Bourbon County Stout or Black Note?

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by ChugginOil, Feb 1, 2013.

?

BCBS or Black Note?

  1. Goose Island Bourbon County Brand Stout

    71.8%
  2. Bell's Black Note Stout

    28.2%
  1. ChugginOil

    ChugginOil Sep 23, 2010 Illinois

    I love me some Bourbon County as well as all beers aged in barrels. That being said, after trying Bell's Black Note I thought it tasted quite similar to BCBS, just a bit thinner. Kinda like similarities between Pepsi and Coke. So which one stands out more to you?
     
  2. mborden

    mborden Jan 28, 2009 New York

    I voted Black Note, but that might just be the recency effect. Damn they are both tasty beers.
     
    mcrago likes this.
  3. PackPride

    PackPride Oct 31, 2011 North Carolina

    Tough one, but I gotta go with BCBS. However, I think the BCBS will be favored in that poll only because it's been around longer than Black Note, and seems more available.
     
  4. MarcatGSB

    MarcatGSB Jan 8, 2011 Michigan

    BCBS will be favored because it's just a completely different beer. It's bigger, more body, more barrel character. Some other barrel aged beers may have more nuances, but BCBS IS THE barrel aged stout.
     
  5. ndepriest

    ndepriest Feb 21, 2012 Georgia
    Beer Trader

    Easily Black Note. BCBS is great, but a bit heavy too want more than a couple of times a year. I could drink Black Note all day long.
     
    beerhan and BlackBelt5112203 like this.
  6. PackPride

    PackPride Oct 31, 2011 North Carolina

    Yeah, I agree. That's hard to argue against. The Bell's Black Note is very very good, but yeah the BCBS is everything that you said it is.
     
  7. chrisp450

    chrisp450 Oct 23, 2012 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Out of the bottle I think BCBS.

    I have had Black Note on tap, and thought it was FANTASTIC. Have yet to have BCBS on tap though...

    I know BCBS ages well, hoping Black Note is the same!
     
    Marti403 and BlastBeats like this.
  8. pschul4

    pschul4 Jan 7, 2011 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    Depends on what you are looking for. BCBS is more bourbon heavy, which I love. Whereas Blacknote is crazy chocolately, which I love every so slightly less than bourbon. I would drink both of these in as large of quantities as possible, but if forced to choose I would give the edge to BCBS
     
  9. gatornation

    gatornation Apr 18, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Both tasty vote goes to Black Note the bourbon was present but did not overpower the velvet texture of the stout,also liked the slight coffee and fruit taste also
     
  10. GRDave

    GRDave Oct 7, 2011 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    This is a tough one. This year is the first year I've had either and I love both, but they are different beers. BCBS is an 'in your face' BBA stout, and being a big fan of Founders, I love a crazy unbalanced huge flavor beers. That's just where my palette is right now. Black note is so smooth and creamy and yet still soothes the need for BBA beer. It's like BCBS is the devil on one shoulder and BN is the angel on the other. I walked down to the cellar tonight and had both staring me in the face, BCBS won...tonight.
     
    Stevedore likes this.
  11. kzoobrew

    kzoobrew May 8, 2006 Michigan

    I would go Black Note just based on its availability to me. I will agree with the others who say the two are very different beers and choosing between the two largely depends on preference at the moment.

    I will say that I would take Bells Bourbon Barrel Cherry over either, I'll add Bourbon Expedition too.
     
  12. jplopez21

    jplopez21 Nov 14, 2012 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    Black note for sure (thx again). That shit is just balance all around. So much flavor.
     
  13. stayclean

    stayclean Mar 17, 2012 Wisconsin

    I've had BCBS more than I've had Black Note, so I guess I'll go with it. Really enjoyed having Black Note on tap, looking forward to eventually trying it again via bottle soon.
     
  14. aasher

    aasher Jan 27, 2010 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    Bourbon County is a far superior beer. I did a side by side at the store after work one day and the staff said that compared to BCBS, BN isn't even beer.
     
    BlastBeats likes this.
  15. Irishize75

    Irishize75 Nov 4, 2012 California

    Couldn't agree more. BCBS great, but its a pretty tough one to get in the ring with consistently. The Black Note is like velvet.
     
    szmnnl99 likes this.
  16. Snowrs

    Snowrs Oct 10, 2009 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    I poured my BCBS and BN into a single glass and babies with harps flew out.
     
  17. MichPaul

    MichPaul Jan 28, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Yeah, I let staff choose what I like better all the time... WHAAA?
     
    mellowmark likes this.
  18. aasher

    aasher Jan 27, 2010 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    My hoard of Bourbon County speaks for itself. Black Note was purchased solely to send to those who haven't had it yet.
     
    mcrago likes this.
  19. MichPaul

    MichPaul Jan 28, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Hmmm... I have had plenty of BCBS, and only just had my first 12oz of Black Note just two days ago. Blew BCBS out of the park for me. But that's just me. We all have different tastes like we all drive different cars. I wouldn't kick either out of bed. I mean my glass... :p
     
  20. BlastBeats

    BlastBeats Mar 24, 2011 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    Black Note is really good...

    but Bourbon County is definitely the best (while also being the first of its kind)
     
  21. Naterobsnyk4

    Naterobsnyk4 Jan 25, 2012 New York

    Based on drinkability alone I'd have to take black note. I can't put back a bcbs on a consistent basis, where as with Black Note I really could drink it all day long. I enjoy being able to taste the more subtle features, and I found it to be far less hot within the first month or so of brewing.
     
  22. WYVYRN527

    WYVYRN527 Jan 8, 2007 Minnesota

    Both beers are excellent, but I have to give Black Note a slight edge. I find it a bit more rounded and easier to drink right away. BCBS is legendary with a few years on it, so the real test for me will be how the Black Note holds up with some time on it.
     
  23. xnicknj

    xnicknj May 25, 2009 Pennsylvania

    can i take both? :cool:
     
  24. rodlavers

    rodlavers Jun 20, 2012 Pennsylvania

    Trying Black Note for the first time, right now, actually, in the 12oz format. I won't be able to pass judgment right away, but I can say that BCBS is one of favorite beers ever. Therefor, BN faces some serious competition. I have one other 12oz bottle, and three of the larger format bottles, which I plan to hold onto for quite some time.
     
  25. UCLABrewN84

    UCLABrewN84 Mar 18, 2010 California

    BCBS by a huge amount. I was able to try Black Note after the release of the 750s and I thought it was good but nothing all that special for a barrel aged stout.
     
  26. johngalt12345

    johngalt12345 Feb 19, 2012 Maryland

    my black note hasn't arrived yet, but my friends are saying it is superior to bcbs
     
  27. codysjb

    codysjb Jun 16, 2010 Prince Edward Island (Canada)
    Beer Trader

    BCBS. Black note is amazing but personally I dont think its worth the fuss when compared to similar barrel aged beers like BCBS, BCBCS, Damon, BASC... maybe since its getting vastly easier to get it will be worth the fuss but I would never trade for a 750 after drinking through several growlers of Black Note this fall and realizing that its worth looking for but not worth trading for when BCBS is easier to get.
     
  28. Crackerroll

    Crackerroll Jan 16, 2011 Missouri

    Haven't tried Black Note. Just bought my first 4 pack of BCBS last weekend. Drinking the third one now. Wow, it is such a great beer. Had wanted to try it for a long time. It is definitely a top 5 beer.
     
  29. falcon1

    falcon1 Jan 28, 2006 Ohio

    Without any doubt - Goose Island BCBS!
     
  30. founder26

    founder26 Sep 9, 2009 Michigan

    blew it out of the water, really??? :eek:
     
  31. AlTrombley

    AlTrombley Dec 25, 2012 Connecticut

    I wish we got bells in New England. I have read so much about it. I hate to say it but if it was not for AB/InBev I would not be drinking a bourbon county coffee stout right now. Which is AWESOME!!!!!!!
     
  32. VncentLIFE

    VncentLIFE Feb 16, 2011 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    Fresh - Black Note
    Aged at least a year - BCBS
     
  33. szmnnl99

    szmnnl99 Apr 3, 2006 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    BCS is awesome for the bourbon flavor, while Black Note is more subtle and complex. I wouldn't want all of one or the other. In this case, diversity is good.
     
  34. MichPaul

    MichPaul Jan 28, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Dude, I don't know what it was, but that night it sure did! Right out of the friggin water! :)
     
  35. Casedogg43

    Casedogg43 Jan 4, 2012 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    I'm finding it pretty amazing that Black Note is so highly sought after. Good For Bell's.

    I really like it, but can't seem to catch all the hype on this one.
    I've got a couple bottles, and have had it on tap recently too.

    I'll drink it every time it's put in front of me, but will chase others, plenty of them, before I run around, or give up good beer for it. JMO
     
  36. mmikey8

    mmikey8 Aug 2, 2012 California
    Beer Trader

    It's like choosing a favorite child - they're each different in their own way, but you love them both :)
     
    Docrock likes this.
  37. jtmiller03

    jtmiller03 Feb 2, 2008 Oklahoma

    Yeah, I thought BN was better than this year's BCBS.
     
  38. kdb150

    kdb150 Mar 8, 2012 Pennsylvania

    These two beers are in no way similar enough to say which is "better" in a direct comparison.
     
  39. MichPaul

    MichPaul Jan 28, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Both listed as: American Double / Imperial Stout ... I think that qualifies...
     
  40. antoines15

    antoines15 Dec 14, 2008 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    Had the first and now the second release of Black Note side by side with Bourbon County and it wasn't even close really. BCBS was better in every aspect. Black Note is solid, if unspectacular, while BCBS is dynamite. I think there was four of us drinking and all chose BCBS over Black Note.
     
    siege06nd and CORKSCREWFISH like this.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Return of the Belgian Beer Fest

    BeerAdvocate Brings its All-Belgian Fest to Portland, Maine on September 17, 2016. Tickets are on sale now.

    Learn More
  • Get the Mag

    Become a BeerAdvocate magazine print subscriber today.

    Subscribe