I would go as far to say 3.61 on a 1-5 scale, is "Good", approaching "Very Good" And in my opinion, a 3.92 in a 1-5 scale, is in the "very good." range. I think the only way to call a 3.92 "Not very good at all" is if you are rating on a 3-5 scale. Which is not the rating system used here. But I think all this largely misses the point, the new system is taking on style bias. I'm glad to see where a beer stands amongst beers of a similar style. I get that most people these days don't like pilsners as much as Hazy IPAs. But within the Pilsners style, people are still going to rank the ones they like higher then the ones they don't like. A weighed system takes that into account.