Oatmeal Stout to Rival Sam Smith's

Discussion in 'Beer Talk' started by TheGoldsmith, Feb 2, 2013.

  1. TheGoldsmith

    TheGoldsmith Jan 20, 2013 Missouri

    I'm a big fan of stouts in general, but especially oatmeal stouts (or any sweet stout). While I've liked most I've had I haven't had anything to quite rival Samuel Smith's Oatmeal Stout. But being the beer to revive the style, surely there are some out there that compete? Personally, I wouldn't say it's better, but I do have a soft spot for Tallgrass Buffalo Sweat.
     
    teal and Willbfun like this.
  2. ThirstyFace

    ThirstyFace Jan 11, 2013 New York

    Wolaver's Organic Oatmeal Stout
    FBS
     
    acevenom, Goblinmunkey7 and kneary13 like this.
  3. match1112

    match1112 Mar 2, 2011 Illinois

    Have you tried Firestone Walkers Velvet Merlin or Shakespeare Oatmeal Stout by Rogue?
     
  4. SpongeRuiner

    SpongeRuiner Nov 27, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    New Hollands The Poet.
    The best
     
    PABSTMASTER likes this.
  5. bifrost17

    bifrost17 Dec 16, 2011 Washington

    Anderson Valley Barney Flats is pretty damn good.
     
    acevenom, WYVYRN527, floraday and 6 others like this.
  6. PghBeerAlien

    PghBeerAlien Feb 13, 2012 Pennsylvania

    I really like Samuel Smith's, but think that Elysian Dragonstooth Stout is better.
     
    bifrost17 likes this.
  7. TongoRad

    TongoRad Jun 3, 2004 New Jersey
    Beer Trader

    Once upon a time I would've suggested Young's- too bad we can't get it any more. Other than that I can't think of any I've had recently with such a strong yeast signature. That is one type of beer you'd think that some of the 'ringwood' breweries would excell at, but I can't think of one.

    For more straightforward coffee/chocolate forward takes I do like Ipswich and New Holland's The Poet.
     
    sirtomtom, xanok and ThirstyFace like this.
  8. bifrost17

    bifrost17 Dec 16, 2011 Washington

    Good call, I'm not a fan of most Elysian beer, I think it's all pretty mediocre, but Dragonstooth is sooooooo good.
     
  9. luisc123

    luisc123 Oct 20, 2011 California

    Had Velvet Merlin and Merkin on nitro last week. Deelish.
     
  10. denver10

    denver10 Nov 17, 2010 New Mexico

    Love Oatmeal Stouts as well. My favorite used to be Rogues Shakespeare Oatmeal Stout until I got to try Ipswich Oatmeal Stout, which blew it out the waters.

    Anderson Valley was also a good rec.
     
  11. njhopspop

    njhopspop Oct 17, 2010 New Jersey

    Local to me (NJ) is River Horse Oatmeal Milk Stout. It's a seasonal that I look forward to every year.
    Another that I sing the praises of often is Stockyard Oatmeal Stout. It's the Trader Joe's brand and it's one of my favorites of the style. Plus it's dirt cheap at $7 a sixer.
     
    Willbfun likes this.
  12. Andygirl

    Andygirl Jan 3, 2013 Michigan

    St Ambroise Oatmeal Stout. It's exceptionally good.
     
    TheHammer, elgiacomo, Tut and 2 others like this.
  13. fox227

    fox227 Nov 19, 2010 California

    Samuel Smith's Oatmeal Stout is my favorite easy drinking beer, so I can't really suggest anything else.
     
    2beerdogs, Dope, Bear1964 and 3 others like this.
  14. BB1313

    BB1313 Jul 16, 2009 Ohio

    New Holland The Poet is super..
     
  15. Boilerfood

    Boilerfood Jun 5, 2012 Indiana

    Came to say this.
     
    mecummins likes this.
  16. BigCheese

    BigCheese Jul 4, 2009 Massachusetts

    Ipswich oatmeal stout, I think its better. best year round oatmeal stout for the price. imo
     
  17. ste5venla

    ste5venla Oct 25, 2010 California

    Try Ballast Point Sextant from San Diego. It is nitro conditioned always. Amazing and sessionable.
     
  18. shahn

    shahn Jan 13, 2010 Maryland

    Founders Oatmeal Breakfast & Founders Kentucky Breakfast Stouts
     
  19. Hanglow

    Hanglow Feb 18, 2012 United Kingdom (Scotland)

    Glencoe organic wild oat stout is a nice one. Real good on cask at least. Youngs is good too.
     
    Zimbo likes this.
  20. Willbfun

    Willbfun Sep 28, 2012 New York

    I love Samuel Smiths Oatmeal Stout and I like a few others that people have suggested however tonight for saturday night stout night. I think I'm going with The Poet. I've seen it where I go was thinking about it for the Superbowl. I'm not a big ravens fan or a 49ers fan either but for tonight I might have to give it a shot. Beside I already got word that hot russian girl is gonna be down there giving out vodka samples. thanks and happy tippling
     
  21. Catchy_Name

    Catchy_Name Dec 21, 2011 California
    Beer Trader

    Just about any oatmeal stout named is better than Sam Smith's. I really don't get everyone's infatuation with their stouts. FW Velvet Merlin walks all over Sam Smith's oatmeal stout.
     
    match1112 likes this.
  22. onefalsemove711

    onefalsemove711 Jul 20, 2011 California

    BORIS THE CRUSHER!!!
     
    CircusBoy likes this.
  23. tjwarren

    tjwarren Dec 31, 2008 Ohio

    Sam Smith's is the standard and I personally do not seek anything else out. I understand people's preferences vary and that everyone like to try something new but I cannot recommend anything better.
     
  24. Ryan2BSU

    Ryan2BSU Mar 16, 2012 Indiana

    I snagged a Samuel Smith today actually, and stumbled across a Left Hand Smoke Jumper from '06. We shall see how it ages. I also made the trek to 3 Floyd's a couple weeks ago, and tried their oatmeal stout named Backmasking. I really enjoyed it.
     
  25. eatabagofbooger

    eatabagofbooger Mar 27, 2009 Oregon
    Beer Trader

    Velvet Merlin, Boris, FBS, and the oatmeal stout from SN's basecamp sampler are my faves. At the same time, I don't like Sam Smith (odd metalic flavour), so our tastes might be quite different.
     
  26. bstave

    bstave Aug 21, 2008 Washington

    It's a seasonal, but Fish Brewing's Fish Tale Organic Oatmeal Stout is really good.
     
  27. LordFoul

    LordFoul Oct 7, 2012 South Carolina

    I have tried many examples of the style, but have had none better than Sam Smiths...
     
    BrownAleMale and morimech like this.
  28. Jgwink2

    Jgwink2 Feb 6, 2011 Kentucky

    Left Hand Milk Stout in Nitro is pretty damn incredible. It's like a beer milkshake, which is all together, incredible!
     
  29. Dope

    Dope Oct 5, 2010 Massachusetts

    Great beer but it's a milk stout, not an oatmeal stout ;)

    Dope
     
  30. morimech

    morimech Nov 6, 2006 Minnesota

    Tyranena Down'n Dirty Chocolate Oatmeal Stout is one that I like more than Sam Smiths. Wish they would brew that rather than Hop Whore. Flat Earth Black Helicopter use to be another one but it is more a coffee stout, and the last batch sucked.
     
    Otis32 likes this.
  31. Blueribbon666

    Blueribbon666 Jul 4, 2008 Ohio

    For my $$$ not enough can be said about St. Ambroise Oatmeal Stout. A bench mark for the style, Sam Smith was a gateway to the style for me. But there are a few others I would purchase before it.
     
    Andygirl likes this.
  32. kneary13

    kneary13 Jan 30, 2010 Massachusetts

    +1 for Wolavers.
     
  33. smartassboiler

    smartassboiler Apr 9, 2012 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    Nobody has mentioned Southern Tier Oat? I love that beer.
     
  34. czfreeman

    czfreeman May 22, 2007 California

    Southern Tier Oat anyone?..
     
    dt_gbpackersfan and BMitch like this.
  35. czfreeman

    czfreeman May 22, 2007 California

    apparently we were thinking the exact same thing at the same time
     
    smartassboiler and BrownAleMale like this.
  36. BMitch

    BMitch Jul 10, 2012 Virginia
    Beer Trader

    Good call
     
  37. BMitch

    BMitch Jul 10, 2012 Virginia
    Beer Trader

    Better call
     
  38. Stockfan42

    Stockfan42 Jan 20, 2009 Massachusetts

    Ipswich and Mayflower. Both make very good oatmeal stouts. Honorable mention goes to Shorts Mystery Stout.
     
    BigCheese and Goldfishman like this.
  39. Ispeakforthetrees

    Ispeakforthetrees Apr 2, 2012 Colorado

    Over the winter I've had a lot of Winter Warlock Oatmeal Stout by Bristol.
    Good stuff.
     
    denver10 likes this.
  40. yemenmocha

    yemenmocha Jun 18, 2002 Arizona

  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Return of the Belgian Beer Fest

    BeerAdvocate Brings its All-Belgian Fest to Portland, Maine on September 17, 2016. Tickets are on sale now.

    Learn More
  • Get the Mag

    Become a BeerAdvocate magazine print subscriber today.

    Subscribe