Surly Overrated West Coast IPA

Discussion in 'Midwest' started by jera1350, Jan 31, 2013.

  1. jera1350

    jera1350 Dec 15, 2007 Minnesota

    [​IMG]
    From beerpulse.com:

    (Minneapolis, MN) – On Thursday, label approval came in for Surly Overrated West Coast IPA. On rare occasion, labels that get approved may never make it to market but it is the exception rather than the rule. So, there is a good chance that Surly has a new 16 oz. can coming out in the future though details are unavailable at the moment. Below is the label copy…
    It’s been said, “It’s easier to brew an extremely balanced beer.” And you know us, we are always looking for the easy way out, so we jumped on the West Coast IPA Bandwagon and brewed this dry and hoppy ale. “Surly’s a little bit of a one-trick pony, they just brew gimmick beers,” and maybe we are OVERRATED, but at the end of the day, it’s just a beer. If you like it, great, so do we. If you only liked us when we were small, then leave this one on the shelf. Let one of the fanboys grab it.
    We dug around for a source to what appears to be a chip on Surly’s shoulder but couldn’t come up with the quote on the label.
    But there was this Beer Advocate review by member, BeerLover…
    [...] i dont wonder with “surly’s “Our Sh!t dont stink, we are better than every1 else’s) attitude if this is not just a marketing trick/ploy/gimmick to make their already high in demand beers even more crazed over [...]
    And this one by JamesMN
    [...] I tend to think that Surly is a little overrated (due mostly to the high price point and the “we’re better than you” attitude). [...]
    Who knows…maybe your comments may someday upset a brewery into releasing a new beer.
     
  2. StarRaptor

    StarRaptor Jun 8, 2010 California

  3. Penguin3200

    Penguin3200 Dec 28, 2008 Minnesota

    Canning Bandwagon! Sweet!
     
  4. cmannes

    cmannes Mar 15, 2009 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    LOL! This is great!
     
  5. incutrav

    incutrav Jan 16, 2007 Minnesota

    Confirmed same recipe?
     
  6. GFG

    GFG Oct 24, 2012 North Dakota

    LOL

    This is one of the greatest things I've ever seen. Can't wait for it!
     
  7. GFG

    GFG Oct 24, 2012 North Dakota

    Hasn't been said yet to my knowledge but bandwagon is a west coast IPA. So it's possible I guess. I have a feeling it's a new recipe though.
     
  8. Penguin3200

    Penguin3200 Dec 28, 2008 Minnesota

    Just figured since they say Bandwagon right on the new can lable. Just have to wait and see.
     
  9. GFG

    GFG Oct 24, 2012 North Dakota

    Can't believe I didn't notice that. It's capitalized too. You might be right on this one!
     
  10. shawnp

    shawnp Jan 15, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Year round or seasonal? I enjoyed Bandwagon at Twins games....
     
    Philly82785 likes this.
  11. BrettHead

    BrettHead Sep 18, 2010 Nebraska

    TheBushman likes this.
  12. Mealhouse

    Mealhouse Feb 19, 2012 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    I enjoyed his Ruination 10th anniversary review where he said he'd like to age it 2 or 3 months....
     
  13. jera1350

    jera1350 Dec 15, 2007 Minnesota

    Maybe we should steer this guy to the craigslist add for 2012 Hopslam.
     
    Ish1, arniepnminne, yamar68 and 5 others like this.
  14. GFG

    GFG Oct 24, 2012 North Dakota

    What he fails to realize in that review is simple math. A 4 pack of 12oz bottles at $12 really isn't that much cheaper. Abrasive is a usually around $17 for a 4 pack of 16oz cans.

    Abrasive: 26 cents per oz
    Ruination: 25 cents per oz

    It's amazing what a little intelligence can bring to ones life
     
  15. Ungertaker

    Ungertaker Apr 30, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    http://beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/13014/46849/?ba=Beerlover
    "I dont like giving beers a bad review, but this definatley needs to be brought down a few notches... not a horrible beer by any means, but when you factor in the price (which unfortunatly is not part of the rate system) this beer is a RIP-OFF!!! there are many other double ipas you can find out there that are just as good if not BETTER for a LOT less $$$!! some examples- these being much better tasting in my humble opinion than abrasive and MUCH cheaper - my top 3 favorite double ipas all taste much better than this:
    1: Stone's "Ruination" - 4 pack bottles 11.99 ($0.24979 per ounce)
    2: Odell's "Mycenary" 4 pack bottles 10.99 ($0.22896 per ounce)
    3: Weyerbacher "Double Symcoe" 4 pack bottles 11.99 ($0.24979 per ounce)
    and a 4th just to hit it home, the best double ipa - bang 4 ur buck wise
    4: Pyramid "Outburst ipa" 6 pack for 8.99!!! INSAIN DEAL & GREAT FLAVOR!!!" ($0.12486 per ounce)


    My comparison:

    4. Surly's "Abrasive" 4 pack cans= $0.24984 per ounce

    Overpriced? Maybe compared to Outburst (85 rating on Outburst, 100 on Abrasive- with Abrasive having over five times the reviews). Is it overpriced compared to the others? Only if $0.00005/ounce or $0.02088 means something to you! Someone just needs to do the math...
     
  16. Ungertaker

    Ungertaker Apr 30, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Edit: I was typing my above comment as you posted yours...

    *Insert joke about intelligence here* See: spelling errors and mathematical errors in reviews
     
    MrMcGibblets, BrettHead and GFG like this.
  17. dc55110

    dc55110 Oct 24, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    “Surly’s a little bit of a one-trick pony, they just brew gimmick beers.”

    Didn't this quote come from the old board? I remember a similar statement form an employee of, I think, MGM in Burnsville. I could be wrong, but I know I've read that quote before...
     
  18. BrettHead

    BrettHead Sep 18, 2010 Nebraska

    stupid is as stupid does ;-)
     
    TheBushman likes this.
  19. Revenant

    Revenant Aug 8, 2012 Minnesota

    Could have sworn I read somewhere in an old interview where Todd or Omar said they were toying with the name "Over Rated" a while back for something. Can't quite remember though.
     
  20. incutrav

    incutrav Jan 16, 2007 Minnesota

    I, of course always like some price talk. To be fair, Ruination is priced at 9.99 about everyplace i see it. Thats $.20 an oz.

    My comparable buy to Abrasive is Sucks, at about $.14 an oz.

    For the record(is anyone keeping one?!), I like Surly when they were small and still like them now. I cant imagine me ever enjoying a beer more then Fury. Its the first Surly I ever tried at Arborfest in '06, and still my top!
     
  21. Yulles

    Yulles Apr 12, 2009 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    I remember that. Funny enough, they now carry Surly and advertise it quite a bit.
     
  22. gatornation

    gatornation Apr 18, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    this could/will be there best selling beer of course overrated , this cant get on the shelves fast enough 4 me
     
    BottleCaps80 and yamar68 like this.
  23. biglobo8971

    biglobo8971 May 6, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    will have your back.
     
    sliverX likes this.
  24. Ungertaker

    Ungertaker Apr 30, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Yeah, I think that thread was started and deleted multiple times!
     
  25. dc55110

    dc55110 Oct 24, 2010 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Ungertaker likes this.
  26. gatornation

    gatornation Apr 18, 2007 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Ungertaker likes this.
  27. minnesotaryan

    minnesotaryan Dec 27, 2010 Minnesota

    want to pour into mouth now.
     
    sliverX, shawnp and Mealhouse like this.
  28. brbe6

    brbe6 Nov 26, 2012 Minnesota

    Honestly couldn't be happier they are trying to can Bandwagon, since I don't like baseball at all and could never talk myself into buying a twins ticket just to try a beer.
     
    feloniousmonk likes this.
  29. GraniteSkunk

    GraniteSkunk Apr 17, 2007 Illinois

    Anyone that gives Hop*A*Potamus a perfect five has taste buds that are not to be trusted.


    Also, Torgo ... buddy ol' pal .... how're things going up there? Just sayin' hi .. :D
     
  30. HomeBrewed

    HomeBrewed Dec 10, 2006 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Yup, that was my thread...her exact quote's were..."Look at all this beer here! Why would I need Surly? It's nothing more than a Minnesota novelty." "They make mediocre beer."

    I wish they would've named it "Minnesota Novelty"
     
    arniepnminne likes this.
  31. steggers

    steggers Apr 9, 2011 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Pretty sure it is a 'novelty' that MGM Burnsville now carries. It was on their sign when I drive by today. I guess she jumped on the 'Bandwagon' as well.
     
  32. elshaggy

    elshaggy Jul 12, 2009 Minnesota

    Gotta love the tongue in cheek humor. Especially since it's their take on one of the most popular styles of craft beer. Brings a smile to my face as I drink my Lagunitas Sucks!
     
  33. GFG

    GFG Oct 24, 2012 North Dakota

    Surly is still "small." They're basically still ONLY in the Twin Cities, with the addition of a couple other Minnesota towns/cities. They won't come up to East Grand Forks, MN because they still have over 300 places on a wait list before the place here that wants them. :(

    The guy here tonight said that they more than likely won't be receiving Surly until the new brewery opens
     
  34. UMNbeerhunter

    UMNbeerhunter Oct 21, 2010 Minnesota

    Time to put on my boner pants.
     
  35. pmccallum86

    pmccallum86 Apr 7, 2009 Minnesota

    I hope its like bandwagon with a more caramel malt backbone. I wonder if it'll be a year round beer
     
  36. mnbearsfan

    mnbearsfan Dec 25, 2009 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    You are just putting them on? Mine were on at 12:55 today.
     
    minnesotaryan likes this.
  37. norcalhophead

    norcalhophead Jan 28, 2010 Wisconsin

    Perfect name for ALL of their beers - OVERRATED!
     
    domtronzero likes this.
  38. mnbearsfan

    mnbearsfan Dec 25, 2009 Minnesota
    Beer Trader

    Kind of like Aaron Rodgers?
     
  39. jawzman

    jawzman Mar 20, 2010 Minnesota

    Easy pal... When is the last time your squad bested my beloved Pack?

    Looking forward to trying this beer...
     
  40. minnesotaryan

    minnesotaryan Dec 27, 2010 Minnesota

    the abrasive in my snifter is calling shenanigans on this.
     
  • About Us

    Your go-to website for beer (since 1996), publishers of BeerAdvocate magazine (since 2006) and hosts of world-class beer events (since 2003). Respect Beer.
  • Return of the Belgian Beer Fest

    BeerAdvocate Brings its All-Belgian Fest to Portland, Maine on September 17, 2016. Tickets are on sale now.

    Learn More
  • Get the Mag

    Become a BeerAdvocate magazine print subscriber today.

    Subscribe