Closest beer to Heady Topper

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by danedelman, Jul 30, 2012.

  1. danedelman

    danedelman Apr 3, 2011 Pennsylvania

    Just wondering if anybody know this so i don't need to drink every DIPA or IPA out there.

    Anybody know of a beer that is easier to access that has the same flavor profile (dont' care if abv is even 3%) as Heady Topper?
     
  2. TinCup69

    TinCup69 Jun 26, 2012 West Virginia

    I'm still kind of a noob but I haven't found anything yet.
     
    richobrien likes this.
  3. oldp0rt

    oldp0rt Feb 24, 2011 Quebec (Canada)

    to me ipas from lawsons and hill farmstead are in the same range of delicious. But Heady is hard to beat.
     
    richobrien, meefmoff, Mersh and 7 others like this.
  4. pschul4

    pschul4 Jan 7, 2011 Illinois
    Beer Trader

  5. Robtobfest

    Robtobfest Oct 21, 2009 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    Elevated IPA by La Cumbre.
     
  6. danedelman

    danedelman Apr 3, 2011 Pennsylvania

    Those are just as hard to find. Thanks though. Anybody know the hops used??
     
    oldp0rt likes this.
  7. Blanco

    Blanco Oct 11, 2008 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    That's a great question. I haven't had it a lot, but can't say I can recall having a beer that has a similar profile. Better, but not similar.
     
  8. brooklynbrews

    brooklynbrews Jan 21, 2010 Uzbekistan

    Ghandi Bot, maybe? It's not really the same flavor profile but I would put it in my top 5 DIPAs and it's a bit easier to find depending on where you live.
     
  9. nrs207

    nrs207 Sep 8, 2011 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    Closest thing I've had is Abner from Hill Farmstead, but that's significantly harder to come by. So doesn't really help.
     
  10. MarkF150

    MarkF150 Feb 9, 2009 Massachusetts
    Beer Trader

    Abner is soooo delicious.And I would have to say just as good as Heady. Both amazing
     
    richobrien, Gosox8787, MEW and 3 others like this.
  11. DevilsCups

    DevilsCups Mar 3, 2010 New York

    Nothing out there, and I'll say that with my own experience. I've tasted many, many different IPA's and DIPA's and nothing easily accessible comes close to the flavor. Lawsons Double Sunshine tastes exactly like Heady but is more pungent, while many of the Hill Farmstead beers hit the same notes. This is probably why they're held in such regard, as they're amazing beers.

    Peekskill Brewing in NY makes a damn good Double IPA that's really close. I believe they use Simcoe, Citra and Amarillo hops in their version, with the emphasis on the Simcoe and Citra. It's called "Double Standard". It has that same dank musty hop note.

    Hill Farmstead Double Citra and Kern Double Citra are very different from Heady as well, more of the pineapple sweeter hop notes. Heady has that dankness to it that must be a product of the hop combinations. I also hear Heady is dry-hopped while it's being packaged into the can/keg, but I can't verify this.

    Abner is outstanding. It leaned more towards the grapefruit profile for me.
     
  12. SammyJaxxxx

    SammyJaxxxx Feb 23, 2012 New Jersey
    Subscriber Beer Trader

    And what is wrong with trying to drink every DIPA/IPA out there?
    I've been trying for years to drink each and every of them.
     
    mtvolkens, Lobina, RobNewton and 12 others like this.
  13. Hophead717

    Hophead717 Oct 21, 2011 Massachusetts
    Beer Trader

    This will be a semi-unsatisfactory answer, but outside of the Vermont offerings, Ballast Point Sculpin is a solid option. The hop profile is noticeably distinct from HT (which I picked up one when I did them side-by-side), but of the even semi-available beers for PA, Sculpin does decently in comparison. That said, Heady Topper is my favorite IPA, so I haven't found anything that can match it.
     
  14. brownswisscow

    brownswisscow Feb 9, 2012 Vermont

    surly abrasive is what you are looking for
     
  15. Number45forever

    Number45forever Jan 6, 2012 Vermont
    Beer Trader

    Surly Abrasive is very close... Lawson's Double Sunshine is similar too (but probably harder to get). HF makes like 2,938 IPAs in Heady's class as well. That's just a rough estimate, I don't have the exact count.
     
  16. deadonhisfeet

    deadonhisfeet Apr 23, 2011 Kentucky

    You don't have to drink every last one. Just keep drinking 'em until you find one you really like that you don't have to jump through too many hoops to get on a regular basis. If it doesn't taste like Heady Topper, that's okay. When you finally do get hold of some Heady Topper again, it'll be like visiting an old friend.

    Whatever you do, please do not let yourself become that woman at my bottle shop who never drinks any beer but Hopslam. Every damn January she buys 12 cases worth to last her the entire year (I am not making this up).
     
    richobrien and SammyJaxxxx like this.
  17. Longstaff

    Longstaff May 23, 2002 Massachusetts

    Surly Furious but with a lighter malt color/flavor....murkier and more floaties too. ;-)
     
  18. OSUBeerStudent

    OSUBeerStudent May 2, 2008 Washington

    Nobody knows for sure. There was a pretty extensive thread in the homebrew forum about trying to clone Heady both before and after the forum switch:
    http://beeradvocate.com/community/threads/heady-topper-clone.7489/
    To my taste there's definitely a lot of Simcoe, Columbus, and Centennial but from there it's hard to say anything definite. The consensus seemed to be not so much newer hops (Citra, NZ varieties and co) with disagreement about how much Amarillo's present. Likely some Simcoe, Columbus, Centennial, possibly something else like Nugget and then lots of opinions (Cascade, Citra, Magnum, and so on).
     
  19. DanE

    DanE Feb 24, 2012 Connecticut

    Don't they use hop extract as well?

    I am also would love a HT replicator/band aid until i can travel up there
     
  20. Zhiguli

    Zhiguli Jul 12, 2012 California

    i'm not all that knowledgeable but from recent experiences i would say Hoptimum isn't that far off as far as the experience i got from heady. big, well rounded, full flavored and with plenty of maltiness.
     
  21. VncentLIFE

    VncentLIFE Feb 16, 2011 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    If I had to throw something out there, Id go Ruination and Double Trouble. Not as good HT, but it should do for the time being.
     
  22. KevSal

    KevSal Oct 17, 2010 California
    Beer Trader

    i actually thought heady topper taste like a bigger version of fresh sn celebration ale. must be similar hops or something. and its way easier to get. anwway the way seasonals are coming out, we'll be drinking celebration labor day
     
  23. Providence

    Providence Feb 24, 2010 Rhode Island

    I couldn't disagree more on this suggestion. I was blown away by Heady, while Abrasive, to me at least, smelled and tasted like cat pee.
     
  24. nc41

    nc41 Sep 25, 2008 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    Maybe Kern Citra, maybe.
     
  25. brownswisscow

    brownswisscow Feb 9, 2012 Vermont

    I've had more heady topper than most and Abrasive is the closest thing I've tasted to it.
    I'll seek out more abrasive as it has been 9 months or so since I've had it. I know some people's palates are more sensitive to certain hops, so it could be something along those lines or maybe just batch variation.
     
    tylerstravis and McNuts like this.
  26. miketd

    miketd Mar 2, 2006 Ohio
    Beer Trader

    There are many great IIPAs and IPAs out there. Unfortunately, many of them aren't canned or bottled. Such is life.
     
    richobrien likes this.
  27. huskermike12

    huskermike12 Nov 14, 2011 Vermont

    I agree with this. Still very different, but the closest I have had.
     
  28. CEDAMA

    CEDAMA Aug 5, 2011 California

    double sunshine
     
    steve50 likes this.
  29. GabrielM

    GabrielM Jun 22, 2010 New Mexico
    Beer Trader

    Funny, I came here to say the same. I've had everything mentioned in this thread except for the HF brews and I can easily say that La Cumbre is the closest in my book. They share that extreme grapefruit/mango hoppiness action.
     
    rgfellow and SenorHops like this.
  30. Robtobfest

    Robtobfest Oct 21, 2009 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

  31. brownswisscow

    brownswisscow Feb 9, 2012 Vermont

    HF and Lawson's make amazing IPA's, they just don't have a similar flavor profile (other than citrus) to HT in my opinion.
     
  32. Psychmusic

    Psychmusic Jun 22, 2012 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    Interesting you say Abner, I picked up a few 4-packs of Heady and a growler of Abner this weekend. I absolutely loved Abner, actually more than Heady, but I thought they were very different. Abner drinks much heavier, and its somewhat sweeter. Heady tastes cleaner, and is a slightly more dry.

    I'm really a n00b though so take my input with a grain of salt.
     
  33. nrs207

    nrs207 Sep 8, 2011 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    Abner was definitely a little fruitier and less piney for me. I didn't really think either was heavier, but if I had to say I think Heady was a touch lighter. I drank a growler of Abner followed by a couple cans of Heady when I was in VT a couple months ago, so I did have them back to back. That's why our palates are different I guess. They're definitely not identical, but they're the closest things to each other that I've had. Nothing is even close from what I've had so far.
     
    Psychmusic and Pahn like this.
  34. mwrecording

    mwrecording Nov 14, 2009 Maryland

    Hoptimum is probably the closest beer I've had and its not terribly close, hoptimum is a little too sweet on the balance scale.

    Pliny probably could be if it wasn't too grapefruit/sour fruit-y, I would've LOVED Pliny if it has some sweet malt backbone that I find Heady to have.

    I'd be broke and an alcoholic if I lived in Vermont, I could drink Heady all day and I think I would. I almost try not to trade for it so much for that reason.
     
    CA_Infidel2o9 likes this.
  35. Horbar

    Horbar Feb 24, 2012 Rhode Island

    I know Meadowlark IPA isn't a double, but it has some similarities.
     
  36. brees6221

    brees6221 Aug 4, 2009 Western Sahara

    All the hop-snobs just turned their nose up at you for recommending such a semi-widely-distributed IPA, but I got your back. HH717 FTW!
     
  37. Pahn

    Pahn Dec 2, 2009 New York
    Beer Trader

    weird time that we're in that sculpin is the "semi-widely-distributed IPA". not that the distribution area isn't wide, but finding sculpin--much less fresh sculpin--has rarely been a given in most places.

    p.s. i'm as big a hop snob as they come without being totally absurd, and i'll recommend hoptimum day in and day out.
     
  38. brees6221

    brees6221 Aug 4, 2009 Western Sahara

    I guess I can only speak to my experience, but I can usually get Sculpin that tastes pretty fresh to me now that Ballast Point is in MD, and didn't have a problem getting it before that, from a friend in NJ.
     
  39. Mealhouse

    Mealhouse Feb 19, 2012 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Going to want to wait awhile to seek out any abrasive its only a December to March seasonal from Surly so anything you'd get now wouldn't be fair to stack up against Heady.
     
  40. apaisncsu

    apaisncsu Mar 25, 2011 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    How about Dale's Deviant. It has a great hop profile, though is a bit maltier, and comes in a similar tallboy :)

    This may be my vote because it has been a recent favorite of mine. Going to try the Gubna tonight.
     
    NotHereForGold likes this.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Return of the Belgian Beer Fest

    BeerAdvocate Brings its All-Belgian Fest to Portland, Maine on September 17, 2016. Tickets are on sale now.

    Learn More
  • Get the Mag

    Become a BeerAdvocate magazine print subscriber today.

    Subscribe