Dismiss Notice
We're celebrating 10 years of BeerAdvocate magazine with $10 print subscriptions for US residents.

Subscribe now!

Comment Personal Greatest +/- rDev and highest/lowest rating

Discussion in 'Feedback' started by gillagorilla, Apr 25, 2013.

  1. gillagorilla

    gillagorilla Feb 27, 2013 Maryland
    Beer Trader

    So far:

    +15.5% with a 5 for Firestone Walker 16th Anniversary (it was at a bar and before I took notes, but it was the first of that night and it is damn near perfection if you ask me, with all its complexity) That is also my only 5 and thus highest rating. Out of reviews it is Bigfoot with +11.5% for a 4.65. I really need to go out and stock up on them. That was my first one and I really want to try them with age. It really tastes like a top-notch IPA when it is had fresh.

    -31% with a 2.18 for Sobrehumano Palena'ole by Maui w/ Jolly Pumpkin (drain poured into a beer bread mix)

    p.s. I realize that the highest rating and lowest rating will most likely coincide with your greatest +/- rDevs.
     
  2. Frankinstiener

    Frankinstiener Jul 28, 2009 Illinois
    Beer Trader

    These are called beer bread mix pours. Haven't you seen all the "First beer bread mix pour" threads?
     
    SadMachine and kemoarps like this.
  3. gillagorilla

    gillagorilla Feb 27, 2013 Maryland
    Beer Trader

    Nope, I haven't seen one yet. Are they usually in the main Beer Talk forum?
     
  4. kojevergas

    kojevergas Aug 15, 2010 New York
    Beer Trader

    Highest rDev = +67.4% for Fischer's Desperados with a 3.9 rating.
    Lowest rDev = -67.9% for Strange Brewing's Paint It Black with a 1.23 rating.

    Highest rating = 4.9 for Kaggen! Stormaktsporter. +5.4% rDev.
    Lowest rating = 1.0 for Budweiser Chelada. -51% rDev.
     
  5. LeRose

    LeRose Nov 24, 2011 Massachusetts

    Highest rating Palo Santo Maron - 4.73 tied with Boulvard Tank 7.
    Lowest rating - Oso Doe in Heat at 2.05.

    Highest rDev - plus 20.7 for DFH Rasoin d'être and minus 38.7 for....drum roll...Oso Doe in Heat. Sorry WI.

    Somebody please, please tell New Glarus to get some beers to Wisconsin Rapids restaurants. As a frequent visitor, I am virtually begging.
     
  6. gillagorilla

    gillagorilla Feb 27, 2013 Maryland
    Beer Trader

    Where was this moved to?
     
  7. BlackDragon

    BlackDragon Feb 16, 2013 Michigan

    Highest Rating Dragons Milk 5
    Lowest Rating Drain Heady Topper 1

    Highest rDev Fort +30.5%
    Lowest rDev Drain Heady Topper -78.8%
     
  8. alex_hart

    alex_hart Feb 28, 2013 Oklahoma

    This is my highest, +41.3% (huuuuge +, but I have no idea why it has such a low rating on here!!) being Brother David's Triple Abbey Style Ale. That beer was one of my absolute favorites, heres my review on it. http://beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/193/17498/?ba=alex_hart

    My largest negative was -28.6% for Abita's Strawberry Harvest Lager. I just thought it tasted like a Bud Light with a hint of strawberry. Worthless, IMO.
     
  9. chippo33

    chippo33 Feb 29, 2012 Vermont
    Beer Trader


    Did you get a can that was more than a week or two old?
     
    dfillius likes this.
  10. sukwonee

    sukwonee Dec 13, 2011 Washington
    Beer Trader

    Voodoo Doughnut Maple Bacon Ale +18%

    Switchback Russian Imperial Stout -28%

    Man, you guys must truly hate Voodoo Doughnut beer! I only gave it a 3.5 and I was still 18% over.
     
  11. Daemose

    Daemose Oct 3, 2011 Texas
    Beer Trader

    You suck. I like that beer.
     
    alex_hart likes this.
  12. alex_hart

    alex_hart Feb 28, 2013 Oklahoma

    You suck. I like that beer.[/quote]

    Haha! Sorry! But at least there is more for you!
     
  13. rboinski

    rboinski Mar 19, 2012 California

    +10.6 Russian River segal select. Thought it was an extremely well crafted beer, though I wasn't super fond of the flavor it was still very good.

    -16 Backwoods bastard. Seems totally unbalanced to me, like sugar in bourbon. Totally not a fan.
     
    slim2043 likes this.
  14. BlackDragon

    BlackDragon Feb 16, 2013 Michigan

    No just didn't like it. Think it had too many hops only time I ever spit out beer.
     
  15. Daemose

    Daemose Oct 3, 2011 Texas
    Beer Trader

    Haha! Sorry! But at least there is more for you![/quote]

    Very true!
     
  16. Colosdog

    Colosdog Jan 30, 2013 Massachusetts

    Highest rDev: +23.8% BJ's Restaurant and Brewery Hopstorm IPA (Rated 4)

    Lowest rDev: -48.5% DFH Noble Rot French Oak Pinot Gris Barrel Aged (Rated 2)

    I love DFH beers but there was something about that Pinot Gris Noble Rot that really turned me off.
     
  17. Bobheed

    Bobheed Dec 27, 2010 Texas

    Highest rDev: +23.6% Dogfish Head Fort

    Lowest rDev: -45.7% Sierra Nevada Summerfest Lager

    Highest Rating: Firestone Walker Parabola - 5
    Lowest Rating: Lake Front Fuel Cafe Coffee Flavored Stout - 1.85
     
  18. thatsnotbutter

    thatsnotbutter Apr 24, 2013 Missouri

    I couldn't agree more. Abita Strawberry is straight-up wretched
     
    alex_hart likes this.
  19. Beerlover

    Beerlover Mar 15, 2012 Minnesota

    +72.9%!! for Cold Spring's "Honey almond wiess" the problem with this beers low ratings was that for a number of years the cold spring brewery was making beer inconsistant, but recently they have had a brewery revamp, also i think people were getting this beer outdated and drinking it from a bottle! i had it in a can (canned beer is ALWAYS better!) and it was perfect for this style.

    -53% for Sam Adams "Fat Jack double pumpkin ale" I like pumpkin beers but this thing was RUFF!! Pure liquid pumpkin pie in a glass! this was far too over spiced! there was 4 or 5 different spices in this where as they should have been 2 or 3.
     
  20. fox227

    fox227 Nov 19, 2010 California

    +28.6% for Belgo Anise Imperial Russian Stout - Stone. I know that that one will make many bust laughing, but I really enjoyed it, but I'm not sure I'd rate it 4.5 if I had it again.
    -38.9% for Seismic IPA from SoCal Beer Company. From a tasting, I remember there being no real hop character, but just a bland, stale bitterness, and bland malt character. I'm inclined to believe that it was a bad batch or bottle.
     
  21. djsmith1174

    djsmith1174 Aug 21, 2005 Minnesota

    Highest Rating: Boulevard BBQ - 4.95
    Lowest Rating: Ommegang Rare Vos - 3.63

    Highest rDev: Brooklyn Local #2 +20.2%
    Lowest rDev: Ommegang Rare Vos -10.8%

    Yes, I am a shitty reviewer. And that is why I don't do it much.
     
  22. alex_hart

    alex_hart Feb 28, 2013 Oklahoma

    you must try a tooonn of good beers to have your lowest be the Rare Vos!
     
    JMS1512 likes this.
  23. djsmith1174

    djsmith1174 Aug 21, 2005 Minnesota

    There's a ton that I've had that would rank lower than Rare Vos, I'm just too lazy to review them. :D
     
    alex_hart likes this.
  24. EnronCFO

    EnronCFO Mar 29, 2007 Massachusetts
    Beer Trader

    Throwback Hopstruck -60%
    Throwback Fat Alberta -58.2%
    Sam Adams Utopia -43.8%
    Hill Farmstead Susan -33%
    Shed IPA +27.5%
     
  25. TheLostGringo

    TheLostGringo Dec 7, 2011 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    Couple big deviations for me:

    HF Edward +13.1 (to me its the perfect beer)
    CCB Jai Alai +12.1

    Sam Adams Merry Mischief -33.4
    Devil's Backbone Eight Point IPA -32.4%
     
  26. elgiacomo

    elgiacomo Jun 28, 2007 Georgia

    Highest rDev: +56.4% for Kaliber. Rated to style and found it superior to other low-alcohol beers I've had.
    Lowest rDev: -67.7% for Magic Hat #9. Apparently I really hated this beer...

    Highest Rating: 4.83 (tie) for Founders CBS & Bell's Expedition Stout
    Lowest Rating: 1 (tie) for Bud Light Lime & Milwaukee's Best Ice. If I could rate lower than a '1', then Beast Ice would take top honors for my lowest-rated beer.
     
  27. afluentturtle

    afluentturtle Dec 16, 2012 Texas

    Highest rDev: +28% For Gordash Brewing Panic Attack
    Lowest rDev: -37.2% Karbach Sympathy for the Lager

    Highest rated: 5 for Jesterking OG Black Metal
    Lowest rated: 2.25 for Karbach Sympathy for the Lager
     
  28. THANAT0PSIS

    THANAT0PSIS Aug 3, 2010 Wisconsin
    Beer Trader

    Highest Rating: Goose Island Bourbon County Brand Coffee Stout (2012) - 5, +7.5%
    Lowest Rating: Ale Asylum Satisfaction Jacksin - 2.9, -23.7% (I think I had a bad bottle, so I offer another option)
    New Belgium Lips of Faith Tart Lychee - 3.1, -21.9%

    Highest rDev: Sierra Nevada/Dogfish Head Life and Limb - 4.73, +17.7%
    Lowest rDev: The two beers mentioned as lowest ratings, but other than that, Firestone Walker Union Jack - 3.75, -12.6%
     
  29. frothyhead

    frothyhead Mar 14, 2007 New Jersey

    Highest +rDev: Storm (Islay Whisky Cask Aged IPA) - BrewDog; 4.22/+50.7

    There is a heavy bias against peaty beers on this site. I have no idea why, but I really like them. Also really liked the Schlafly single malt scotch ale, similar profile.

    Highest -rDev: Andygator - Abita; 2.38/-32.2

    This beer is god awful.

    That said, I don't actually have nearly as many ratings on here as I've had beers, so I'm sure there would be quite a few others that deviated a bit. Taste is a brilliantly personal thing.
     
  30. beertunes

    beertunes Sep 24, 2007 Washington
    Beer Trader

    Biggest positive Rdev- +74.7 for American Brewings Blonde.

    Biggest negative Rdev- -65.6 for Cascade Bourbon Barrel Quad

    Highest scores - 5.0 for North Coast Old Stock Ale and Unibrou La Fin du Monde.

    Lowest score - 1 for Bud Select 55.
     
    JMS1512 likes this.
  31. KS1297

    KS1297 Apr 14, 2013 Wisconsin

    +69.8% for Labatt Blue at 4.5
    -5.7% for Spotted Cow at 3.5
     
  32. arfenhouse

    arfenhouse Oct 29, 2012 California

    Victory at Sea +9.8%
    Night Stalker -69.5%... infected as fuck
     
  33. cavedave

    cavedave Mar 12, 2009 New York
    Beer Trader

    Hard to tell, since you don't review, but I am guessing from a glance at your hads
    1. You don't rate to style
    2. You dislike hoppy beers
    Just another reason I think hads ought not to be considered for overall scores of beer. At least if some person doesn't rate to style you can see something like "ugghh, I get all kinds of bitter and hoppy flavors in this IIPA" written when they give a world class beer a stunningly improper review.
     
    Brenden, founder26, BrettHead and 2 others like this.
  34. mctizzz

    mctizzz Dec 23, 2010 California
    Beer Trader

    Tröegs Mad Elf 11.00 1 -74.2%
    Just can't do super sweet brews, had it once and had to give the bottle away after half a small glass.
    Every beer I have ranked really high or low I want to try again to see if I still feel that way. I had a 2013 Sucaba last night and didn't think it was nearly as great as I remembered.
     
  35. Roguer

    Roguer Mar 25, 2013 Connecticut
    Beer Trader

    I generally rate higher than others; I only have two negative rDevs. That said:

    Lowest: Redd's Apple Ale, -9.4% rDev (also my lowest pure rating, at 2.4). Honestly, I'm stunned that a 2.4 is BELOW the average rating; I thought I was being quite generous. I'm actually tempted to go back and LOWER my review, rDev be damned; it's that bad.

    Highest: Amstel Light, +40.2% (at only 3.38!). Apparently, a lot of people REALLY hate that beer! I do consider it better than "average" for the style (that style being mass-produced BMC-style lagers).

    Highest Pure Rating: Westmalle Tripel, 4.75 (+10.2% rDev). This is absolutely one of my favorite beers.
     
  36. BlackBelt5112203

    BlackBelt5112203 Jan 2, 2012 Michigan
    Beer Trader

    Highest rDev for me: Founders Frangelic Mountain Brown - +23.1%
    I thought this was a fantastic example of a brown ale and the blast of hazelnut really added to it.

    Lowest rDev: Newcastle Brown Ale - -42%
    I may have gotten a skunked bottle, but in my opinion, I think it's still valid to rate a skunked version of a beer that comes from across the pond in a clear bottle. They don't do the work to preserve their product. If that's not acceptable:

    Next Lowest rDev: Firestone Walker Sucaba - -21%
    I thought it tasted like biting a bourbon barrel.
     
  37. Rohkey

    Rohkey Jan 13, 2013 Michigan

    Highest Rating: Rochefort 8 (5.0) - If I did full reviews, I'm sure this would probably end up getting an aggregate of a 4.85 or 4.9, but I just do hads...
    Lowest Rating: Miller 64 & MGD 64 (1.0) - Again, a full review might yield a 1.2 or 1.3 or something, but I can't justify giving this anything higher than the worst rating possible.

    Highest rDev: Shock Top (+24.6%)
    2nd highest rDev: Hofbrau Muncher Weise (+22.7%)

    Lowest rDev: Budweiser (-46.4%)
     
  38. Petela

    Petela Mar 21, 2013 New Jersey

    Highest: Chocolate Oak Aged yeti: +3.3%

    Lowest: Southern Tier Choklat: - 14%

    However, these are my only beer ratings on BA =/
     
  39. TheBrewo

    TheBrewo Nov 11, 2010 New York

    +56.4 Presidente Light (Honorable mention to +36.8 for Voodoo Doughnut Maple Bacon....I love that beer...don't care what any of you say!! :p)
    -39.5 Bavaria Malt
     
  40. ubenumber2

    ubenumber2 Sep 1, 2012 Arkansas
    Beer Trader

    +28.8 for Shipyard IPA , I like this beer

    -28.3 for Innus and Gunn Original , I didn't like that beer
     
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Extreme Beer Fest® Cometh

    February 3-4, 2017. Boston, Mass. Limited tickets available. Prepare for epicness.

    Learn More
  • 10 Years of BeerAdvocate Magazine

    We're celebrating 10 years of BA mag with $10 print subscriptions for US residents!

    Subscribe