Drinking out of bottle/can vs. pouring in to glass

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by happy4hoppybeer, Dec 8, 2012.

  1. Gus_13

    Gus_13 Jul 2, 2012 Mississippi
    Beer Trader

    That is true. I've done the side by side with Heady Topper. I think the main reason they want you to drink from the can is because of all the hop residue floating in it. It didn't bother me when I poured it but I can see that turning someone off. I thought the aroma was much better when I poured HT into a tulip glass.
     
  2. rocdoc1

    rocdoc1 Jan 13, 2006 New Mexico

    I mostly drink from an appropriate glass, but I feel no guilt or shame at drinking directly from the bottle or can. Sometimes my mustache or nose hairs get tangled in the pop tops of cans, but that's a small price to pay for not having to wash a fancy beer glass
     
  3. rocdoc1

    rocdoc1 Jan 13, 2006 New Mexico

    I really hope you're not serious about this. There are as many ways to enjoy a beer as there are beer drinkers.
     
    happy4hoppybeer likes this.
  4. jhartley

    jhartley Aug 22, 2010 Florida
    Beer Trader

    Always pour into a glass. AAL' s would be the only exception, imho. I could be wrong though, it's happened before.:)
     
  5. bradcochran1234

    bradcochran1234 Jan 22, 2011 Georgia

    I could never imagine drinking a stout, barleywine, old ale, sour, or pretty much anything strait out of the bottle. I don't need the best glass wear but I'm not gonna try a big ass beer out of a bottle. That's just rude. As for the Heady argument, I don't follow their rules.
     
    RBassSFHOPit2ME and rjniles like this.
  6. TKEbeerman

    TKEbeerman Jun 6, 2009 Florida
    Beer Trader

    Yes, its wide on the bottom and skinny at the top, which funnels the aromas from the beer to a consintrated point. Thats my theory based on my drinking experience and nothing scientific behind it
     
  7. TKEbeerman

    TKEbeerman Jun 6, 2009 Florida
    Beer Trader

    I have a Sam Adams Perfect Pint, its obviously the best glass otherwise "perfect" would not be in the name. But on a serious note, I pour Heady into a glass, no reason to fear an unfiltered beer's appearance.
     
  8. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    According to whom??
     
  9. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    According to whom??
     
  10. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    No, I don't think so.
     
  11. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    Smell is irrelevant to taste. FACT
     
  12. Optifron

    Optifron Aug 17, 2012 Minnesota

    Any food scientist will refute that point, unless taste is purely referring to sweet, sour, salty, bitter or umami (and I think they have discovered a sixth taste receptor for fat according to Randy Moser's Tasting Beer?)

    Or I've been trolled. Seems about just as likely.
     
  13. CurtFromHershey

    CurtFromHershey Oct 4, 2012 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Successful troll is successful.
     
  14. BeerBum

    BeerBum Nov 13, 2012 California

    Smell is irrelevant to taste, per se. However, I think many people are confusing the concept of beer taste and beer flavor. Hopefully this explanation clears it up.

    Why are taste receptions and smell receptions so closely related? Why is it that, if we are sick, we can hardly taste what we are eating because our nose is blocked? Why would it be detrimental for a chef to not have that good of a sense of smell? Actually, the relationship is like this because “what we often call taste is in fact flavor. Flavor is a combination of taste, smell, texture (touch sensation) and other physical features (e.g. temperature)” (4). When we eat, the reception that our taste buds get also react to the odors released by the food and therefore we are able to identify what it is we are actually eating (5). If we didn’t have a sense of smell, then we could distinguish between something that might be sweet and something that is bitter, but we wouldn’t know which food was which because we identify the food based on smell. This would explain the detriment bestowed upon a chef if he or she were only able to taste, but not smell. They would not be able to understand the full complexities of the ingredients they were working with and, because cooking is such a chemical process, they would never be able to find a “perfect combination” of ingredients for a meal. They wouldn’t be able to understand what factors may turn some people on and off to certain foods. In a way, tasting is only half the package for enjoying food.

    I always try and use the appropriate glass, because smell and taste combine to produce flavor. Cheers!
     
  15. darkandhoppy

    darkandhoppy Dec 26, 2008 Connecticut

  16. SlickRick

    SlickRick Jun 4, 2005 Georgia

    I refuse to drink out of a glass and always prefer the bottle. Unless reviewing the beer, I don't need to see what it looks like or what the head looks like, I want the taste and I think it tastes best right out of the bottle!
     
    happy4hoppybeer likes this.
  17. brplatz

    brplatz Oct 3, 2012 New Mexico

    So you will rather drink right out of a bomber or growler too?

    Do you drink wine from the bottle or scotch.....

    I thought it was well accepted that bottles are generally storage containers, while glasses are for consumption.
     
    BoneyardBrewer likes this.
  18. kevanb

    kevanb Apr 4, 2011 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    I had a good time reading this thread as I typically pour into a glass, to let the beer decant, warm and to get a good head to really enjoy the aroma. However, I understand going straight from the bottle of can, it's simple and the experience isn't DRASTICALLY (but it IS noticeably) different. However, saying that smell has NO affect on taste is just patently false. The way our brain receives taste starts with our nose as the beer (or food or whatever we are deciding to ingest) nears our mouth and we begin to smell it. The reason that we strive to have a nice head on the beer or for residual lacing to be present is because they make the aroma a lot more powerful during the drinking session, and that my friend has big implications for taste.
     
  19. SlickRick

    SlickRick Jun 4, 2005 Georgia

    I don't buy bombers or growlers and I mentioned beer, not wine or scotch, seems some are offended someone might drink beer in a different manner from these or that they may use something other than someone else's approved method.
     
    happy4hoppybeer likes this.
  20. EJLinneman

    EJLinneman Mar 2, 2009 New Jersey
    Beer Trader

    I can't remember the last time that I DIDN'T pour into a glass.
     
    RobertColianni likes this.
  21. SlickRick

    SlickRick Jun 4, 2005 Georgia

    BTW, I respect rocdoc's position that there are many ways to enjoy beer, and am OK if someone else likes it in a glass, but I will continue to enjoy beer the way I like it best, from the bottle!
     
    happy4hoppybeer likes this.
  22. CincyTK

    CincyTK Dec 21, 2010 Ohio

    Glass .... always
     
  23. kpodolanko

    kpodolanko Dec 7, 2012 Texas

    I am appalled that so many of you "craft beer drinkers" would actually drink from the bottle. Half of your sense of taste comes from smell. Pouring a thick head is crucial to picking up complex aromas, thus adding to the overall flavor enjoyment of the beer. Furthermore, drinking from the bottle, regardless of alcoholic beverage, makes you look white-trashy.
     
    Wingfan13 likes this.
  24. CellarGimp

    CellarGimp Sep 14, 2011 Missouri

    Always and I mean always from a glass my man.
     
  25. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania

    Yes on both questions.
     
  26. brplatz

    brplatz Oct 3, 2012 New Mexico

    Fair enough then. To each his own mate!
     
  27. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    Better "white-trashy" then pretentious out-of-tocuh elitist/snob.
     
    kpodolanko likes this.
  28. Doppelbockulus

    Doppelbockulus Jan 3, 2012 Florida

    This one is tricky. Taste and smell are independent of one another. However, taste and smell are both components of flavor, along with texture and temperature. So flavor is dependent on smell. The brain processes taste, texture, temperature, and smell together and we interpret this as flavor. This is why the flavor of a beer is different when cold or at room temperature, when exposed to one's nostrils or not, and when swished about in the mouth or immediately swallowed. I would have included a specific "taste" comparison but no one drinks a beer without letting it flow over their taste buds.

    There is also the chemistry involved with pouring a beer, or wine, and allowing it to chemically interact with oxygen, so if you really wanted to take the glass pour experience to the extreme, enjoy a beer in a 100% oxygen environment. Anyone have a hyperbaric chamber? This is another reason why some beer enthusiasts enjoy their beer directly from the initial container as opposed to poured into a glass. Some of us enjoy the flavor of mild oxydation, and some of us do not. Some of us enjoy DARK TOAST, and some of us enjoy VERY LIGHT TOAST; this is a comparable principle in terms of flavor and how various individuals enjoy the exact same food or beverage.
     
  29. Doppelbockulus

    Doppelbockulus Jan 3, 2012 Florida

    My preference is to pour a beer into a glass, and let it warm up a little as I drink it. The exception is when I am out at a party or get together of some sort. When I'm drinking big flats or Michelob or Hell Or High Watermelon on a boat, at a party, or any other setting where I want to drink the contents and toss the container, I avoid glasses and typically drink beers that are meant to be consumed in those environments. Similarly, you'll never see me drinking a Le Baladin Xyauyu at a 4th of July boat party, beers that good are reserved for dining room tables, couches, and quite corners in a back room at partys........ in a glass.
     
  30. haddon

    haddon Jul 13, 2009 Kentucky

    Interesting. I think almost the exact opposite of you on this topic.
     
    RobertColianni likes this.
  31. Wingfan13

    Wingfan13 Aug 10, 2009 Texas
    Beer Trader

    This is all an inside joke, right ? More aroma from a bottle ? Taste has nothing to do with smell ?
     
  32. fox227

    fox227 Nov 19, 2010 California

    I'm not sure that the OP is serious, or is just messing with our heads. If so, poor job.
     
  33. krl2112

    krl2112 Nov 10, 2012 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    I totally disagree that pouring into a glass diminishes the flavor. This is simply not true. First, pouring allows the beer to react to the air similar to decanting a wine. Secondly, flavor is not just accepted by the taste buds but also through the nose. The only way u can do this is from a glass. Sight is the final sense that is involved and you can experience the color, head, lacing, etc which can not really be experienced from the bottle.
     
  34. MystikCelt

    MystikCelt Jun 11, 2011 New York

    The only beers I'll drink out of the bottle at home are Schlitz '60's formula for the nostalgia, or Brooklyn Ale, which just happens to go great straight out of the bottle with pizza.

    When in Rome, do as the Romans do... so, yeah, if I'm out somewhere and I'm drinking a Bud or something to fit in with the group, then that'll be out of a bottle too, but at that point it's just drinking to be social.

    If it's a craft beer and I'm home, or with friends of a mind, or a craft bar, I'll go with the glass appropriate to the beer.
     
  35. ImJ2x

    ImJ2x Jan 3, 2012 California

    Keep it simple: Caldera IPA, straight out of the "yellow can." Life is good...
     
  36. Mothergoose03

    Mothergoose03 May 30, 2005 Michigan
    Subscriber

    Anyone who thinks that smell/aroma is independent of experiencing peak enjoyment of a beer needs to hold their nose while eating dinner tonight. (Or recall how off-flavored your food tasted the last time that you had a good head cold.) You simply won't enjoy the food as much.
     
  37. RobertColianni

    RobertColianni Nov 4, 2008 Pennsylvania

    Love this reply.
     
  38. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    Fine, will do. I call BS on what you wrote.
     
  39. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania

    Yes on last two questions.
     
  40. happy4hoppybeer

    happy4hoppybeer Nov 19, 2009 Pennsylvania


    I'm dead serious.
     
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Return of the Belgian Beer Fest

    BeerAdvocate Brings its All-Belgian Fest to Portland, Maine on September 17, 2016. Tickets are on sale now.

    Learn More
  • Get the Mag

    Become a BeerAdvocate magazine print subscriber today.

    Subscribe