Good (not great) breweries

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by MetalMountainMastiff, Jan 23, 2013.

  1. MetalMountainMastiff

    MetalMountainMastiff Oct 1, 2012 California
    Beer Trader

    I've been thinking lately about some Breweries, that are very good! but NOT great. This came to me when tasting with my friends some Widmer Bros. Many good beers....But none ever shock me with greatness!!!

    What others are there, or if anyone disagrees with Widmer not being great.
     
  2. bryanole27

    bryanole27 Jun 24, 2011 North Carolina

    Mine has always been Highland, Sweetwater, and I'll agree on Widmer.

    I'm sure there's more though.
     
    Keith_R, kylelenk and mecmd like this.
  3. JulianC

    JulianC Mar 9, 2012 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    Two Brothers.
     
  4. Duff27

    Duff27 Feb 10, 2010 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    If I had to rate breweries based on their beers, Widmer would be lower than "good".
     
  5. ubenumber2

    ubenumber2 Sep 1, 2012 Arkansas
    Beer Trader

    I think the ones that I can get my hands on that make very good beer , but nothing that would be considered great are Abita , Tallgrass and Diamond Bear. I drink beers from all three of them and really like them , but they have yet to make a beer that makes people go crazy outside of their brewing region
     
  6. lookrider

    lookrider Apr 22, 2007 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    For me, the first that comes to mind here in PA is Weyerbacher
     
    lsummers, st9647v3 and wvsabbath like this.
  7. BB1313

    BB1313 Jul 16, 2009 Ohio

    Thirsty Dog, Two Brothers, Ithaca, Arcadia, and Anderson Valley come to mind.. all have a couple homeruns, but have a couple strikeouts as well..
     
    Bitter_Echo likes this.
  8. jasonmason

    jasonmason Oct 6, 2004 California

    New Belgium has always been at that level for me. Good stuff, but can't think of anything of theirs that's been on my "You HAVE to try this" list.

    Bootleggers, just because of their inconsistency.
    Ninkasi
     
  9. CommanderOfAwesome

    CommanderOfAwesome Aug 30, 2012 California

  10. MetalMountainMastiff

    MetalMountainMastiff Oct 1, 2012 California
    Beer Trader

    Actually I should add Knee Deep brewing to this. Though Simtra is a great beer. One great won't save many good.
     
    afrokaze likes this.
  11. tjensen3618

    tjensen3618 Mar 23, 2008 California

    There are tons of them, so I'll do some controversial one's

    Ballast Point: V@S is great, Sculpin's quality has taken a nosedive, all the rest are decent but I don't think I have ever repeat purchased any of them.

    Deschute's: Black Butte is one of my most purchased beers ever & Jubelale is a buy every year. Other than that I don't really find too much to get from them. Not a fan of any of the reserve series beers aside from Jubel 2010.
     
    CommanderOfAwesome likes this.
  12. ThisWangsChung

    ThisWangsChung Oct 15, 2011 Maryland
    Beer Trader

    Flying Dog. I like a LOT of their stuff (Wildeman, Raging Bitch, Horn Dog, Gonzo, Pearl Necklace, Kujo), but nothing they do really wows me.
     
  13. cjoc83

    cjoc83 Jul 31, 2010 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    The first thing that popped into my head when I saw the title of this thread was Victory. Sure, they make some really solid beers (Hop Devil, Golden Monkey, Whirlwind Wit), and even some pretty amazing ones (Yakima Glory, Prima Pils, Hop Wallop, Dark Intrigue), but they seem to lack a certain creativity as far as brewing varying styles and barrel aging.

    Flying Fish also comes to mind (although I'm a huge fan of the Exit 16 DIPA).
     
    ESeab and mattbk like this.
  14. hopsbreath

    hopsbreath Aug 28, 2009 Oregon

  15. mecummins

    mecummins Nov 16, 2012 Illinois

    I'll second Two Brothers. I really like some of the beers (Domaine DuPage for starters), but the more I taste from other breweries, the more I can see where they are just OK beers, not amazing. 5 Rabbits out of Chicago falls into this category for me as well.
     
    JulianC likes this.
  16. BigStein88

    BigStein88 Nov 5, 2007 New Hampshire
    Beer Trader

    So three "solids" and four "amazing" and you are disappointed? Tough company to keep!
     
  17. Nectar

    Nectar Jan 17, 2013 New Jersey

    Victory, Ballast Point, Blue Point, Flying Fish, Weyerbacher, Flying Dog, Long Trail.


    I would say that opinions in this thread are relative. I thought a lot of these breweries listed were great at one pount in time. However, as the obsession evolved and I found other breweries not as readily available, well, theres only so much room at the top......
     
    petah12, hutch24 and Bitter_Echo like this.
  18. cjoc83

    cjoc83 Jul 31, 2010 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    I kind of consider Weyerbacher to be closer to 'great' than 'good'. Insanity and Heresy are amazing BA RIS's and barleywines, Riserva is a seriously great and seriously underrated sour, and Double Simcoe is an amazing DIPA. That's too many great beers for it to be just a 'good' brewery.
     
  19. cjoc83

    cjoc83 Jul 31, 2010 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    Pretty amazing, as in almost-great. They just don't brew any single beer that's a "must-try" or world-class. Maybe they're on the cusp of greatness? Lol...
     
  20. lookrider

    lookrider Apr 22, 2007 Pennsylvania
    Beer Trader

    You're right. So we'll move Weyerbacher into the tweener category since it's better than good but not quite great.
     
  21. VncentLIFE

    VncentLIFE Feb 16, 2011 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    Flying Dog makes a few good beers, the rest are average. Weyerbacher as well. I just havent had enough great things from them to throw them in the great category.

    Highland makes good beer, but only one great beer (Thunderstruck). Triangle Brewing here in Durham makes good beer, and a few greats (Bourbon sour Dubbel comes to mind first).
     
  22. TheMonkfish

    TheMonkfish Jan 8, 2012 Chad

    For me Smuttynose (local to me) is a good but not great one. They have a few rotating beers that are pretty good, but most of their stuff doesn't do much for me. I'm looking at you Finestkind - I want to like you, I really do.
     
    BrownAleMale and SalukiAlum like this.
  23. Immortale25

    Immortale25 May 13, 2011 North Carolina
    Beer Trader

    +1 for Flying Dog, Long Trail, Abita and Blue Point in descending order.
     
  24. tectactoe

    tectactoe Mar 20, 2012 Michigan

    Arbor Brewing, New Holland, Arcadia Ales
     
    craigo19, abraxel and JulianC like this.
  25. incapacitant

    incapacitant Jan 15, 2011 New York

    Sixpoint
     
    highlifeCO and Whimpers like this.
  26. victory4me

    victory4me Oct 16, 2004 Pennsylvania

    That's blasphemy (no pun intended).
     
    RobertColianni, ESeab and cjoc83 like this.
  27. brewfly

    brewfly Dec 13, 2012 New York

    magic hat, custom brewcrafters, saranac. has to be 100 varieties of beer between the 3 and nothing real memorable for me in the bunch
     
  28. MetalMountainMastiff

    MetalMountainMastiff Oct 1, 2012 California
    Beer Trader

    Auburn Ale house....not that that is an interesting one to add.
     
  29. BradtheGreat7

    BradtheGreat7 Jul 22, 2011 Ohio

    Just good? I think of Weyerbacher as in the 'big' 2nd tier of breweries. Just my thoughts though
     
  30. MetalMountainMastiff

    MetalMountainMastiff Oct 1, 2012 California
    Beer Trader

    Possibly....fiftyfifty...not sure..I love BART and ICED bart. Some Eclipse, and Donner Party and Annularity ....But something about them makes me want to say them..........maybe not!
     
  31. gatornation

    gatornation Apr 18, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Central Waters regular lineup MEH but Illumination BB stout BBBW stellar
     
    WYVYRN527 likes this.
  32. Whimpers

    Whimpers Dec 17, 2010 New York
    Beer Trader

    Sixpoint and Dogfish Head , a few fantastic beers apiece and a few not so much
     
  33. MikeWard

    MikeWard Sep 14, 2011 Pennsylvania

    Sticking to breweries where I've tried a bunch of their beers, I'll echo earlier posts about Anderson Valley, Flying Dog, Long Trail (barely makes "good" though) and Magic Hat. And I'll throw in Boulder, Heavy Seas, and Otter Creek.
     
  34. SeaOfShells

    SeaOfShells Feb 22, 2011 California

    Honestly, I'm going with North Coast. Aside from Old Rasputin, they haven't wowed me. With that said though, Raspy is one of my favorite beers. I don't care for Scrimshaw, Red Seal, or Old #38 and La Merle is average at best. I do like Pranqster though. I just don't buy it very often. Oh and Old Stock...alcohol burn city.
     
    MetalMountainMastiff likes this.
  35. CommanderOfAwesome

    CommanderOfAwesome Aug 30, 2012 California

    I was just thinking this. I bought a few on Saturday after a long hike and was pumped to have a Sculpin. Really disappointed and didn't live up to what I remembered.
     
  36. mvdillman

    mvdillman Dec 30, 2012 Indiana
    Beer Trader

    Two Brothers for sure. Nothing really wows me
     
    hardy008 and Boilerfood like this.
  37. jbertsch

    jbertsch Dec 14, 2008 Massachusetts

    This is hilarious. "Good", not "great"? Talk about vague... aren't we just splitting hairs?

    Makes me want to start a thread like this in the New England Forum called " Awesome, but not wicked awesome breweries"
     
    fineout, sharpski, Errto and 11 others like this.
  38. distvan

    distvan Jun 8, 2010 Pennsylvania

    +1 sixpoint
     
    JulianC likes this.
  39. cavedave

    cavedave Mar 12, 2009 New York
    Beer Trader

    Russian River. Other than Beatification, Temptation, FFAC, Supplication, Pliny the Elder, Consecration, Blind Pig, Sanctification, and Pliny the Younger, their beers are merely good.
     
    mdvatab, aab, SatlyMalty and 18 others like this.
  40. BrewTasting

    BrewTasting Dec 8, 2010 Nevada
    Beer Trader

    6-pack of Drifter makes everything great
     
    kuhndog and Falcone like this.
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer FestĀ® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • Free Trial Subscription

    Reside in the US? Interested in a free 1-month trial subscription to the print edition of BeerAdvocate magazine?

    Yes! Sign Me Up!