last time i was down visiting Sanibel we went across the causeway there is a world of beer and a total wine on US 41
Nothing at the beach. The area is pretty dead for craft beer. My two suggestions are Total Wine in Ft. Myers and World of Beer bar across the street.
+1 to the Total Wine Ft. Myers. You can search Total Wine inventory online. I visit the area and always hit that spot and usually drink Cigar City stuff.
A non-beer related comment: If you have the time, drive out to Sanibel Island. Great beaches and food.
I was there a few months ago, and the brands I noticed that I couldn't get in Texas were Cigar City (Jai Alai...amazing), Southern Tier (very good IPA), Bell's (loved Two Hearted Ale, although you might get Bell's in Indiana), and Terrapin (Athens, Georgia- didn't try any of their stuff, but heard it's pretty good). They also have Victory, but I'm not sure if you get that in Indiana either.