part. Drink almost everything neat. Splash of water to open up some. Makers and 7Up was my gateway. Most overrated for me is Pappy 23 (10 isn’t great either, but the 12 and 15 are). Most underrated vote would probably be SiB Evan Williams. Especially at $28. Four Roses is up there too. Bang for your buck... Henry McKenna or Eagle Rare. Although Wild Turkey and Dickel Rye for under $20 are great daily drinkers.
Favorites... Probably have to go with EH Taylor, Buffalo Trace Mash 1 White Dog, Bookers, and Knob Creek Rye. (I’m a Beam mash fan boy).
Every day drinkers... Redemption Rye (probably still my favorite rye with Willet 3&4 yr right behind), Buffalo Trace, and Weller Antique. I would include Old Grand Dad in both, but not distributed in Ohio. I’ll stop rambling now. Wait, don’t sleep on Old Forester 1897 or 1920. Now I’m done.
Looks like someone went to Lizzardville at Polaris. Love beer shopping for German imports while drinking whiskey there. Make sure to try the New Riff stuff next time. It’s real good.
I remember you talking about this and we had some conversations. Bought a few of the EC 12 yr bottles as I saw it transpiring as you foretold. Drank them. Still have an empty though.
Irritating and stupid too. First because it has been a Bottled in Bond, 10 yr, 100 proof, single barrel for $30 (or less) that has sat on shelves for years without anyone noticing. Then it wins best bourbon at the SF Spirits competition and suddenly everyone can see it. But, It’s. A. Single. Barrel. People. You aren’t going to get to drink the one that they crowned anyway. Stop driving the price up on a good priced bourbon.
My bourbon/rye collection has dwindled as my rum collection has increased. Most of my "bunker" is still bourbon though. My all time favorite daily drinker is Elijah Craig 12. I only have 2 unopened bottles left sadly.
I agree, I usually keep a bottle in the house. My friend said it was $100 when he saw it, he generally gets a bottle every few months. Oh well if it goes up I will just keep getting Larceny.
That’s very interesting. I have to admit that I’ve never had any other vintage but ORWV 10 has been the best bourbon my lips have met so far. I loved the intense caramel/vanilla notes. I’m assuming the older vintages are smoother , but I thought the 10 was damn good myself.
i tend to agree (10 v 12) & would love to know which vintage the 12 year old was he enjoyed so much.
in my view the 12 has repeatedly been the middle stepchild. i'd chalked some of that up to the 10 & 15 - 107° lending more flavor as well as perhaps (more recently) the 12 competing for barrels with Weller 12 & possibly WLW.
Thank you for the correction! I figured vintage was the wrong term but couldn’t come up with a better expletive.
Goddamn! What is that, an 8oz pour?! That's a Hunter S. Thompson pour
no worries there! i only honed in on that because in this specific exchange, that word "vintage" carries the same kind of significance or weight (in terms of value / interest) as high-end wine would.
Currently going between Jefferson's Reserve, Yellow Rose Outlaw bourbon, and Michter's US-1 Single Barrel Straight Rye. Need to stock up on more before my birthday, though.
Don’t get me wrong. 10 is still a very nice bourbon. I even had another one last time I was in Louisville that I paid $16 or 18 for. It just isn’t worth the secondary prices or chasing. 23 on the other hand is not a particularly good bourbon.
While I do tend to go with heavy pours, that one is a little deceiving. Probably a 5-6 oz glass. Tall and skinny.
Can’t believe there is no Blantons love yet.
I loved the Weller 12
It's my favorite bourbon that I can actually buy. Other than that, I agree with the love for Elijah Craig and Buffalo Trace. I like those more than many bottles that cost twice as much.
For rye I like Whistle Pig and Willett. For cocktails I go with either Sazerac or Rittenhouse but both are also good to just drink and are easy on the wallet.
My absolute favorite bourbon is Pappy 15 and rye is Thomas H. Handy Sazerac but I'll never own a bottle given the current market.
I've been enjoying Eagle Rare lately and it's been hard to branch out because it's so good!
107 is what got me hooked on bourbon, great stuff! Store picks are even more complex and amazing!
Current Line up
2018 Buffalo Trace Line up
THH / GTS / Saz / WLW / ER17
Weller SR & 107 / Stagg Jr / BH 10 / ER10 / Baby Saz
If you haven’t had the new Old Forester rye, or the 1897, try both. Highly recommend both. Then never buy either again and spend all your money on this one.
I'm always getting the numbers mixed up Loved the standard Old Forester, and wondering which to go with next (and not break the bank)
This one is at the top of the bank breaking scale unfortunately. For what it’s worth though, I would pay well above the $60 tag.
It's a good bourbon for sure. But it's so hard to come by. It has the subtle notes of something to savor slowly, but some bottlings can be underwhelming. There is just so much better bourbon that can be had anytime, anywhere. Some Blanton bottlings are really special...other's fall short of your typical $25 Buffalo Trace.
The 1920 is one I have waffled on a little. Some say...EPIC...others say, PASS. I think this has to be one of my next special purchases (Father's Day and Birthday upcoming).
$49.99 at Total Wines out here.
Ohio availability is decent, but prices are not. That’s why I always try to load up across the river from Cincinnati whenever I’m down there
Love the fact this is a thread now.
Craft beer introduced me to good bourbon/whiskey. One of my first BA beers was aged in Buffalo Trace barrels. Needless to say I'm a big fan of BT, Blanton's and Bulleit. I also really enjoy Willet aged beers, but I can find the 4 year anywhere here in NC.
This is tasting like a one time purchase.
Just finished a fifth of Michter's Rye. Loved it, but of the three Michter's mainstays (Rye, Bourbon, American Whiskey) my favorite was the American Whiskey. Dangerously light and smooth, drinks way too easily