If you get an infected bottle, is it fair to give a poor rating? Personally, I think if you got an infected bottle you shouldn't give it a rate as it is not a true representation of the beer. But that's just me. I wasn't able to get coffee this year but I did get barleywine.....I was lucky enough to not get an infected bottle and it was amazing. Just wanted to get peoples thoughts on this subject. Thanks for your input.